Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

reelguy227
Posted

I think I might have asked this before, but where can I find a list of Catholic Colleges that really follow the Church's teachings? Those that would be in the same group as Ave Maria and Stuebenville. Thanks much

Ricky

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[center]J.M.J.[/center]
[quote name='reelguy227' post='1274801' date='May 16 2007, 12:13 AM']I think I might have asked this before, but where can I find a list of Catholic Colleges that really follow the Church's teachings? Those that would be in the same group as Ave Maria and Stuebenville. Thanks much

Ricky[/quote]

I don't know where a list really is, but here are some that I know of (and will be applying to myself next year).

I'm applying here:

Ave Maria
Stuebenville
Christendom College
St. Thomas Aquinas College (in Santa Paula, CA)

Here are some I've heard really good things about, but I'm not sure if I am applying too.

John Paul the Great Catholic University (really new. I believe it opened in 04' or 05')
Belmont Abbey College
Magdalen College
Benedictine College

In Jesus and Mary,
Marie

Totus Tuus
Posted

Magdalen
Ave Maria
Benedictine
Thomas Aquinas
Christendom

fearundercontrol
Posted

[quote name='TotusTuusMaria' post='1274855' date='May 16 2007, 01:48 AM'][center]J.M.J.[/center]
I don't know where a list really is, but here are some that I know of (and will be applying to myself next year).

I'm applying here:

Ave Maria
Stuebenville
Christendom College
St. Thomas Aquinas College (in Santa Paula, CA)

Here are some I've heard really good things about, but I'm not sure if I am applying too.

John Paul the Great Catholic University (really new. I believe it opened in 04' or 05')
Belmont Abbey College
Magdalen College
Benedictine College

In Jesus and Mary,
Marie[/quote]

JP is really specific. You'd only be going there if you're going for media stuff.

reelguy227
Posted

What about Gonzaga?

fearundercontrol
Posted

never heard of them. what are you thinking of going for, anyway?

reelguy227
Posted

Gonzaga Jesuit University in Spokane.

I'm going for a double in Japanese and Accounting, with a minor in Econ.

TotusTuusMaria
Posted (edited)

[center]J.M.J.[/center]
[quote name='reelguy227' post='1275025' date='May 16 2007, 11:48 AM']What about Gonzaga?[/quote]

I've heard good things and I have heard bad things about Gonzaga. I heard someone new is over them now and wants to bring back the Catholic identity to the school. How that is going to go and if it is going to go at all I don't know. I know people who really want to go there, and they are really solid Catholics. But still I have heard some not so great things about Gonzaga too. Pray about it.

I would not say Gonzaga's Catholic identity is as firmly known as Ave Maria's or Stuebenville's.

In Jesus and Mary,
Marie

Edited by TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[size=1]I was told that though Ave Maria is an AWSOME school, they are not certified by like the state or something so their degrees are not worth anything.


Or something like that....ANYONE ELSE KNOW ABOUT THIS?
[/size]

reelguy227
Posted

Really? smells of elderberries for them....

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

Ave Maria's accreditation information:
[url="http://www.naples.avemaria.edu/academics/undergraduate_programs/accredit.asp"]http://www.naples.avemaria.edu/academics/u...ms/accredit.asp[/url]

I don't know what that means, but it looks like they have some legitimacy.

Posted

I go to a little treasure called St. Mary's University in San Antonio, TX.
The Marianists (Society of Mary and Daughters of Mary Immaculate, along with lay Marianist groups) take every student in as family. [url="http://www.stmarytx.edu"]http://www.stmarytx.edu[/url]
There are many students working hard to drench the campus in our Catholic identity (myself included - yay!).

Posted

Benedictine College
www.benedictine.edu

Go Ravens!

reelguy227
Posted (edited)

I already checked out Benedictine, they don't offer the majors I'm looking for. But thanks anyway. Has anyone heard of College of St. Benedict-Saint John's University. It's a joint University in Minnesota? Seemed pretty good to me.

Edited by reelguy227
Posted

[quote name='TotusTuusMaria' post='1275294' date='May 16 2007, 05:27 PM'][center]J.M.J.[/center]
I've heard good things and I have heard bad things about Gonzaga. I heard someone new is over them now and wants to bring back the Catholic identity to the school. How that is going to go and if it is going to go at all I don't know. I know people who really want to go there, and they are really solid Catholics. But still I have heard some not so great things about Gonzaga too. Pray about it.

I would not say Gonzaga's Catholic identity is as firmly known as Ave Maria's or Stuebenville's.

