Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Buying A New Computer


Recommended Posts

Brother Adam
Posted

So really then, Father Brian, what you are saying is that one should definitely not buy a Mac?

The Joey-O
Posted

I'm a great big computer nerd. Everything from building PCs, to drooling over reviews in PC Mag. Let me just say this:

YOU DON'T HAVE TO BUY A MAC TO GET A QUALITY PC. Or, laptop for that matter.

If you're looking for quality and you're gunna fork over the incredible amount of dough it takes for a Mac, go with a Lenovo Thinkpad instead. It's identical in quality, has better tech support and is about the same price.

However, I believe that the smartest way to go about these things is buy a less reliable brand and purchase the 3 year warrenty. You save about $1200 on the laptop. After cost of the warrenty, you save $850. This is especially good if you of lack basic knowledge about safety, computer maintenance, etc. If you're a novice with a computer, I don't care if you have a Mac, Lenovo, HP or Wal-Mart Brand, you're going to damage your laptop in some way that you won't be able to repair at least once within three years. This will be due to user error, not the product. Heck, I've been messin' with computers since I was 11 and user-error is still the main cause of my problems.

Last Time I checked, Consumer Reports (and this is basically true of all ratings sites) ranks reliability as:
Lenovo and Apple: 9/10
HP and Toshiba: 7.5/10
Gateway, Dell, Compaq (now owned by HP, but still of less quality), etc: These are ranked lower then the above, but I can't remember exactly what the rating was.

I'd suggest going with anything in the HP Pavillion series. Toshiba has a lot of different models, a safe one is Satellite, though there may be others.

I'm going to stress again the importance of a good warrenty. I went with the HP Pavillion, because it has good reliability, very good customer support, a great warrenty for pretty cheap price. If you've got money to throw around, go with the Lenovo (or the Apple if you must), but even still, buy the extended warrenty. You'll regret not doing it.

Posted

Apple home computer,Dell laptop! The Apple is very old and reliable. The dell battery on the Laptop dies fast! Thats all I know! I listen to Kim -Commando on the radio,Computer nerd-a-roni.....She has a website google "Kim commando!"She knows just about everything,people always are asking these kinds of questions! JC

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

Joey-O,

I have both windows and Mac, the less problems I have had, of course, have been with the Mac...and I built the windows machine myself...yet, the majority of the problems, apart from faulty hardware, have always been with windows inability to play nice with certain drivers, programs, etc. The only reason I still use windows is because Apple has not yet released a Media Center, and since I watch my TV and record it through the Media Center, I am short on options. I also do not like the fact that everytime you upgrade or change a piece of hardware you have to call Microsoft and let them know what you are doing and get a new serial number, otherwise windows will disable itself.

Also, in terms of stability, windows does not have a good track record...I can count the times my Mac has crashed (mostly always due to Office for Mac...a Microsoft product...hmmm :idontknow:) I could not even begin to tell you how many times I have seen that wretched BSoD...for non-techies (Blue Screen of Death).

Also, windows machine are horrible for networking...I can pinpoint every single networking problem I have had to a windows machine and its poor ability to either play nice with servers or routers...of which I have had a few. The Mac is built on a Unix based operating system, known for their great ability to be network operating machines...why do you think those who hate windows and won't switch to Mac are now moving over to Linux or any variation thereof? In fact, Dell is going to start shipping ubuntu.

I also had to go through countless upgrades, drivers, and tv tuner cards themselves because of windows poor ability to integrate hardware that is not owned by them...countless hours and thousands of headaches.

Also, I don't know how many companies put out system updates for their operating system only for it to disable other key drivers. I dloaded some update from windows update and it shut off my sound drivers...took me a while before I was able to pinpoint it on that...but when I realized sound card worked excellent up until that update, I realized something was amiss. I have sinced disabled those stupid updates and choose the ones I think I need, not those Microsoft tells me I need, because 9 times out of 10 you don't need them and they are more for "security" reasons...in other words, more ways to make sure you have a "genuine windows product" which means that if you installed another copy of XP on another home computer you might as well toss that computer, because you need a new OS for each computer....they never did that with 98....and, I seem to recall their popularity being the strongest with that OS...again...hmmmmm :idontknow:

Finally, I have used but refuse to buy Vista, because, as the Mac commercial has shown, it is incredibly limiting. I cannot tell you how many times I had to agree with something before being able to install the Mozilla browser on a friend's computer. I don't need that...Mac...you type your password in once and all is well from there.

So, my distaste for Microsoft has come after many many years of using them and hoping they would get their act together, but when someone drops the ball as many times as they did, I just cannot be bothered. I think if I ever build another computer it will be running Linux and my only dealing with Microsoft and windows will be at the parish office where I maintain the wireless network I created for them. Too many headaches and too many options to be bothered with windows..Otherwise, I will wait and hope that Mac does a Media Center...and not AppleTV, that was actually quite disappointing...mostly due to the quality of the video on iTunes....

But you are right you don't need a Mac to have a quality computer...you need anything that is not windows

Just my long winded rant/.02

Edited by Theologian in Training
The Joey-O
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1274964' date='May 16 2007, 09:18 AM']Joey-O,

I have both windows and Mac, the less problems I have had, of course, have been with the Mac...and I built the windows machine myself...yet, the majority of the problems, apart from faulty hardware, have always been with windows inability to play nice with certain drivers, programs, etc. The only reason I still use windows is because Apple has not yet released a Media Center, and since I watch my TV and record it through the Media Center, I am short on options. I also do not like the fact that everytime you upgrade or change a piece of hardware you have to call Microsoft and let them know what you are doing and get a new serial number, otherwise windows will disable itself.[/quote]

1. I practically lived with my best friend in high-school. His whole family was mac obsessed. They had like 7 desktop sets (anything from stuff running OS9 to a G4), plus they all had ibooks (the family was rich, the dad was a doctor of some sort). Anyways, I watched their Macs break with greater frequency, then my pc with a crappy Pentium III. They also had a heck of a time getting customer support to fix the problems. Whereas, I could fix just about all of mine.

