Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Bush Promises To Veto Abortion Measures


Recommended Posts

Lounge Daddy
Posted (edited)

[quote][url="http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=D8OTPTFG0&show_article=1&catnum=3"]WASHINGTON (AP)[/url] - President Bush is warning Democratic leaders that any attempt to weaken federal policies that restrict abortion will be met with a veto.

White House deputy press secretary Tony Fratto said Friday that the warning, issued in letters to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, was intended to stop abortion amendments from being added to spending bills and other legislation that Congress will be considering in the coming weeks.[/quote]

I'm just waiting for the Dems to drop the retreat- i mean "redeployment"- deadline from that emergency spending bill that the Pentagon needed back in April (I believe it was needed by the 19th of April) and then include some kind of abortion amendment in it's place and then send it to Bush again.

but don't forget - the Dems in Washington can support our troops without supporting the mission
as Pelosi repeatedly said, it's for the children! ...in some convoluted way

Edited by Lounge Daddy
RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1265598' date='May 5 2007, 07:04 PM']I'm just waiting for the Dems to drop the retreat- i mean "redeployment"- deadline from that emergency spending bill that the Pentagon needed back in April (I believe it was needed by the 19th of April) and then include some kind of abortion amendment in it's place and then send it to Bush again.

but don't forget - the Dems in Washington can support our troops without supporting the mission
as Pelosi repeatedly said, it's for the children! ...in some convoluted way[/quote]

Don't forget that Bush is also for abortion, as even while controlling the house and senate, Mr. Bush refused to completely abolish abortion, and didn't even propose such a law.

Reza

Lounge Daddy
Posted (edited)
:rolleyes: right I forgot that Bush is really secretly pro-abortion because he didn't push for sweeping anti-abortion legislation as king of America

i can see you know exactly how our government works here in the US Edited by Lounge Daddy
RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1265812' date='May 6 2007, 07:00 AM']:rolleyes: right I forgot that Bush is really secretly pro-abortion[/quote]

There's nothing "secrete" about it, it's the facts that neo-cons like yourself don't bother to pay attention to... while demonizing the other side of the spectrum. Seriously, if Bush was so "anti-abortion", then why didn't he propose a law [which would have gotten passed since the Republicans had control of the house and senate] that abolished every form of abortion, before the last election when the republicans had control of the house and senate?

Lounge Daddy, you're always talking "about the facts" but what are the facts in this situation? The facts are that bush tells people like you [that take him at his word] that he's against abortion, while never even proposiing a nationwide ban the entire time that the house and senate were under his party's [the republican party's] control! He's just as pro-abortion as the other candidates, he just pretends to be anti-abortion to win the votes of people like yourself.

Reza

goldbug16
Posted

[quote]WASHINGTON (AP) - President Bush is warning Democratic leaders that any attempt to weaken federal policies that restrict abortion will be met with a veto.

White House deputy press secretary Tony Fratto said Friday that the warning, issued in letters to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, was intended to stop abortion amendments from being added to spending bills and other legislation that Congress will be considering in the coming weeks.[/quote]

:clap:

Posted

[quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1265814' date='May 6 2007, 09:10 AM']There's nothing "secrete" about it, it's the facts that neo-cons like yourself don't bother to pay attention to... while demonizing the other side of the spectrum. Seriously, if Bush was so "anti-abortion", then why didn't he propose a law [which would have gotten passed since the Republicans had control of the house and senate] that abolished every form of abortion, before the last election when the republicans had control of the house and senate?

Lounge Daddy, you're always talking "about the facts" but what are the facts in this situation? The facts are that bush tells people like you [that take him at his word] that he's against abortion, while never even proposiing a nationwide ban the entire time that the house and senate were under his party's [the republican party's] control! He's just as pro-abortion as the other candidates, he just pretends to be anti-abortion to win the votes of people like yourself.

Reza[/quote]

he's more anti-abortion than you think. It's gonna be a long process to overturn roe v wade and make abortion illegal. Some leaders might be cowardly, but the most important thing at any given second is to be assured that the leaders in office are not against us. Bush has not made the country worse, as would have been under Kerry. In fact, we have gotten the unborn victims of violence act and Justice Roberts out of him. That sounds anti-abortion enough for me to support him over the mainstream liberal democrats you categorize him with. ("He's just as pro-abortion as the other candidates").

