Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[b]The U.S. Catholic Church Is Sinking Fast [/b]
The New Oxford Review
June 2007


[quote]The March 9th National Catholic Reporter (NCR) reported on two recent sociological surveys of Catholics.

One survey, conducted by Vincent Bolduc at St. Michael's College in Colchester, Vermont, collected data on more than 1,600 students at five Catholic colleges. According to NCR, "Bolduc said young Catholic students he studied are steeped in a national culture that often regards the Catholic sexual prohibitions against premarital sex, artificial birth control, abortion, divorce, women priests and homosexual behavior as anachronistic." These are the future Catholics.

The other survey (the full report is in NCR, Sept. 30, 2005) was conducted by William V. D'Antonio, James Davidson, Dean Hoge, and Mary Gauthier.

They found that, among highly committed Catholics, 62 percent support priestesses.

In part, this is a longitudinal study of pre-Vatican II Catholics (ages 65 and older), Vatican II Catholics (ages 45-64), post-Vatican II Catholics (ages 26-44), and Millennial Catholics (ages 18-25).

Those Catholics were asked to respond to this statement: "[You]can be a good Catholic without attending Mass every week." Agree: Pre-Vatican II Catholics, 69 percent; post-Vatican II Catholics, 76 percent; Millennials, 95 percent. (We will leave the Vatican II Catholics aside.)

"Individuals [as opposed to the Church hierarchy] have final say on abortion." Agree: Pre-Vatican II Catholics, 31 percent; post-Vatican II Catholics, 44 percent; Millennials, 77 percent.

"[You] can be a good Catholic without obeying the church's opposition to abortion." Agree: Pre-Vatican II Catholics, 44 percent; post-Vatican II Catholics, 59 percent; Millennials, 89 percent.

"Catholicism contains a greater share of truth than other religions do." Agree: Pre-Vatican II Catholics, 61 percent; Millennials, 44 percent. (No data on post-Vatican II Catholics given.) However, in the Bolduc survey, among college Millennials, only 19 percent agree. These college Millennials will make up the leading tier of future Catholics.

We are saddened to say that things are just not working in the U.S., and Europe is worse. No springtime here. Actually, the forecast calls for an extended winter.[/quote]

Posted

hopefully it'll come back and be better then ever

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Red flag 1.) National Catholic Reporter.
Red flag 2.) Vermont.

I'm just sayin'.

Even if it were true for the time being, the law of nature shows that Cafeteria Catholics are just going to contracept themselves to near extinction anyway.

Posted

Friends, I also hope everything goes for the better, and perhaps we have the consolation that liberalism is self defeating, but we have to deal with the fact that we are shrinking. More of us cross over to the other side than the other side coming to us, and those that do don't just leave, they often want their views to become Magesterial teaching.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1294014' date='Jun 13 2007, 03:14 AM']Friends, I also hope everything goes for the better, and perhaps we have the consolation that liberalism is self defeating, but we have to deal with the fact that we are shrinking.[/quote]

"You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my Church. The gates of hell shall not prevail against it."

He will take care of us. He promised. This is not an excuse for laxity, obviously, but so long as we are doing our best to be faithful to Jesus in prayer and in action I don't see that we should get unduly worried by the cafeteria contingent.

During Lent I forced myself to abstain from debates on 'liberal' Catholic discussion boards. The sheer number of dissenting people who genuinely believed that they were Catholic frightened me. I was getting increasingly worried about the quality of my apologetics. In short, I had made myself the centre of the problem. I had tried to nudge Jesus aside. He used my fast to remind me that He is the one at the head of this Church and that He will stay there for good.

Posted

Think about Arianism. The Barque of Peter is still upright and sailing for home.

Moral: Better catechesis is required. That's not news.

Posted

That's all true stuff. I like your witness, Cathoholic. Canada is the same way. Going down hill. I guess there will be pruning of the Church. It will grow back better than ever though.

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1294014' date='Jun 12 2007, 09:14 PM']Friends, I also hope everything goes for the better, and perhaps we have the consolation that liberalism is self defeating, but we have to deal with the fact that we are shrinking. More of us cross over to the other side than the other side coming to us, and those that do don't just leave, they often want their views to become Magesterial teaching.[/quote]


i'd like to suggest a different opinion. those of us (i'm a teen) who ARE in line with catholic teaching are in the midst of a great renewal. i've seen so much fervor devotion and love for the church in young people that i am shocked and amazed. young people today really love their church and i believe that the us catholic church is not on a decline. perhaps the older population? *shrugs* but i am a youth and i havent seen a decline...i HAVE seen many people who disagree with the church and many of them leave the church but there are many more of us who love the church and the future of the church is not something that i am too worried about. excited would be a much better word.

Posted

While things may be grim in many ways, I for one do not believe that "liberal Catholicism"is the future of the Church.
I know quite a few young (and orthodox) converts to the Faith, and those young people most actively involved in the Church are often orthodox. Yes, there is a lot of catechizing to be done, but let's not wallow about in despair.

