Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

All,

Am I being too fearful?

I recently tried to correct my 4 year old little girl on her input of 'magic.'

Here are some problems:
-Has trouble learning what is real (Jesus is God, we will go to heaven) with make believe (Barbie, Aslan)
-When asked what Angels do to help us, she answer, "They use magic."


The straw that broke the camels back was when she made a wish before blowing a dandeloin. I told her she was to say a prayer.


I suppose my "Halloween and Dungeons and Dragons is evil" upbringing is bugging me.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

When I was a kid, I loved to play D&D. ;)

In honesty, I think the real problem is that the history of Christianity is so foreign to our modern culture. For example:

Ask a little girl to start naming Disney princesses and telling you who they are. Or, ask a little child to start naming the characters in Harry Potter (or their favorite story) and talk about each of the characters.

Then, ask the same child to start naming Jesus' twelve Apostles (or broaden it to any historical saint), and ask who each of them are.

I suspect that they will know quite a bit about the former (i.e. our secular culture), and not too much about the latter (i.e. our Christian culture).

My point is: I'm not so concerned about the message of Harry Potter or Disney princesses. I'm more concerned that we are inundated with popular culture to the point that our own Christian history has been nearly drowned out. The only solution I can think of is to educate myself and those around me (particularly my daughter) about our Christian Culture.

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1277886' date='May 20 2007, 05:18 AM']Here are some problems:
-Has trouble learning what is real (Jesus is God, we will go to heaven) with make believe (Barbie, Aslan)
-When asked what Angels do to help us, she answer, "They use magic."
The straw that broke the camels back was when she made a wish before blowing a dandeloin. I told her she was to say a prayer.
I suppose my "Halloween and Dungeons and Dragons is evil" upbringing is bugging me.[/quote]
IMHO you don't need to worry. She'll sort out truth from fiction soon enough.
It would probably be too much to expect a 4-year-old to distinguish conceptually between, say, magic and miracle.
Some very rigorous Christian (I hope not Catholic) parents used to punish their children for indulging in make-believe at all. Think what harm that must have done? I don't mean to compare you with them of course. :)

Posted

It can take time and patience to help sort out the difference between magic and make-believe and prayer and grace. Just keep doing what you are doing and eventually she'll sort it out with your help.

The Joey-O
Posted

I believe that children may confuse things like magic with reality. I was obsessed with fantasy and sci-fi as a kid, but I didn't grow up to believe in things like magic and super-powers. As you get older, you realize what is real and what isn't.

*whispers* Now to go feed my unicorn...

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='The Joey-O' post='1278228' date='May 21 2007, 02:09 AM']I believe that children may confuse things like magic with reality. I was obsessed with fantasy and sci-fi as a kid, but I didn't grow up to believe in things like magic and super-powers. As you get older, you realize what is real and what isn't.

*whispers* Now to go feed my unicorn...[/quote]

Haha! :lol_roll:

No, I agree. I mean, when I was 4, I made up all sorts of scenarios with the My Little Ponies I had, and watched Star Wars with my brother, and various things. I loved those things, and even tried to fly like Superman, but of course grew out of that. Fact and fiction can be more difficult concepts sometimes (as I learned after teaching elementary kids for almost 2 years), but having a healthy imagination isn't such a bad thing. And she'll get it, because you're there to set a good example for her, jswranch. :)

Posted

Thanks guys.

Posted (edited)

In this line, a lot of Catholics are really scared of the Harry Potter series.

But I don't really know any kids who think Harry Potter is real... :idontknow: And really besides the magic and all that, there's not anything all that objectionable about the content from what I can tell. One of my college friends even has a book called "The Gospel According to Harry Potter" which is supposed to show how the Harry Potter books promote Gospel values. I've only ever read the first Harry Potter book so I can't judge...

Edited by Maggie
Posted

Your daughter is being influenced by culture.

She needs Biblical training.

THe Catholic Church and most mainline Prot. churches have fallen down on this. They concede to culture. There are many Catholics who think Harry Potter is great. As an ex UU pagan, I know Harry potter teaches many things of the occult first hand including symbology most people are not familiar with.

That may be the Holy Spirit reminding you of your previous upbrining.

Posted

[quote name='Budge' post='1281627' date='May 26 2007, 09:33 AM']Your daughter is being influenced by culture.

She needs Biblical training.

THe Catholic Church and most mainline Prot. churches have fallen down on this. They concede to culture. There are many Catholics who think Harry Potter is great. As an ex UU pagan, I know Harry potter teaches many things of the occult first hand including symbology most people are not familiar with.

That may be the Holy Spirit reminding you of your previous upbrining.[/quote]

This isn't the debate table, Budge.

farglefeezlebut
Posted

These books teach children that they must stand up for good even if it means risking their own lives, their own happiness, their relationships with friends and family.
These books teach children that there is nothing more powerful than love.
They aren't damaging.

Markjwyatt
Posted (edited)

jswranch:

This is something that I have struggled with all my life. I have two daughters (9 and 10), and have had similar experiences. I want them to be children and grow up with happiness, but I also want them to understand the realities.

One of the things I did to help offset the secular ideas was to introduce Catholic ideas in the same form. I bought several of the [url="http://www.catholicfamilycatalog.com/ccc.htm"] CCC videos for childern[/url]. This includes videos on Fatima, Lourdes, Guadalupe, St. Francis, St. Francis Xavier, St. Nicholas, Columbus, etc. When they were 5-7 they watched these quite often. Even now they occassionally watch them. I also bought a series of [url="http://www.emmanuelbooks.com/product_detail.cfm?ID=759"]St. Joseph picture books[/url]. These are basically childrens cathecism books, nicely illustrated, short, and fairly traditional. I read these to them when they were younger, and as they got older they read them. I assure you your four year old will be fascinated by these videos, and they will give her a positive influence later on. I actually learned a lot by watching them (but don't tell anyone)! In short, don't get frustrated, take action and take what your child sees in to your own hands. Don't let the world decide what is availible to them. That is not to say that children should not watch some [carefully chosen] secular videos, also.

You are not being too fearful. We are living in the age of the Apocalypse- i.e., the Church Age. The beasts (the one with the seven heads and the one who looks like a lamb) are active and using every secualr means to attack the gospel. This is the reality of the Church Age, as taught to St. John through his vision (see my [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=68557"]thread[/url] here). We need to understand that the secular culture is used against the Church, but not be too fearful because we know that we are "sealed on the forehead" (i.e., baptism, the other sacraments, Mass, Eucharist) and can exist in this world. Still we need to understand what we are up against, and that is exactly the primary purpose of the Apocalypse- to tell us how the Church age works (not to predict future events). After finally studying the Apocalypse (see my reviews), I wonder if all parents (if not all Catholics) should not be required to do the same for the perspective it gives you.


Mark Wyatt
www.veritas-catholic.blogspot.com

Edited by Markjwyatt
phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='The Joey-O' post='1278228' date='May 20 2007, 10:09 PM']I believe that children may confuse things like magic with reality. I was obsessed with fantasy and sci-fi as a kid, but I didn't grow up to believe in things like magic and super-powers. As you get older, you realize what is real and what isn't.

*whispers* Now to go feed my unicorn...[/quote]
haha!! you're awesome dude. good to see you at phatmass again.

Posted

Thanks all.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...