The Joey-O Posted May 11, 2007 Posted May 11, 2007 I feel a little guilty reposting this question again, but I really need an answer soon. I posted it in the question and answer section a few days ago. Hope I'm not causing too much trouble. My question is: [quote]1. It seems that since Christ gave his life to the whole church and calling all Christians to do the same when he says "take up the cross and follow me", one would conclude that Christ called all to act in the manner of bridegroom. This is not to deny that all are to act in the manner of Bride as well, being ever open to Christ as a vessel of grace. If all can act as bridegroom in this sense, why can't all act as bridegroom in the sense of becoming a priest? 2. Please explain how the following sentence is wrong (I know it is, I just don't know why): If we believe (a) that the nature of priesthood is bridegroom and therefore masculine and not suitable for women to hold, then logically we should believe (b) that the nature of the Church is bride and therefore feminine and suitable for men to hold. I'm really not trying to be antagonistic. I'm currently reading what the church says on this subject, I'm just trying to get pointed in the right direction.[/quote] To contextualize my question, we were discussing an article from [url="http://www.zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=107049"]Zenit about Pia de Solenni[/url].
Nathan Posted May 12, 2007 Posted May 12, 2007 Trust the Church. Have faith that the Church's teaching on this matter is what it is because Christ has guided it to be so.
The Joey-O Posted May 12, 2007 Author Posted May 12, 2007 [quote name='Nathan' post='1271525' date='May 11 2007, 09:34 PM']Trust the Church. Have faith that the Church's teaching on this matter is what it is because Christ has guided it to be so.[/quote] I absolutely agree. I just would also like to have supporting logic and a full understanding.
Aloysius Posted May 12, 2007 Posted May 12, 2007 [quote]If we believe (a) that the nature of priesthood is bridegroom and therefore masculine and not suitable for women to hold, then logically we should believe (b) that the nature of the Church is bride and therefore feminine and suitable for men to hold.[/quote] The difference comes down to the very difference between "masculinity" and "femininity" with the feminine there is immanence; male and female are both, at one point, joined to an overwhelming female such that they are truly part of her. the female can have members which are male and female, can be an overarching thing; which is why when Christ says He wanted to gather up the children of Israel so many times, He likened it to a mother, because that would be female, to gather into one both male and female. the male is completely different; masculinity is an offshoot into the wilderness, an active force, not immanent. priests are all joined into one man, basically; there is not the mantal of a man over them, they are all consolidated into one man; so much so that we say the priest is really just excercising the ministry of the bishop, who is really just exercising the ministry of Christ. It consolidates into one masculine force and there is only One High Priesthood. But we are joined to the Church in a broader union; we are under the mantel of the "bride" not consolidated into one bride, but expanded out into this larger-than-ourselves "bride of Christ"; the Church is our "mother"; we are, as it were, part of her because we are in her 'womb'. Our being members of the mystical Body of Christ is also not a consolidation into one person, as the priesthood is, but being under a broader category of his mystical body; which is why, while we say we are members of the mystical Body of Christ, we do not treat the Church as if it had the masculinity of Christ in the Divine Drama, for the Church has the femininity of Christ's bridegroom united to His Body as true "flesh of His flesh, bone of His bone", united into one flesh by being bride and bridegroom. As to whether we are taking the "role" of "bridegroom" individually by taking up our cross to follow Him, we unite our Suffering to His as the Bride becomes One with the Groom, we take up Our Cross because we are united to Him who has the Headship of the Cross; I see it as us being in the role of the Bride still, in a sense, though it is true that are crosses are likened to His. It is the same way, to me, that the Church can be both "Body of Christ" and "Bride of Christ" we are both "taking up His Cross (bridegroom)" and "uniting our cross to His Cross (bride)"
The Joey-O Posted May 12, 2007 Author Posted May 12, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1271931' date='May 12 2007, 01:37 PM']The difference comes down to the very difference between "masculinity" and "femininity" with the feminine there is immanence; male and female are both, at one point, joined to an overwhelming female such that they are truly part of her. the female can have members which are male and female, can be an overarching thing; which is why when Christ says He wanted to gather up the children of Israel so many times, He likened it to a mother, because that would be female, to gather into one both male and female. the male is completely different; masculinity is an offshoot into the wilderness, an active force, not immanent. priests are all joined into one man, basically; there is not the mantal of a man over them, they are all consolidated into one man; so much so that we say the priest is really just excercising the ministry of the bishop, who is