Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

My sister-in- law and I got to talking about catholic weddings. Does anyone know the correct way to determine attendance? A Protestant wants to marry catholic,catholic was just raised catholic and does not attend church. They want to marry in a garden. or any other scenario? Two none practicing catholics,married in a garden? What is the correct protocol and when is it determined that as a catholic you should not attend? Anyone? JC It is the wedding season!

homeschoolmom
Posted

Frankly, I think there are no hard and fast rules.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1293906' date='Jun 12 2007, 06:20 PM']Frankly, I think there are no hard and fast rules.[/quote]
Really,??? I thought there was some kind of protocol for weddings? I had always heard that there was!

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

In my humble opinion, as a Catholic, you can attend the wedding of a fallen away Catholic if you think it may drive a person further from the Church for you not to show up and if you think that the fallen away Catholic won't take your attendance as a sign of approval of their bad standing in the Church.

When I was in the seminary, we were told not to attend such weddings, because, however skewed a view it is, people would take our presence as a sign of Church approval. As a youth minister, I personally think the same holds true. I can't go to such a wedding.

Posted

I was taught that you can attend any type of wedding. But you couldn't be apart of the wedding if it was not done right. Catholics are suppose to be married in the church or on blessed grounds.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1294490' date='Jun 13 2007, 12:48 PM']In my humble opinion, as a Catholic, you can attend the wedding of a fallen away Catholic if you think it may drive a person further from the Church for you not to show up and if you think that the fallen away Catholic won't take your attendance as a sign of approval of their bad standing in the Church.

When I was in the seminary, we were told not to attend such weddings, because, however skewed a view it is, people would take our presence as a sign of Church approval. As a youth minister, I personally think the same holds true. I can't go to such a wedding.[/quote]

That's basically what I've heard Karl Keating explain when people call Catholic Answers on the radio with similar questions.

1. Attend if you think it would drive the fallen-away Catholic further from the Church if you didn't show up (a lot of times they fall away because of some kind of bitterness, and your not coming could deepen that bitterness).

2. Don't attend if you think your coming would be a mark of approval for their not practicing the Faith.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1294614' date='Jun 13 2007, 03:06 PM']That's basically what I've heard Karl Keating explain when people call Catholic Answers on the radio with similar questions.

1. Attend if you think it would drive the fallen-away Catholic further from the Church if you didn't show up (a lot of times they fall away because of some kind of bitterness, and your not coming could deepen that bitterness).

2. Don't attend if you think your coming would be a mark of approval for their not practicing the Faith.[/quote]
Maybe I'm secretly Karl Keating. :ninja:

Posted

My daughter is being a flower girl in my fallen away sister's wedding in an outdoor garden ceremony. I want to puke thinking about it, but if we didn't it would just push her (and several other family members) further away.

MissScripture
Posted

My aunt was invited to a "committment ceremony" by her niece and niece's boyfriend...who have been living together for like a year already, anyway. They made it clear that this is not an engagment ceremony or legal wedding or anything...just their own little "committment ceremony." My aunt isn't going, but is trying to figure out how to say this without creating world war 3...

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1294675' date='Jun 13 2007, 04:20 PM']My aunt was invited to a "committment ceremony" by her niece and niece's boyfriend...who have been living together for like a year already, anyway. They made it clear that this is not an engagment ceremony or legal wedding or anything...just their own little "committment ceremony." My aunt isn't going, but is trying to figure out how to say this without creating world war 3...[/quote]
Tell them she has a prior commitment. :hehe:

No, don't do that. :mellow:

homeschoolmom
Posted

Last month we went to RussianGirl's wedding. (For those of you who don't know, RussianGirl was an exchange student who lived with us in HS and through most of college... until she moved in with her now husband...) She is a close "member" of the family. She is Catholic, though not practicing. The wedding was in an historic mansion-- done by a judge. Her parents came from Russia for the wedding. They don't speak English. Had we, her American family, not attended we would have no way of explaining to her parents and (we believe) would have been a bad witness to them. We are the only practicing Catholics they know (or probably the only practicing Christians they know). So, we went. She knows we did not approve of her shacking up or marrying outside the Church. But our not being there would have caused irreperable division.

Posted

Okay,My sister and my sister in-laws brother were married already in the church,both have since divorced and have been seeing other people. If in the future they decided to marry without an taking the proper steps,we should not attend,even if it would cause division, right???? because they were both married in the church before?????? What do you think????? Neither are obviously practicing. I thought the fact you were married in the church before meant something. JC

Posted

Or, suggest now that they should be applying for annullments. Tell them the process can take over a year. Then deal with things from there.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1295270' date='Jun 14 2007, 01:29 PM']Or, suggest now that they should be applying for annullments. Tell them the process can take over a year. Then deal with things from there.[/quote]
Well My own mother brought that up with my sister and she just laughed it off. She doesn't practice so why bother?(is her way of looking at it) JC

Church Punk
Posted

I can think of one instance of my cousin (who hasnt been married yet) Thank GOD! He wants to have a black wedding in a cemetary (he is a fallen catholic into this gothic vampire carp). This will definatelybe a case of not showing up.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Church Punk' post='1295355' date='Jun 14 2007, 04:53 PM']I can think of one instance of my cousin (who hasnt been married yet) Thank GOD! He wants to have a black wedding in a cemetary (he is a fallen catholic into this gothic vampire carp). This will definatelybe a case of not showing up.[/quote]
well... yeah... that's beyond normal.... :unsure:

Posted

Well at least my sis is not into vampires! That is so scary to me where the sanctity of marriage is headed! JC :marriage:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...