jeffpugh Posted April 28, 2007 Posted April 28, 2007 I've been dialoguing (the debates are still at the moment) with my Pentecostal friend as of late, and he wants to know the reasoning about Mortal and Venial sins and why we have them sorted. He basically says 'one should just not sin' and "where is THAT in the bible?". A bit of his background consists of his fascination with absolutes (good thing for sure). Any way I could run with this? Would classifying killing with telling a lie in the same category be like relativism? And yes those examples (along those lines) were discussed. Thanks a bunch. Pax Christi ><>
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted April 28, 2007 Posted April 28, 2007 [quote]16 If anyone sees his brother sinning, if the sin is not deadly, he should pray to God and he will give him life. This is only for those whose sin is not deadly. There is such a thing as deadly sin, about which I do not say that you should pray. 17 All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not deadly. [url="http://www.usccb.org/nab/bible/1john/1john5.htm"]1 John 5:16-17 (New American Bible)[/url][/quote]
jeffpugh Posted April 28, 2007 Author Posted April 28, 2007 I did find out about that verse... is it the only one? I also wanna discuss a bit about relativism in sin...
123 Posted April 28, 2007 Posted April 28, 2007 I believe, and I could be wrong on this one, but in the Book of St. John there is a verse that states that not all sins are as harmful as others. (Don't quote me on that.) Venial is not that devistating to your spiritual life. But, over a period of no confssion it can be Mortal requires confession and penace. This is found in Matthew 16:18.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted April 28, 2007 Posted April 28, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1258418' date='Apr 27 2007, 08:37 PM']I did find out about that verse... is it the only one? I also wanna discuss a bit about relativism in sin... [/quote] Not sure, but it is the one that comes to mind as being real clear. I think by relativism in regards to sin you are talking about conscience. Sin is sin no matter what, but the state of our conscience, as well as our disposition at the time, determines our culpability. It goes back to the three requirements for mortal sin. Is this what you mean? God bless!
johnnydigit Posted April 28, 2007 Posted April 28, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1258400' date='Apr 27 2007, 06:26 PM']"where is THAT in the bible?".[/quote] i love that one, "HEY, THAT'S NOT BIBLICAL!" -my new catch phrase. there are numerous verses in the Bible where Jesus and others talk about different gravity of sins. sorry i don't know them off my head.
LouisvilleFan Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 Jesus told Pilate that although they were both directly involved in the Crucifixion, it was Judas who had the worse sin.
jeffpugh Posted May 3, 2007 Author Posted May 3, 2007 Yeah that's a good one Louisville... gah I just had a thought on another verse but I've lost it now...
johnnydigit Posted May 3, 2007 Posted May 3, 2007 [url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1995/9505fea4.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1995/9505fea4.asp[/url] Why did he say that the one who knows his master's will and does not do it will be beaten with many blows, while the one who does not know his master's will and does not do it will be beaten with few blows (Luke 12:47-48)? "If anyone sees his brother commit sin that does not lead to death, he should pray and God will give him life. I refer to those whose sin does not lead to death. There is a sin that leads to death. I am not saying that he should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, and there is sin that does not lead to death" (1 John 5:16-17) [url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2000/0010frs.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2000/0010frs.asp[/url] both seem to be supported mostly by church fathers..
farglefeezlebut Posted May 6, 2007 Posted May 6, 2007 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1263145' date='May 3 2007, 03:50 PM']"If anyone sees his brother commit sin that does not lead to death, he should pray and God will give him life. I refer to those whose sin does not lead to death. There is a sin that leads to death. I am not saying that he should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, and there is sin that does not lead to death" (1 John 5:16-17)[/quote] Does that mean that we shouldn't pray for those in mortal sin?
jeffpugh Posted May 6, 2007 Author Posted May 6, 2007 No St John says that we should, but it takes more than prayer for the person to come around... that is he/she needs confession.
Paddington Posted May 7, 2007 Posted May 7, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1266272' date='May 6 2007, 09:54 PM']No St John says that we should, but it takes more than prayer for the person to come around... that is he/she needs confession.[/quote] Could you say some more on that? I still think that St. John is saying do not pray for such a person. Also, it is confusing that I have heard Catholics say that nobody can know for sure if somebody is in a state of mortal sin. In this text, St. John says that we can know and then act on our knowledge of somebody's soul.
johnnydigit Posted May 7, 2007 Posted May 7, 2007 why would you think we shouldn't pray for those in mortal sin? common sense says everyone on earth needs prayers. even those in purgatory. the only places where they wouldn't need prayer is heaven and hell since those are final.
