Bonbon Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 There is a topic about this in the lame board but I wanted some facts without all the spam. As Catholics I heard that we should not take birth control for reasons I'm unclear on, besides the fact that we are married to have children. I know there is a pill that allows you to have only four periods a year. I wish to join the Military and the last thing I wanna worry about is my period once a month. So if I took the pill only for that reason, Would I still be sinning?
fundy_mental Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 If you had a medical condition that meant that you needed to take the pill (such as POS) then yes it is ok as long as your [u]intended purpose[/u] is not to make yourself sterile, this is called double effect. I don't think that your situation is grounds for doing this. Unless you have a health reason to not menstruate regularly. Aside from the religious standpoint; medically you should not be taking these drugs unless you really need to for medical reasons as they cause all kinds of risks to your health.
Katholikos Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 Christ founded the Catholic Church for the salvation of the world. We all should make the effort to learn [b]what[/b] the Church teaches [b]and why[/b]. One of the critical things she teaches is about human fertility, including artificial birth control and natural family planning. The Church speaks for Christ (Luke 10:16).
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 If you are called to marriage, I suggest not taking that pill. Like as stated above, unless if it is a serious health condition, and recommended and perscribed by your doctor, do NOT take it. As I wrote in the lame board it is like getting your tubes tied or talking the birth control pill while being sexually active. Just remember we are NOT God. May God Bless You
franciscanheart Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Katholikos' post='1290624' date='Jun 7 2007, 09:56 PM']Christ founded the Catholic Church for the salvation of the world. We all should make the effort to learn [b]what[/b] the Church teaches [b]and why[/b]. One of the critical things she teaches is about human fertility, including artificial birth control and natural family planning. The Church speaks for Christ (Luke 10:16). [/quote] Yes, papi! Amen.
IcePrincessKRS Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 If you took this pill with the intent to suspend your cycles, and thereby, for all practical purposes, sterilizing yourself (however temporary it may be) it would, indeed, be a sin. You may not take such measures unless they are [i]medically[/i] necessary and must be done to maintain your health. "I want," and "its convenient" are not good enough reasons, I'm afraid. Even if you are not sexually active there is no reason to use the pill unless its is required by a medical condition. If you are curious [i]why[/i] the Church teaches against the use of contraceptives and sterilization there are plenty of people here who can help.
jckinsman Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 Ditto the PM'ers above! Plus Why would you want to put your health at risk anyway? If it's not for medical reasons,why stuff yourself with a bunch of chemicals? JC
Archaeology cat Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='jckinsman' post='1290745' date='Jun 8 2007, 07:59 AM']Ditto the PM'ers above! Plus Why would you want to put your health at risk anyway? If it's not for medical reasons,why stuff yourself with a bunch of chemicals? JC[/quote] Just adding that the only medical reasons that would actually be helped by the pill are those that are hormone-related. And the pill does mess up your body, believe me. I was a nightmare to live with coming off of them, because my body didn't know what to do with my own hormones. Of course, I'm one of the lucky ones whose fertility returned fairly quickly after coming off the pill (obviously, since I'm now pregnant). Oh, and often, when you are doing that much physical activity and such, your body will compensate for you. Female athletes often have fewer periods (not always, but often).
Mary-Kathryn Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Cardinals Flower' post='1290589' date='Jun 7 2007, 10:50 PM']There is a topic about this in the lame board but I wanted some facts without all the spam. As Catholics I heard that we should not take birth control for reasons I'm unclear on, besides the fact that we are married to have children. I know there is a pill that allows you to have only four periods a year. I wish to join the Military and the last thing I wanna worry about is my period once a month. So if I took the pill only for that reason, Would I still be sinning?[/quote] You may want to look at God's Will versus you will right now. If joining the military would mean compromising your faith, then why are you even considering it? I understand about the pill thing and not wanting to worry about your period. After all we are at war. The guys sometimes go days without a bath, they are hot, smelly, and cramped altogether sometimes. Not ideal for a woman on her period. However, As a woman would you even be part of that? I don't know. So what would would you do if they did send you to Iraq? In my strogn opinion, they can't know yet what this pill will do in the long-term to a woman's body. It's simply too new. It's your generation that will eventually suffer from the effects. And I am certain there will be suffering. God made the female body in a very particular way. Our bodies are meant to have monthly periods, we can't deny it that natural cycle. Most important here is is that you need to go talk to a loving priest. Don't be shy, priests have heard it all. Ask him to give you the facts about the teachings of The Church and have a good talk. Everything I just said, is just my opinion. The priest will hopefully make everything clear.
