Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is Homosexuality Really More Disordered Than, Say, Contraception?


Recommended Posts

Posted

I've always thought of contraceptive sex as the heterosexual version of sodomy. Heck, a guy could commit "sodomy" with a woman, sorta.

Then again, I'm not sure what the Catholic stance is on this. Could anyone dig up a Church teaching for me? :)

Posted

Homosexuality is a disorder of the object of the sexual appetite. The difference with disordered heterosexual behavior is that the object of the appetite is correctly ordered (to the opposite sex), but the appetite is used contrary to its purpose. Homosexuality not only uses the sexual appetite contrary to its purpose, but it has lost the purpose, or the end, as well (the opposite sex).

farglefeezlebut
Posted

Please can we make a clear distinction between homosexuality and homosexual acts.

It is not a sin to have homosexual inclinations. It is a sin to act on them. That is what the Chruch teaches. I just want to make that clear because any non-Catholics looking at this thread could get the wrong idea.

Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1288752' date='Jun 5 2007, 01:23 PM']I've always thought of contraceptive sex as the heterosexual version of sodomy. Heck, a guy could commit "sodomy" with a woman, sorta.[/quote]

Aquinas would agree with you here (as told to me in a summa of the summa). Coitus interuptus and other activities are a subsection of sodomy. He even placed masterbation, sodomy, and bestiality as more of an offense against the design of sex than rape. [Disclaimer: rape is a double whammy as it is an offense of violence, which makes it worse than the others.]

Posted

[quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1289337' date='Jun 6 2007, 04:20 AM']Please can we make a clear distinction between homosexuality and homosexual acts.

It is not a sin to have homosexual inclinations. It is a sin to act on them. That is what the Chruch teaches. I just want to make that clear because any non-Catholics looking at this thread could get the wrong idea.[/quote]
GAH. You are absolutely right. I'm very sorry for not making that clarification.

93 Phillies
Posted (edited)

I don't see how masturbation is a sin. Especially with people getting married around thirty these days. Your supposed to do nothing but nocturnal emissions for possibly a few decades? Would your parts even still work after all that time without being used?

Edited by Era Might
Posted (edited)

Hi, Phillies,

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293374' date='Jun 12 2007, 09:27 AM']I don't see how masturbation is a sin.[/quote]
Yes, sometimes when we like something a lot, we try really hard "not to see" that it is a sin. I know from experience. :rolleyes:

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293374' date='Jun 12 2007, 09:27 AM']Especially with people getting married around thirty these days.[/quote]
I fail to see how this point helps. If masturbation were a sin (which it is, as we Catholics rightly believe) it still would be sinful to do it only because a person would get married at the age of thirty. So, instead of looking at the matter through the angle of age, we must be clear if it is a sin or not. If it is not sinful, then there's no problem doing it even before marriage even if one were married at fifteen. However, masturbation happens to be sinful, and so this point really does not help:

The [url="http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a6.htm#2352"][color="#FF0000"][b]CCC[/b][/color][/url] leaves no wriggle-room about whether it is sinful or not:

[quote]
2352 By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. "Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action." "The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose." For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of "the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved."[/quote][quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293374' date='Jun 12 2007, 09:27 AM']Your supposed to do nothing but nocturnal emissions for possibly a few decades?[/quote]
Is it wise to consider your sexuality as a separate entity from your person? In reality, in a situation where a person maintains his/her chastity, the person's reproductive system is not "doing nothing". That person glorifies God through the proper use of his sexuality.

Anyway, Peter Kreeft [url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics/sex-in-heaven.htm"][color="#2E8B57"][b]has some interesting things to say[/b][/color][/url] about how sexuality forms an integral part of a person.

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293374' date='Jun 12 2007, 09:27 AM']Would your parts even still work after all that time without being used?[/quote]
You worry too much, methinks! :P: Anyway, there's no medical evidence of the atrophy of the reproductive system due to lack of premartial masturbatory activity. We should trust God to give us blessings of good health as he sees fit, and follow what he says. At any rate, in the previous sentence you talk of nocturnal emissions, and then why do you now say "without being used"?


Yours in Christ,
Innocent

Edited by Era Might
farglefeezlebut
Posted

If you are struggling with that sort of temptation, pray.

If the temptation is so strong that praying doesn't work, take a walk into a public place. Then you won't be able to do it however much you want to.

Also, I heard that cold showers help.

93 Phillies
Posted (edited)

Quote Innocent



My will power is as strong as anyone's. I just happen to have different views. I don't take everything exactly from the Church. I feel like I'm smart enough to decide what is and is not a sin with *guidance* from the Church. You may see that as prideful or whatever, but that's best way to go about things, in my opinion. Thanks for the reply though.

Edited by 93 Phillies
Posted (edited)

Dear Phillies,

Thanks for the reply to my post.

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293883' date='Jun 13 2007, 04:14 AM']Quote Innocent
My will power is as strong as anyone's.[/quote]

Good for you. I envy you. I have a very weak will-power! :weep:

(I don't think I implied anything about your will-power in the above post, at any rate.)

