cappie Posted May 27, 2007 Posted May 27, 2007 Describing 17th and 18th century laws banning the British monarch and his or her spouse from being a Catholic as "unacceptable" today, a Liberal Democrat party spokesperson has called for the laws to be repealed. Catholic Online reports that the move challenges more than 300 years of state-sponsored sectarian discrimination and bigotry against Catholics. Liberal Democrat equality spokesperson Lorely Burt announced 23 May that the party has introduced in the House of Commons the "Discrimination Against Catholics" motion that takes aim sections in the Bill of Rights 1688, Act of Settlement 1700 and the Union with Scotland Act 1706 which prevent a "monarch from being a Catholic and the spouse of the monarch from being a Catholic". "There is a fundamental principle of discrimination here," said Burt, reported Independent Catholic News. "It is unacceptable that in 2007 we still have ridiculous laws on our statute books that, for example, prevent a Catholic from marrying the heir to the throne." Burt called upon British Prime Minister Tony Blair to "consider removing this institutional discrimination" before stepping down on June 27. "After all," Burt said, "if reports are to believed, he may have a rather more personal interest in Catholic affairs when he leaves Number 10" Downing St., the residence and office of the prime minister, referring to rumors of Blair's imminent conversion to Catholicism. "He should act whilst he still has the chance." The text of the Early Day Motion 1532 reads as follows: "That this house believes that nobody should be subject to unfair discrimination on grounds including, but not limited to race, sex, sexual orientation, disability, age, gender identity or religion; notes that the laws of this country continue to discriminate against Catholics in a completely unjustifiable manner; resolves to remove the bar on a Catholic marrying the heir to the throne; and further resolves to allow a Catholic diocese to be given the same name as an Anglican diocese and calls on the government to include such measures in its forthcoming Single Equality Bill. "Currently the Bill of Rights 1688, Act of Settlement 1700 and the Union with Scotland Act 1706 prevent the monarch from being a Catholic and the spouse of the monarch from being a Catholic. These laws concerning Catholics have not been repealed. The Roman Catholic Relief Act (1926) ended punishment for naming a Catholic diocese that same as an Anglican diocese, but doing so still remains technically illegal." Last year, a Scottish cardinal launched an attack on the 300-year-old Act of Settlement, decrying "state-sponsored sectarian discrimination" which leaves a blight on the cultural landscape. Cardinal Keith O'Brien of St Andrews and Edinburgh said Scotland remains afflicted by a "shadowy sectarian culture". He said that sectarianism is codified in law through the Act of Settlement. "Our constitution contains legislation which describes my faith as 'the popish religion' and defines me and my co-religionists as 'papists'. That this arcanely offensive language enjoys legal sanction is outrageous," Cardinal O'Brien said. Cardinal O'Brien called upon "all those involved in anti-sectarian initiatives, at every level to accept and acknowledge that this legislation constitutes a blight on their efforts and its repeal would dramatically improve the prospects of their work bearing fruit." Change in the Act of Settlement would have to be ratified by 15 parliaments of the British Commonwealth and would require amendments to at least eight separate acts stretching as far back as 1688, and including the Union with Scotland Act of 1706. Opponents of repeal believe that repeal could lead to a Catholic assuming the throne, and could lead to the disestablishment of the Church of England as the state religion, as the English monarch must swear to defend the faith and be a member of the Anglican Communion. Earlier in 2006, Blair rejected calls for repeal. British Cardinal Cormac Murphy O'Connor of Westminster urged repeal of the law in June 2002. The Act of Settlement, he said, "is not so much that it is an act of discrimination against Roman Catholics - which it is - but it seems to me to be discrimination against the royal family." "Talking about Prince William, he can marry by law a Hindu, a Buddhist, anyone, but not a Roman Catholic," he said. "That seems to me anomalous and I think it should go."
Didymus Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 i once heard that there are more Catholics in England than Anglicans.
Resurrexi Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 I don't see why any Catholic would want to be monarch of England seeing as it would require him to be the head of a heretical sect. I also don't see how "That this house believes that nobody should be subject to unfair discrimination on grounds including, but not limited to...sexual orientation...gender identity..." supports laws according to the Natural Law at all.
XIX Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 You do realize that if Brownback was elected President, he would in a lot of ways be the head of a heretical sect.
aalpha1989 Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 admittedly i read the first few paragraphs and skimmed the rest, but stm sounds right to me. why would a catholic want to be the head of the anglican church? unless the anglican church has changed it's structure?whatev.
