Megz Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 I'm having trouble in my life with many Catholic Church issues. I don't like some of the things catholic persons in authority have done to me, espeally when it goes to the diocean level. I do not "believe" one bit. There is nothing in me that has any faith in the least eon. However, becuase I've studied other Religions I am pretty sure, well I am positive, that the Catholic Church provieds one with the greatest moral compas, spiritual direction and truth. Therefore I have commited to follow the rules of the Catholic Church, just like I follow the rules of my workplace, school, and state.(although the latter are clearly flawed) I have stopped recieving Communion beucase my thought process is based on facts and not on respect or love. My protestant friends say I'm not Catholic then, and my Catholic friends say that if I'm not in Mortal sin then I'm being bellergant. My Catholic friends say that I am sinning because I am failing to recive grace that would help myself and others. I don't really care about that becuase I can't see it. When I tell them that they say I give Catholocism a worse name than if I didn't go to church at all. My feeling is that I am following church law and attending Mass weekly and there is no law that sais I have to recieve Communion (except at Easter, which I did) so I don't. Am I breaking any rules that I am unaware of? x-posted to catholic answers
Moneybags Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 What are some of the issues that you are having problems with?
Maggyie Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 I am so sorry to hear that you are having problems with some members of the hierarchy... Is it some teaching of the Church that is causing trouble, or is it just a personality issue? I myself have gone through periods in my spiritual life when I was not "feeling it" and pretty much only remained a Catholic Christian because I knew that as a fact it was absolutely true. I really don't think it's a mortal sin; there's no real reason you shouldn't receive, and receiving the Eucharist really strengthens us to get through the difficult times. But we are not bound to receive at any time except Easter, it's true. So no, you are not breaking any rules. My own personal course of action would be to really ramp up my reception of the Sacraments - particularly Confession, especially if you don't feel you can receive the other, the Eucharist, with integrity. I would make my prayer the great one from Scripture, "I believe, Lord, help my unbelief." Again I am sorry to hear this You will be in my prayers!
Chiquitunga Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 You are not sinning if you decide to not receive Holy Communion. The Sunday obligation does not include receiving the Blessed Sacrament, just attending Mass, which you are doing. I believe it is only an obligation that a practicing Catholic receive Holy Communion once a year, at Easter time. (others will know the specifics better on this though than I) But your refraining from Communion is definitely not a sin. I'm sure someone else here can give a good explanation of St. Paul's words regarding discerning the Body of the Lord. I believe you are doing the correct thing if you truly do not believe the Blessed Sacrament is the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ, by not receiving. You are doing what is right and just then, by refraining from receiving. Please someone, correct me if I'm wrong. So many it seems do the opposite, and receive the Lord without a thought, often in mortal sin, but also consciously not believing in the Real Presence. I believe receiving and not believing in the Real Presence may be a sin. I'm sure someone else here can give a better explanation though. It is great you attend Sunday Mass. I will keep you in prayer. God bless you!
Megz Posted April 30, 2007 Author Posted April 30, 2007 most of my issues are in things the church government in America has done to me personally. Bad decisions on the level of priests, bad decisions on the level of parishioners, horrible tretement by of diocean adminisrators. I don't even so much mind that the chuch had no care for me and brushed me off in my early youth, but then they (on all levels) latter attacked me as in the wrong when it was my accusers who were. They persued to make me guilty even when it was extremely clear I wasn't. I can't go into detail on an open forum, as to exactly why, but it broke all of my faith and belief. The only reason I adhere to the Catholic church is now on a logical level.