And I would not waste time reading either the National Catholic Reporter (liberal dissenting trash) nor the New Oxford Review (slanderous "conservative" trash, wallowing in scandal and despair).

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1293982' date='Jun 12 2007, 08:53 PM']Red flag 1.) National Catholic Reporter.
Red flag 2.) Vermont.

I'm just sayin'.

Even if it were true for the time being, the law of nature shows that Cafeteria Catholics are just going to contracept themselves to near extinction anyway.[/quote]

That was definitely my first thought when I read the first couple of lines...

Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1294049' date='Jun 12 2007, 10:47 PM']That's all true stuff. I like your witness, Cathoholic. Canada is the same way. Going down hill. I guess there will be pruning of the Church. It will grow back better than ever though.[/quote]


Agreed!

We have many reasons to be optimistic.

I think that in the not too distant future (perhaps 1-2 generations) the cafeteria Catholic will become a thing of the past. In my opinion, the divide between being a person of Faith and an agnostic/atheist is growing. I think that people who have no real devotion to the Faith will ultimately drop any associations that they might have with the Church. Perhaps it is due to the resurgence of orthodoxy, but whatever the reason may be, I have a hard time imagining cafeteria Catholics remaining in an increasingly orthodox Roman Catholic Church.

Fewer Clergy preaching about "using your conscience when it comes to contraception", the potential release of the Motu Proprio and its possible effects on liturgical celebration, Pope's like B16, orthodox material on Church teaching, legitimate Catholic Universities like S.T.A. & Ave Maria and............. PHATMASS!!! are all very good signs for the future of the Church.

On another note, what an exciting time this is to be Catholic, the Lord needs workers!! He must have very big plans for us if he appointed us for this challenging time!

Posted

The questions are worded in a way to encourage bias.

"[You]can be a good Catholic without attending Mass every week." Well DUH, of course you can. If I'm sick and can't get out of bed, or if my car breaks down on the way to evening mass, I didn't attend mass every week but I'm still a good Catholic. If I miss mass and then am in confession the next week, I'm still a good Catholic.

The correct wording would have been, "Do you agree with the church's teaching of attending mass every week."

Secondly, if it was up to me, we'd DRAMATICALLY drop in numbers, with everyone who doesn't agree with church teaching leaving.

johnnydigit
Posted

red flag 3.) "highly committed Catholics"

"3 out of 4 dentists choose Crest."


prune prune prune. maybe i'm just young, but i sense a strong renewal brewing too.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1294361' date='Jun 13 2007, 01:33 AM']The questions are worded in a way to encourage bias.

"[You]can be a good Catholic without attending Mass every week." Well DUH, of course you can. If I'm sick and can't get out of bed, or if my car breaks down on the way to evening mass, I didn't attend mass every week but I'm still a good Catholic. If I miss mass and then am in confession the next week, I'm still a good Catholic.

The correct wording would have been, "Do you agree with the church's teaching of attending mass every week."[/quote]

EXACTLY! I don't mean to sound ambivalent about the state of the church in America, but given who conducted this survey, and where this survey is done makes it suspect. The MSM and the National Catholic Reporter are absolute hogwash to be taken with more than just a grain of salt -- more like a cow's salt lick block.

[img]http://www.blinman.com/salt_lick_s.jpg[/img]

Posted

I would have to concur with the people who have pointed out sampling errors and experimenter bias in this survey. I see a lot of hope for the future of the Church. Thanks to sites like this and others, I hae come across many tweenaged (between 12 and 30) catholics with a great love of the Church and her teachings, and a great desire to know more and draw other people closer. I am told there was a bit of a demographic dip after the First Vatican Council as well.

But indeed the greatest sign of hope is that the Gates of Hell will not prevail against it.

farglefeezlebut
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1294361' date='Jun 13 2007, 07:33 AM']The questions are worded in a way to encourage bias.

"[You]can be a good Catholic without attending Mass every week." Well DUH, of course you can. If I'm sick and can't get out of bed, or if my car breaks down on the way to evening mass, I didn't attend mass every week but I'm still a good Catholic. If I miss mass and then am in confession the next week, I'm still a good Catholic.

The correct wording would have been, "Do you agree with the church's teaching of attending mass every week."

Secondly, if it was up to me, we'd DRAMATICALLY drop in numbers, with everyone who doesn't agree with church teaching leaving.[/quote]


That's exactly what I thought when I was reading it. One of the best Catholics I know is frequently unable to make it to Church, through no fault of her own.

I'd like to know more about the sampling and methodology of this questionnaire, also.

Anyway, one hundred and four percent of people know that four out of three statistics are made up and twenty bajillion per cent of them aren't even plausible.

The abortion thing worries me. I was against it even in my "liberal phase."