Posted

Reza, the Supreme Court in today's day and age has precedent to declare such laws unconstitutional. As such, the law would have been useless; struck down by the Supreme Court before it was ever enforced.

If he wanted to really risk everything, ie if he was 100% pro life instead of the 75-80% or so that he actually is, he could have issued an Executive Order banning abortion in the US, but it would have caused an uproar, would not have been enforced, and he likely would've been impeached since most American Political Theory nowadays does not give as much power to the Executive Branch as it used to have. had he done that, and nothing would have changed and it would've just swung everything in the wrong direction.

RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1266022' date='May 6 2007, 11:47 AM']he's more anti-abortion than you think. It's gonna be a long process to overturn roe v wade and make abortion illegal. Some leaders might be cowardly, but the most important thing at any given second is to be assured that the leaders in office are not against us. Bush has not made the country worse, as would have been under Kerry. In fact, we have gotten the unborn victims of violence act and Justice Roberts out of him. That sounds anti-abortion enough for me to support him over the mainstream liberal democrats you categorize him with. ("He's just as pro-abortion as the other candidates").[/quote]

Anti-abortion enough? Do you know what you're saying? It's like saying "some abortions are alright but not all"...


[quote name='Aloysius' post='1266145' date='May 6 2007, 01:55 PM']Reza, the Supreme Court in today's day and age has precedent to declare such laws unconstitutional. As such, the law would have been useless; struck down by the Supreme Court before it was ever enforced.[/quote]

IT WASNT EVEN PROPOSED! He didn't even propose laws remotely close to abolishing abortion, as the abortion clinic on Martin Luther King Jr. [about a block from where I live] is still as active as ever...

[quote]If he wanted to really risk everything, ie if he was 100% pro life instead of the 75-80% or so that he actually is, he could have issued an Executive Order banning abortion in the US, but it would have caused an uproar, would not have been enforced, and he likely would've been impeached since most American Political Theory nowadays does not give as much power to the Executive Branch as it used to have. had he done that, and nothing would have changed and it would've just swung everything in the wrong direction.[/quote]

If he issued an executive order [and I'm glad you brought that up], he wouldn't have been "impeached", that's a gross overexaggeration. His false intelligence about the war, was far worse of an offense then an executive order regarding abortion and that didn't even get him even close to being impeached. As I'd mentioned previously, he didn't even propose such a law. It wouldn't have caused much of an uproar [far less then the war did, for that matter], as those that voted him into power would have expected it [especially considering he had control of the house and senate, that also claim his same position].

Reza

Posted

Reza, it's obvious you aren't even listening to the other side. You're basically responding to arguments they aren't even making.

RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1266322' date='May 6 2007, 06:42 PM']Reza, it's obvious you aren't even listening to the other side. You're basically responding to arguments they aren't even making.[/quote]

If that's your view, I'm not offended. Executive authority was mentioned, I responded. How is that not listening to the other side and responding to arguments that aren't being made? The arguments that are being made is that Bush is against abortion and he isn't against it, it's a politically proven fact. It's also a fact that this post was created by someone that is a political right wing neo-con that blames everyone that isn't of his particular political affiliation for everything revolving around abortion [and nearly every other issue].

Reza

Posted

[quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1266341' date='May 6 2007, 08:04 PM']The arguments that are being made is that Bush is against abortion[/quote]
I rest my case. :mellow:

RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1266346' date='May 6 2007, 07:06 PM']I rest my case. :mellow:[/quote]

obviously cause you dont have nothing better to add to this discussion but since you don't think so... check the topic starting post!

[quote]he's more anti-abortion than you think[/quote] If this quote isn't saying that he's anti-abortion, and making execuses for his lack of policy against abortion, then I don't know what is....

Posted

Reza, there have been laws which outlawed abortion on the books for a long time. they were overturned as unconstitutional. if Roe v Wade were overturned, they would be in effect again.

making new laws would just add redundant laws which are considered unconstitutional by the judicial branch and thus are unenforceable.

certainly Bush is not perfectly pro-life... a lot of Republicans want the decision left up to the states (which would be a good step, both from the point of view of constitutional theory in the relationship between the States and the Federal Government and in the view of allowing this evil to be outlawed)

there is no one with any remote chance of getting to Washington prepared to undertake an attempt at federally illegalizing abortion. in an ideal world, it'd be great for that to happen. in the United States of America, the only thing possible, except that we organize an armed uprising, is the overturning of Roe v. Wade and its illegalization in all the red states.

