Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

The Joey-O
Posted

First, let me describe the situation where I orignally encountered my problem:

My wife and I had an old friend from out of town visit for the weekend. My wife hadn't been feeling well the whole weekend (pretty bad back pain, etc, not anything contageous). My wife did a pretty good job of toughing stuff out and being nice. However, there were times where all she wanted to do was stay in the house and lay down. We did some of that, and I could tell my friend was getting pretty board. He didn't say anything, because he knew my wife wasn't feeling well. I felt really torn, because I wanted to help my wife feel better and be with her. And, I wanted to show our friend a good time; I felt obligated as host. Needless to say, they both got mad at me. And, I ended up yelling, because I was stressed.

I think that I could have handled things better, if I had a clearer understanding of what the right thing to do was. So, I'm asking you all to help me. As a Catholic husband, should my focus, in general, be my family, with service to the rest of humanity secondary? Or, should there be an agreement between my wife and I, that together we should sacrifice our well-being for the sake of others within reasonable limits?

Posted

Wasnt me..:P

best wishes to your girl.

In my view it depends on the friend. if you and I were chillin I would want you to care for the wifey and just let me go with the flow, or go and come back another day. The issue is debating "entertaining" a guest, and taking care of your wife. There is no need to entertain the guest. There is no obligation to host.

ofpheritup
Posted

[quote name='The Joey-O' post='1280519' date='May 24 2007, 12:49 PM']First, let me describe the situation where I orignally encountered my problem:

My wife and I had an old friend from out of town visit for the weekend. My wife hadn't been feeling well the whole weekend (pretty bad back pain, etc, not anything contageous). My wife did a pretty good job of toughing stuff out and being nice. However, there were times where all she wanted to do was stay in the house and lay down. We did some of that, and I could tell my friend was getting pretty board. He didn't say anything, because he knew my wife wasn't feeling well. I felt really torn, because I wanted to help my wife feel better and be with her. And, I wanted to show our friend a good time; I felt obligated as host. Needless to say, they both got mad at me. And, I ended up yelling, because I was stressed.

I think that I could have handled things better, if I had a clearer understanding of what the right thing to do was. So, I'm asking you all to help me. As a Catholic husband, should my focus, in general, be my family, with service to the rest of humanity secondary? Or, should there be an agreement between my wife and I, that together we should sacrifice our well-being for the sake of others within reasonable limits?[/quote]

Your wife and your family are your first priority. If your friend had indeed been a "friend" they would have understood. Your last line is interesting. If you sacrifice your well being then how are you going to be able to help others? There are no "reasonable limits" when taking care of your health.

This is just my opinion but if I had been the friend and seeing what was going on my little "servant" mode would have kicked in. I would not have made you feel what "uncomfortable" for trying to take care of your wife.

The Joey-O
Posted

Hmmm...Could I blame this on the fact that my friend is a liberation theologian? I think I should. ;)

He wasn't trying to make us feel uncomfortable. I just know him well enough to know that he was getting board . His grumpiness wouldn't have shown had I not made a few mistakes from being stressed. I don't want to make him sound like a bad guy.

The Joey-O
Posted

[quote name='ofpheritup' post='1281135' date='May 25 2007, 07:34 AM']Your wife and your family are your first priority. If your friend had indeed been a "friend" they would have understood. Your last line is interesting. If you sacrifice your well being then how are you going to be able to help others? There are no "reasonable limits" when taking care of your health.

This is just my opinion but if I had been the friend and seeing what was going on my little "servant" mode would have kicked in. I would not have made you feel what "uncomfortable" for trying to take care of your wife.[/quote]

May be my language was wrong in my post. The idea I had in that option was that my wife and I become a "team" in service. As a team, there is a certain emphasis on each other. However, in that option, if it comes to a friend's hospitatlity or each other's, we would have an agreement to take care of the friend first. Not at the sacrifice of each other's health. It would be more like a sacrifice of each other's comfort.

NOTE: I'm not really disagreeing with you, ofpheritup; you make some good points. I'm just clarifying.

ofpheritup
Posted

[quote name='The Joey-O' post='1281154' date='May 25 2007, 07:45 AM']NOTE: I'm not really disagreeing with you, ofpheritup; you make some good points. I'm just clarifying.[/quote]
:D: Okee Dokee!! Not a problem.

Posted

[quote name='The Joey-O' post='1281151' date='May 25 2007, 08:40 AM']Hmmm...Could I blame this on the fact that my friend is a liberation theologian? I think I should. ;)

He wasn't trying to make us feel uncomfortable. I just know him well enough to know that he was getting board . His grumpiness wouldn't have shown had I not made a few mistakes from being stressed. I don't want to make him sound like a bad guy.[/quote]


Taylor?

Tell him to booger off, He should know better...What other Liberation theologian do you know? Aint Chad. (loves Moltmann but is not a liberation theologian)

Im curious now cause I wanna give them a wedgy

Posted

Your first responsiblity is to your wife.

Especially if shes sick, let the friend, who sounds like he was doing just fine, come back on another day.

No decent friend would ask you to ignore a sick wife, to entertain them.

Theologian in Training
Posted

If the shoe was on the other foot, and it was his wife, what would you do?

Do that :)

The Joey-O
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1281467' date='May 25 2007, 10:43 PM']Taylor?

Tell him to booger off, He should know better...What other Liberation theologian do you know? Aint Chad. (loves Moltmann but is not a liberation theologian)

Im curious now cause I wanna give them a wedgy[/quote]

I will emphasize again. He was not trying to let on that he was bored or upset. It's only because I know him so well that I knew that he was board.

Posted

[quote name='The Joey-O' post='1281882' date='May 27 2007, 07:24 AM']I will emphasize again. He was not trying to let on that he was bored or upset. It's only because I know him so well that I knew that he was board.[/quote]

With a good friend, I would just be honest and say something like "I am feeling really bad because I know you must be bored, but my wife is sick and really needs me right now. Is there anything I can do to make things better for you, and still take care of her?"

And if he was a good friend, he would have said something like, "Wow, don't feel bad about me - I'm fine. I'll find something to do to amuse myself - you go take care of the wife!"

Honesty goes a long way towards solving relationship problems.

I don't think it's reasonable to expect your wife to be a "team" sacrifice - only she knows how she is feeling and what she needs. I would put compassion for her ahead of expectations of sacrifice. The friend was not sick and if all he had to endure was a little boredom - then so be it.

The Joey-O
Posted

[quote name='nunsense' post='1281962' date='May 26 2007, 10:14 PM']With a good friend, I would just be honest and say something like "I am feeling really bad because I know you must be bored, but my wife is sick and really needs me right now. Is there anything I can do to make things better for you, and still take care of her?"

And if he was a good friend, he would have said something like, "Wow, don't feel bad about me - I'm fine. I'll find something to do to amuse myself - you go take care of the wife!"

Honesty goes a long way towards solving relationship problems.

I don't think it's reasonable to expect your wife to be a "team" sacrifice - only she knows how she is feeling and what she needs. I would put compassion for her ahead of expectations of sacrifice. The friend was not sick and if all he had to endure was a little boredom - then so be it.[/quote]

Great answer!

I think that the specific situation has been adequately addressed. How would ya'll define the principle applied in this situation?

Posted

Your wife comes first over a buddy?

:idontknow:

farglefeezlebut
Posted

Help the person who needs help the most.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...