Resurrexi Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote name='XIX' post='1282388' date='May 27 2007, 09:07 PM']You do realize that if Brownback was elected President, he would in a lot of ways be the head of a heretical sect.[/quote] The United States of America is not a heretical sect, it a great republic and would be even greater if it supported traditional morals.
aalpha1989 Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1282391' date='May 27 2007, 10:13 PM']The United States of America is not a heretical sect, it a great republic and would be even greater if it supported traditional morals.[/quote] how bout correct morals? traditional morals dont make something right. in some places of the world its a traditional moral that men are greater than women and that they can't show their faces in public. that doesnt make it right.
Sojourner Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 I hope they drop it so I can have a shot at marrying Harry ...
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1282383' date='May 27 2007, 08:44 PM']I don't see why any Catholic would want to be monarch of England seeing as it would require him to be the head of a heretical sect.[/quote] That's law of the Church of England, but is it civil law of the state of England? If not, I wouldn't see why a Catholic king couldn't simply renounce his claim to the primacy of the Church of England and still remain king. Or better yet, as head of the Church of England, depose the bishops and return all Church property to the Catholic dioceses of England...then convert back to Catholicism... :
Resurrexi Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 (edited) [quote]how bout correct morals? traditional morals dont make something right. in some places of the world its a traditional moral that men are greater than women and that they can't show their faces in public. that doesnt make it right.[/quote]I'll just let the Pope do the talking for me [quote]We, indeed, have no thought of rejecting everything that modern industry and study has produced; so far from it that we welcome to the patrimony of truth and to an ever-widening scope of public well-being whatsoever helps toward the progress of learning and virtue. Yet all this, to be of any solid benefit, nay, to have a real existence and growth, can only be on the condition of recognizing the wisdom and authority of the Church.[/quote] [quote]That's law of the Church of England, but is it civil law of the state of England? If not, I wouldn't see why a Catholic king couldn't simply renounce his claim to the primacy of the Church of England and still remain king. Or better yet, as head of the Church of England, depose the bishops and return all Church property to the Catholic dioceses of England...then convert back to Catholicism... P.gif[/quote] That might have been possible in centuries past, but today morals in England are not in a position that this would be possible. Edited May 28, 2007 by StThomasMore
aalpha1989 Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 (edited) [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1282450' date='May 27 2007, 11:59 PM']I'll just let the Pope do the talking for me That might have been possible in centuries past, but today morals in England are not in a position that this would be possible.[/quote] ok.....neither of your arguments make sense. first of all the pope never used the word traditional (i was just arguing against your choice of words which could be confusing)..... second of all 'morals in england' dont exclude someone from leadership positions. in fact they mean someone catholic SHOULD seek leadership positions to help change things. the only qualm i have is that the monarch of england is the head of the anglican church. Edited May 28, 2007 by aalpha1989
MissScripture Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1282419' date='May 27 2007, 10:42 PM']I hope they drop it so I can have a shot at marrying Harry ... [/quote] Why Harry? William is cuter!
Sojourner Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote name='MissScripture' post='1282459' date='May 27 2007, 11:22 PM']Why Harry? William is cuter![/quote] maybe, but Harry is more fun
cathoholic_anonymous Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote]i once heard that there are more Catholics in England than Anglicans.[/quote] There are more[i] practising[/i] Catholics in England than there are practising Anglicans. This comparison only includes the regular churchgoers. If you take into account all the people who go to church just a few times a year, but still identify as Christian, there are a lot more Anglicans than Catholics.
IcePrincessKRS Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1282419' date='May 27 2007, 11:42 PM']I hope they drop it so I can have a shot at marrying Harry ... [/quote] He's so cute in his uniform. [quote name='MissScripture' post='1282459' date='May 28 2007, 01:22 AM']Why Harry? William is cuter![/quote] [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1282483' date='May 28 2007, 02:52 AM']maybe, but Harry is more fun[/quote] Actually, I'm partial to Harry in the looks department... But then again, he bears a [b]very[/b] vague resemblance to Matt, and anyone I find remotely similar to Matt I think is cute, so I guess that explains it. lol [img]http://www.metimes.com/images/photos/full/20070516-011859-3954.jpg[/img] [attachment=2522:IMG_0457.JPG]
Sojourner Posted May 28, 2007 Posted May 28, 2007 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1282508' date='May 28 2007, 05:32 AM']He's so cute in his uniform. Actually, I'm partial to Harry in the looks department... But then again, he bears a [b]very[/b] vague resemblance to Matt, and anyone I find remotely similar to Matt I think is cute, so I guess that explains it. lol [img]http://www.metimes.com/images/photos/full/20070516-011859-3954.jpg[/img] [attachment=2522:IMG_0457.JPG][/quote] He is cute in his uniform!! I actually don't find William all that attractive ... but I might if his public personality were more like Harry's. Personality and attitude etc. play such a huge role in attraction for me ...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now