Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Q&a


Recommended Posts

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

So, given the overwhelming success with the questions that 3rd graders posed, I opened it up to all grades...check out some of these questions:

How did God create the world?
How did the poor get poor?
How did God make people?
What does God look like?
How did God make the first person?
While Jesus was on earth who was in Heaven?
Why was Joseph chosen as Jesus' father on earth?
Is there anything important that happened after the Resurrection cuz I didn't hear nothing else about it?
How did God create spirits and things is He was a spirit Himself? Was He just there?
When was the first bible written and who wrote it and where?
Why can't priests get married or have children?
Why is Jesus called God's Son and God? Which one is it?
Do priests have to plan every Mass?
Where do they get the ashes from?
How many years of school do you have to go through to be a priest?
Why do people judge the saints when nobody knows him (exactly what was written, need to "translate")
Why can't priests dress normal?
What is the Diocese?
Were Jesus and Maria married and did they have a daughter?
Why does the Catholic Church deem it necessary to keep certain things about Catholicism hidden?

I have already answered the one about priests dressing normal and how many years of school...

BTW, if any of you want to add your own insights they are more than welcome.

God Bless

Edited by Theologian in Training
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Hehehe...cute. Some of them are very important questions that could use a lot of background, lol.

"Why is Jesus called God's Son and God? Which one is it?"

I used to ask myself that all the time! :lol:

Posted

I have one my three year old asked me:

God created people, Jesus is a person, so God created Jesus. But isn't Jesus God? How did he create himself?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1255411' date='Apr 24 2007, 03:35 PM']I have one my three year old asked me:

God created people, Jesus is a person, so God created Jesus. But isn't Jesus God? How did he create himself?[/quote]
Awww...cute, confused little Arian.

Try explaining that Jesus is a divine Person, not a human person. :P:

Posted

At Good Friday Mass she was litening to the readings and she said "Jesus died??" And I said yes honey and she said "Who killed Jesus mom?"

So I told her lots of people and left it at that.

sorry :hijack:

Posted

[quote]Why does the Catholic Church deem it necessary to keep certain things about Catholicism hidden?[/quote]


lol what the heck does that even MEAN?! :lol_roll:

Posted

[quote]Were Jesus and Maria married and did they have a daughter?[/quote]

Ooo, the Da Vinci code fooey is trickling down... I wonder where the little one heard [i]that![/i]

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1255582' date='Apr 24 2007, 09:38 PM']Ooo, the Da Vinci code fooey is trickling down... I wonder where the little one heard [i]that![/i][/quote]

Well, seeing as that was one of the books on the High School reading list....

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1255579' date='Apr 24 2007, 09:32 PM']lol what the heck does that even MEAN?! :lol_roll:[/quote]

Not the best question, but at least they are asking, and at least they are thinking...

Posted
:rolling: It looks like you have your work cut out for you Father! I especially love the first 5 questions.
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1255601' date='Apr 24 2007, 06:55 PM']Well, seeing as that was one of the books on the High School reading list....[/quote]


please tell me its nota catholic school :sadder:


and yes, it is good they're asking questions, i didn't mean that, it just made me laugh :disguise:

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1255637' date='Apr 24 2007, 10:32 PM']please tell me its nota catholic school :sadder:
and yes, it is good they're asking questions, i didn't mean that, it just made me laugh :disguise:[/quote]

No public school

  • 1 month later...
Theologian in Training
Posted

[b]When was the first bible written and who wrote it and where?[/b]

The bible was not written like an ordinary book, with one set author, at one set place at one set time. Rather, it is the result of a collection of many different authors of many different books, written in many different places and eventually compiled into what we know as the bible today.

This came about when either an individual or a group of people got together and tried to discern those books that seemed to be inspired by divine revelation and those that did not seem to be. This came be known as the “canon” of the bible, which is a Greek term that means, “reed,” “straight rod” or “measuring stick.” It is this last description that really helps us to understand why it is used in this context, because it is from these books that we are able to “measure,” as it were, the norms by which we believe, and also how the books we have in the bible came to be those that we have today.

It was the result, as was mentioned, of many different people, not just one specific person. First, it was a bishop of Asia Minor, by the name of Melito, who tried to “canonize” the Old Testament, then it was The Council of Laodicea, which compiled a list quite close to the canon we have today, then Pope Damasus, who wrote a decree, inspired largely by the Council of Rome, whose canon we use today. Following this, from Pope Innocent I to the Councils of Hippo, Carthage, Florence and Trent, they upheld this same exact canon, and, in fact, was deemed infallible at the Council of Trent.

In the end, Catholics hold that there are 27 books in the New Testament and 46 in the Old Testament.

Although this last part may be a little “technical,” I think it important to point out that there is actually a distinction between how a book is categorized. For example, there are what are known as protocanonical, deutorocanonical, and apocryphal books.