2. I've been building computers since I was 15 and I've never had to call Microsoft for serial numbers (I've never had to call them for anything). I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about in that regard. Besides, this guy is getting a lap top, something that if he wants to upgrade he'd have to send in and let the technicians worry about it.

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1274964' date='May 16 2007, 09:18 AM']Also, in terms of stability, windows does not have a good track record...I can count the times my Mac has crashed (mostly always due to Office for Mac...a Microsoft product...hmmm :idontknow:) I could not even begin to tell you how many times I have seen that wretched BSoD...for non-techies (Blue Screen of Death).[/quote]

I've never gotten a BSoD on any pc with XP. I've never even seen it on friends'. Also, I've never seen an XP crash. My buddy is a tech guy at a little private school. He says that since they've upgraded all their computers to XP, he doesn't have to worry about crashing or BSoD. He still does have to worry a lot about viruses and user error, however. I concede that since Macs make less than 15% of the market share for pcs and desktops that hackers don't take the time to make viruses for them.

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1274964' date='May 16 2007, 09:18 AM']Also, windows machine are horrible for networking...I can pinpoint every single networking problem I have had to a windows machine and its poor ability to either play nice with servers or routers...of which I have had a few. The Mac is built on a Unix based operating system, known for their great ability to be network operating machines...why do you think those who hate windows and won't switch to Mac are now moving over to Linux or any variation thereof? In fact, Dell is going to start shipping ubuntu.[/quote]

Windows machines are difficult to network, in general. However, once again, XP does a good job of making it easier. The problem with Windows networking is not that it's based on a crappy OS, but that it's designed for advanced users who want to create crazy networks right out of the box. XP gave pcs a more intuitive "plug and play".

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1274964' date='May 16 2007, 09:18 AM']I also had to go through countless upgrades, drivers, and tv tuner cards themselves because of windows poor ability to integrate hardware that is not owned by them...countless hours and thousands of headaches.

Also, I don't know how many companies put out system updates for their operating system only for it to disable other key drivers. I dloaded some update from windows update and it shut off my sound drivers...took me a while before I was able to pinpoint it on that...but when I realized sound card worked excellent up until that update, I realized something was amiss. I have sinced disabled those stupid updates and choose the ones I think I need, not those Microsoft tells me I need, because 9 times out of 10 you don't need them and they are more for "security" reasons...in other words, more ways to make sure you have a "genuine windows product" which means that if you installed another copy of XP on another home computer you might as well toss that computer, because you need a new OS for each computer....they never did that with 98....and, I seem to recall their popularity being the strongest with that OS...again...hmmmmm :idontknow:[/quote]

Again, this isn't going to be a problem for the guy who's buying a laptop. Driver errors, difficult upgrades, etc. are only problems if you build your own PC. HP, Toshiba and most other companies who make premade sets not only ensure good compatibility but also have software to monitor your drivers and such for you, giving you the ability to update them automatically (they ensure the compatibility of the updated forms as well).

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1274964' date='May 16 2007, 09:18 AM']Finally, I have used but refuse to buy Vista, because, as the Mac commercial has shown, it is incredibly limiting. I cannot tell you how many times I had to agree with something before being able to install the Mozilla browser on a friend's computer. I don't need that...Mac...you type your password in once and all is well from there.[/quote]

So get XP. Vista will eventually be better, but it has some initial flaws. These flaws aren't akin to the initial release of Windows '98. They are mostly superficial. However, they can be difficult for a novice to deal with. Either wait a year for the big security update or just stick with XP.

I've had a lot of experience with both Macs and PCs. Buying a PC smartly is smarter than throwing your money away on an Apple. Apple has issues of its own. A lot of software is Windows only. Macs aren't safe, because of great security. Macs are safe, because they're not popular enough for people to target. I know my friend's dad has had his identity stolen using a Mac. The bottom line is getting your money's worth. If you buy an Apple, you're money isn't going to go as far.

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

Joey-O,

We will have to agree to disagree...and with regard to serial numbers, wait until you upgrade a piece of hardware in your PC, (I think I switched out a harddrive or if not that, it was a video card) and you will understand what I am talking about.

Also, how could you have never seen XP crash...I have to see it to believe it...and one more thing, though toshiba, hp, etc. do a faily decent job at keeping you updated on certain problems, that is not across the board all the time. And just wait until he has to try and find a driver he needs....good luck!

Edited by Theologian in Training
The Joey-O
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1275127' date='May 16 2007, 03:01 PM']Joey-O,

We will have to agree to disagree...and with regard to serial numbers, wait until you upgrade a piece of hardware in your PC, (I think I switched out a harddrive or if not that, it was a video card) and you will understand what I am talking about.

Also, how could you have never seen XP crash...I have to see it to believe it...and one more thing, though toshiba, hp, etc. do a faily decent job at keeping you updated on certain problems, that is not across the board all the time. And just wait until he has to try and find a driver he needs....good luck![/quote]

No prob. We can agree to disagree.

BTW, I upgrade my desktop all the time. I have never had to call up Microsoft for anything. And though I've only had my laptop for 9 months, I've never had any problem with finding drivers. In fact, the drivers update themselves with a little HP updater deal. With laptops, you don't have much need for finding new drivers, becuase you're, generally, not adding hardware. Besides, hardware usually comes with its own drivers on a CD.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...