Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

reelguy227
Posted

I'm torn between deciding on getting a laptop for college or upgrading my desktop. What should I do? I've heard advantages from both sides of the story. It's just that I really don't want to spend 1200 dollars on a laptop when I can upgrade my computer for half that. Thanks

Ricky

philosophette
Posted (edited)

I think that it really depends upon your personality and work type. I got a laptop for college because I know that I cannot stand being home a lot to do my homework, so I would go to bookstores, libraries, coffee shops and such to do my work and it was great. It also made it easy to use the lag time between classes to do work so that I would have more free time.

I would find a desktop to be really inconvenient because it is tied to one place, you cannot take it out to work on something if you get sick of being in your room, and it is bulky.

One thing to be aware of, though, is if you get a laptop GET a good insurance policy on it from the place you buy it because it WILL probably break when your life depends upon it... or at least know how to fix most problems. Generally the problems are related to them taking a beating (monitor and such)... and invest in a good USB flash drive to backup your work.

Do not get a laptop over 7lbs. The less the better. My first one was 8lbs and it nearly killed me. My new is is a lot less and it has made a world of difference.

Invest in a good backpack that pads the shoulders and has good padding for the laptop with plenty of room for power cords and such. After trying many different options I found one that is FANTASTIC. It is the O'GIO backpack. [url="http://www.academicsuperstore.com/market/marketdisp.html?PartNo=786833&sourcecode=s10142&promocode=se01L6"]Here is the one that I have[/url] and [url="http://www.ogio.com/product.php?product=125&nav=0"]here. [/url]
[url="http://www.ogio.com/products.php?category=41"]and another link for other styles. [/url]

Needless to say, at least 1GB RAM and 60 GB Memory.... or you might as well use a typewriter. ;)

I hope this helps.

Edited by philosobrat
Posted

get an abacus


those are pretty sweet.

journeyman
Posted

that's not what you told the rev . . .

besides, an abacus is lousy for word processing and a web browser is a non-standard plug in

Posted

ok fine, you got me

I much prefer a laptop to a desktop ... but then, I really value portability. I use mine in class to take notes, during study group, and in personal study. I could never do that stuff with a desktop. Except the personal study, of course.

All this is aided by the fact that my school is set up to accommodate laptops ... wireless internet, wireless printers, etc. Most people have laptops. Some also have desktops. I don't know how undergrad institutions are ... back in the day, when I was in undergrad, not many people had computers period ... we all used school computers. Things have definitely changed ...

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Depends if you plan on actually DOING your homework and such.

I had a desktop in college and spent way too much time on games and BBS sites (precursor of the internet..YES I'm THAT old). One of the few times I actually used it for homework, I accidentally transferred a virus to the school's mainframe. oops. :unsure:


so -
homework and studies - laptop
hardcore gaming sessions - desktop

Totus Tuus
Posted

Amen, Groo.

Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1281982' date='May 26 2007, 10:25 PM']Depends if you plan on actually DOING your homework and such.

I had a desktop in college and spent way too much time on games and BBS sites (precursor of the internet..YES I'm THAT old). One of the few times I actually used it for homework, I accidentally transferred a virus to the school's mainframe. oops. :unsure:
so -
homework and studies - laptop
hardcore gaming sessions - desktop[/quote]
yeah ... good point

I am not a big gamer, so a laptop suffices for me. I only have one game on it and I haven't played in months ...

Posted

Laptop all the way! Desktops are so bulky. Dorm rooms are tiny--you want all the space you can get. If you need your desk for something, you can always fold up your laptop and put it up on some shelf or something. And you can take it with you to classes, study groups, the library, the coffee shop, etc.

I second the whole getting insurance thing--get the highest insurance you can and don't skimp. With mine, I can basically throw my laptop off a building and get a new one. Not that I would--but it's comforting. Accidents happen, and it's reassuring to know that if your screen breaks, or you accidentally pour water in the keyboard, or something like that, you're covered--and when you carry your laptop everywhere, who knows what'll happen? You could drop it accidentally. A lot of insurance is money wasted, but I really don't think that's the case with a laptop.

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='jiyoung' post='1282022' date='May 27 2007, 01:50 AM']Desktops are so bulky.[/quote]
Not if you get a Mac. :thumbsup:

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I really dislike desktops, so my vote goes to the laptop (and BTW, they're making laptops more gamer compatible these days, too lol).

Posted

Well, I'm going to share with you a piece of information that my brother gave me. I was intending to buy a laptop next year, also for University/College. But my brother mentioned to me, that do I really need it? He is in college and he has a laptop, but really, it's not an ABSOLUTE necessity. Plus, a few years down the road, if you want to upgrade your laptop...good luck with that. You'll most likely land up buying a new one. Whereas if you have a desktop, you can upgrade it for 1/4 the price of a new laptop.

So, I've changed my mind, I'm keeping my desktop, it saves me money. Plus if I need to do homework, I'd just go to the computer lab or library or whatever at the University and use it.