Paddington Posted May 7, 2007 Posted May 7, 2007 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1267326' date='May 7 2007, 09:29 PM']why would you think we shouldn't pray for those in mortal sin? common sense says everyone on earth needs prayers. even those in purgatory. the only places where they wouldn't need prayer is heaven and hell since those are final.[/quote] johnnydigit, I'm not a Catholic or any kind of Christian. I'm also very much in favor of prayer. I was giving what is my impression of the text in 1 John 5. Hopefully, Sacred Music Man or you or somebody will clear it up for me. This is how I am understanding it....(not trying to be a translator) * If they commit a lesser sin, pray for them and God will help them. * Yup, those commiting a lesser sin. * There are of course people on the face of the earth who are committing greater sins. * I'm not telling you to pray for them. Maybe it means that you say something to the person committing a grave sin instead of praying. But, since you don't know if sb's grave sin is mortal or not, then why not pray too? Also....there could be the idea of physical death in here. It truly would be lame to just pray for a sb about to kill sb or themselves without trying to prevent it. But, why not pray too? Maybe it is a sin that killed them. And it is too late to repent. So don't pray for them. They either had some kind of "perfect contrition" thing at the end or it is too late. Or it was a venial sin that killed them...then....why not pray for them? It all looks difficult so far. Just some guesses. Eager to hear other ideas. Peace, Paddington
jeffpugh Posted May 9, 2007 Author Posted May 9, 2007 Well, my bible translation the NRSV says mortal, not death... (1John 5:16ff) "If you see your brother or sister committing what is not a mortal sin, you will ask, and God will give life to such a one--to those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin that is mortal; I do not say that you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not mortal" Umm... by this translation, it seems that John was addressing a misconception about severity of sin. Apparently the community thought that all sin was mortal, but he urged them to pray for those in mortal sin. But he says "I do not say that you should pray about that", which is a pretty ambiguous line. I guess it could mean either you have to or you don't. It is best to pray for those in mortal sin anyways. Christians have been praying for conversions for centuries. Mortal sin is just turning away from God, so I guess what St John is ultimately referring to is self analysis? Yeah... maybe that is it... okay I decide on self analysis for this one... (sorry I had inspiration here in mid paragraph)...
Paddington Posted May 9, 2007 Posted May 9, 2007 [quote name='Paddington' post='1267062' date='May 7 2007, 06:32 PM']In this text, St. John says that we can know and then act on our knowledge of somebody's soul.[/quote] I definitely should've said "St. John SEEMS TO say......." Sorry.
Paddington Posted May 9, 2007 Posted May 9, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1268508' date='May 9 2007, 12:17 AM']Well, my bible translation the NRSV says mortal, not death... (1John 5:16ff) "If you see your brother or sister committing what is not a mortal sin, you will ask, and God will give life to such a one--to those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin that is mortal; I do not say that you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not mortal" Umm... by this translation, it seems that John was addressing a misconception about severity of sin. Apparently the community thought that all sin was mortal, but he urged them to pray for those in mortal sin. But he says "I do not say that you should pray about that", which is a pretty ambiguous line. I guess it could mean either you have to or you don't. It is best to pray for those in mortal sin anyways. Christians have been praying for conversions for centuries. Mortal sin is just turning away from God, so I guess what St John is ultimately referring to is self analysis? Yeah... maybe that is it... okay I decide on self analysis for this one... (sorry I had inspiration here in mid paragraph)...[/quote] Sacred Music Man, Thank you. There are some things I'm still not seeing unfortunately. It does sound like they could've been lost on what is mortal and not mortal. I'll have to read 1John if I can respond anymore. Maybe tonight, maybe never. Peace, Paddington
johnnydigit Posted May 9, 2007 Posted May 9, 2007 [url="http://www.cin.org/mateo/9307151.html"]http://www.cin.org/mateo/9307151.html[/url] Are there different degrees of sin, i.e., are some sins worse than others? What does Scripture say about this? What do Christian writers earlier than the 11th century say? These are your three questions. We do not need divine revelation to answer the first question. Reason and experience alone tell us that, for example, an angry, impatient retort is a milder fault than deliberate murder or child abuse or peddling drugs to children. When anybody tells me that his theology does not recognize different degrees of sin, I simply don't believe him. Or rather, I surmise that in real life he simply ignores his theology and goes along with experience and common sense. As always, Catholic theology starts with reason, experience and commonsense and never departs from these norms. God created our nature and our environment, and His revelation and saving grace do not conflict with our realities, but redeem and heal them. Hence in dealing with sin, Catholics observe and recognize differences among sins and call serious sins "mortal" and trifling sins "venial". (This is our vocabulary, developed through the centuries). Scripture, of course, approves this distinction and makes use of it, clearly teaching that some sins are worse than others. [b]See Jeremiah 7:26, Lamentations 4:6, Ezechiel 16:44-58, 1 John 5:16-17, Matthew 11:22, John 19:11. Some sins are so great that they exclude the sinner from God's Kingdom (1st Corinthians 6:9-10; Galatians 5:19-21); others are less serious, deserving temporal but not eternal fire (1st Corinthians 3:11,15). Daily small faults are found even in holy people (Ecclesiastes 7:21; James 3:2; 1st John 1:8).[/b] Before the 11th century, the degrees of gravity among sins were recognized with ever growing clarity by Origen (Commentary on John), Ambrose (On Penance), Jerome (Against Jovininian), Caesarius of Arles (Sermon 104), and especially Augustine (Sermon 351; On the Spirit and Letter, 27, 48; Treatise on John's Epistle to the Parthians 1, 6; Enchiridion, 64). You can find patristic evidence for every Catholic doctrine in the 3-volume set "Faith of the Early Fathers", edited by William Jurgens. When individuals or groups leave the Catholic Church they thereby inevitably "unhook their life supports". They loosen their grip on one or other aspect of Christian truth and so lose that part of God's revelation. So it has happened with some Christian groups who do not perceive anymore that there are indeed distinctions of seriousness among sins. Sincerely in Christ, Father Mateo
Paddington Posted May 9, 2007 Posted May 9, 2007 If anybody can give an explanation of how St. John says "DO pray for those committing a sin leading to death" then please lay it out. What if he is saying "pray from them conditionally." As in "God, please help that person UNLESS they have committed a sin that leads to death." Thanks, Paddington
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now