really just exercising the ministry of Christ. It consolidates into one masculine force and there is only One High Priesthood. But we are joined to the Church in a broader union; we are under the mantel of the "bride" not consolidated into one bride, but expanded out into this larger-than-ourselves "bride of Christ"; the Church is our "mother"; we are, as it were, part of her because we are in her 'womb'. Our being members of the mystical Body of Christ is also not a consolidation into one person, as the priesthood is, but being under a broader category of his mystical body; which is why, while we say we are members of the mystical Body of Christ, we do not treat the Church as if it had the masculinity of Christ in the Divine Drama, for the Church has the femininity of Christ's bridegroom united to His Body as true "flesh of His flesh, bone of His bone", united into one flesh by being bride and bridegroom. As to whether we are taking the "role" of "bridegroom" individually by taking up our cross to follow Him, we unite our Suffering to His as the Bride becomes One with the Groom, we take up Our Cross because we are united to Him who has the Headship of the Cross; I see it as us being in the role of the Bride still, in a sense, though it is true that are crosses are likened to His. It is the same way, to me, that the Church can be both "Body of Christ" and "Bride of Christ" we are both "taking up His Cross (bridegroom)" and "uniting our cross to His Cross (bride)"[/quote] Thank you! This is excellent! Exactly what I needed to hear! I'm going to rewrite it in my own words, just to make sure I understand: As the church, we are the body of Christ, we are called to take up the cross, etc. in as much as we are called to "bear the mantle of Christ", "reflect Christ (and therefore God) to the world" and work to essentially conform ourselves to the Perfect Man (and in so doing being [i]like[/i] Christ but not in such a way as to actually take on ontological unity with Christ). [b]Maybe, my use language of essence is wrong. It seems like if I use the language of essence, I may be implying that feminine aspect of the Church has to be overidden by the masculine aspect of Christ. However, I think that "mantle" might not be a strong enough word to describe the Body's conformity to Christ. Maybe I don't have a good enough understanding of the term mantle?[/b] As the bride of Christ, we are called to serve Him and serve like Him, in the uniquely feminine way we can. We cannot make His presence appear, but we can reflect a vision of Him to the world through our own actions. Whereas priests, called to bring His ontological Presence to the world must ontologically be assumed into him, and thereby they conform themselves personally and ontologically to the Perfect Man (they must conform their person to Him, as opposed to the Bride who just has to conform her essence to Him). [b]Could you site where you got this from?[/b] : Edited May 12, 2007 by The Joey-O
Aloysius Posted May 12, 2007 Posted May 12, 2007 Oh boy.... you want explanations, I'm your guy... but citations? that's another matter altogether. lol. just a bit of anthropological insight on the nature of masculinity and femininity from an anthropology major influenced by the lectures of Fr. Mark Gruber, OSB, PhD x 4 in Anthropology mixed with the nature of the priesthood and the Church as I understand it. I guess if I were to cite anything... I'd site for my understanding of the Church Pius XII's Encylcical "Mystici Corporis Christi": [quote]96. And first of all let us imitate the breadth of His love. For the Church, the Bride of Christ, is one; and yet so vast is the love of the divine Spouse that it embraces in His Bride the whole human race without exception.[/quote] To me, studying cross-cultural understandings of the sexes, I see this "Bride of Christ" femininity for its immanence as is the natural insight accross cultures about the feminine, with the analogy to the larger body of the woman overwhelming the body of both her male and female babes, it makes perfect sense with the proper anthropology of masculinity and femininity; and as Paul VI said regarding Christ's decision to ordain only men: "The real reason is that, in giving the Church her fundamental constitution, her theological anthropology-thereafter always followed by the Church's Tradition- Christ established things in this way." So it is basic to the Church's anthropology itself to have this understanding. As to the understanding of the priesthood, I guess I'd just cite John Paul II's [i]Ordinatio Sacerdotalis[/i] or something, or just any teaching that describes the priest as sharing the prieisthood of the bishop who is just sharing the priesthood of Christ; for something like that you could probably find something in the Early Church Fathers, or in a catechism somewhere... pretty basic fact about the priesthood. I used the word mantle to describe how we are united to the Bride; we are under her mantle, as it were, in her arms, or if we extend the physical nature of femininity and masculinity further, in her womb. It's a unity with a larger and broader community, that which we are joined to is larger than ourself the way a mother's body is larger than her baby's. Whereas the priesthood is not being under the mantle of a larger body, but every priest basically being consolidated into one person; not broadening into a larger and more inclusive immanent thing, but narrowing into a more specific thing. The former being by nature feminine, the latter being by nature masculine.
