Lounge Daddy Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 [url="http://www.guardian.co.uk/medicine/story/0,,2081755,00.html"]From the Guardian Unlimited[/url] [quote][size=3][b]Hybrid embryos get go-ahead[/b][/size] UK - The government has overturned its proposed ban on the creation of human-animal embryos and now wants to allow them to be used to develop new treatments for incurable diseases such as Parkinson's and Alzheimer's. The proposal, in a new draft fertility bill published today, would allow scientists to create three different types of hybrid embryos. Scientists would be allowed to grow the embryos in a lab for no more than two weeks, and it would be illegal to implant them in a human.[/quote]
SJP Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 OK, I've got a question. It might sound silly but here goes. If God gives every Human Being a Soul, than how would we classify a manufactured half human half animal? Would that even be possible? Perhaps my rudimentary understanding of biology is showing I suppose every human being begins as an embryo, whatever might be added to that embryo is irrelevant; a human is a human is a human and must be treated as such. With the "advances" (should read perversions) of modern science, it seems that in the not too distant future, it may be difficult to distinguish between what is human and what is not.
Guest T-Bone Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 Scientists are too busy asking "Can I?" when they should be asking "Should I?"
prose Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 [quote]I suppose every human being begins as an embryo, whatever might be added to that embryo is irrelevant; a human is a human is a human and must be treated as such.[/quote] I think that they are taken an already fully formed human embryo and adding animal to it.
fearundercontrol Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 [quote name='T-Bone' post='1276375' date='May 18 2007, 03:30 AM']Scientists are too busy asking "Can I?" when they should be asking "Should I?"[/quote] Well said.
The Joey-O Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 I think something very important to keep in mind is our disposition to those who are chimeras. It is terrible that scientists mess with nature in this way. However, when they do, we cannot shun their "creations" as evil. It's unfortunate that they are made this way, just as it is unfortunate that some people are born blind. But, we still have to recognize that these people deserve love and respect. I worry that so much deserved antagonism against the messing with embryos in this way will result in antagonism toward the innocents harmed by the scientists.
SJP Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 I found this on another board and it seems to make sense: "The Soul is what animates otherwise lifeless matter. You can tell if a material creature has a soul if it is alive or not. If it is made of matter and is alive, then it has a soul. This is true from amoebas, plants, animals and humans. Humans are unique because our soul is spiritual and immortal. If you want to know if a clone has a soul, check to see if it's breathing and has a pulse. Secondly, since it is the soul that animates the body, it is a one to one relationship. One soul is animates one body. If there are two living bodies present that means two souls. One does not make a 'copy' of a soul by copying the genetic structure. There is no 'soul gene'. It is de fide teaching of the Catholic Church that souls are unique and made by God out of nothing. To say otherwise is to deny Church teaching. Human souls are also unique because they are rational. A human has the capability of reason, and this faculty is provided by the soul. So, in short: If a clone is living, it has a soul. This soul would have been created by God for that particular body. If the soul is rational, it is a human person." I suppose the same reasoning would apply to chimeras. Agree?? Disagree??
Pontifex Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 [quote name='SJP' post='1276688' date='May 18 2007, 02:13 PM']I found this on another board and it seems to make sense: "The Soul is what animates otherwise lifeless matter. You can tell if a material creature has a soul if it is alive or not. If it is made of matter and is alive, then it has a soul. This is true from amoebas, plants, animals and humans. Humans are unique because our soul is spiritual and immortal. If you want to know if a clone has a soul, check to see if it's breathing and has a pulse. Secondly, since it is the soul that animates the body, it is a one to one relationship. One soul is animates one body. If there are two living bodies present that means two souls. One does not make a 'copy' of a soul by copying the genetic structure. There is no 'soul gene'. It is de fide teaching of the Catholic Church that souls are unique and made by God out of nothing. To say otherwise is to deny Church teaching. Human souls are also unique because they are rational. A human has the capability of reason, and this faculty is provided by the soul. So, in short: If a clone is living, it has a soul. This soul would have been created by God for that particular body. If the soul is rational, it is a human person." I suppose the same reasoning would apply to chimeras. Agree?? Disagree??[/quote] Disagree. Not all living things have souls. Human beings have souls, not plants, animals, etc.
Era Might Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 Here is how Frank Sheed explains it: [quote]The mingling of spirit and matter in human actions arises from a fact which distinguishes man's spirit from all others. Ours is the only spirit which is also a soul--that is to say, the life principle in a body. God is a spirit, but has no body; the angels are spirits, but have no body. Only in man spirit is united with a body, animates the body, makes it to be a living body. Every living body--vegetable, lower animal, human--has a life-principle, a soul. And just as ours is the only spirit which is a soul, so ours is the only soul which is a spirit. --"Theology for Beginners"[/quote]
Groo the Wanderer Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 I think it has already been done.... At least, most of my family thinks I am an ape-man. Must be all the hair hm... Going for a banana now
SJP Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 [quote name='Pontifex' post='1277005' date='May 18 2007, 09:09 PM']Disagree. Not all living things have souls. Human beings have souls, not plants, animals, etc.[/quote] I was under the impression that every living thing had a soul. However, only a Human Being could have a rational soul.
Sojourner Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 [quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1277101' date='May 18 2007, 08:19 PM']I think it has already been done.... At least, most of my family thinks I am an ape-man. Must be all the hair hm... Going for a banana now [/quote]
Didacus Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 [quote name='SJP' post='1276688' date='May 18 2007, 01:13 PM']{snip} If it is made of matter and is alive, then it has a soul. This is true from amoebas, plants, animals and humans. Humans are unique because our soul is spiritual and immortal. {Snip}[/quote] A soul is by definition immortal and spiritual. Unless heaven is not eternal, the above is true, and brings to error your statement.
SJP Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Didacus' post='1277181' date='May 19 2007, 12:37 AM']A soul is by definition immortal and spiritual. Unless heaven is not eternal, the above is true, and brings to error your statement.[/quote] SUMMA THEOLOGICA: How the human soul knows what is above itself ... Question 75. Man who is composed of a spiritual and a corporeal substance: and in the first place, concerning what belongs to the essence of the soul [b]"I answer that, To seek the nature of the soul, we must premise that the soul is defined as the first principle of life of those things which live: for we call living things "animate," [i.e. having a soul], and those things which have no life, "inanimate." "[/b] CCC 367 Sometimes the soul is distinguished from the spirit: St. Paul for instance prays that God may sanctify his people "wholly", with "spirit and soul and body" kept sound and blameless at the Lord's coming. The Church teaches that this distinction does not introduce a duality into the soul. "Spirit" signifies that from creation man is ordered to a supernatural end and that his soul can gratuitously be raised beyond all it deserves to communion with God. Spirit is a non-material being. Soul is the animating principle of a living being. For human beings, our soul is spiritual (i.e. non-material) in nature. Edited May 19, 2007 by SJP
jeffpugh Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 I think SJP is right... animals have a temporal 'soul'. That is, it dies with their body... but the Human soul is spiritual and rational. That is why we have these conversations over a virtual world wide network on complex machines of silicon and plastic.
Didacus Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 I stand corrected. (why do people stand when corrected anyways? Wouldn't it be easier sitting down?)
Era Might Posted May 19, 2007 Posted May 19, 2007 [quote name='Didacus' post='1277327' date='May 19 2007, 10:12 AM']I stand corrected. (why do people stand when corrected anyways? Wouldn't it be easier sitting down?)[/quote] And yet when someone wants to correct you, they give you a dressing [i]down[/i].
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now