Saint Bernadette's prayers kept me in the Church. I know it. I thought about leaving Cathoplicism to become a Quaker or even not to have any organised religion, but what held me back was the memory of my confirmation (Bernadette is my confirmation Saint) and the memory of pilgrimage to Lourdes. So I think she prayed for me and that is why I stayed. Also my family fixed the poor catechesis I had received. There was so much they assumed I knew. When they realised I didn't know it they were shocked. :)

Cathechesis needs sorting out. Where are the Dominicans when we need them?

Jesus will look after us.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1294014' date='Jun 12 2007, 08:14 PM']Friends, I also hope everything goes for the better, and perhaps we have the consolation that liberalism is self defeating, but we have to deal with the fact that we are shrinking. More of us cross over to the other side than the other side coming to us, and those that do don't just leave, they often want their views to become Magesterial teaching.[/quote]

The Pope has essentially acknowledged that the Church will "shrink," but with a view toward "quality" rather than "quantity." We can't force people to believe, all we can do is ask that those who are "on board" to be so 100%.

philosophette
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1294107' date='Jun 12 2007, 10:30 PM']i'd like to suggest a different opinion. those of us (i'm a teen) who ARE in line with catholic teaching are in the midst of a great renewal. i've seen so much fervor devotion and love for the church in young people that i am shocked and amazed. young people today really love their church and i believe that the us catholic church is not on a decline. perhaps the older population? *shrugs* but i am a youth and i havent seen a decline...i HAVE seen many people who disagree with the church and many of them leave the church but there are many more of us who love the church and the future of the church is not something that i am too worried about. excited would be a much better word.[/quote]


[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1294369' date='Jun 13 2007, 02:52 AM']red flag 3.) "highly committed Catholics"

"3 out of 4 dentists choose Crest."
prune prune prune. maybe i'm just young, but i sense a strong renewal brewing too.[/quote]


[quote name='Staretz' post='1294385' date='Jun 13 2007, 06:00 AM']I would have to concur with the people who have pointed out sampling errors and experimenter bias in this survey. I see a lot of hope for the future of the Church. Thanks to sites like this and others, I hae come across many tweenaged (between 12 and 30) catholics with a great love of the Church and her teachings, and a great desire to know more and draw other people closer. I am told there was a bit of a demographic dip after the First Vatican Council as well.

But indeed the greatest sign of hope is that the Gates of Hell will not prevail against it.[/quote]


I would totally agree. I think that if the survey was done among those Millennial Catholics who actually practice their faith as opposed to those who call themselves Catholic as a matter of convenience, the results would be very different. I also agree with dUST that the wording was totally biased and designed to get a certain result.

I never pay much attention to these surveys and I object to how the NOR named this piece - "The US Catholic Church is Sinking Fast". What piffle. There is a revival of faith taking place, it might be slowly happening, but it is happening, and are we really all that much worse compared to the Catholic Church in Spain or other such countries where they also allow abortion? Are other countries simply better in their faith because they have Gothic Churches?

I think that if anyone is paying any attention at all to the numbers of young people entering religious life (so far [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=60330"]13 this year just among PhatMasser[/url]s) they would also not even pay heed to such a study. I am among eight women entering the Salesian Sisters in August... the year before there were three, the year before that one, before that zero... and had been for several years.

Let us not insult the work of the Holy Spirit among the young, NOR.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='philosobrat' post='1294456' date='Jun 13 2007, 11:32 AM']I would totally agree. I think that if the survey was done among those Millennial Catholics who actually practice their faith as opposed to those who call themselves Catholic as a matter of convenience, the results would be very different. I also agree with dUST that the wording was totally biased and designed to get a certain result.

I never pay much attention to these surveys and I object to how the NOR named this piece - "The US Catholic Church is Sinking Fast". What piffle. There is a revival of faith taking place, it might be slowly happening, but it is happening, and are we really all that much worse compared to the Catholic Church in Spain or other such countries where they also allow abortion? Are other countries simply better in their faith because they have Gothic Churches?

I think that if anyone is paying any attention at all to the numbers of young people entering religious life (so far [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=60330"]13 this year just among PhatMasser[/url]s) they would also not even pay heed to such a study. I am among eight women entering the Salesian Sisters in August... the year before there were three, the year before that one, before that zero... and had been for several years.

Let us not insult the work of the Holy Spirit among the young, NOR.[/quote]


Can't remember if it was Moses or Joshua, but the Isrealites were about to go to battle and God said you have to many men. He used some tests to whittle it down from about 10,000 to 300 as I recall. Then gave them victory.

I heard Benedict XVI say that there may be some pruning back in the Church. I've heard others say it as well. I would not be surprized.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1294462' date='Jun 13 2007, 11:37 AM']Can't remember if it was Moses or Joshua, but the Isrealites were about to go to battle and God said you have to many men. He used some tests to whittle it down from about 10,000 to 300 as I recall. Then gave them victory.

I heard Benedict XVI say that there may be some pruning back in the Church. I've heard others say it as well. I would not be surprized.[/quote]
Gideon.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...