The Joey-O Posted May 13, 2007 Author Posted May 13, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1272077' date='May 12 2007, 06:17 PM']I used the word mantle to describe how we are united to the Bride; we are under her mantle, as it were, in her arms, or if we extend the physical nature of femininity and masculinity further, in her womb. It's a unity with a larger and broader community, that which we are joined to is larger than ourself the way a mother's body is larger than her baby's. Whereas the priesthood is not being under the mantle of a larger body, but every priest basically being consolidated into one person; not broadening into a larger and more inclusive immanent thing, but narrowing into a more specific thing. The former being by nature feminine, the latter being by nature masculine.[/quote] Ok. Then how would you describe how all are called to conform to Christ and the uniqe conformity of priests to Christ?
Aloysius Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 priests conforming to Christ is a narrowing into a specific role, the role of His priesthood. our conformity to Christ is the united of our suffering to His Suffering, our following after Him, our being like Him. we are united to His Body in the way we join to the over-arching mantle of His Bride, which is flesh of His flesh; so that is a type of 'under the mantle' thing, gathered into Him as a mother hen gathers Her Children, gathered into the Bride of Christ. we do not narrow down into a specific role, each one of us individually cannot be consolidated down into the one person of Christ, they have to be added up into the overarching person of Christ, which is why that is spoken of in the feminine of the Church as Christ's Bride which is flesh of His flesh (and thus united to the mystical Body of Christ). But we do not consolidate into one specific role of Christ, we enter into the broadening over-arching figure of His Entire Body, only some go into the head, and those some are male for all the reasons I've been discussing, and in that sense they consolidate and each share the One Headship of Christ (which is where the idea comes in that the priest acts in persona christi capitas, in the person of Christ the Head; vs the idea of one acting in persona Christi servis, the person of Christ the servant. the laity are called to the latter, the priests and religious are called to the latter as well, but on occassion as is necessitated they act in the former too.), whilst we all, including them as well, share the broader membership into the whole body because we are united under the Mantle of His Bride, Our Mother, which brings us into union with His Body. but all priests can be consolidated down into the One High Priest, they all share the same priesthood of Jesus Christ. we're all under the mantle of the Church, the mantle of Our Mother the Bride of Christ; and by that we all fall under that one category which is larger than ourselves; and we become the Body of Christ because Christ comes into His Bride infusing it and making it the True flesh of His flesh so that we are fully and substantially incorporated into His Body. All discussion of marriage creating "one flesh" is true by analogy to the TRUELY one-flesh shared by the ultimate archetype of marriage between Christ and His Church. There's a lot of deep symbols at work here, they can all be reconciled but not in a way that would make total sense according to human relationships; because human relationships only exist as analogies to these relationships; but these relationships do not carry the same biological restrictions as human relationships would. Between Christ and His Bride is not just a marriage like human marriage; human marriage only approximates that marriage by analogy; that marriage is the fullest and most complete marriage whereby we can say Christ's Bride is the Body of Christ because the two have truely become one.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now