Just thought I would share. It's up to you, if you're on the go a ton, and you don't spend much time at home, a laptop would be better. And yes, get the slimmest lightest laptop you can find if you do decide to get one!

Posted

i would say definitely get a laptop. they are so much easier to carry around. When your roommate has friends over until 1 in the morning and you have a 10 page paper to write, you will probably want to go somewhere else. How are you gonna do that with a desktop??

Laptop all the way. its better in the long run

Theologian in Training
Posted

All good points, but, based on what he has said, he already has a computer, a desktop. He seems to be watching his wallet, which is smart given college kids don't make a lot of money, and, if he is in college, the dorm room will be the majority of where homework will get done unless, of course, he just uses the computer lab.

Based on what you have said Ricky, and your needs, I would say your best bet would be to upgrade the computer. You can do it for cheap, maybe even less than half of that laptop you are looking at...provided you have the skills to do so. (BTW, I assumed you did, if not, then best bet is laptop).

Check this site out, it is designed for people who build their own computers and just want parts rather than whole computers. Besides, they are a more inexpensive way to go.

[url="http://www.newegg.com/"]http://www.newegg.com/[/url]

Posted

[quote name='chelsea' post='1282076' date='May 27 2007, 10:24 AM']i would say definitely get a laptop. they are so much easier to carry around. When your roommate has friends over until 1 in the morning and you have a 10 page paper to write, you will probably want to go somewhere else. How are you gonna do that with a desktop??

Laptop all the way. its better in the long run[/quote]
That is a really good point. Many times your room is not the best place to study ... I had a roommate who liked to study until the wee hours with lights and music on ... it drove me nuts.

Like Dudette said, laptops are not an absolute necessity. And I know I won't be upgrading my laptop later -- I'll be getting a new one, so there are additional expenses associated with them. But they sure do make life simpler.

God the Father
Posted

Before I read the thread I would have definitely said upgrade the desktop but what people have said changed my mind. Laptop seems to be the way to go.

reelguy227
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1282078' date='May 27 2007, 11:39 AM']All good points, but, based on what he has said, he already has a computer, a desktop. He seems to be watching his wallet, which is smart given college kids don't make a lot of money, and, if he is in college, the dorm room will be the majority of where homework will get done unless, of course, he just uses the computer lab.

Based on what you have said Ricky, and your needs, I would say your best bet would be to upgrade the computer. You can do it for cheap, maybe even less than half of that laptop you are looking at...provided you have the skills to do so. (BTW, I assumed you did, if not, then best bet is laptop).

Check this site out, it is designed for people who build their own computers and just want parts rather than whole computers. Besides, they are a more inexpensive way to go.

[url="http://www.newegg.com/"]http://www.newegg.com/[/url][/quote]

You hit the nail on the head Theologian in Training. Ya, I have the skills to upgrade, I just did last summer. The price of the laptop would be 1200, the upgrades would be maybe 500. So I'd be saving a lot of money in the process. Thanks for the info everyone, keep em coming.

God bless

Posted

I was forced to purchase a new computer when my home desktop died, so I decided to go with a laptop, I bought a gateway laptop for 700 dollars and had it customized for an extra 175. I like my computer so far, but time will only tell.

In Christ,

Edward

Posted

I took a laptop with me to school my first two years (and will do so during these next two) but after much debate I decided when I upgraded this spring to a new computer that I wanted a desktop. The thing for me was that my laptop was two years old and might as well have been 10. The processor was a bit out of date and it wouldn't have killed to have it upgraded, same thing with the RAM. And the video card. While I could have upgraded it and I do most likely have the skill required to open my laptop and mess with it, it is something I would rather no do. I have messed with desktops in terms of upgrade them just fine but a laptop is a little (lot) more limited.

In general, those who have laptops get made after a year or two when Moore's law comes knocking and they can't upgrade. Desktop users get mad every where when there is a nice fall or spring day that they can't go outside and enjoy because they are limited to their desk. In terms of transporting a computer, to class or to do work, I have only really done so a few times. I do a lot of work in the chem department's computer lab, so for me to lug a computer is just silly, but I know not everyone has the luxury.

My advise is dependent on the power of your current desktop. If it really really bites and hardly runs programs like Word or Excel or doesn't deal well with multi-media (I found I watched a lot of movies and stuff on my computer, and iTune's TV shows are nice), then I think I would upgrade that and sit on the laptop for a while. If it does run the Office suite fine and all that and is a just fine unit other then that it could use more power, I might be tempted to get a decent laptop and maybe throw 512mb RAM or something into the desktop to keep it competitive and have both computers with you.

Because it really smells of elderberries having Linux get mad with your harddrive and then not be able to use your computer for a week while helpdesk fixes it. Or having your motherboard short. Or your logic board go out. Or the power supply. Or your video card. Or your harddrive. Or your (fill in the blank)... All of which has happened to my friends and myself over the past two years.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...