Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Authentic And Ordinary And Etc


Recommended Posts

dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

i'm looking for clarification on infallibility. there's authentic magisterium and ordinary. the first is not infallible, but what's said must be accepted with intellect and willl. the ordinary is infallible so also must be all around accepted.

one question is what is it when the pope says we shouldnt go to war? i assume that's another category. but how do you know if it's authentic or ordinary or just another category?

another question is what is it when the church teaches you can't remarry if your spouse divorces you? things like that. how do you know if it's authentic or ordinary? or, even the extra category like saying we shouldn't go to war? i assume it's not the latter bc of the way it's treated.

there's also things like how the church, maybe not through the pope though, thought that the world was flat, and doctors working on dead bodies was a violation against God. (in the 1500s the CC thought that, i saw on TV, though i'm not sure) (i'm not sure if you can answer the last ones bc i'm not sure how it was believed)

isn't there, or couldn't there be uncertainty as to which of the three categories these and other things are? it seems like there's just what you seem to think the thing is, and usually what you think is right, and it's not reasonable to think otherwise. but.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
marielapin
Posted

I hope this answers your question. From: fisheaters.com



How Infallibility Works

The Authentic (i.e. "authoritative") Magisterium of the Church -- i.e., the teaching office of the Church exercised by proper authority -- has different levels of infallibility:

*

Extraordinary Infallible Magisterium ("Solemn Magisterium"): this is exercised when the Pope, as supreme pastor of the entire Church, speaks ex cathedra (from the Chair of Peter) and solemnly defines a dogma concerning faith and morals to be held by the entire Church, or when a Dogmatic Council convened and endorsed by a Pope formally defines a matter of faith and morals to be held by the entire Church. This is a very rarely excercised assertion of authority (only a few times in the past few hundred years). When the Pope teaches using his extraordinary infallible Magisterium, or when a Council dogmatically defines something and the Pope endorses that defintion, Catholics must believe what is taught de fide, as an article of faith.

*

Ordinary Infallible Magisterium ("Constant Magisterium" or "Universal Magisterium"): this is exercised when the Pope, Council, Bishop, priest or any authorized teacher teaches in accordance with Tradition, the Sacred Deposit of Faith, and what has been always accepted and taught by the Church in the past

*

Merely Authentic Ordinary Magisterium: any teaching by Pope, Bishop, priest, or any authorized teacher, that does not fall into the above two levels of infallibility is, quite simply, fallible, even though it may be part of the Authentic Magisterium (that is, it is "authorized" teaching). Teaching at this level is owed obedience -- as long as obeying does not harm the Faith, lead to sin or the loss of souls, does not contradict the Faith, etc. If what is being taught contradicts the Faith, it not only can be resisted, it must be resisted.


In addition to Magisterium, the Pope can, of course, simply act as a private person and offer his personal opinions on anything from current events to sports to food to movies. These may be of interest to us Catholics, who tend to sensibly love -- or at least respect the office of -- the Holy Father, but they are not "Church teaching" in any way. In the same way, a Council may be called that is pastoral and not dogmatic in nature (such as Vatican II).

Now, some Catholics forget the second level of the Magisterium, the "Ordinary Infallible Magisterium." They forget the Sacred Deposit of Faith, the unanimous agreement of the early Christian Fathers, and Sacred Tradition. These "Catholics" are the "liberal Catholics" or "modernist Catholics" you hear so much from in the media. They are the ones who root for the ordination of women, the eradication of the Christian view of homosexuality, etc. These are the well-organized, well-funded loudmouth "Catholics" who eat away at the Church's teachings and have become well-entrenched in various dioceses.