I don't think anyone's saying Bush's stand is personally morally righteous; but it is the only supportable pragmatic effort... unless you have the means to take on the military might of the US military and overthrow the government. if you had the means, it'd be just and I might support it, because no government which allows the murdering of babies has any moral right to govern and no people which murders its own babies has the right to own its land... but otherwise: you're just going to have to deal with the fact that Bush's policies in Washington are the ONLY POSSIBLE POLICIES given the current status of constitutional theory (ie, the legislative branch is considered to be unable to legislate laws which contradict the precedents of the judicial branch in the form of the Supreme Court)

Personally, I think the Legislative and Executive Branches need to re-assert their power and enact laws which challenge Supreme Court precedents; and the Executive Branch should consider it possible to make an Executive Order which makes a Supreme Court Decision unenforced and irrelevant (Lincoln comes to mind as doing this)... ie order the Federal Government, by Executive Order, not to enforce the Supreme Court decision.

but such things are not considered possible in the current thought-process of constitutional theory... any president who attempted such a thing would likely be impeached, and legislation that challenged a precedent of the Supreme Court immediately shot down.

RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1266353' date='May 6 2007, 07:11 PM']Reza, there have been laws which outlawed abortion on the books for a long time. they were overturned as unconstitutional. if Roe v Wade were overturned, they would be in effect again.

making new laws would just add redundant laws which are considered unconstitutional by the judicial branch and thus are unenforceable.

certainly Bush is not perfectly pro-life... a lot of Republicans want the decision left up to the states (which would be a good step, both from the point of view of constitutional theory in the relationship between the States and the Federal Government and in the view of allowing this evil to be outlawed)

there is no one with any remote chance of getting to Washington prepared to undertake an attempt at federally illegalizing abortion. in an ideal world, it'd be great for that to happen. in the United States of America, the only thing possible, except that we organize an armed uprising, is the overturning of Roe v. Wade and its illegalization in all the red states.

[color="#FF0000"]I don't think anyone's saying Bush's stand is personally morally righteous[/color]; but it is the only supportable pragmatic effort... unless you have the means to take on the military might of the US military and overthrow the government. if you had the means, it'd be just and I might support it, because no government which allows the murdering of babies has any moral right to govern and no people which murders its own babies has the right to own its land... but otherwise: you're just going to have to deal with the fact that Bush's policies in Washington are the ONLY POSSIBLE POLICIES given the current status of constitutional theory (ie, the legislative branch is considered to be unable to legislate laws which contradict the precedents of the judicial branch in the form of the Supreme Court)

Personally, I think the Legislative and Executive Branches need to re-assert their power and enact laws which challenge Supreme Court precedents; and the Executive Branch should consider it possible to make an Executive Order which makes a Supreme Court Decision unenforced and irrelevant (Lincoln comes to mind as doing this)... ie order the Federal Government, by Executive Order, not to enforce the Supreme Court decision.

but such things are not considered possible in the current thought-process of constitutional theory... any president who attempted such a thing would likely be impeached, and legislation that challenged a precedent of the Supreme Court immediately shot down.[/quote]

good post... atleast you were willing to admit the fact that Mr. Bush isn't pro-life because the topic starter isn't.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1265814' date='May 6 2007, 09:10 AM']There's nothing "secrete" about it, it's the facts that neo-cons like yourself don't bother to pay attention to... while demonizing the other side of the spectrum. Seriously, if Bush was so "anti-abortion", then why didn't he propose a law [which would have gotten passed since the Republicans had control of the house and senate] that abolished every form of abortion, before the last election when the republicans had control of the house and senate?

Lounge Daddy, you're always talking "about the facts" but what are the facts in this situation? The facts are that bush tells people like you [that take him at his word] that he's against abortion, while never even proposiing a nationwide ban the entire time that the house and senate were under his party's [the republican party's] control! He's just as pro-abortion as the other candidates, he just pretends to be anti-abortion to win the votes of people like yourself.

Reza[/quote]

+

That is simply not true. Look at the judges he appointed, the vetos he signed, and the candidates for whom he campaigned. Sure, we would like him to come around a bit further, but he is overwhelmingly pro-life compared to the democrats platform. Need I mention the partial birth abortion ban? On the otherhand, a republican controlled house isn't entirely (although relatively greatly) pro-life. In the end, this isn't a dictatorship and the president doesn't have the supreme authority, which seems to have been suggested above. On the otherhand, President Bush -God Bless Him- is definitely moving things in the right direction where he legitimately can in many areas.

