jiyoung Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 Yeah, it basically has to do with cultural norms--some say that women's hats have fallen out of fashion and that's why. But men's hats, aside from baseball caps, aren't exactly in fashion anymore...but it is still considered rude for a man to wear a hat indoors or in the presence of a lady. So that could be a contributing factor. But I'm strongly of the opinion that it's pretty much the feminazis' fault. Really, what of the moral decay of our society CAN'T you blame on the liberals? I'm in an area where most of the time you'll get funny looks (LA Archdiocese--go figure) but the circles I personally travel in are more traditional and either don't mind veils, like them, or the women wear them themselves. lol. So I'm good on that area, anyway. I had a beautiful experience with a friend who's very charismatic and doesn't really understand why I'm so traditional--all semester he looked at me with my veil and had no idea why I did it, and my own explanations didn't clear it up for him really well either. But at the Theology of the Body conference we were at, he finally understood it in the context of the imagery of the Bride and the Bridegroom--a concept he loves--and started to really appreciate its significance. That was wonderful for me because it actually gave me a lot of new insight to meditate on, and it's a way to show that it's not just a "traddy" devotion that only makes sense to the rad-trads. Sure, it's very traditional, but so is the rosary. I think if you take away the feminazi glasses that our society sort of puts on us, you can see how it really accentuates our womanhood and the dignity intrinsic to humanity, both in how it guards the woman's femininity and hides it from the man, making it a beautiful mystery for him. It really provides a sharp contrast to what women do to lure men nowadays--instead of flaunting her goods, a woman conceals them. I mean you can take this part or leave it, it's really just a product of my own thoughts about it. But I think it really provides an almost shocking display of...modesty! How sad that modesty is something so shocking in this society. As far as the canon law goes--the fact that the majority of canon lawyers do say it's optional now, and because Rome hasn't said anything, is pretty significant. Though--and here's the thing--I think it would be foolish to crack down on that now, because the Church has some waaaay bigger fish to fry. When women are coming into church with midriffs and thighs and shoulders and everything showing, telling them that not only do they need to cover up but they also have to wear a veil, it just wouldn't make sense to them. It's sad, but there's a much bigger problem to be addressed, and then maybe a statement could be made on headcoverings. And, again, I really appreciate that it's become a personal choice made with prayer and discernment. I think it requires a lot of humility for most women to finally make the plunge, because they feel God calling them to it but are afraid of the social backlash. That's what I usually hear, anyway. And not in any way to suggest my own humility--my decision didn't involve so much of that as it did blind obedience to my sense of duty, having been convinced that I should be wearing one. But maybe that's just how God works with me. and yeah, John, it's me
cathoholic_anonymous Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 [quote name='misereremi' post='1291403' date='Jun 9 2007, 09:45 PM']I wear mine at the Youth 2000 retreats during mass and adoration, rosary if we are in church, anytime I enter a church, whenever there is the Blessed Sacrament. Not sure if Steubenville is a similar thing. I don't know what anyone else thinks but I'm sure no one really minds me wearing one. I hadn't thought of that... In the week I might catch mass after/before work and I'm often wearing sneakers and tracksuit, so it does look a bit of an odd contrast when I put my pretty mantilla on. But I don't tend to care. Maybe I should care. [/quote] You go to Y2k?! This is off-topic, but...will you be at the Ealing retreat on 22nd June? Or the Walsingham prayer festival? I hope to get to both and it would be so amazing to meet a Phatmasser!
misereremi Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1291601' date='Jun 10 2007, 04:49 AM']You go to Y2k?! This is off-topic, but...will you be at the Ealing retreat on 22nd June? Or the Walsingham prayer festival? I hope to get to both and it would be so amazing to meet a Phatmasser![/quote] Yes! I plan to get to both, Godwilling. I'm not hard to spot... will PM you
misereremi Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1291487' date='Jun 10 2007, 12:43 AM']Just as a suggestion, you might consider keeping with you a non-wrinkle skirt so that you can slip it on in exchange for your tracksuit pants when you go to Mass. There are some skirts (I think they're nylon-based?) which do not wrinkle at all, and can be rolled up to fit in a backpack or something.[/quote] Sound like a good plan. I'm not into skirts but I have no excuse not to wear one really.
farglefeezlebut Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 My parents have expressly asked that I [b]don't [/b]wear a mantilla at our usual mass. They don't mind an ordinary headscarf, but they're worried that I will look like I'm "being political" and "trying to show off" and that people willnot only judge me for it but judge them.
