93 Phillies Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 What is the Catholic Churches definition of the "soul"? Personality is something generated by the brain. What are the characteristics of a soul? How is the soul bound to the body? Upon death is the soul released in some way? Are pre-existings souls appointed to a human upon conception? Or is a soul created for the body upon conception? For those that believe in evolution, at what point did our species begin to have souls?
farglefeezlebut Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 That is an interesting klot of questions. I have one to add. The Church teaches animals have no souls wheras humans do, because humans are sentinet and animals are not. The Church also teaches that human life is sacred from conception. But an embryo in the earliest stages of life (before the brain has begun to form) is not sentient. So how does it work? I'm not asking this to criticise the Church,. I'm just interested in people's thoughts.
The Joey-O Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 [quote name='93 Phillies' post='1289144' date='Jun 5 2007, 10:51 PM']What is the Catholic Churches definition of the "soul"? Personality is something generated by the brain. What are the characteristics of a soul? How is the soul bound to the body? Upon death is the soul released in some way? Are pre-existings souls appointed to a human upon conception? Or is a soul created for the body upon conception? For those that believe in evolution, at what point did our species begin to have souls?[/quote] This is a very good link to read about the soul: [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14153a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14153a.htm[/url] I did a little bit of review, but I'm going, largely off of what I remember, so corrections to what I'm about to say are probably going to be needed. However, I should be fairly close to the actual teachings of the church. The "characteristics" of the soul: the soul is the "formal" principal of the person. This means that it contains the "organization" of the person. It is possible to make a rough analogy to DNA, in this case, but it would ultimately be a false comparison. More than simply containing a "roadmap" for the development and organization of a person, the soul is also the seat of the "intellect" and "will". Basically, the entirety of neuro-science (science of the brain) is spent trying to figure out how the sum of all the parts that we think could exist in brain is significantly less than the whole that is actually present. A LOT of energy is being spent on this problem. Now, if the soul is real, then they shouldn't be able to come up with a "material" answer to this problem. The soul is the immaterial reality that holds the higher functions of our minds, the ones that scientists can't account for. Also, the soul is "simple". It is one, unified and without parts. Though we can distinguish different responsibilities that the soul has and different powers, etc., this does not mean that it has many parts. It is one, indivisible thing. Finally, the human soul is unique, in as much as it can exist without the body. It is wrong to say that it is a preferrable state for the soul to be without a body, however, it is evident that souls have existed without bodies. How is the soul bound to the body: I don't know that I can say a whole lot more for this question. However, I can say that the human person is body and soul. These two "parts" exist positively for each other. The soul is the spiritual/immaterial part of Man. The body is the "animal" part of Man. However, this doesn't set the soul in opposition to the body. Both are genuinely good, indeed both support and aid the formation of the other. For example, the soul is bettered through learning and education, which often begins with the bodies' eyes and ears. And, the body is bettered through the proper ordering of diet and excersise, which the mind (a "part" of the soul) organizes and the will (another "part" of the soul) enacts. Upon death is the soul released in some way: Yes. The soul is seperated from the body until the Resurrection of the Dead. Then, we get bodies again! Are pre-existing souls appointed to human bodies; Or is the soul created for the body: The soul is created at the moment of conception. It does, however, bear the marks of "inheretance" from your parents. Thus, people have tendencies to look, act, etc. like their parents. Also, original sin is transmitted in this process. [quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1289335' date='Jun 6 2007, 05:16 AM']That is an interesting klot of questions. I have one to add. The Church teaches animals have no souls wheras humans do, because humans are sentinet and animals are not. The Church also teaches that human life is sacred from conception. But an embryo in the earliest stages of life (before the brain has begun to form) is not sentient. So how does it work? I'm not asking this to criticise the Church,. I'm just interested in people's thoughts.[/quote] I can answer this one, hopefully clearly. The church doesn't say that humans have a soul, because humans are sentient. Humans have a soul, because they are composite material and spiritual beings. Sentience is only evidence of our spiritual nature. Babies, the severely mentally challenged, etc. are still spiritual beings, and therefore possess a soul, even though they do not display sentience.