Totus Tuus Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1290748' date='Jun 8 2007, 03:18 AM']Oh, and often, when you are doing that much physical activity and such, your body will compensate for you. Female athletes often have fewer periods (not always, but often).[/quote] Yup! Edited June 8, 2007 by Totus Tuus
chelsea Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 Talk to a priest. If you're in the middle of combat and you get your period, that would really smell of elderberries. If your purpose isnt to prevent conception, then i dont understand why it would be wrong. HOWEVER, i am not for certain on the Church teachings. Go talk to a priest.
prose Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='jckinsman' post='1290745' date='Jun 8 2007, 01:59 AM']Ditto the PM'ers above! Plus Why would you want to put your health at risk anyway? If it's not for medical reasons,why stuff yourself with a bunch of chemicals? JC[/quote] I was just thinking the same thing However, I am not sure it would be a sin if it was not being used for contraceptive purposes. You aren't planning on using it as a contraceptive, so I can't see why that would be a sin. But again, even if it wasn't a sin, that is a lot of chemicals to stick into your body that are dangerous.
Bonbon Posted June 8, 2007 Author Posted June 8, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Proud2BCatholic139' post='1290625' date='Jun 7 2007, 09:57 PM']If you are called to marriage, I suggest not taking that pill. Like as stated above, unless if it is a serious health condition, and recommended and perscribed by your doctor, do NOT take it. As I wrote in the lame board it is like getting your tubes tied or talking the birth control pill while being sexually active. Just remember we are NOT God. May God Bless You[/quote] Well I wouldn't take the pill if i was married. If I went in to Military life I wouldn't be married. If i got married later I'd switch to reserves and off the pill, That is if I take it. [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1290715' date='Jun 7 2007, 11:59 PM']If you took this pill with the intent to suspend your cycles, and thereby, for all practical purposes, sterilizing yourself (however temporary it may be) it would, indeed, be a sin. You may not take such measures unless they are [i]medically[/i] necessary and must be done to maintain your health. "I want," and "its convenient" are not good enough reasons, I'm afraid. Even if you are not sexually active there is no reason to use the pill unless its is required by a medical condition. If you are curious [i]why[/i] the Church teaches against the use of contraceptives and sterilization there are plenty of people here who can help.[/quote] I am curious why the Church teaches that its wrong...Not being rebellious, I just know a lot of ppl who don't understand why they shouldn't. [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1290748' date='Jun 8 2007, 02:18 AM']Oh, and often, when you are doing that much physical activity and such, your body will compensate for you. Female athletes often have fewer periods (not always, but often).[/quote] I heard that too. I'm pretty active now and only get it ever other month or six weeks. [quote name='prose' post='1290866' date='Jun 8 2007, 10:53 AM']I was just thinking the same thing However, I am not sure it would be a sin if it was not being used for contraceptive purposes. You aren't planning on using it as a contraceptive, so I can't see why that would be a sin. But again, even if it wasn't a sin, that is a lot of chemicals to stick into your body that are dangerous.[/quote] I wouldn't be using it for contraceptive purposes. and i think you're all right I should talk with a priest. Edited June 8, 2007 by Cardinals Flower
Bonbon Posted June 8, 2007 Author Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Mary-Kathryn' post='1290789' date='Jun 8 2007, 08:18 AM'][b]You may want to look at God's Will versus you will right now. If joining the military would mean compromising your faith, then why are you even considering it?[/b] I understand about the pill thing and not wanting to worry about your period. After all we are at war. The guys sometimes go days without a bath, they are hot, smelly, and cramped altogether sometimes. Not ideal for a woman on her period. However, As a woman would you even be part of that? I don't know. So what would would you do if they did send you to Iraq? In my strogn opinion, they can't know yet what this pill will do in the long-term to a woman's body. It's simply too new. It's your generation that will eventually suffer from the effects. And I am certain there will be suffering. God made the female body in a very particular way. Our bodies are meant to have monthly periods, we can't deny it that natural cycle. Most important here is is that you need to go talk to a loving priest. Don't be shy, priests have heard it all. Ask him to give you the facts about the teachings of The Church and have a good talk. Everything I just said, is just my opinion. The priest will hopefully make everything clear.[/quote] How am I compromising my faith by joining the Military?
