Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I like the one: "Examine God's Sexism"

:lol_roll:

Posted (edited)

Okay here's the okkam's razor version of the responses:

1, 2, 9, 10, 11) Just because God doesn't give us exactly what we ask for, doesn't mean that our requests fall on deaf ears or are unappreciated. Christians should not believe in a "Name it and claim it God."
3) This actually is evidence to the contrary, that the Greek religions were striving for the same God that we were. Whether they actually were going for that is an entire different story, but coincidental religions actually supports our argument, not yours. It proves that religion isn't just random
PS: "Love your enemies" was pretty original, methinks. I don't think that would have gone over too well in ancient Sparta.
4) Doesn't prove anything, just your opinion that God gets in the way of science, based on the assumption that they can't even work together. This of course is a silly assumption.
5) Again this doesn't prove anything, just your opinion that the Bible promotes violence. Even if it does, that's not really evidence that God doesn't exist. PS: read the 10 commandments.
6) Just because God plans for something does not mean he causes it, wants it, or condones it. I can plan for a hurricane, but that does not mean I like hurricanes or want to contribute to them.
7, 12) Actually, Santa Clause is based on a real character by the name of St. Nicholas, but let's just assume for the sake of argument that we are referring to the fairy tale.
a) Jesus existed. That is a historical and scientific fact. Whether He is God or merely a quack, is another story. But there is not a debate about whether Jesus existed. There isn't even a debate that Muhammad existed. Santa and the tooth fairy don't even exist.
b) Dude, the tomb was empty. People saw Him after His crucifixion. People still see Him today. People died tortorous deaths because they saw Him. If that's not evidence that Jesus performs miracles, then I don't know what would be.
c) Faith isn't blind. See a and b.
PS: You clearly miss the point of prayer if you think that a coin flip is a proper analogy for a prayer intention.
8) You admitted that this isn't proof that God is imaginary, so let's move on.

--------
It's shotty but it's remarkable how easy it is to debunk atheism sometimes.

Edited by XIX
Posted

I think that these are so funny, are because they arent even logical.

Saying, "Look at God's sexism" isnt a proof that God doesnt exist.... :crazy:

Posted

Ooooh Al came to play too!!

Posted

haha, and I'm gaining their trust by destroying your arguments :P:

haha just playin. but it's always more effective to strengthen their arguments first before dismissing them, it shows them that someone can carry their argument to the strongest possible place and still disagree.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1283427' date='May 29 2007, 11:01 AM']haha, and I'm gaining their trust by destroying your arguments :P:

haha just playin. but it's always more effective to strengthen their arguments first before dismissing them, it shows them that someone can carry their argument to the strongest possible place and still disagree.[/quote]

I don't care if its considered a defect. I just need it to be acknowledged

Posted

aha... so in that sense I'm strengthening you. great. :cool:

Posted

I'm not looking for a good cop bad cop thing here Al. I'm just being as straightforward as I can with the Godless.

Posted

I'm not looking for a good cop bad cop thing here Al. I'm just being as straightforward as I can with the Godless.

KnightofChrist
Posted

I believe you both are making great arguments thus far... maybe in a couple weeks Aloysius will be able to move past the existence of existence. ^_^

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

Some stuff from a book I have:
[quote]Saying God does not exist is like a young kid saying he has no grandfather just because he has never seen him.

Why show so much animosity against God? Animosity must itself be directed against an illusion or a reality. If it is against a figment of a person's imagination (an illusion), then it would lead to questioning of the the person's mental balance.

If there is no God, why the need to show such hostility? Is there anyone still around today who still vehemently opposes Cicero or Hannibal or Napoleon? They were all hated when they lived, but that hatred died when they died. Hate ceases when the thing hated ceases. Either the opposition is against something that does not exist, leaving them bereft of reason for opposition, or the target of their hostility does in fact exist.

From history, every civilization from every part of the world had some sort of religion professing a belief in a higher power or deity of some sort. No race has yet been found that did not believe in some supreme being, something greater than themselves. A belief so universal that it cannot b attributed to any one nation, that is present among tribes which have no contact with the rest of the world, cannot be due to chance. If we accept human reason as trust worthy, we must recognize the fact of the existence of God.

In everything in the world, there is a long line of causes, each dependent on a higher one before it. No evidence can be found to contradict that assertion. We cannot go back through this list indefinitely, There has to be an uncaused cause that began that line of causes. If there ever was a moment at which nothing existed, nothing could ever exist. We believe that nothing can precede from nothing in the natural world, but when it comes to God's creation, some proclaim, "This is an exception." Yet they do not prove the exception, they merely deny the fact. They do not believe because they do not want to believe. It does not solve the problem to become vague by going to the distant past. Some say that the first living being came from lower beings. Then where did those beings come from? A being cannot cause itself. Some may suggest that the sun is responsible for life. Then where does the sun get the power to give life.

You cannot give money to a person in need of money if you simply have no money.

The idea that life just sprang up in the beginning and developed as time progressed is scientifically unsound and even Pasteur through his scientific findings proved the impossibility of spontaneous generation years ago.

"Show me a watch without a watch maker, then I'll take a universe without a Universe-maker"--G.K. Chesterton

Wherever we see a thing in perfect order or acting according to plan, our common sense tells us that there is an intelligent planner behind it. All over the earth there are things working in perfect order. Therefore, these things demand some Intelligent Planner.

Suppose we paid taxes according to our own conscience and nothing else? Perhaps a few would pay more than their share; some would give what they pay now, but the vast majority would pay little or nothing at all. The government simply could not function! Private judgment and individual opinion are just as unreliable in determining whether worship is to be paid to God as in determining the taxes to be paid to the government. There are standards outside ourselves regulating religion, governing our relations with God. Even all nations have possessed at least some primitive form of religion. It is a part of our very nature. Otherwise people would have abolished it as unnecessary a long time ago.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1283469' date='May 29 2007, 03:26 PM']I'm not looking for a good cop bad cop thing here Al. I'm just being as straightforward as I can with the Godless.[/quote]
I know. I wasn't really doing anything like that. I'm just introducing myself by exhibiting how I can make points on both sides and how I'm really more interested in the truth than in just defending my position (it seems clear that most Christians they get over there just go in and try to advance the idea that there is a God by any means necessary)

[quote]maybe in a couple weeks Aloysius will be able to move past the existence of existence.[/quote]

lol. I am quite enjoying myself in that discussion, though. :cool:

Posted (edited)

Some of these arguments are absolutely hilarious!

A lot of these are arguments against Christianity anyway, not that God does not exist.
"Jesus is a jerk" therefore there is no God...

I love this one: Pascal's wager is wrong because different people believe in different gods.

Who formulated these arguments? I suppose the person was completely unbiased and logical because he was an atheist? eh?

I'm no philosopher, but I could refute a bunch of these...

Edited by scardella
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1283212' date='May 29 2007, 01:42 AM'][img]http://www.vampirerave.com/premium/files/moonmystic/scary%20bunny.jpg[/img]

hot stuff link me...I wanna play.[/quote]

That should be the FBC logo!!!

:hehehe:

Posted

Al, your stuff is too dense for me. :P:

That's what I get for being a business major. :D:

Posted

Which forum are you posting in?

Posted

questions and debates


Al is already beating me. someone gave him a positive karma point.

Posted

haha yep. we should compete for karma points. haha

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1283731' date='May 29 2007, 05:56 PM']haha yep. we should compete for karma points. haha[/quote]

you're on!

But I'm trying to figure out which is better, getting karma points or not..

Posted

KnightofChrist has joined the ranks!! Woohoo!!


I haven't had this much fun online in a while!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...