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293883' date='Jun 13 2007, 04:14 AM']I don't take everything exactly from the Church.[/quote]
You're missing out on a lot of goodies then, you know! :lol:

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293883' date='Jun 13 2007, 04:14 AM']I feel like I'm smart enough to decide what is and is not a sin with *guidance* from the Church.[/quote]
I'm a bit confused about this, though. If you're really smart enough that you can be right when the Church is wrong, why is the guidance of the Church needed in the first place? Hmm.. :idontknow:

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293883' date='Jun 13 2007, 04:14 AM']You may see that as prideful or whatever, ..........[/quote]
Nevermind what I see it as. Are you quite convinced it's not pride, yourself? If you are really convinced, then you just might be saved from sin by the 8th Sacrament! :lol:
[quote]
When I was a child, my old parish priest taught me that there were eight Sacraments, the eighth being ignorance. And the eighth sacrament saves more people than the other seven put together. To commit mortal sin implies grave matter but also full and deliberate consent.
-[url="http://www.speroforum.com/site/article.asp?id=2879"][b][color="#FF0000"]Fr. Gabriele Amorth[/color][/b][/url], exorcist of Rome.[/quote]

If you're not sure about it, well, that's another story entirely, isn't it?

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1293883' date='Jun 13 2007, 04:14 AM']Thanks for the reply though.[/quote]

You're most welcome, kind sir! :D:

However, even speaking from a NPOV (as they call it at Wikipedia), it's still possible that the Church is right when we poor sinners (meaning I and others like I. No speculation about the state of [u]your[/u] soul was intended. ;) ) think that we know better.

With love and prayers,

Yours in Christ,
Innocent

Edited by Innocent
93 Phillies
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Innocent' post='1294355' date='Jun 13 2007, 01:49 AM']Dear Phillies,

Thanks for the reply to my post.
Good for you. I envy you. I have a very weak will-power! :weep:

([b]I don't think I implied anything about your will-power in the above post, at any rate[/b].)[/quote]

[quote]Yes, sometimes when we like something a lot, we try really hard "not to see" that it is a sin. I know from experience.[/quote][quote]
You're missing out on a lot of goodies then, you know! :lol:
I'm a bit confused about this, though. If you're really smart enough that you can be right when the Church is wrong, why is the guidance of the Church needed in the first place? Hmm.. :idontknow:



Nevermind what I see it as. Are you quite convinced it's not pride, yourself? If you are really convinced, then you just might be saved from sin by the 8th Sacrament! :lol:
If you're not sure about it, well, that's another story entirely, isn't it?
You're most welcome, kind sir! :D:

However, even speaking from a NPOV (as they call it at Wikipedia), it's still possible that the Church is right when we poor sinners (meaning I and others like I. No speculation about the state of [u]your[/u] soul was intended. ;) ) think that we know better.

With love and prayers,

Yours in Christ,
Innocent[/quote]

I don't think God wants anyone to follow the Church like a lemming, do you? The church has had its fair share of corruption throughout the years.

I think we need to challenge our faith in order for it to be truly strong. And it's not really a challenge if you plan on coming out the way you came in. Our critical thinking skills are not just for solving math problems or managing relationships. More than anything we should use them to look at the something far mor important - our faith.

And about that "eighth sacrament" thing, there is no reason to call me or anyone ignorant because they don't have the same view that you or someone else does. That is pretty condescending.

Edited by 93 Phillies
Posted (edited)

Dear Phillies,

I'm sorry if it appeared condescending. That was not my intention. I sincerely apologise. Perhaps my post was in too jocular a vein.

I didn't mean to use the word "ignorance" to imply anything degratory about you.

I'm ignorant of many things, too. I'll be the first to admit it. No single human person can know everything, obviously.

All I meant is that imperfect understanding lessens the seriousness of sins, in general.

But why did I mention this in my previous post? I was just trying to say that I wouldn't be hasty to label you as "prideful", since I don't really know the state of your soul, and I don't think I, or any Catholic, for that matter, would be so reckless as to presume anything about it.

Having said that, I'm sure you'll agree that all men suffer from pride, (especially I) It's a very easy sin to give in to...

Once again, I apologise if I have hurt you.

Please pray for me. I shall pray for you.

Yours in Christ,
Innocent

P.S. I'd love to discuss further about following the Church, but I'll leave off, since that isn't exactly the subject of this thread.

P.S.S. I'm sorry if I've diverted the thread. It was meant to be a discussion about homosexuality and contraception, wasn't it? I'll be careful in future.

Edited by Innocent
93 Phillies
Posted

Hey no problem. I wasn't hurt, but more just rubbed the wrong way. It's not too uncommon to have a misunderstanding in conversations like these, especially on the internet. If you want to talk about this in another thread I'd be glad to.

Posted

93 Phillies,

When you masturbate what do you think about? Are they loving thoughts that you would be happy to share with a future spouse? Would you be comfortable sharing those thoughts with Jesus?

I ain't saying, I'm just saying...

93 Phillies
Posted

[quote name='peach_cube' post='1294766' date='Jun 13 2007, 07:52 PM']93 Phillies,

When you masturbate what do you think about? Are they loving thoughts that you would be happy to share with a future spouse? Would you be comfortable sharing those thoughts with Jesus?

I ain't saying, I'm just saying...[/quote]

Uh yeah it's not like I'm thinking about violent weirdo stuff. I'm aware that God knows what I'm thinking at all times and like I said before I'm comfortable with what I'm doing.

Posted

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1294796' date='Jun 13 2007, 07:53 PM']Uh yeah it's not like I'm thinking about violent weirdo stuff. I'm aware that God knows what I'm thinking at all times and like I said before I'm comfortable with what I'm doing.[/quote]

+

So are most pedophiles and rapists, sadly. Our feelings aren't always conducive to reality. The problem with masturbation is that it is an abuse of the self. God gave us the pleasure of sex for two reasons: 1. unitive 2. procreative. Masturbation misses out on both. Like the homosexual act. Ultimately, your body belongs to God. It's just as wrong to abuse your own body as it is someone else's.

Pax.

www.couragerc.net has some additional information on both of these topics.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...