Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Prof Could Face Theft Charges After Confiscating Student Phone


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.jconline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070519/NEWS0501/705190334/1152/NEWS"]Story here[/url]
[quote]Judge Les Meade said he was just dealing with a class disturbance in a reasonable way when he took a cell phone away from a Purdue University student last month.

But when he refused to return the phone to the student at the end of the business law class, Meade said, Purdue police accused him of theft.

Now a special prosecutor is looking into the matter.
...
Here is Meade's version of events:

Meade, who is the elected judge of Tippecanoe Superior Court 5, has taught business law and business ethics classes in Purdue's Krannert School of Management for 28 years.

He was teaching a late-afternoon business law class on April 16 when a student's cell phone began ringing with a musical ringtone. The student, seated in the front row of the class, took out the phone, opened it and began reading messages while the phone continued to ring, according to Meade.

Meade said he could not disclose the student's name without violating federal law. The Journal & Courier has not been able to identify the student otherwise, and his version of events could not be obtained for this story.

Meade said he asked the student to turn off the phone, but the student ignored him and continued to read messages while the phone continued to ring.

Meade said he took the phone away from the student, closed it and put it in his pocket.

"It was still playing music when I put it in my pocket," Meade said. Five to 10 minutes later, he said, the phone rang again while Meade continued his lecture.

At the end of the class, the student asked Meade to return the phone, but Meade refused, saying he planned to turn it over to the Krannert dean's office the next morning.

Meade said his decision was warranted because he's never encountered a situation -- either in class or in the courtroom -- in which a person refused to turn off a cell phone when told to do so.

Meade said the student left, but a few minutes later, two Purdue police officers arrived and asked him if he had taken away the student's phone.

"You have to give it back now. If you don't, it's theft," Meade said, quoting the police officers.

Meade said he identified himself as a judge and said, "This is not theft."

The officers called Lt. Sarah Sheppard to the scene, and Sheppard told Meade that failure to return the cell phone would constitute theft.
...
Neither Meade nor the student was disciplined, Norberg said.

Since the incident, instructors in Krannert have been advised to dismiss from class any student who causes a similar disruption. If a student refuses to leave after being dismissed, police should be called, Norberg said.

"Judge Meade certainly has a right to keep his classroom in order," Norberg said. "It's just a question of the best way to deal with disruptions."[/quote]
We've had students' phones ring in class as well, but no one has ever let it keep ringing and read texts after being told to stop. I think the prof was totally within bounds to confiscate the phone and that it was ridiculous to call police ...

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1277370' date='May 19 2007, 09:32 AM'][url="http://www.jconline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070519/NEWS0501/705190334/1152/NEWS"]Story here[/url]

We've had students' phones ring in class as well, but no one has ever let it keep ringing and read texts after being told to stop. I think the prof was totally within bounds to confiscate the phone and that it was ridiculous to call police ...[/quote]

you can't snatch away something from an adult like that (although it didn't specifically say if he took it from his hands or if he gave it to him willingly?) it could have induced a struggle, and possibly violence. he should've done what they said at the end, asked him to leave or else he would call the police. poor judgment by a *judge*. i think they both are guilty of excessive ego trips..

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1277370' date='May 19 2007, 09:32 AM'][url="http://www.jconline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070519/NEWS0501/705190334/1152/NEWS"]Story here[/url]

We've had students' phones ring in class as well, but no one has ever let it keep ringing and read texts after being told to stop. I think the prof was totally within bounds to confiscate the phone and that it was ridiculous to call police ...[/quote]
agreed - i think this is part of society (especially younguns :P:) that have no respect for any authority, and when disciplined, whines about it.

Posted

[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1277372' date='May 19 2007, 09:43 AM']you can't snatch away something from an adult like that (although it didn't specifically say if he took it from his hands or if he gave it to him willingly?) it could have induced a struggle, and possibly violence. he should've done what they said at the end, asked him to leave or else he would call the police. poor judgment by a *judge*. i think they both are guilty of excessive ego trips..[/quote]
well then how is it any different in a high school setting? teachers take away notes, cell phones, etc, when they interrupt the class. it's a way of keeping order. how can you say the prof is guilty of excessive ego trip?