Archaeology cat Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Cardinals Flower' post='1290897' date='Jun 8 2007, 05:25 PM']Well I wouldn't take the pill if i was married. If I went in to Military life I wouldn't be married. If i got married later I'd switch to reserves and off the pill, That is if I take it. I am curious why the Church teaches that its wrong...Not being rebellious, I just know a lot of ppl who don't understand why they shouldn't. I heard that too. I'm pretty active now and only get it ever other month or six weeks. I wouldn't be using it for contraceptive purposes.[/quote] Oh, I understood you weren't using it as a contraceptive. I was on it for medical reasons, but they weren't hormone-related, so I went off it. Some of them can do worse things to you than others. It only took 4 months for my cycle to return (not be normal, just return), while it can take up to 2 years. So it's just something to think about for the future. I was just angry when I found out all the things the pill had been doing to me, and the other things it could have done, that no doctor had told me about. So I got off pretty quickly when I found that out. That being said, not every pill is the same, and I don't know about all of them, just the one I was on. As for the Church teaching that it is wrong, the pill is wrong because it can, and does at times, cause an abortion of a fertilised egg. Now obviously if you aren't using it for contraception this isn't the concern. But I'll echo what others have said, which is to pray, and talk to a priest. That sounds like the best advice, in my opinion. By the way, what branch of the military?
Era Might Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1290648' date='Jun 7 2007, 11:31 PM']Yes, papi! Amen.[/quote] Did you call him papi?
franciscanheart Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1290913' date='Jun 8 2007, 11:45 AM']Did you call him papi? [/quote] Yes.
Mary-Kathryn Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Cardinals Flower' post='1290899' date='Jun 8 2007, 01:27 PM']How am I compromising my faith by joining the Military?[/quote] That's why I said to talk to a priest. If he says it's sinful to take this pill, you may want to re-consider joiming the military if you feel there's going to be a need for this pill while you are on active duty. A priest is the best source for all the correct teachings.
Bonbon Posted June 8, 2007 Author Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1290901' date='Jun 8 2007, 11:32 AM']Oh, I understood you weren't using it as a contraceptive. I was on it for medical reasons, but they weren't hormone-related, so I went off it. Some of them can do worse things to you than others. It only took 4 months for my cycle to return (not be normal, just return), while it can take up to 2 years. So it's just something to think about for the future. I was just angry when I found out all the things the pill had been doing to me, and the other things it could have done, that no doctor had told me about. So I got off pretty quickly when I found that out. That being said, not every pill is the same, and I don't know about all of them, just the one I was on. As for the Church teaching that it is wrong, the pill is wrong because it can, and does at times, cause an abortion of a fertilised egg. Now obviously if you aren't using it for contraception this isn't the concern. But I'll echo what others have said, which is to pray, and talk to a priest. That sounds like the best advice, in my opinion. By the way, what branch of the military?[/quote] I'll most likely be going Army now. For awhile and still want to go Marines, but there are some complications [quote name='Mary-Kathryn' post='1291018' date='Jun 8 2007, 02:18 PM']That's why I said to talk to a priest. If he says it's sinful to take this pill, you may want to re-consider joiming the military if you feel there's going to be a need for this pill while you are on active duty. A priest is the best source for all the correct teachings. [/quote] Oh i see. I'll join the military even if i don't take the pill. I was just wondering if I was able too. But I definitely talk to a priest.
Katholikos Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1290913' date='Jun 8 2007, 12:45 PM']Did you call him papi? [/quote] Nice nick, hughey. Thanks. But is it pronounced "poppy" or "pappy"? I always say, "Call me anything, as long as you call me [i][b]Catholic![/b][/i]!" :
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now