They are Greek words that each designate some part of the books in the bible. The protocanonical books are those that were accepted as divinely inspired without any controversy whatsoever. The deuterocanonical books, however, were under discussion for a little while until their authenticity and canonicity could be determined. The apocryphal books, meaning “hidden away,” are those books where neither their authenticity nor their authorship could be determined. These are books that were not accepted into the canon, unlike the proto and deuterocanonical books, and, as a result is the reason such books as the Gospel of Thomas or the Gospel of Mary are not in the canon of the bible today.

This is very brief explanation of the bible as a whole and the books themselves, and perhaps, it is a little more information that you might have been looking for, but now you have a better idea of where the bible came from, how it came to be, and why we believe that books contained therein are ones that took many years of discernment, prayer and discussion before they made it into the canon.

Fr. Brian

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1283339' date='May 29 2007, 11:39 AM'][b]When was the first bible written and who wrote it and where?[/b]

The bible was not written like an ordinary book, with one set author, at one set place at one set time. Rather, it is the result of a collection of many different authors of many different books, written in many different places and eventually compiled into what we know as the bible today.

This came about when either an individual or a group of people got together and tried to discern those books that seemed to be inspired by divine revelation and those that did not seem to be. This came be known as the “canon” of the bible, which is a Greek term that means, “reed,” “straight rod” or “measuring stick.” It is this last description that really helps us to understand why it is used in this context, because it is from these books that we are able to “measure,” as it were, the norms by which we believe, and also how the books we have in the bible came to be those that we have today.

It was the result, as was mentioned, of many different people, not just one specific person. First, it was a bishop of Asia Minor, by the name of Melito, who tried to “canonize” the Old Testament, then it was The Council of Laodicea, which compiled a list quite close to the canon we have today, then Pope Damasus, who wrote a decree, inspired largely by the Council of Rome, whose canon we use today. Following this, from Pope Innocent I to the Councils of Hippo, Carthage, Florence and Trent, they upheld this same exact canon, and, in fact, was deemed infallible at the Council of Trent.

In the end, Catholics hold that there are 27 books in the New Testament and 46 in the Old Testament.

Although this last part may be a little “technical,” I think it important to point out that there is actually a distinction between how a book is categorized. For example, there are what are known as protocanonical, deutorocanonical, and apocryphal books.

They are Greek words that each designate some part of the books in the bible. The protocanonical books are those that were accepted as divinely inspired without any controversy whatsoever. The deuterocanonical books, however, were under discussion for a little while until their authenticity and canonicity could be determined. The apocryphal books, meaning “hidden away,” are those books where neither their authenticity nor their authorship could be determined. These are books that were not accepted into the canon, unlike the proto and deuterocanonical books, and, as a result is the reason such books as the Gospel of Thomas or the Gospel of Mary are not in the canon of the bible today.

This is very brief explanation of the bible as a whole and the books themselves, and perhaps, it is a little more information that you might have been looking for, but now you have a better idea of where the bible came from, how it came to be, and why we believe that books contained therein are ones that took many years of discernment, prayer and discussion before they made it into the canon.

Fr. Brian[/quote]
Tell them to think of it as a library, not a single book .

Church Punk
Posted

I like this one..."[quote]Why can't priests dress normal?[/quote]


HAHAHA

Love it

God Conquers
Posted

[quote]Is there anything important that happened after the Resurrection cuz I didn't hear nothing else about it?[/quote]

That one is the best!

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

wowsers! Some of those are really AWESOME questions! Nice to see some kids thinking instead of just drinking the koolaid the world hands 'em...

Q. How did the poor get poor?
A1. Because God loves them (see the Be Attitudes)
A2. Because God loves us and through the poor, gives us an opportunity to do his work
A3. Some are born that way, some are that way because of poor choices they have made, some are that way because of injustice due to sin in the world


I guess pick the best answer for the age group...

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Church Punk' post='1283425' date='May 29 2007, 01:56 PM']I like this one..."
HAHAHA

Love it[/quote]

I already answered this one...I know some of the things in here are not exactly theological proofs, and I know I messed up on the number of years for priesthood, but I gave it my best :)

Given the great success and interesting questions the 3rd graders posed for me a while back, I decided to return to the 3rd grade class and have them ask some more questions, but I also decided that it would be interesting to open it up to all the grades. Therefore, the next couple of weeks I will be answering questions from 3rd graders all the way up to 8th graders. They have some very interesting and quite profound questions, and I am sure you will agree. Also, in order to keep some type of continuity between the questions, I am going to organize them according to a specific “theme” or commonality that is shared between them. For example, this weekend I will deal with questions related to the priesthood.