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1277377' date='May 19 2007, 09:48 AM']well then how is it any different in a high school setting? teachers take away notes, cell phones, etc, when they interrupt the class. it's a way of keeping order. how can you say the prof is guilty of excessive ego trip?[/quote]

high school students are mostly minors, under 18. by all means discipline them. heck, bring back corporal punishment.
this however, was in a university where most everyone is an adult. universities have campus police because you are entering the adult world, and things should be handled as such. this scenario is basically equivalent to laying hands on someone, if he did snatch it from his hands. now if it was sitting on the table i guess that would be another story..

Posted

i guess i don't see it as 'laying his hands' on him. but i guess we don't know the full story :idontknow:

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1277370' date='May 19 2007, 11:32 AM'][url="http://www.jconline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070519/NEWS0501/705190334/1152/NEWS"]Story here[/url]

We've had students' phones ring in class as well, but no one has ever let it keep ringing and read texts after being told to stop. I think the prof was totally within bounds to confiscate the phone and that it was ridiculous to call police ...[/quote]
Completely acceptable to take the phone away (imho) as it was posing a distrubance to the teacher and other students. If the student in question was too important to be bothered paying attention to the lecture that s/he had to check messages, s/he should have stayed home so as not to bother others.

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1277375' date='May 19 2007, 11:47 AM']agreed - i think this is part of society (especially younguns :P:) that have no respect for any authority, and when disciplined, whines about it.[/quote]
:yes::yes::yes:

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

I think he should have just asked the student to leave... Especially if he didn't know how to turn the phone off. If it continued to ring, the Professor should have asked the student to turn it off or leave. Especially if it continued ringing, taking it would not end the distraction.

Edited by CatholicCid
homeschoolmom
Posted

Well, he did ask the student to turn it off. When he was [i]ignored[/i] he was probably pretty taken aback-- seriously, who has the... uh... guts to ignore their law professor? He probably had not thought out to clearly his game plan. "Okay... if a student ever ignores my request to turn off his phone and just goes about his business as though we aren't there, I will just ask him to leave." He was probably mad that it kept ringing and just took it.

Guest T-Bone
Posted

One of my professors had the posted class policy that your phone can ring twice during the year. The first time, it costs you one letter grade. The second time you'd fail the class. (He did have the exception of phones needed for medical emergencies.)

Another one had the policy (approved by the university) that the second time a phone rang in class, the professor would "dissect" it (with a hammer).

CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1277506' date='May 19 2007, 01:29 PM']Well, he did ask the student to turn it off. When he was [i]ignored[/i] he was probably pretty taken aback-- seriously, who has the... uh... guts to ignore their law professor? He probably had not thought out to clearly his game plan. "Okay... if a student ever ignores my request to turn off his phone and just goes about his business as though we aren't there, I will just ask him to leave." He was probably mad that it kept ringing and just took it.[/quote]

Yes, but once the class is over, then the item should be returned. As said, it's college. You're not dealing with little kids and can go "I'll take this and you can have it back at the end of the school year."

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1277683' date='May 19 2007, 03:28 PM']Yes, but once the class is over, then the item should be returned. As said, it's college. You're not dealing with little kids and can go "I'll take this and you can have it back at the end of the school year."[/quote]
Well, yes, I agree with that. However, I would immediately institute a new phone policy like the ones T-Bone posted.

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone' post='1277620' date='May 19 2007, 01:01 PM']One of my professors had the posted class policy that your phone can ring twice during the year. The first time, it costs you one letter grade. The second time you'd fail the class. (He did have the exception of phones needed for medical emergencies.)

Another one had the policy (approved by the university) that the second time a phone rang in class, the professor would "dissect" it (with a hammer).[/quote]

the first part is probable, but i doubt the dissecting was actually "approved by the university"!

for those that approve of such actions, put it this way, what if it is attached to your belt? is he going to lift your shirt and pull it off? if in your pocket, is he going to reach in your pocket? does it need to be in your hands? sitting on the table? what if in your purse on the table? as you can see this can cause a lot of legal implications and calling the campus security is the only viable option. i'd like to see a professor pull my pda from my cold dead hands inside my blue jeans. (ok forget the last part.)

