ILOVEMARY Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 Impediments to the priesthood are divided into "irregularities", which are permanent unless removed by the competent authority and "simple impediments" which may pass with time without action of an ecclesiastical authority. Canon Law also lists various impediments to the exercise of a priesthood that has already been conferred. The bishop can remove most irregularities and simple impediments, except for those involving public apostasy, heresy, or schism; abortion or murder, even if in secret; and existing marriages. Irregularities that cannot be removed by the bishop can be removed by the Holy See. One such impediment is the following: Attempt to perform an act proper to the priesthood or episcopate. This applies to hearing acts such as hearing confessions, presiding at marriages, etc. when one has not received the proper ordination to do so. (Can. 1041, 6°) Now hypothetically let's say a candidate for ordination at the age of twelve entered a yahoo chatroom and pretended to be a priest, someone wanted him to hear their confession online in a private chat and the kid accepted the invite. The kid does not believe he typed the prayer of absolution, but it is possible that he did, and he also recalls entering the chatroom at a later time and the person confronting him about not being a priest. Now, would this be an impediment for the man who has now aged in years. He had recalled he had done such a thing when he was 18 so he confessed it to a priest and thus was validly absolved. But the question reamins would this be an impediment to ordination. The kid at the age of twelve was not cannonically an adult and thus isn't bound to cannonical law. Secondly, any confession done via an instant messenger system would be null and void. Thirdly it is not like the individual was walkign around with a collar on, saying mass, hearing confessions, etc. even though he wasn't ordained, it was most likely a childhood prank or a realization he could fufill his dream of doing a priestly duty when he was so young. The question then is: Is there a cannonical impediment? and Does the individual need to inform his vocation director of his actions when he was twleve years old in a chat room? Thank you. ILOVEMARY
Pio Nono Posted June 8, 2007 Posted June 8, 2007 JMJ 6/8 - Ninth Friday ILOVEMARY, There are a number of reasons why I would say there is no impediment and that the issue described is not one to worry about. 1.) Since online "confessions" aren't valid anyway (even if a real priest tried to perform one), I don't see the situation as an impediment. 2.) Since there is serious doubt that the correct form was transmitted, and that any good Catholic would notice the difference if it were faulty, I don't see the situation as an impediment. 3.) In order to be counted "against" the individual, he has to have known that his actions created an impediment. Since it doesn't seem like he did, I don't see this situation as an impediment. Those are my big three. If there is still a question, I'd talk to a wise, holy priest about the issue (one who is not the Vocation Director). If he says the VD needs to know, then it would be time to talk. Otherwise, don't sweat it. Hope this helps. Yours, Pio Nono
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now