Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Need Sound Facts And Reasoning


Recommended Posts

Miss Cat Ballou
Posted

I really need big time help with this! The following editorial was placed in my school newspaper this past week:

"Gay marriage; equality for everyone"

Gay marriage has become a popular and controversial topic in the United States. I believe that people within our school would be less divided on the issue if everyone understood a couple points.

First, gay marriage does not have anything to do with the Catholic Church. There are around 1,049 United States laws that give rights to married couples (seeing as how gay marriage is still illegal in the United States). Gay marriage is a legal debate, not a religious one.

Supporting gay marriage does not necessarily mean that you are condoning being gay. It means that you believe all Americans should have equal rights to marry whom they love and experience the benefits of being married.

Some people believe that marriage should be reserved for heterosexual couples because homosexual couples cannot produce children. However, there are heterosexual couples that cannot have children and they are still allowed to get married.

Another argument is that gay marriages are not a good environment to raise children because it is unnatural. How would the fact that the child's parents are gay affect him/her? Are single-parent families not unnatrual? As far as how they child would grow up with gay parents and how it will affect the child, the possibility of the child being gay should not be a big concern because homosexual children have come from and been raised by heterosexual couples. Obviously, homosexual couples can also raise children whose sexuality does not match their own.

These are just a couple of the arguments given by each side of the debate on gay marriage. Gay marriage is a fairly simple issue for me because I strongly believe that all people should be able to marry whomever they want to and experience the benefits that come with marriage.


:ohno: This article was written by a senior female.

So, what do I do? I write back! This is what I have so far:

The Facts about Homosexual Marriage

There are many myths circulating in our society about homosexual marriage. These myths do not circulate in means of leading people astray from the truth; they are circulated because they are sincerely believed to be true. Clearly, many people in our society misunderstand homosexual marriage as well as why the Church teaches what She does. In this editorial, I hope to provide factual information concerning homosexual marriage and Church teaching.
One myth is that homosexual marriage has nothing to do with religion (the Catholic Church included). However, if this is true, then what is marriage? The definition of marriage since its very beginning is, “is the legal union between one man and one woman as husband and wife, and that a spouse is a husband or wife of the opposite sex.”


But, I really need strong facts! And I have been searching, but I don't know where they are and how to find the direct ones that I am looking for. I want to address this editorial argument by argument using facts and sound reasoning. Like, for the first argument, I would like to say that marriage was ordained by God in the first place, but where are the facts for that? I really am clueless about where to look for these certain facts. Any help would be great!!!!

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I'm going to move this to a place where you may get more answers. :)

Paddington
Posted
:)

Miss Cat Ballou,

The strong tradition of man/woman marriage has to be pointed out, but it won't carry weight to people who have decided gays should be allowed to marry. Overall, I'm not sure there is that much you can say to persuade them.

The only one I can offer up is that..........By their own standards, they should give weight to the fact that gay marriage is disapproved by so many people that it is a conflict of interest for them to expect clerks, judges, employers, and (in a way) everybody.... to have to acknowledge something as a marriage that they are against. People wanting gay marriage can not be idealist if they value freedom of religion.

One time on here, I said that I wished gays could get domestic partner benefits from government employment. They do the same work and it is just health insurance. Sb else said, "their could be 'friend benefits' that could cover that as well as best friends, etc. And it wouldn't be a fuss." The idea really impressed me. There are solutions to some of the problems. Unfortunately, there are people on both sides who won't work together.

Best Wishes,
Paddington

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...