In Jesus and Mary,
Marie[/quote]

I go to Gonzaga. There are some good elements here and some bad. I could go on and on with describing things here because I am one of the "orthodox Catholics" who is most active and vocal in pushing for true Catholic identity.

To put it simply, Gonzaga is not on the same level as the other well known orthodox colleges mentioned in this thread. However, our president, Fr. Spitzer, is really great, he is an awesome philosopher and scientist, who is very good with the students (I have had him over for dinner at my house along with a couple other orthodox Jesuits!). He is very pro-life, and an active writer on topics from metaphysics to culture in America. There are some other good Jesuits as well, but then there are the Jesuits here who are openly heretical. The Religious Studies department is horrible. The history department is good, and the philosophy department has some good professors as well. I am majoring in Electrical Engineering, which is why I ended up at Gonzaga and not at a college which is fully orthodox.

More bad: the University Ministry is not that great, they talk to much about your spiritual path rather than the Catholic faith, and the Masses they put on leave much to be desired (luckily, there is a beautiful Gregorian chant Mass on campus every week, which is said by diocesan priests as well as some Jesuits). The student body is very secular, and there is a lot of partying and foolishness associated with the stupid basketball team, kind of like you would find at any state school. There is a lot of debate about persons with SSA, there is a club on campus which calls itself a "Gay Straight Alliance" which does not agree with Catholic teachings, and so on. Luckily there is some good, there is a Catholic fellowship of students which gets together often to pray in front of PP and we have Lord's Day Meals together every few weeks, and there is a Right to Life club (of which I will be president in the fall) and we do good stuff. The university does not allow PP or others like that to speak on campus, so there are limits, but the Religious Studies department has a speakers series which basically teaches heresy and criticizes Church teaching, and all the Call to Action types from Spokane show up for those, as well as students getting extra credit from their religion professors.

I can't recommend Gonzaga as a good Catholic school. I like it, and I like Spokane quite a bit, but I feel like I am in the minority here (although interestingly the heretics claim that they are the minority and are oppressed by people like me).

PM me if you have any more questions, I would be happy to go into more detail.

Some of the orthodox Catholics publish a magazine called the Gonzaga Witness with various articles and such every month, you can take a look if you want, I have a few articles in there: [url="http://www.gonzagawitness.com/"]http://www.gonzagawitness.com/[/url]

farglefeezlebut
Posted

I think it's better to go somewhere secular, so there are more opportunities for evangelization.

Posted

Well, I'm looking at the 1768 page 2007 US News & World Report Ultimate College Guide...

Thousands of universities and colleges...

rankings are national leaders--first tier; regional leaders for lib arts and universities--second tier. Third and fourth tiers are after that.

[b]Ave Maria [/b]is not listed.

[b]Magdalen[/b] is not listed.

[b]Steubenville:[/b] www.franciscan.edu 1818 full time rank: #30 in Midwest Universities; SAT 25/75th: 1060-1290; tuit $17,350. ave debt on grad: $26,192.

[b]Christendom[/b]: 372 students, coed, 4th tier (out of 4 tiers; 1st tier is highest) of liberal arts colleges. www.christendom,edu. tuition $15,800. 76% accepted.

[b]Benedictine[/b], Atchison KA www.benedictine.edu. third tier; 1,176 full time. tuit $25,760/yr. Ave graduating debt $22,333.

[b]Thos Aquinas[/b] Santa Paula CA www.thomasaquinas.edu 359 full time coed; 73rd rank liberal arts colleges; tuit $19,300. Average debt at grad $14,000-fairly low. Also the ranking is higher than many Catholic colleges.
[b]
St Mary's[/b] San Antonio, www.stmarytx.edu 2,185 fulltime rank 15th 9regional, west) universities tuit $20,534. ave debt at grad; $25,736.

[b]Belmont NC[/b] 800 full time, 90 part time; Rank: 33rd south (regional) tuit: $17,728. Ave grad debt: $18,950. 76% accepted.

[b]Gonzaga [/b]in Spokane ranks high. 4000 students, rank #3 university in regional (west) tuition 25,000. ave debt 23,000. more selective-don't know how they determine this, but SAT range 1100-1300; acceptance rate 73%.

It would be very unwise to attend a college that has no ranking and is unaccredited. College credits may not transfer and much work may have to be repeated.

The best schools generally speaking will be in the first and second tiers. All the rest depends on the majors, the aid package, the location, the size, and your impression when you visit.