Another type of Catholic forgets about that third level of teaching that is not infallible at all. Any time the Pope teaches, he must be heard, his authority given respect, and the teaching given the benefit of the doubt because it comes from the Vicar of Christ. But if it contradicts prior infallible Magisterium, it is not infallible -- and it must not be obeyed if it proves harmful to the faith. Catholics who forget this level of Magisterium try very hard to be "orthodox" by being obedient, but they often have a false sense of obedience -- an obedience that sometimes borders on a pre-conscious papolatry ("pope worship"), though, of course, they know better and know that "worshipping the Pope" would be a terrible sin. They usually have a very healthy sensus catholicus, a desire for traditional Catholicism, and a virtuous patience, but they simply attribute to the Pope authority he does not have and they truly need to come to a better understanding of what the Magisterium is. These Catholics are often called "neo-conservatives," "conservatives," or "neo-Catholics" (they often think of and refer to themselves as "traditional Catholics" though they are not). You will see these otherwise wonderful Catholics tying themselves into knots trying to defend some of the novelties that followed Vatican II, or sweating bullets making excuses for some of the Holy Father's more scandalous actions (e.g., "ecumenical" services that include praying with Animists, Buddhists, Muslims, Jews, Protestants; allowing altar girls and "Extraordinary Eucharistic Ministers", etc.), failures to act (e.g., lack of discipline given to Bishops), and opinions (e.g., support for the anti-subsidiarity, anti-life, anti-Christ United Nations).

Their desire to protect the Holy Father is understandable -- and laudable! -- especially since the papacy has been attacked so unfairly since the Protestant Rebellion and the ensuing secular revolution, most often with outrageous lies. But these Catholics have to wake up, study a bit, and defend true Catholic teaching as it has been known for 2,000 years.


How to recognize what is and isn't infallible

If it has always been taught by the Church as a matter of faith or morals, it is infallible. If it is a solemn definition, it is infallible.

Ex., you are reading two Encyclicals. The first Encyclical reads:

Venerable Brethren, the red dogs runs at night. The cow jumped over the Moon. Jesus Christ is God. Little Jack Horner sat in a corner. Women may not be ordained to the priesthood.

In this document, the only parts which would be infallible would be the lines "Jesus Christ is God" and "women may not be ordained to the priesthood" because these have always been taught. This is teaching at the level of the Universal Magisterium, which is infallible.

The second Encyclical reads:

By the authority of our Lord Jesus Christ, of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul, and by our own authority, we pronounce, declare, and define it to be a divinely revealed dogma: that X, Y, Z. Hence if anyone, which God forbid, should dare willfully to deny or to call into doubt that which we have defined, let him know that he has fallen away completely from the divine and Catholic Faith. And, by the way, the red dog runs at night.

Notice the explicit "we define" here? Notice that it is addressed to "anyone," not just to members of the Latin Church or of the Eastern Churches, etc.? Notice the penalty in place for non-acceptance of what is being said (if you don't believe this, you have fallen away from the Catholic Faith)? By these marks, you can know that infallible teaching is being expressed.

In this document, X, Y, and Z are infallible, but not "the red dog runs at night." This is teaching at the level of the Extraordinary (or Solemn) Magisterium, which is also infallible and is to be accepted "de fide." (Note: Protestants and uneducated Catholics who ask blankly, "Is Enclyclical X infallible?" need to recognize that a 100-page Encyclical may be written that is not infallible in any way, or has 10 paragraphs that are infallible, or 1 sentence that is infallible, etc.). This sort of exercise of the Solemn Magisterium is very rare, but very necessary when clarity is needed over a teaching that has always been taught, but whose details haven't been strictly defined.

All other teachings are owed obedience as long as they do not lead to a loss of Faith, harm the Church, impede the salvation of souls, lead to an evil, etc.

Summary:

*

Always been taught and believed: infallible
*

Solemnly defined by Pope or Council: infallible
*

Other teachings: fallible, but owed religious assent unless they prove harmful, lead to sin, etc.

marielapin
Posted

you can also go here:

[url="http://mafg.home.isp-direct.com/magist03.htm"]http://mafg.home.isp-direct.com/magist03.htm[/url]

for even more information.

The Joey-O
Posted

Wow. That was excellent. I don't think I've ever seen that spelled out before.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

That was a pretty good website.
but.

It seems a little phony to say if the pope tries to teach something that hasn't always been taught that it's not infallible. Or the pope could teach something never taught then contradict that and it don't matter.
This is just a website, the problem I am presenting I cannot think of any examples, necessarily.