Sojourner Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 [quote name='Megz' post='1260844' date='Apr 30 2007, 03:08 PM']I'm having trouble in my life with many Catholic Church issues. I don't like some of the things catholic persons in authority have done to me, espeally when it goes to the diocean level. I do not "believe" one bit. There is nothing in me that has any faith in the least eon. However, becuase I've studied other Religions I am pretty sure, well I am positive, that the Catholic Church provieds one with the greatest moral compas, spiritual direction and truth. Therefore I have commited to follow the rules of the Catholic Church, just like I follow the rules of my workplace, school, and state.(although the latter are clearly flawed) I have stopped recieving Communion beucase my thought process is based on facts and not on respect or love. My protestant friends say I'm not Catholic then, and my Catholic friends say that if I'm not in Mortal sin then I'm being bellergant. My Catholic friends say that I am sinning because I am failing to recive grace that would help myself and others. I don't really care about that becuase I can't see it. When I tell them that they say I give Catholocism a worse name than if I didn't go to church at all. My feeling is that I am following church law and attending Mass weekly and there is no law that sais I have to recieve Communion (except at Easter, which I did) so I don't. Am I breaking any rules that I am unaware of? x-posted to catholic answers[/quote] To the best of my knowledge, I think that you are within bounds. There is, as far as I know, no requirement that you receive Communion outside of Easter. I think it's great that you're still attending Mass, even though your emotions are not in it at this point. All of us go through times when we struggle in our faith, when we don't feel it. But it's important to remember that you made a vow ... it's kinda like a marriage vow -- for better or worse and all that. There are times that you stay in out of duty, and sometimes you're there because of love, but the thing underlying all this is the promise you made. That's what keeps you coming back. Maybe you don't see hope for the love to come back anytime soon, and it may not for a while. But keep at it. There are times our actions shape our hearts, just as there are times that our hearts inform our actions. Maybe while you are in church, think about being open to hearing God's voice. The practice of being open to God's call in your life is an important part of the practice of faith. That might help you to focus on him rather than on all the stuff that's making it difficult to receive communion right now. But I'd definitely encourage you to keep going. I'll be praying.
theculturewarrior Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 (edited) As far as receiving communion at Easter, I think there is the requirement to believe what the Church teaches, which I understand from your post that you do not. I do not judge, but I ask, if you do not believe, why receive communion at all? That said, I commend you for attending Mass. I completely understand where you are coming from. I think it was Saint Ignatius of Loyala who said that sometimes we suffer for the Church and sometimes we suffer from the Church. Many view the Church as a place to network with community leaders, and Christ comes second. Often, persons in authority are abusive to the persons they have authority over. I hear you, and I understand what you are saying, but I submit that the Cross is either true or false, and nobody can change that for you. I suggest that before you disavow Catholicism, you test it philosophically, and test everything else against philosophically. If you want to be Catholic pray for an increase of faith and that God heal you of the damage the scandal caused. If not, disbelieve on grounds of Truth, and not because someone made it ugly for you. Edited April 30, 2007 by theculturewarrior
Era Might Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 [quote name='Megz' post='1260844' date='Apr 30 2007, 04:08 PM']I do not "believe" one bit. There is nothing in me that has any faith in the least eon. However, becuase I've studied other Religions I am pretty sure, well I am positive, that the Catholic Church provieds one with the greatest moral compas, spiritual direction and truth. Therefore I have commited to follow the rules of the Catholic Church, just like I follow the rules of my workplace, school, and state.(although the latter are clearly flawed)[/quote] Can you explain what you mean when you say you do not believe? Do you mean that you do not believe that the faith of the Church is true (for example, that Jesus is God), but you continue to follow the Church because it helps you be a better person? If I'm understanding you accurately, then yes, your decision not to receive Holy Communion is the correct one. It is the Sacrament of unity, and that includes unity of faith. You are always welcome to attend Mass without receiving communion. It is good that you are not severing ties with the Church completely. I would raise one point, though. The Pope says in his Encyclical Letter "Deus Caritas Est" that "being Christian is not the result of an ethical choice or a lofty idea, but the encounter with an event, a person, which gives life a new horizon and a decisive direction." Ultimately, Christianity is not about being an ethical person. You may attend Mass every week and obey the commandments and the laws of the Church, but that cannot replace the personal encounter with Jesus Christ. Being a Christian is about following him and loving him completely. We can be ethical without being holy, and we must be holy to enter the Kingdom of God. Again, I would encourage you to continue to attend Mass (without receiving Holy Communion) and at least keep the door open to the truth of the Catholic faith. But I would also challenge you to think about what it means to be a Christian, and not become complacent and settled where you are now. Our Lord tells us in Scripture that we must be hot or cold, but if we are lukewarm, he will vomit us out of his mouth (strong imagery). In other words, either the faith is true or it isn't, either we follow him with all of our heart or we don't. We cannot serve two masters. Peace.
prose Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 Faith by feeling will never last. I think you are probably making the right decision. In the meantime, pray for faith, and I will pray for you.
alicemary Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 We all go through periods where we question and we doubt. Do the best that you can during this time. The Lord certainly understands. He gives us these times in our lives so that we might grow. So do not despair and this too shall pass.