Posted

the article says the student had it in his hands and was reading messages from it.

and i would say if it's ringing but not visible, i would ask for the phone. if the student refused to give it up, i would ask the student to leave. and if the student wouldn't leave, i would call the police.

Posted

personally I think it'd have been perfectly acceptable to destroy the phone with a hammer on the spot, morally speaking. "they're adults"? please. any "adult" who disrespects his professor in class forfeits any right to adult treatment. moreover, "adults" in the real world outside of the University Setting do not have licence to be rude in public places with their cell phones.

of coruse, destroying it wouldn't have been legal, but it would have been absolutely just and moral.

confiscating it, however, was perfectly legal. by being in the classroom, he legally consented to being under the authority of the teacher. this judge was absolutely correct.

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1277762' date='May 19 2007, 03:07 PM']personally I think it'd have been perfectly acceptable to destroy the phone with a hammer on the spot, morally speaking. "they're adults"? please. any "adult" who disrespects his professor in class forfeits any right to adult treatment. moreover, "adults" in the real world outside of the University Setting do not have licence to be rude in public places with their cell phones.

of coruse, destroying it wouldn't have been legal, but it would have been absolutely just and moral.

confiscating it, however, was perfectly legal. by being in the classroom, he legally consented to being under the authority of the teacher. this judge was absolutely correct.[/quote]

hm do you not live in the US? i know that in other countries teachers are highly respected and sometimes students respect them more than their parents. however, here teachers do not have any authority that violates rights over other people. US citizens can be as rude as they want outside, and boy do they use that right. sometimes even worse in class than outside. it's a shame really, teachers are sometimes treated like dirt, and they know they can't do anything otherwise they would have a lawsuit on the school district and they would likely have their job compromised.

therefore, confiscating it was not legal here in the US. there is no release of basic rights to the teacher when in the classroom unless specifically written for some odd reason. basically a student can do whatever the heck he pleases - run around the classroom like a madman and no one can legally do anything if he isn't harming or in danger of harming anyone, until the police come and tackle him down. the judge made an emotionally charged mistake. the only person that could have done such a thing would have been the peace officer, but the student beat him to it by calling them first.

Posted

I'm from the US. the Judge is from the US, and knows the law better than you probably, and he knew that he had the right to confiscate that phone. the police were wrong to side with this student, the student has made an implicit contract with the teacher (actually, likely explicitly laid out in some type of syllabus) that he will not disrupt the classroom. He is bound to follow that; if he does not, the teacher has every right to remove that which he is causing a distraction with; and he needn't give it back, he can give it to the institution (the dean) where the student can then retreive it. That is not a violation of any rights; it should be the same out in the real world.

And I still believe in etiquette, and I still believe no one has the right to be rude in society and some snotty nosed college student here is claiming rights that I do not believe should be afforded to anyone. I'm not saying it should be illegal, but people have the right to confront him and stop his behavior if he is doing something like that and disrupting a restaurant or a movie theatre.

All I'm saying is this brat of a kid has gone and whined to the cops when he was in the wrong. I pine for the days when the teacher could have smacked this kid (I do not call him an adult, one must earn the right to be called an adult, not just by age or by attending college, but by acting respectably) upside the head.

If it was illegal, which I do not believe it was (because the student had submitted himself to the authority of the university by attending class there), then I disagree with the law.

ofpheritup
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1277762' date='May 19 2007, 04:07 PM']personally I think it'd have been perfectly acceptable to destroy the phone with a hammer on the spot, morally speaking. "they're adults"? please. any "adult" who disrespects his professor in class forfeits any right to adult treatment. moreover, "adults" in the real world outside of the University Setting do not have licence to be rude in public places with their cell phones.

of coruse, destroying it wouldn't have been legal, but it would have been absolutely just and moral.

confiscating it, however, was perfectly legal. by being in the classroom, he legally consented to being under the authority of the teacher. this judge was absolutely correct.[/quote]

I agree, also if this person was "so adult" where was the "adult" consideration that the phone is turned off before entering the classroom so as not to disturb the other students. "Adults" tend to think about others.

homeschoolmom
Posted

No one has any legal right to be rude and disrespectful and expect no consequences. Just becuase people often get away with being rude here does not mean that they should get their dander up when they are called on it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...