Era Might Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 We often say we "have" a soul, but it is more correct to say we "are" a soul. The soul is who we are, and it operates through the body. The definition of death is the separation of soul and body. The human soul is also a spirit (eternal and rational), and this distinguishes it from the souls of animals, which are not "persons" as humans beings are. The soul is not pre-existing, but is created out of nothing at the moment of conception. It is a mystery how the soul and the body cooperate. We were not created to exist only as spirits, but as souls animating a body. This is why the separation of death is the greatest natural evil, because while our souls may continue without a body, that is not the purpose for which they were created. Hence, the importance of the resurrection of the dead in Christian revelation.
kenrockthefirst Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1289422' date='Jun 6 2007, 10:43 AM']We often say we "have" a soul, but it is more correct to say we "are" a soul. The soul is who we are, and it operates through the body. The definition of death is the separation of soul and body. The human soul is also a spirit (eternal and rational), and this distinguishes it from the souls of animals, which are not "persons" as humans beings are. The soul is not pre-existing, but is created out of nothing at the moment of conception. It is a mystery how the soul and the body cooperate. We were not created to exist only as spirits, but as souls animating a body. This is why the separation of death is the greatest natural evil, because while our souls may continue without a body, that is not the purpose for which they were created. Hence, the importance of the resurrection of the dead in Christian revelation.[/quote] So animals DO have souls? Is the soul in some way definable as the "spark of life?" If so, does that mean that plants and other living matter have "souls?" In the absence of the Fall, or after Christ's return, when the mortal will put on the immortal, will animals, plants, and other living matter also be immortal? Is sapience or even sentience required for immortality?
Era Might Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 All living things have souls, because a body cannot animate itself. I don't know if there will be plants and animals in the Kingdom, but their souls are not immortal, because they are not spirits. Maybe they will continue to exist as they do now, with non-rational souls, and God will just keep them alive forever. When plants and animals die, however, their souls cease to exist. The different between a soul and a spirit is that a spirit is a person, an "I" rather than an "it". Angels are pure spirit and animals are pure soul. Humans are a combination of both.
kenrockthefirst Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1289479' date='Jun 6 2007, 12:34 PM']All living things have souls, because a body cannot animate itself. I don't know if there will be plants and animals in the Kingdom, but their souls are not immortal, because they are not spirits. Maybe they will continue to exist as they do now, with non-rational souls, and God will just keep them alive forever. When plants and animals die, however, their souls cease to exist. The different between a soul and a spirit is that a spirit is a person, an "I" rather than an "it". Angels are pure spirit and animals are pure soul. Humans are a combination of both.[/quote] But prior to the Fall, there was no death. To put it another way, death, disease, disintegration, etc., are a result of the Fall. In the absence of the Fall, without death, would all living things have simply continued to live forever, because they in some way had a "spark of life" from God, even if they weren't also spirit?
