Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Bertone Shows Original Third Fatima Secret Letter On Tv


Recommended Posts

brendan1104
Posted

Chris Ferrara responded to that letter you posted in August 2004. I linked to it. It should be noted that he's a Canadian citizen, living in Canada, so the American nuncio (RIP) didn't have anything to do with him, or his status.

Posted

This kind of thing is why I very reluctantly tend to avoid even approved apparitions... If your devotion and interest in a particular apparition is sucking you into paranoid conspiracy theories, it is taking up too much of your time.

Our Lady's whole point was that we need to preach the Gospel and repent. She did not appear in Portugal so that people could argue and rack their brains trying to figure out if the Pope did this or that in precisely the right manner meeting exactly the right
conditions or if it was "off" ever so slightly and needs to be done again, like an invalid sacrament or something. I am sure Our Lady grieves over these distortions of her message.

Fr. Grunner is on my prayer list :( He is clearly a zealous priest and could do much to bring souls to Jesus through Mary. It would be better if he spent less time writing articles about "modernist attacks" on Fatima (which no one is required to believe in, by the way) and put more energy into spreading the Good News. Apparitions like Fatima are private revelation, not public. Fatima is not necessary for salvation. The Gospel is.

Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1336032' date='Jul 20 2007, 09:33 PM'][size=5]NOT TRUE

FALSE[/size]

He did the same on the back, saying,

[size=5]THIS IS TRASH[/size]

The quotes were entirely fabricated.

Hope this clears matters up :)

God bless![/quote]


Who is convinced by such a "response"? Not I.

Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1336106' date='Jul 20 2007, 11:40 PM']This kind of thing is why I very reluctantly tend to avoid even approved apparitions... If your devotion and interest in a particular apparition is sucking you into paranoid conspiracy theories, it is taking up too much of your time.

Our Lady's whole point was that we need to preach the Gospel and repent. She did not appear in Portugal so that people could argue and rack their brains trying to figure out if the Pope did this or that in precisely the right manner meeting exactly the right
conditions or if it was "off" ever so slightly and needs to be done again, like an invalid sacrament or something. I am sure Our Lady grieves over these distortions of her message.

Fr. Grunner is on my prayer list :( He is clearly a zealous priest and could do much to bring souls to Jesus through Mary. It would be better if he spent less time writing articles about "modernist attacks" on Fatima (which no one is required to believe in, by the way) and put more energy into spreading the Good News. Apparitions like Fatima are private revelation, not public. Fatima is not necessary for salvation. The Gospel is.[/quote]

I agree.

Regardless of whatever is going on with Fatima and its interpretation, it's not necessary to our salvation. It's a beautiful place to go on pilgrimage, and Our Lady's message is good, but it's only reiterating what's already being taught to us.

brendan1104
Posted

Remember, we've already (like so many other issues) debated Fatima - Russia's Consecration, the Third Secret, etc. [i]ad nauseam[/i]. :)

Posted (edited)

Just getting to this today. Will be back with more references later.

[quote name='Chris Ferrara responded to that letter you posted in August 2004']Chris Ferrara responded to that letter you posted in August 2004[/quote]

Brendan - I've met Chris Ferrara, and he is not a credible source to cite. Anyone on Phatmass can Google him and learn of the plethora of reasons why.

[quote name='jiyoung']It included this, which was really interesting...[/quote]

Thanks for posting that letter, JIYoung. Much obliged.

[quote name='jiyoung']I don't know much about either Fr. Fox or Fr. Gruner--I do know Fr. Fox wrote a beautiful article about the use of veils in Mass, which is where I first heard his name--but this letter makes me instantly wary of anything he says.[/quote]

I'm confused; you're wary of Fr. Fox or Fr. Gruner?

[quote name='Mortify']Who is convinced by such a "response"? Not I.[/quote]

This is a good point, which I thought about before posting Fr. Fox's letter. This seems to be a matter of credibility. I guess we're only going to go in circles if we don't have the same credentials for credibility. I think for most of us on Phatmass, a person is credible if he is faithful to the Magisterium, and is not credible of he is defiant of it.

[quote name='Maggie']Our Lady's whole point was that we need to preach the Gospel and repent. She did not appear in Portugal so that people could argue and rack their brains trying to figure out if the Pope did this or that in precisely the right manner meeting exactly the right
conditions or if it was "off" ever so slightly and needs to be done again,[/quote]

Maggie,

I think we're all in agreement with you on these points. But it's important for our unity as Catholics to understand the Church's authority when she makes a statement. Right now we're not discussing so much the apparitions as the authority of the Church in saying that Russia [i]was[/i] consecrated.

Edited by Totus Tuus
brendan1104
Posted

Why post more references? The arguments have already, and more than a few times, been presented and debated. Both sides will continue to disagree. Look at the Debate Table, or Transmundane Lane, or here in Open Mic. Been there, done that.

Just remember Our Lady's words:

"In the end, my Immaculate Heart will triumph."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...