The Joey-O Posted June 13, 2007 Posted June 13, 2007 The Catechism of the Catholic Church says: [quote]1263 By Baptism all sins are forgiven, original sin and all personal sins, as well as all punishment for sin. In those who have been reborn nothing remains that would impede their entry into the Kingdom of God, neither Adam's sin, nor personal sin, nor the consequences of sin, the gravest of which is separation from God. 1264 Yet certain temporal consequences of sin remain in the baptized, such as suffering, illness, death, and such frailties inherent in life as weaknesses of character, and so on, as well as an inclination to sin that Tradition calls concupiscence, or metaphorically, "the tinder for sin" (fomes peccati); since concupiscence "is left for us to wrestle with, it cannot harm those who do not consent but manfully resist it by the grace of Jesus Christ." Indeed, "an athlete is not crowned unless he competes according to the rules."[/quote] I need to have this issue clarified. It seems like one would need to go to Purgatory to purge concupiscence even if one were struck by a lightening bolt immediately after baptism. Or, does God, in the case of those who only bear concupiscence from prior to baptism, simply ignore these instances of concupiscence? I would like to see a discussion unravel at some length, because I really need clarification on this issue.
Myles Domini Posted June 13, 2007 Posted June 13, 2007 [quote name='The Joey-O' post='1294145' date='Jun 13 2007, 04:58 AM']The Catechism of the Catholic Church says: I need to have this issue clarified. It seems like one would need to go to Purgatory to purge concupiscence even if one were struck by a lightening bolt immediately after baptism. Or, does God, in the case of those who only bear concupiscence from prior to baptism, simply ignore these instances of concupiscence? I would like to see a discussion unravel at some length, because I really need clarification on this issue.[/quote] I think point 1264 explains it quite well. The sin is in submitting to concupisence not in concupisence itself. For example, certain people have aggressive tendencies. Its just how they're wired. Nonetheless, their sin is not in having the tendency to be aggressive but in submitting to these urges and acting in a violent and destructive manner. Human beings were created out of nothing and tend without grace towards nothing as St Athanasius illustrates in De Incarnatione Verbi. My interpretation of St Athanasius works from the understanding of evil as a privation of the good. Evil can only appear where something that should be ceases to be because it is a privation and not a substance. Being is good and good is being, the privation of being would be non-being and thus non-being is evil. Creation was from nothing, it is not evil because it does not come from a substance called evil. Creation is fundamentally (and cannot be anything but) good because all created things partake in Being as a result of their being and being and good as previously stated are synonyms. Nonetheless, that does not remove the fact that man has without grace a tendency to turn back towards nothingness and that is what St Athanasius said happened to man as a result of the fall. Man's nature was endowed with certain gifts in his state of original integrity that do not fall under his natural powers. As a created, changeable entity, man does have a tendency towards the nothingness from which he came but by grace God gifted man with his likeness as well as his image. By original sin we lost the likeness. Baptism's purpose is to restore the likeness by removing sin and opening up the soul to the one grace completed from the Father, through the Son by the Holy Spirit (Athansius, ad. Serap. 1:14). However, the graces that God choses to give us when we are restored are His own to decide. The preevient gifts such as immortality, invulnerability and mastery of the will have not been given to us as they were given to Adam but from this one need not infer that there is something incomplete about baptism. Being subject to natural evil via our tendency towards non-being be it manifested through a taste for privations of the good or straightforward death is not something that needs to be remitted before you go to heaven. If you died (the very fact that you can die shows the temporal consequences of sin) immediately after baptism you would enjoy beatitude immediately subsequent.
The Joey-O Posted June 13, 2007 Author Posted June 13, 2007 [quote name='Myles Domini' post='1294204' date='Jun 12 2007, 11:33 PM']I think point 1264 explains it quite well. The sin is in submitting to concupisence not in concupisence itself. For example, certain people have aggressive tendencies. Its just how they're wired. Nonetheless, their sin is not in having the tendency to be aggressive but in submitting to these urges and acting in a violent and destructive manner. Human beings were created out of nothing and tend without grace towards nothing as St Athanasius illustrates in De Incarnatione Verbi. My interpretation of St Athanasius works from the understanding of evil as a privation of the good. Evil can only appear where something that should be ceases to be because it is a privation and not a substance. Being is good and good is being, the privation of being would be non-being and thus non-being is evil. Creation was from nothing, it is not evil because it does not come from a substance called evil. Creation is fundamentally (and cannot be anything but) good because all created things partake in Being as a result of their being and being and good as previously stated are synonyms. Nonetheless, that does not remove the fact that man has without grace a tendency to turn back towards nothingness and that is what St Athanasius said happened to man as a result of the fall. Man's nature was endowed with certain gifts in his state of original integrity that do not fall under his natural powers. As a created, changeable entity, man does have a tendency towards the nothingness from which he came but by grace God gifted man with his likeness as well as his image. By original sin we lost the likeness. Baptism's purpose is to restore the likeness by removing sin and opening up the soul to the one grace completed from the Father, through the Son by the Holy Spirit (Athansius, ad. Serap. 1:14). However, the graces that God choses to give us when we are restored are His own to decide. The preevient gifts such as immortality, invulnerability and mastery of the will have not been given to us as they were given to Adam but from this one need not infer that there is something incomplete about baptism. Being subject to natural evil via our tendency towards non-being be it manifested through a taste for privations of the good or straightforward death is not something that needs to be remitted before you go to heaven. If you died (the very fact that you can die shows the temporal consequences of sin) immediately after baptism you would enjoy beatitude immediately subsequent.[/quote] I'm not confusing concupisence with sin. I am fully aware that having the desire or tendency to sin does not equal a sin. I was under the impression that concupisence still had to be purged from the individual to ensure that a person would continually "do good" in Heaven, and thus there would be no "second fall" for individuals.
The Joey-O Posted June 13, 2007 Author Posted June 13, 2007 If the title was deceiving, I guess I would rephrase it, "all of our sins are forgiven in Baptism, but not all the penalties of said sin???"
peach_cube Posted June 13, 2007 Posted June 13, 2007 [quote name='The Joey-O' post='1294748' date='Jun 13 2007, 06:21 PM']If the title was deceiving, I guess I would rephrase it, "all of our sins are forgiven in Baptism, but not all the penalties of said sin???"[/quote] The penalties of sin are our fallen nature, if those penalties were also forgiven we would be like Adam and Eve.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now