ofpheritup Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 [quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1292076' date='Jun 10 2007, 03:52 PM']My parents have expressly asked that I [b]don't [/b]wear a mantilla at our usual mass. They don't mind an ordinary headscarf, but they're worried that I will look like I'm "being political" and "trying to show off" and that people willnot only judge me for it but judge them. [/quote] I don't understand why your parents care what other people think. You need to follow your conscience. What you wear or don't wear is between you and God. Your parents only need to be concerned with what makes you happy. I'm a parent and if my daughter wanted to wear one I would support her.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 [quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1292076' date='Jun 10 2007, 10:52 PM']My parents have expressly asked that I [b]don't [/b]wear a mantilla at our usual mass. They don't mind an ordinary headscarf, but they're worried that I will look like I'm "being political" and "trying to show off" and that people willnot only judge me for it but judge them. [/quote] Oh darn it. I knew I shouldn't have sent you that enormous one. I have a slightly smaller one that looks more discreet, as it doesn't flair so much, but I retained it because I prefer that one personally. I shouldn't have been so selfish. Start off with ordinary scarves. You have some dupattas, no? They would make good coverings for Mass. When you go to university you will be able to walk into Mass with a mantilla on your very first day. No one will judge you for it because they will never know that you have been any different. [quote]I don't understand why your parents care what other people think.[/quote] FFB's father is the priest. It is possible that people might think he is trying to forcibly shift the church in a new direction by compelling his daughter to wear a mantilla.
mortify Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 [quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1292076' date='Jun 10 2007, 03:52 PM']My parents have expressly asked that I [b]don't [/b]wear a mantilla at our usual mass. They don't mind an ordinary headscarf, but they're worried that I will look like I'm "being political" and "trying to show off" and that people willnot only judge me for it but judge them. [/quote] You know I've heard that phrase applied to other acts of reverence, i.e. kneeling before the Eucharist, exactly what[i] politics [/i]are being endorsed? It's sad that reverence to Jesus is dealt with so much opposition.
ofpheritup Posted June 10, 2007 Posted June 10, 2007 [quote name='mortify' post='1292197' date='Jun 10 2007, 06:23 PM']You know I've heard that phrase applied to other acts of reverence, i.e. kneeling before the Eucharist, exactly what[i] politics [/i]are being endorsed? It's sad that reverence to Jesus is dealt with so much opposition.[/quote] Thank you Mortify. I look at it this way, when I am judged I would much rather explain to Jesus why I did (show reverence) than why I didn't. There isn't going to be anyone else around, so why would we care what people think? I am not comfortable that our "right" to express our faith seems to be getting watered down for fear of offending someone or doing something that someone doesn't understand. We have a word for that, it's called explaining. My opinion is that the "person" who is behind all this is Satan. Following Jesus means exactly that, not following Mommy, Daddy, The Boss or your Brother or Sister, or the guy that pumps your gas.....it means FOLLOWING JESUS. I've made up my mind (clearly).
TotusTuusMaria Posted June 11, 2007 Author Posted June 11, 2007 J.M.J. You guys have been really great with the replies. I believe I will just take a hand bag that looks kind of "teenish" and put my mantilla and prayer book for Mass in it. I'll just put on the mantilla before Mass and adoration or if I'm in the presence of Jesus . Thanks for the answers. They helped. All of your little thoughts too on the subject of wearing the mantillas were informative and nice to read. I like reading other womens' thoughts and experiences with this. I do not feel so alone. Thanks guys! In Jesus and Mary, Marie
TotusTuusMaria Posted June 11, 2007 Author Posted June 11, 2007 J.M.J. [quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1292076' date='Jun 10 2007, 04:52 PM']My parents have expressly asked that I [b]don't [/b]wear a mantilla at our usual mass. They don't mind an ordinary headscarf, but they're worried that I will look like I'm "being political" and "trying to show off" and that people willnot only judge me for it but judge them. [/quote] My dad and brothers kind of felt the same way. My mom has been the only one that really supported me in the decision to start wearing one (although she herself does not). They kind of said some unkind things too when I started to wear the mantilla, but I believe they warmed up to it. I even kind of think my older brother respects me for wearing it and likes me wearing it now. I think you should talk to your parents again about this. If this is something you feel really called to do then tell your parents. Explain it to them. Maybe if you sit down and present the reasons why you want too and explain it has nothing to do with "politics" then they will warm up to it or at least re-think telling you not too. I said a prayer for your parents. In Jesus and Mary, Marie
mortify Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 Ladies, don't let the [i]man[/i] keep ya down, wear your veils with pride!
