Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

in a ring with refs, etc., sure

but a couple of kids in a backyard? In my day we called that a "fight." And setting that up and allowing it is at best questionable with regard to the legality of it.

And although I know Norseman is in favor of settling disagreements with his fists, but I personally find that a pretty poor way to deal with an argument. Sure it can be effective, but aren't we given reasoning capabilities for a purpose?

I'm not against fighting in general ... have gone to a few boxing matches, even. But to do it as a sport is one thing. To encourage it as a means of "resolving" disagreements is quite another.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1282152' date='May 27 2007, 02:22 PM']in a ring with refs, etc., sure

but a couple of kids in a backyard? In my day we called that a "fight." And setting that up and allowing it is at best questionable with regard to the legality of it.

And although I know Norseman is in favor of settling disagreements with his fists, but I personally find that a pretty poor way to deal with an argument. Sure it can be effective, but aren't we given reasoning capabilities for a purpose?

I'm not against fighting in general ... have gone to a few boxing matches, even. But to do it as a sport is one thing. To encourage it as a means of "resolving" disagreements is quite another.[/quote]

Yeah, I don't know about the backyard thing but I was just saying it is possible if they did the right way as a "one-time" thing even.

Posted

[quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1282158' date='May 27 2007, 01:28 PM']Yeah, I don't know about the backyard thing but I was just saying it is possible if they did the right way.[/quote]
ok, I'll grant that it may not be illegal if done in the right way

but even if it is legal there are still much better ways of handling a disagreement

Norseman82
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1282160' date='May 27 2007, 02:30 PM']but even if it is legal there are still much better ways of handling a disagreement[/quote]

A "DISAGREEMENT"?

Abby, no disrespect intended, but please get your head out of the sand! Choking someone is not a mere "disagreement" - it is a life-threatening situation! You have to dethrone the bully from his "alpha dog" position, otherwise you risk him continuing this with someone else, and since he is only 13 it will probably only get worse, especially if this is in an urban area where there are gangs. Trust me, I live in Chicago, and the park district runs boxing programs for youth in many of the parks in high-crime areas of the city, and I'm sure it servs to keep many, if not most, of them out of trouble and it gives many of them the only positive adult male role models and attention in their lives.

And if you knew anything about sparring in a gym, you would know that people who engage in it wear protective equipment, including mouthguards and headgear. You have a brother or two in the military - I know you mentioned about one in the Marines - I'm sure that they could verify what I'm saying.

In fact, I think charges should be filed (at least to get it on the record) and then the sentence can be suspended subject to a gym session. And after they spar, there might be a strange side effect: [i]the two of them might become friends[/i], and Thessalonian's stepson might be a good influence on the other kid.

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

yeah ... I am still not convinced that more physical violence, even in a controlled environment, is the best way to resolve this issue. And I've lived in pretty urban areas as well.

Thankfully, this isn't a situation I personally have to deal with at the moment, so perhaps the best thing I can do is pray for wisdom for Thess. :)

Norseman82
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1282180' date='May 27 2007, 02:59 PM']yeah ... I am still not convinced that more physical violence, even in a controlled environment, is the best way to resolve this issue. And I've lived in pretty urban areas as well.

Thankfully, this isn't a situation I personally have to deal with at the moment, so perhaps the best thing I can do is pray for wisdom for Thess. :)[/quote]

I think the key here is that if you do this in a controlled environment, then it ceases to be mere "physical violence" and becomes more a sporting competition. At least this way, "honor can be served" with Thess' stepson, and if Thess's stepson is victorious or holds his own, he can show forgiveness to the other kid as a way of being "magnaminous in victory".

And the reason I brough this alternative up is that if this is done properly, the two may actually develop a friendship. I know that sounds weird (and I know there is always the risk of it backfiring), but males have a tendency to develop respect for one another in this type of situation. Additionally, since the alternative with pressing charges may result in the other kid getting lost in or eaten up by the criminal justice system (as was the concern expressed by a previous poster regarding "ruining the kid's life"), it is a way of making sure the other kid is not simply discarded in the system paperwork.

Maybe it's just one of those "testosterone things" that males have to deal with, but I'd rather have it done in the gym than in a street fight with the possibility of deadlier weapons (which is where the other kid might be headed if he continues down this path).

And at least during this time there can be a "cooling off" period, and considering that Thess takes his faith seriously, I'm sure that he already is praying for wisdom about this (and will, no doubt, receive it).

Edited by Norseman82
thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='God the Father' post='1282100' date='May 27 2007, 01:05 PM']Ruining this kid's life isn't enough? I mean sure he deserves it but you've pretty much gone as far as you can go.[/quote]


Thank you for your opinion but you and I see this on a different level. I believe that consequences are for the correction of this young man's soul. If he has no or limited consequneces he will not be reformed and will end up doing this when it can land him in jail. Right he is a juvenile and so the consequences are not permanent. When he is an adult it will affect his life to a far greater degree than now. I consider it mercy to have him brought to realize the seriousness of his actions. The police reports have been made and he is being prosecuted. It will do him good in the end.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Police report is in and prosecution is going forward. The officer for the school says there is a 50/50 chance that he will fight it and my kid will have to go to court.

I found out the teacher was out copying some papers for here next class when it happened. :maddest:

Edited by thessalonian
homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1284467' date='May 30 2007, 04:28 PM']Police report is in and prosecution is going forward. The officer for the school says there is a 50/50 chance that he will fight it and my kid will have to go to court.

I found out the teacher was out copying some papers for here next class when it happened. :maddest:[/quote]
While I don't think that the teacher should have been out of the room, it wasn't like she went out for a smoke.

That said, I hope the system doesn't fail your stepson.

Posted

JMJ
5/30 - Eighth Wednesday

Sounds like we need to go whompin' on some little kids. :boxer:

j/k

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1284497' date='May 30 2007, 05:03 PM']While I don't think that the teacher should have been out of the room, it wasn't like she went out for a smoke.

That said, I hope the system doesn't fail your stepson.[/quote]


Even if its for copies, *always* leaving the kids unattended is a big no-no.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1284593' date='May 30 2007, 07:25 PM']Even if its for copies, *always* leaving the kids unattended is a big no-no.[/quote]
I know. I said that. :mellow:

Posted

Press charges.

Absolutely.

Is your son interested in karate?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...