And, after all, how many non-Catholics are there that have a consistent life ethic? Often, the thought just doesn't exist i.e. hasn't been developed in other traditions, which is sad since it is as much a natural law as a faith issue. Cpnsidering the current culture of today, we are fortunate to have him as our president.

Edited by Veritas
goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1265598' date='May 5 2007, 09:04 PM']WASHINGTON (AP) - President Bush is warning Democratic leaders that any attempt to weaken federal policies that restrict abortion will be met with a veto.

White House deputy press secretary Tony Fratto said Friday that the warning, issued in letters to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, was intended to stop abortion amendments from being added to spending bills and other legislation that Congress will be considering in the coming weeks.[/quote]


This is a good thing. It certainly an act deserving of our respect. But I can't, any longer, support a president who is only "mostly" pro-life. It's good that he's done some decent things for the pro-life cause (partial birth abortion ban, appointing a couple of - mostly - prolife judges etc.). And I think things would be a good bit worse if Kerry had been elected. But he still supports abortion in some cases, add that to the handling of the war and in the end, this is a good thing but for me personally, the ends don't justify the means. I don't think it okay anymore to simply vote the for the "best of the bad" so to speak, simply with the intention of keeping out the worst. But that's just me.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1266637' date='May 7 2007, 02:14 AM']This is a good thing. It certainly an act deserving of our respect. But I can't, any longer, support a president who is only "mostly" pro-life. It's good that he's done some decent things for the pro-life cause (partial birth abortion ban, appointing a couple of - mostly - prolife judges etc.). And I think things would be a good bit worse if Kerry had been elected. But he still supports abortion in some cases, add that to the handling of the war and in the end, this is a good thing but for me personally, the ends don't justify the means. I don't think it okay anymore to simply vote the for the "best of the bad" so to speak, simply with the intention of keeping out the worst. But that's just me.[/quote]

+

It is better to vote the best one can, than to not vote at all, if those are the options. :)

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1266640' date='May 7 2007, 02:25 AM']+

It is better to vote the best one can, than to not vote at all, if those are the options. :)[/quote]

I agree that it's better to vote than not at all. If I didn't vote it wouldn't distinguish my position from all the millions of people that don't vote because they don't care. I would vote, but it would have to be for a third-party candidate. And yes I know such a candidate would never win.

RezaMikhaeil
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Veritas' post='1266635' date='May 7 2007, 12:12 AM']That is simply not true. Look at the judges he appointed, the vetos he signed, and the candidates for whom he campaigned.[quote]

Let me get this straight, if I just agree with murder every once in a while, that makes me pro-life? :unsure:

[quote]Sure, we would like him to come around a bit further, but he is overwhelmingly pro-life compared to the democrats platform.[/quote]

...so you compare one supporter of murder to another supporter of murder? This is the same excuse that neo-cons use to gain support for their campaigns, despite having a lax and ultimately weak social position on abortion.

[quote]Need I mention the partial birth abortion ban?[/quote]Who decides what a "partial human" is? That's like supporting birth control pills, except the overnight pill.

[quote]On the otherhand, a republican controlled house isn't entirely (although relatively greatly) pro-life.[/quote]

That doesn't mean that they wouldn't have voted for it! I promise you, they would have since they supported him on nearly everything else and would continue to do so to provide a united front.

[quote]On the otherhand, President Bush -God Bless Him- is definitely moving things in the right direction where he legitimately can in many areas. [/quote]Moving things in the right direction? More government, a pre-emptive war that has put the country into debt, and not to mention the moral ethical problems like the fraud situations [like Enron] that have compomised the moral fabric of our nation.

[quote]And, after all, how many non-Catholics are there that have a consistent life ethic? Often, the thought just doesn't exist i.e. hasn't been developed in other traditions, which is sad since it is as much a natural law as a faith issue. Cpnsidering the current culture of today, we are fortunate to have him as our president.[/quote]

If someone isn't pro-life, then they shouldn't have a right to claim it.

Reza

Edited by RezaLemmyng
Posted

are we talking about the term 'pro-life' here? or are we looking for results?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...