Moneybags Posted April 30, 2007 Posted April 30, 2007 Perhaps you need to find a parish that offers the Tridentine Mass. For me, it is a great source of comfort and reverence with very holy, reverent priests leading the flock.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 (edited) I'm uncomfortable with that advice, St Benedict. Megz has already explained that her difficulties stem from the poor treatment she has received from people at her current parish and diocese. There is no reason to suppose that people who attend the Tridentine Mass are inherently kinder and less prone to error. If you swap churches because people have behaved badly towards you, you are falling into the bad trap of thinking that the truth resides in the people who share the pews with you. In reality the Truth is in the tabernacle. It doesn't matter how nasty the parishioners are or how cruel the priest is...Jesus is there and it will take more than a few hardened sinners to drive Him away. He came to love the unlovely as well as the unloved, something that we often find very difficult to accept. Megz, I think you should start going to Eucharistic Adoration as regularly as possible. Take your troubles to Christ. Pour them out and in turn feel Him pouring His peace into you. Before you can receive Him in the right spirit you need to love Him. Adoration will teach you that. It will be difficult at first, but persevere. On the days when your church doesn't offer Adoration, go into the chapel when it is empty and spend some time alone in His presence. The best kind of prayer is the prayer that you make in times of struggle or dryness, as there is always courage and patience there. Edited May 1, 2007 by Cathoholic Anonymous
prose Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 (edited) That is not the brightest response I have ever seen (St. Benedict). Going to a different Mass "style" is not going to increase your faith. Being open to God and prayer will. Maybe it will make you "feel" better, but it does not make the Mass any more holy. I guess the best place I can think of to start would be to talk to a priest that you trust. Relationships develop over time. Have patience. Edited May 1, 2007 by prose
Guest T-Bone Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1261141' date='Apr 30 2007, 06:07 PM']Megz, I think you should start going to Eucharistic Adoration as regularly as possible. Take your troubles to Christ. Pour them out and in turn feel Him pouring His peace into you. Before you can receive Him in the right spirit you need to love Him. Adoration will teach you that. It will be difficult at first, but persevere. On the days when your church doesn't offer Adoration, go into the chapel when it is empty and spend some time alone in His presence. The best kind of prayer is the prayer that you make in times of struggle or dryness, as there is always courage and patience there.[/quote] Megz. This is good advice. Consider it. Remember. We are all praying for you.
Moneybags Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 [mod]Catholic vs Catholic debate is not allowed. - dUSt[/mod]
Sojourner Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1261141' date='Apr 30 2007, 07:07 PM']I'm uncomfortable with that advice, St Benedict. Megz has already explained that her difficulties stem from the poor treatment she has received from people at her current parish and diocese. There is no reason to suppose that people who attend the Tridentine Mass are inherently kinder and less prone to error. If you swap churches because people have behaved badly towards you, you are falling into the bad trap of thinking that the truth resides in the people who share the pews with you. In reality the Truth is in the tabernacle. It doesn't matter how nasty the parishioners are or how cruel the priest is...Jesus is there and it will take more than a few hardened sinners to drive Him away. He came to love the unlovely as well as the unloved, something that we often find very difficult to accept. Megz, I think you should start going to Eucharistic Adoration as regularly as possible. Take your troubles to Christ. Pour them out and in turn feel Him pouring His peace into you. Before you can receive Him in the right spirit you need to love Him. Adoration will teach you that. It will be difficult at first, but persevere. On the days when your church doesn't offer Adoration, go into the chapel when it is empty and spend some time alone in His presence. The best kind of prayer is the prayer that you make in times of struggle or dryness, as there is always courage and patience there.[/quote] This is great advice, Meg. St. B, please take your divisive chatter elsewhere.
Moneybags Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 I'm giving my opinion to your question hoping that I can help. Calling someone's advice "divisive chatter" is just rude.
Megz Posted May 1, 2007 Author Posted May 1, 2007 I go to Adoration, infact they started regular Adoration on my campus recently. Looking at Jesus is fine. I pray. And I have havn't been to a trinidine mass of late, but no matter how holy the priest or the Mass I just don't recieve Communion. My dealings with the failings of the church just motivated my final choice not to recieve Communion. Like I said, I'm not Anti Catholic...im just Catholic on a intellectual level only.
dUSt Posted May 1, 2007 Posted May 1, 2007 Well, keep being intellectually Catholic, and through this, you may receive the grace to believe. If you do not believe in the real presence of Christ, do not receive communion, not even at Easter.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now