There are a lot of other lists which can be gone over later, such as which schools offer the most need-based aid; most and least debt; the best deals.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='reelguy227' post='1278299' date='May 20 2007, 11:19 PM']I already checked out Benedictine, they don't offer the majors I'm looking for. But thanks anyway. Has anyone heard of College of St. Benedict-Saint John's University. It's a joint University in Minnesota? Seemed pretty good to me.[/quote]
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NONONONONONONONONONONONONONONO! THEY ARE NOT GOOD! THEY ALMOST ATE MY BROTHERS!
*deep breath*
Okay, both my brothers went to SJU, and while it is good academically, the professors are really nice for the most party, they are NOT good religiously. My oldest brother...well, he was a theology/philosophy major and he left the school no longer Catholic. He has since returned, but it was REALLY bad. They are not orthodox AT ALL. My other brother forbade me from going to St. Ben's. (St. Ben's is girls, St. John's is boys) He is in comp sci and psychology, and has done really well, so they are good in that regards, as far as academics. It's really far off in religious, though. Like, really, way far, to the point of ridiculous. The nuns? Yeah, they're the sort that want women as priests. And think abortion is okay. Like, Roe v. Wade day, my brothers said they had stuff written on the sidewalks in chalk SUPPORTING the decision! Granted, not ALL the nuns are like that. There are some very fine nuns out there, but by and large, it is NOT a good, orthodox, Catholic supporting environment.
I could keep going, but, I'll leave it at this for now. Suffice it to say, don't be fooled by a wolf in sheep's clothing.

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' date='May 30 2007, 11:33 PM' post='1284984']
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NONONONONONONONONONONONONONONO! THEY ARE NOT GOOD! THEY ALMOST ATE MY BROTHERS!
*deep breath*

Yikes!

golly whiz!!

Well, anyway, here are the stats.

[b]St Johns Univ Collegeville MN[/b]

-69th in overall ranking of all liberal arts colleges-- this is relatively high.

-rated as More Selective[b][/b] Tuit $25,000. ave debt $24, 663. acceptance rate 87% prop who borrowed 63%

-1845 full time students; 30 part time. 63% RC.

www.csbsju.edu

[b]College of St. Benedict: [/b]in nearby St. Joseph: the woman's college.

2000 full time, 50 part time ;RC 66%; 86% acceptance rate ; Tuit $25,000 ; ave debt; $24,700 %; borrowed 72%

same website as St. John’s-I assume that they can take classes at each others' schools, but don't know.

BTW, do you know who was scribbling on the sidewalk on "Roe vs. Wade" day? Was it a nun? Prob a student. Free speech is in the Constitution, you know...

I have two older brothers and I made sure that they had nothing to say about where I went to college!

[b]Things to consider when selecting any college:[/b]

*% full time students AND faculty. You don’t want commuter campus unless you’re a commuter.Similarly, you don't want a lot of part-time faculty. It smacks of cost-cutting--no benefits--and you can't reach them outside of class. They might be less engaged in teaching because they don't have a full commitment to the school

*% retention rate, indicates the measure of satisfaction and degree of financial support. You don't want to make a lot of friends, only to see them leave.

*Advantage of a Catholic school, for the phatmasser effect-an RC community. You can take classes in religion and go to daily mass. Also may have religious/priests/seminarians on campus.

*% male/female in coed school. In many schools, women are in a majority, and have higher admission scores. Formerly women’s colleges now accept men to boost enrollments, but men are often not as qualified as the women in these schools. Better if the numbers and qualifications are more equal, or school was co-ed from its founding, OR is a women’s school. this will lower the morale of the women.

*More bang for the buck at a more selective school.

*Re going to a RC school: there are also good arguments for being in a minority; the ‘missionary’ effect in a secular school or a “bad” RC school, even a Jesuit school! There is an outstanding prep school in Atlanta, which is Christian, with a mandatory class in New Testament and a born-again headmaster; the school was very popular with Jewish families, as they wanted to send their kids to a school where they would be an embattled minority!

Posted

I really don't think the "missionary effect" is the best mindset to go into a school with. If you're studying theology especially, you should be very careful as to what kind of program you're getting into--I chose Franciscan because it has a great faculty that is faithful to the Magisterium. I would say it's better to go to a secular school with an excellent Newman's center or a church with a good young adult/etc group rather than a "bad" Catholic school--you may think you can guard yourself from heresy, but it's subtle. College are some of your most formative years--you are made into who you will be for the rest of your life in most cases. I know what I want to be like, and I know that while I may have a firm resolve now, if I had chosen a school with immoral students all over the place, I may have become like them. It's not by my choice but almost osmosis, I guess--and I know some people who were strong Catholics before who changed a lot. It's dangerous territory.

I vote FUS! lol. Ave isn't accredited, unfortunately, but it's a great school as well--very rigorous academics.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...