cathoholic_anonymous Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 [quote name='ofpheritup' post='1292225' date='Jun 11 2007, 01:51 AM']Thank you Mortify. I look at it this way, when I am judged I would much rather explain to Jesus why I did (show reverence) than why I didn't. There isn't going to be anyone else around, so why would we care what people think? I am not comfortable that our "right" to express our faith seems to be getting watered down for fear of offending someone or doing something that someone doesn't understand. We have a word for that, it's called explaining. My opinion is that the "person" who is behind all this is Satan. Following Jesus means exactly that, not following Mommy, Daddy, The Boss or your Brother or Sister, or the guy that pumps your gas.....it means FOLLOWING JESUS. I've made up my mind (clearly). [/quote] The spiritual significance of the mantilla does not lie in the mantilla itself. It lies in the fact that you've got your head covered. FFB's parents have said that they don't mind her using an ordinary scarf to cover her head, so it's not as if she is being prevented from following her to desire to honour Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament in this way. FFB's dad is one of Britain's comparatively few married Catholic priests. As such, he and his family are 'on show' during the Mass in a way that other families are not. A mantilla is much more noticeable than a scarf. If the priest's daughter appeared in one, the other parishioners might not read it as a private act of devotion on her part but as an attempt made by the priest to turn the parish more traditional. And they might get skittish. It is easy for us to say, "Well, he's a priest - he should only care about Jesus, not what the parishioners might think!" But I suspect that it is very very difficult for a priest to go about his work without some sensitivity to 'parish politics'. As he has agreed to let FFB wear a scarf, she has got the best of both worlds. She can veil her head before Christ in the Blessed Sacrament, and she has the opportunity to honour her father and her mother.
ofpheritup Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1292723' date='Jun 11 2007, 09:53 AM']It is easy for us to say, "Well, he's a priest - he should only care about Jesus, not what the parishioners might think!" But I suspect that it is very very difficult for a priest to go about his work without some sensitivity to 'parish politics'. As he has agreed to let FFB wear a scarf, she has got the best of both worlds. She can veil her head before Christ in the Blessed Sacrament, and she has the opportunity to honour her father and her mother.[/quote] I find the word "let" curious. What she chooses to do to honor God is between her and God. I honor my Mother and Father as long as what they ask does not conflict with what God is asking of me. My parents have been informed. I said it earlier, I would rather explain to Jesus why I showed reverence than why I didn't. As far as "Parish Politics" are these people Jesus? What right do they have to comment. Their time would be better spent minding their own business. Their lives (trust me) are not perfect. Ladies, Yahoo has a support group for women (of any age) who choose to 'cover.' PM me for info.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 Again, FFB's dad is not stopping her from covering her head. When I felt called to cover my hair, Jesus didn't specify the precise type of covering (style, colour, length, material, fabric blend...) that He wanted. That much was left to me. Is there something more honourable about a mantilla than there is about a solid scarf? Are women who cover with mantillas showing more respect to Our Lord than those with scarves? [quote]As far as "Parish Politics" are these people Jesus? What right do they have to comment. Their time would be better spent minding their own business. Their lives (trust me) are not perfect.[/quote] It is easy for us to say that. We aren't in the position of FFB's dad and we don't have his priestly responsibilities. As it is, I'm sure he's doing the best he can in the circumstances he knows. As I know the family and I've seen the kind of contributions they make to the Catholic community (one of them being six absolutely great children) I have to say it's a good best. He would never deliberately stifle FFB's sense of devotion.
Lil Red Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 [quote name='ofpheritup' post='1292780' date='Jun 11 2007, 09:33 AM']As far as "Parish Politics" are these people Jesus? What right do they have to comment. Their time would be better spent minding their own business. Their lives (trust me) are not perfect.[/quote] have you ever been involved at a parish staff level? parish politics (unfortunately) play a lot into how a parish is run - and people can make a priest's life very hard.
jiyoung Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 I can understand that--at least her parents aren't asking her to not wear a headcovering at all. And a scarf works, too...I think it's nice to be able to respect your parents' wishes in that respect, because we are bound to obedience to a point, after all, and they're not asking her to do anything that goes against her conscience. You can still wear a mantilla when you're not at your home parish, after all.
farglefeezlebut Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 Please do not criticise my family. I will wear a scarf. That is the same. In fact, it covers more and is less likely to fall off.
jiyoung Posted June 11, 2007 Posted June 11, 2007 lol...it's true, those mantillas are dang slippery. I put bobby pins in to hold them in place now.
TotusTuusMaria Posted June 11, 2007 Author Posted June 11, 2007 [quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1292990' date='Jun 11 2007, 02:50 PM']Please do not criticise my family. I will wear a scarf. That is the same. In fact, it covers more and is less likely to fall off.[/quote] I did not mean to sound as if I was criticising your family. I thought you meant that your parents would not allow you to wear a headcovering period. When I made this post I wrote "for those women who wear mantillas" rather hastily. I wear the mantilla, so that would probably be why I phrased it that way. I should have written "for those women who cover their heads". I personally chose the mantilla because it did not matter what I wore on my head... anything would have been odd. I understand that over seas though one is more likely to see someone wearing a scarf or a hat. I am in the States... and the south at that. One usually does not see many women wearing hats or scarfs. Plus I owned a mantilla where as I did not own an appropriate hat, and I have never owned a scarf. Like someone else said... Jesus calls you to cover your head. He never says what material or fabric to use.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now