Quietfire Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 [quote name='93 Phillies' post='1289144' date='Jun 5 2007, 09:51 PM']What is the Catholic Churches definition of the "soul"? Personality is something generated by the brain. What are the characteristics of a soul? How is the soul bound to the body? Upon death is the soul released in some way? Are pre-existings souls appointed to a human upon conception? Or is a soul created for the body upon conception? For those that believe in evolution, at what point did our species begin to have souls?[/quote] Ok...first things first. Every living body has a soul and yes...that would include plants and animals. The soul is the life principle of the body. The key here is...spirit. Every human has one. Plants and animals do not. We interchange the words so much because it isnt as if we can see and feel it. But for us it is one and the same. To quote F.J. Sheed:(my hero): The mingling of spirit and matter in human actions arises from a fact which destinguishes man's spirit from all others. Ours is the only spirit which is also a soul-that is to say, the life principle in a body. Only in man spirit is united with a body, animates the body, makes it to be a living body. Every living body-vegetable, lower animal, human- has a life principle, a soul. And just as ours is the only spirit which is a soul, so ours is the only soul which is a spirit. As the soul is the life principle of a body. The spirit is the element in us by which we know and love, by which we decide. God is a spirit, but has no body. Angels are spirits but have no body. Your second question or statement: [quote]Personality is something generated by the brain[/quote] The brain is an organ of the body and knows nothing. Put your brain on the counter and it would do nothing. If it acted like you, let me know...that would be something to see! Our body (and that includes the organs within) decide nothing, know nothing, loves nothing. Bodily pleasures are not enjoyed by the body, the body reacts to them physically. The key here is...mind. It is the mind (spirit) that knows, loves, decides. We interchange the words mind and brain but they are not the same. Again, the brain is an organ but it is the knowing mind that can split the atom. Your personality is decided by your likes, dislikes and such. A brain cannot do that anymore than a finger. It is your mind that has likes, dislikes, chooses between, decides. A brain cannot produce a personality. A brain is not even aware that its a brain without the mind telling it that it is a brain. Understand? next questions: Actually, it is a union of body and spirit. A living body cannot live without a soul. A human person cannot live without his soul. As to when.... God knows. God created your soul of nothing and at a specific time united it with your physical body. The Church says conception...as I am not God, I therefore completely trust the Church on this one. When its body no longer respond to its animating power then physical death will follow for the body. But your spirit does not die..it has a permanent hold on what it is and cannot be anything else. Since God created your soul, then only God can "let go" of it (annihilation) but he has said he will not will the human soul out of existence. A spiritual being, therefore, cannot lose its identity. Soooo.....we're stuck with ya! LOL. Welcome aboard! hope that helps.
Quietfire Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1289497' date='Jun 6 2007, 12:52 PM']But prior to the Fall, there was no death. To put it another way, death, disease, disintegration, etc., are a result of the Fall. In the absence of the Fall, without death, would all living things have simply continued to live forever, because they in some way had a "spark of life" from God, even if they weren't also spirit?[/quote] What do you think? It isnt hard to imagine that with the absense of sin, living bodies would live forever. But then again, since we were given dominion over plants and animals..it is still possible that they could experience death for our needs. I mean..we ate fruit...that much we know. And before the arguement starts... Some people think that before the fall we had no need to consume animal meat, which is possible, but that doesnt mean that being a vegetarian NOW is gonna solve the answer here. IMOO- this MAY have been the way it was before the fall but we have bigger spiritual fish to fry then worrying about what we're gonna put on the dining room table in relation to pleasing God. Since science is proving that a strickly vegetarian lifestyle NOW does not nourish the body of what it needs. I mean, personally..think about it?...people dont freak out over the fact that someone is eating a head of lettuce...and its a living body. But a cow or some other animal?...Man...with some folks you'd think that we were eating their kid or something. Just an observation here and a personal opinion. Be thankful Im not infallible. I am. You're going philosophically deep here, ya know. Cause anything is possible. We cant know for sure since with the introduction of sin...we can now know suffering and death. But it's food for thought.
kenrockthefirst Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 [quote name='Quietfire' post='1289542' date='Jun 6 2007, 02:22 PM']What do you think? It isnt hard to imagine that with the absense of sin, living bodies would live forever. But then again, since we were given dominion over plants and animals..it is still possible that they could experience death for our needs. I mean..we ate fruit...that much we know. And before the arguement starts... Some people think that before the fall we had no need to consume animal meat, which is possible, but that doesnt mean that being a vegetarian NOW is gonna solve the answer here. IMOO- this MAY have been the way it was before the fall but we have bigger spiritual fish to fry then worrying about what we're gonna put on the dining room table in relation to pleasing God. Since science is proving that a strickly vegetarian lifestyle NOW does not nourish the body of what it needs. I mean, personally..think about it?...people dont freak out over the fact that someone is eating a head of lettuce...and its a living body. But a cow or some other animal?...Man...with some folks you'd think that we were eating their kid or something. Just an observation here and a personal opinion. Be thankful Im not infallible. I am. You're going philosophically deep here, ya know. Cause anything is possible. We cant know for sure since with the introduction of sin...we can now know suffering and death. But it's food for thought.[/quote] What do I think? [list=1] [*]That without the Fall, living things would live forever. [*]That prior to the Fall, Adam and Eve were vegetarians. Animals needed to be killed [i]after[/i] the Fall for the blood expiation. Granted, that was then and this is now, but I wouldn't want to confuse a concession on the part of God with His ideal. [/list]"Food for thought?" No pun intended, har har. ;-)
Era Might Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 Plants are also alive, so if Adam and Eve were vegetarians, they were killing plants. I don't think we know whether animals were affected by the fall, or if they always died.