The website didn't really say how to tell which a teaching is though. They just explained them more. There's also the thing like women can't be priests, and priests can't marry. I've heard different ideas as t owhich is infalliable and which is not. How do you know? I mean, all admit Peter and the rest were married, and popes were married at first etc. So, it don't seem that'd be infallible but.

marielapin
Posted (edited)

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1272946' date='May 14 2007, 09:07 AM']It seems a little phony to say if the pope tries to teach something that hasn't always been taught that it's not infallible. Or the pope could teach something never taught then contradict that and it don't matter.
This is just a website, the problem I am presenting I cannot think of any examples, necessarily.

The website didn't really say how to tell which a teaching is though. They just explained them more. There's also the thing like women can't be priests, and priests can't marry. I've heard different ideas as t owhich is infalliable and which is not. How do you know? I mean, all admit Peter and the rest were married, and popes were married at first etc. So, it don't seem that'd be infallible but.[/quote]

Actually your questions were answered in the two articles I posted, but this is a pretty hard thing to wrap your mind around for anyone, much less a Catholic...when I was going through them last night I was double and triple checking that they had the answers to your questions. This is just not an easy thing understand, but it does not contradict, there are definite lines drawn. You just have to nearly be a catholic scholar to fully understand the difference between the different types of infallible teachings (and I do not claim to be one).

If a pope tries to teach something that hasn't always been taught before, to be infallible, it must be done ex cathedra. The lines of infallibility only go so far, and these lines are clearly laid out. The pope is not expected to be infallible in every statement made.

To answer your first post and recent examples, I'll give you some examples as to what would be considered infallible and what would not.

Infallible (definitively defined):
anything ex cathedra, including the assumption of mary and immaculate conception
certain outcomes of councils, where they proclaim or define teachings on dogma, including the nature of the Trinity, the divinity of Christ, etc.

Infallible (always been taught and cannot be changed, but not necessarily definitively defined by pope/councils):
Women priests
contraception
abortion
divorce/remarriage
homosexuality
dogmas of the church not defined explicitly under the first heading

"not-infallible" or authentic (these things have not been definitively defined or not always been taught)
a popes opinion on a war/current events
limbo
teaching that the world is flat
teaching on working on dead bodies
teaching on end-of-life decisions (as to when it is licit to remove a feeding tube/life support - euthanasia is considered murder and therefore infallible)
teaching on the death penalty (I am pretty sure about this one but I lost my article, other pm experts, correct me on this one if I am wrong)

Things that are disciplines (these are not infallible and can be changed)
priestly celibacy
the language of the Mass
fasting requirements for Lent/Fridays


Does that help any?

Edited by marielapin
dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

it is something ya gotta wrong your mind around. but that said, i still think a teaching could be construed either infallible or non-infallible. take working on dead bodies. this could very easily be looked at as something that has always been taught, so infallible. instead, you say it's not always been taught and not defined so not infallible. it seems like it can be construed whichever way you want...
maybe even the same with remarriage after your spouse leaves you.
well, i do know priests have said remarriage is wrong. i'll have to show that the earth is flat or working on dead bodies was taught by priests etc to prove my point.


it seems like the death penalty is taught, that today it's practically non needed. that's what it says in the catechism. yet ppl here try to say it's not infallble. i don't see how, my guess if i were catholic would be to say they are simply twisting the teaching to meet their ideology. otherwise, i have no idea how that's not infallible.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
The Joey-O
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1273066' date='May 14 2007, 12:50 PM']it is something ya gotta wrong your mind around. but that said, i still think a teaching could be construed either infallible or non-infallible. take working on dead bodies. this could very easily be looked at as something that has always been taught, so infallible. instead, you say it's not always been taught and not defined so not infallible. it seems like it can be construed whichever way you want...
maybe even the same with remarriage after your spouse leaves you.
well, i do know priests have said remarriage is wrong. i'll have to show that the earth is flat or working on dead bodies was taught by priests etc to prove my point.
it seems like the death penalty is taught, that today it's practically non needed. that's what it says in the catechism. yet ppl here try to say it's not infallble. i don't see how, my guess if i were catholic would be to say they are simply twisting the teaching to meet their ideology. otherwise, i have no idea how that's not infallible.[/quote]

Actually, Augustine said that while it's good to treat dead bodies with respect, God can reconstitute your no matter what happens to it. The argument goes that there have been martyrs whose bodies have been eaten up by lions or burnt, therefore the condition of the body post-mortum isn't of absolute concern. People didn't like scientists working on dead bodies for a long time, because every human body even a dead one deserves respect. This is still the case. The logic then was that it was disrespectful to work on human bodies in such ways. That is no longer the case. The current reasoning isn't new. It ties back to Augustine's argument that God can reconstitute the body. It was never formally, dogmatically stated, even though it was taught for a long time. But, the point is, we have proof of a lack of consensus by authoritative figures.