[b]Why can’t priests dress normal?[/b]

It is obvious from the question that there is something seemingly “abnormal” about wearing clerics (the name of what we priests wear). The thing is that is exactly how it is supposed to seem, because the priest is not a normal man, per se, but, by virtue of his ordination, has been conformed to Christ. For you see, when a priest is ordained he does something very interesting, he lays down completely prostrate on the floor, a symbol that he is now laying down his entire life for the service of God and His people, something commonly referred to as a “dying to himself.” Given this, he is also to indicate to others that this is indeed his life now, and he does so by wearing black (commonly worn at funerals) with a little white tab (which some see as a symbol of the hope of Resurrection). These clothes are an external indication of the internal reality of his becoming a priest, because at the ordination, just as in Baptism, there is a “mark” left on the soul, but you cannot see it, which is why at Baptism we wear white to symbolize this new life. The priest too wears something to indicate this new life, and that is his clerics. It should also be noted that these clerics are not a “work uniform,” indicating that once he changes he is “off the clock” because a priest is a priest forever, as the Book of Hebrews reminds: “You are a priest forever according to the order of Melchizedek” (Hebrews 7:17). Melchizedek, was believed to be the first priest.

Given this, however, priests are free to dress “normal,” but, as the [i]The Directory for the Ministry and Life of Priests[/i], an “instruction manual,” as it were for us priests, states: “The priest should be recognizable above all through his behavior, but also through his dressing in a way that renders immediately perceptible to all the faithful, even to
all men, his identity and his belonging to God and to the Church.” This, with the following exceptions: “It goes without saying that there are reasonable and legitimate
exceptions to this rule, such as during sports and recreation, during one's vacation (in general), while at home with family or in one's private quarters in the rectory. And, of course, the obligation to wear clerical clothing ceases during times of violent persecution. During such a crisis, the guidance of the bishops should be followed.”

[b]How many years of school do you have to go through to be a priest?[/b]

The official number used to be four, however, since John Paul II added an extra year of pre-theology, that is, studies to prepare for the study of theology itself, consisting mostly of philosophy, it has been extended to five years. The next question is probably what we study. Well, it varies from seminary to seminary, but it mostly consists of biblical studies, morality, Church history, something called systematic theology (the more intense stuff dealing with the doctrine of the Trinity, transubstantiation (big word to designate the change of bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ) and field work, that is, “on the job training,” as it were, consisting of visiting hospitals, nursing homes, and working at a parish. At the end of the third or fourth year, depending, one is ordained a transitional deacon for a year, and then at the end of that year he is ordained a priest. In the end, he will also have graduated with a Masters in Divinity, which consisted of a thesis of his own choosing.

Fr. Brian

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1283375' date='May 29 2007, 12:35 PM']Tell them to think of it as a library, not a single book .[/quote]

It was already translated and sent for the bulletin. If they ask, I will tell them that though, that is a good way of looking at it.

Theologian in Training
Posted

The next set of questions this weekend are those that deal with a practical understanding of certain words and curiosities that I am sure many of you have often wondered. One deals with certain practices that occur during Holy Week and the other a term we use to explain the way in which the Church is many but one.

[b]Where do they get the ashes from?[/b]

I assume that this question is referring to the ashes we distribute during Ash Wednesday, and if this is the case, the answer is very simple.

If you remember, every Holy Week begins with a special Sunday, called Passion Sunday, or, as we might better know as Palm Sunday, that Sunday we bless palms as a reminder of Christ’s entry into Jerusalem on a donkey, while people were singing the joyful praise “Hosanna in the highest.” It is these same palms that we blessed a year before, that we use and burn to create the ashes we use for Ash Wednesday. This is why oftentimes we will ask that if you have palms left over from the previous year that you bring them for us to burn.

Our second question is a little different, and deals more with the structure and the “subdivisions,” as it were, that exist within the Church itself.

[b]What is the Diocese?[/b]

In the [i]Catechism of the Catholic Church[/i] a diocese is defined as: “A ‘particular church,’ a community of the faithful in communion of faith and sacraments whose bishop has been ordained in apostolic succession. A diocese is usually a determined geographic area; sometimes it may be constituted as a group of people of the same rite or language.” To put it more simply, it is a territory or a group of churches that are under the authority and jurisdiction of the bishop. In other words, we are in the diocese of Paterson, under the jurisdiction and authority of bishop Serratelli. He has been ordained for this great task and we refer to him as the bishop of our diocese. In another state or even other parts of NJ, there are other dioceses and therefore other bishops who oversee those dioceses.

I know that sounds a little technical and almost “legalistic,” which is really what it is, however, to make it even more simple, in his letters St. Paul would often write to particular churches in Rome, Corinth, Ephesus, etc. and what he was actually doing was more or less writing to what would be equivalent to a diocese, because back then there was not the same degree of division and nor were there enough bishops around to oversee each and every “particular church.”

Now, one thing to always remember is that though there is a division this does not mean that a diocese is independent of the main diocese which is in the Vatican in Rome. We call this being in communion with Rome, and every diocese in the United States and all around the world shares in this same communion. This is why there is no difference, besides the language, when attending Mass in a Catholic church between one that you attend here in NJ or one you attend in France, Columbia, Italy, or anywhere around the world. This is also what it means to be, in the truest sense of the word a Catholic, because the word “Catholic,” by definition, means “universal.”

Fr. Brian

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...