kenrockthefirst Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1289564' date='Jun 6 2007, 03:11 PM']Plants are also alive, so if Adam and Eve were vegetarians, they were killing plants. I don't think we know whether animals were affected by the fall, or if they always died.[/quote] I guess I'm making a distinction about death being the result of the Fall. The risen Lord ate fish, yet again I would consider that concession rather than the ideal. Does the capacity to experience pain result in a differentiation between plants and animals? Can plants, used "correctly," even be killed, i.e. if only fruit is eaten? I mow my lawn, the grass is cut but doesn't die -- although admittedly in my case it does ;-)
Era Might Posted June 6, 2007 Posted June 6, 2007 The definition of death is the separation of soul and body, and since plants are alive, they have non-spiritual souls that must separate when they die, and which then cease to exist. I don't know if God only intended humans to be without death, because we are also spirits. Maybe we will have pork chops in the Kingdom, who knows?
N/A Gone Posted June 7, 2007 Posted June 7, 2007 [quote name='Quietfire' post='1289530' date='Jun 6 2007, 02:54 PM']To quote F.J. Sheed:(my hero):[/quote] Morning brother. I want to recommend Sheed's "Theology for beginners" it would be the perfect book for you. It answers many of these questions and fits them into one solid understanding of the world. (I can even mail it to you if money is an issue...just facebook me) btw, Soul= Together with the body, the soul constitutes the substantial unity of the human being. It is the immaterial, immortal, directly created principle that constitutes a particular individual as human. The distinguishing feature of the human soul is that it is rational or intellective. The immortality of the soul arises from its simplicity or lack of composition: unlike material things, there are no components into which the human soul can break up. Incorruptibility is thus one reason for the soul’s immortality. Another is that man evinces unlimited spiritual capacities. Thus, although the soul and the body are a substantial unity, the soul is intrinsically independent of matter both in being and in origins. The soul endures after biological death. Further, the soul cannot be generated out of material conditions. According to Christian teaching, each soul is directly created by God. Human identity is nonetheless constituted by the unity of soul and body. The relation of the soul to the body is not an instrumental one, but a real, substantial one. (OSV)
Quietfire Posted June 7, 2007 Posted June 7, 2007 I love Sheed. I have almost every book he's written.
Justified Saint Posted June 12, 2007 Posted June 12, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1289422' date='Jun 6 2007, 09:43 AM']The human soul is also a spirit (eternal and rational), and this distinguishes it from the souls of animals, which are not "persons" as humans beings are. The soul is not pre-existing, but is created out of nothing at the moment of conception.[/quote] I am probably being picky here, but (if this is what you are saying) something cannot both be eternal and created. The soul is indeed created, but it isn't eternal.
Era Might Posted June 12, 2007 Posted June 12, 2007 The soul is eternal going forward, not going backward. We usually say, for example, that hell is eternal even though it has not always existed. Strictly speaking, only God is eternal, but eternal can be used in two senses; first in reference to God (who has always existed and is outside of time), and second in reference to those things which have not always existed, but will now never cease to exist. This second sense includes our soul. Pope John Paul II says, "It is by virtue of his eternal soul that the whole person, including his body, possesses such great dignity."
Quietfire Posted June 12, 2007 Posted June 12, 2007 wouldnt be easier to use the word immortal rather than eternal in describing angelic and human souls?
Era Might Posted June 12, 2007 Posted June 12, 2007 They can be interchangeable. Immortal is formulated negatively, that is, the soul does not die. Eternal is formulated positively, that is, the soul has life forever. If I were writing for non-Catholics, I would probably use immortal so as not to confuse the eternal nature of God with anything else.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now