A good example of consistent teaching by the church is the women priests issue. Although, there wasn't a whole lot said on it prior to the previous century, women were never ordained priests. Also, what little that was said did forbid women to become priests. The vast majority of people didn't have a problem with it, so it was basically taken for granted. Now, it had to be dogmatically declared infallible. It did so not by formulating an exact definition, rather it stated that the way things had been done for 2000 years was right and is still right. This is the best example of that second category of infallibility that I know of.

I think I understand this conceptually (I think dairygirl does, too). What I don't know is: are there markers, sayings, phrases, etc. that indicate when something is being taught infallibly? I've seen some contemporary "after-the-fact" markers (like the one that declaired infallibly that women cannot be priests). However, how does one go about identifying it in older manuscripts?

marielapin
Posted (edited)

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1273066' date='May 14 2007, 11:50 AM']it is something ya gotta wrong your mind around. but that said, i still think a teaching could be construed either infallible or non-infallible. take working on dead bodies. this could very easily be looked at as something that has always been taught, so infallible. instead, you say it's not always been taught and not defined so not infallible. it seems like it can be construed whichever way you want...
maybe even the same with remarriage after your spouse leaves you.
well, i do know priests have said remarriage is wrong. i'll have to show that the earth is flat or working on dead bodies was taught by priests etc to prove my point.
it seems like the death penalty is taught, that today it's practically non needed. that's what it says in the catechism. yet ppl here try to say it's not infallble. i don't see how, my guess if i were catholic would be to say they are simply twisting the teaching to meet their ideology. otherwise, i have no idea how that's not infallible.[/quote]

Well Dan Maguire tries to insist that the teaching on contraception, abortion and homosexuality is not infallible but that does not make it so to anyone who knows church history or teaching. Remember, for a teaching to be infallible it has to be either 1-definitively defined by the pope 2- or the pope and bishops, 3- by the bishops in unison.

I would like to see you find something written by the bishops in unison on working on dead bodies, the earth is flat, etc. One or two or even six is not the bishops in unison. You need to keep this in mind. Also, not everything in the catechism is infallible. There are many things in the cathechism that are infallible, but the book itself is not. So yes, the church teaches that the death penalty is wrong. We are to submit to that will intellect and will, but if we do not, we are not in the sin of heresy, but only in error. To make the teaching on the death penalty infallible, the bishops and/or pope in unison would have to proclaim it so, which they very well could.

I know that it probably appears that I'm oversimplifying this and I can easily understand how you can say that one may construe it anyway you like. The facts are, though, that there are very clear lines drawn, just probably not how you think they should be. There is a book on this subject; Ott's "Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma."

This article by Jimmy Akin may clear things up, or may just muddy the waters for you even more. There is, however, in the comments a link to a summary of infallible church teachings listed by Ott which I will list secondly. Maybe it will help.

[url="http://jimmyakin.typepad.com/defensor_fidei/2005/05/noninfallible_t.html"]http://jimmyakin.typepad.com/defensor_fide...fallible_t.html[/url]

[url="http://sammons.gemstream.com/infallible.html"]http://sammons.gemstream.com/infallible.html[/url]



And Joey-O, yes when the pope and/or bishops are proclaiming something infallibly, they use certain binding language, proclaiming their authority and saying that the teaching is binding. See the first article I posted for examples of such language.

Edited by marielapin
Ash Wednesday
Posted

Doesn't the fisheaters site border on being, well, phishy?

[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/sites/site_view.cfm?recnum=1915"]http://www.catholicculture.org/sites/site_...cfm?recnum=1915[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...