The Joey-O Posted June 13, 2007 Posted June 13, 2007 Is "beatitude" as understood by Aquinas considered an atonement model? It definately has atonement implications. Please explain your answer. If the answer is no, then how does it relate to atonement? NOTE: I don't want to "debate" (otherwise I'd put this on the debate table); I want to hear (a) faithful explanation(s).
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 15, 2007 Posted June 15, 2007 I don't fully understand your question so I feel apprehensive about replying positively. In what context are you referring to Aquinas' understanding of beatitude? In broad terms (human) beatitude means for Aquinas the ultimate goal or fulfillment of our nature, our "blessedness" or "happiness". Naturally there is much more that could be said to elucidate the details of "beatitude" in the theology of St. Thomas, as some, such as Servais Pinckaers, have admirably done. But simply for the sake of clarification, what exactly is the impetus of your question in this regard? I am quite uncertain about the sense in which you speak of "an atonement model". Do you mean to ask how the Thomistic concept of beatitude plays out in his soteriology? Or are you perhaps asking something along the lines of whether Thomas' understanding of beatitude suggests a particular or dominant soteriological paradigm that might be described as an atonement model? Or are you perhaps asking if it is fair to describe Thomas' theology of [i]reconciliatio[/i] (atonement) as some kind of "beatitude model of atonement", in a sense similar to how Aristotelian ethics might be called "eudaimonistic ethics"? If my questions are light years away from the intent of your question please forgive me.
The Joey-O Posted June 15, 2007 Author Posted June 15, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1295689' date='Jun 15 2007, 12:15 AM']I don't fully understand your question so I feel apprehensive about replying positively. In what context are you referring to Aquinas' understanding of beatitude? In broad terms (human) beatitude means for Aquinas the ultimate goal or fulfillment of our nature, our "blessedness" or "happiness". Naturally there is much more that could be said to elucidate the details of "beatitude" in the theology of St. Thomas, as some, such as Servais Pinckaers, have admirably done. But simply for the sake of clarification, what exactly is the impetus of your question in this regard? I am quite uncertain about the sense in which you speak of "an atonement model". Do you mean to ask how the Thomistic concept of beatitude plays out in his soteriology? Or are you perhaps asking something along the lines of whether Thomas' understanding of beatitude suggests a particular or dominant soteriological paradigm that might be described as an atonement model? Or are you perhaps asking if it is fair to describe Thomas' theology of [i]reconciliatio[/i] (atonement) as some kind of "beatitude model of atonement", in a sense similar to how Aristotelian ethics might be called "eudaimonistic ethics"? If my questions are light years away from the intent of your question please forgive me.[/quote] I think I'm following your question. While it's not light years ahead of me, your question could be described as "light months" ahead of me. By Aquinas' understanding of "beatitude", I mean his understanding of the "Beatific Vision" or "the supernatural end of Man". My understanding of "Beatific Vision", comes almost exclusively from Pinckaers. Atonement models, as I've traditionally understood them, are things like "penal-substitution", "ransom", "christus victor", "blood-sacrifice", etc. They describe the manner in which Christ atoned for our sins. I was thinking that all of these models are great, but they only partially explain the economy of salvation. While they all describe different aspects of the Son's participation in our salvation, they don't even mention sanctification and thus neglect the Spirit's participation. Is it appropriate to call Aquinas' "Beatific Vision" an atonement model (given the other models I have mentioned)? I ask, because it seems to be an advanced understanding of the economy of salvation. If it's inappropriate to call "Beatifiic Vision" an atonement model, is there an existing atonement model that includes elements of Aquinas' "Beatific Vision".
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 24, 2007 Posted June 24, 2007 [quote name='The Joey-O' post='1295959' date='Jun 15 2007, 10:48 AM']I think I'm following your question. While it's not light years ahead of me, your question could be described as "light months" ahead of me. By Aquinas' understanding of "beatitude", I mean his understanding of the "Beatific Vision" or "the supernatural end of Man". My understanding of "Beatific Vision", comes almost exclusively from Pinckaers. Atonement models, as I've traditionally understood them, are things like "penal-substitution", "ransom", "christus victor", "blood-sacrifice", etc. They describe the manner in which Christ atoned for our sins. I was thinking that all of these models are great, but they only partially explain the economy of salvation. While they all describe different aspects of the Son's participation in our salvation, they don't even mention sanctification and thus neglect the Spirit's participation. Is it appropriate to call Aquinas' "Beatific Vision" an atonement model (given the other models I have mentioned)? I ask, because it seems to be an advanced understanding of the economy of salvation. If it's inappropriate to call "Beatifiic Vision" an atonement model, is there an existing atonement model that includes elements of Aquinas' "Beatific Vision".[/quote] I have never heard of Aquinas' understanding of the Beatific Vision being described as an atonement model. Historically the discussion of the Atonement as a sort of autonomous branch of Theology is something particular to Protestant Theology. Certainly Aquinas does articulate something that can be considered an atonement model. My understanding is that Thomas' treatment can be in large part described as a satisfaction model; something perhaps like penal-substitution but less juridical. But it is important to remember that in Catholic Theology Christ's Atonement is understood in a multifaceted way and no single model of the Atonement ought to be given a place which obscures other important dimensions. So I would say that for Thomas, as for Roman Catholic Theology in general, there is no single theory of the Atonement that can be called "the Catholic atonement model" (although it is surely possible for an atonement theory to be incompatible with Catholic teaching). As a starting point in linking Thomas' insights on the Beatific Vision with what we would call “Atonement Theory” I would highlight the centrality of the Pascal Mystery in the Catholic understanding. Our Redemption, sanctification and future glorification are based on the salvific work of Christ in His Incarnation, Life, Passion, Death, Resurrection and Ascension seen as an integrated and plenary act through which we are reconciled to God and elevated to share in the Divine Life. It is in this sort of context that the various facets of the Atonement are seen as coexisting in a seamlessly integral way. Another point related to your question is that for Thomas (as for Catholic Theology in general), the impetus of Christ's salvific work and the Atonement, is first and foremost the elevation of man to supernatural life and glory. It is restorative and gracious in a superabundant manner. In contrast to this the theology of the Protestant reformers may be characterized as focused on a juridical attitude in which man's sinful nature and objective guilt must be atoned for in the face of Divine Justice. I'm not suggesting that satisfaction for sin in the face of Divine Justice is not a central aspect of the Catholic understanding, but it is understood according to a different paradigm. Another point which may highlight some of the difference between Catholic and Protestant Theology is that essential to the Catholic understanding is the idea of co-redemption. Christ's redeptive act extends through His Mystical Body in history and Christians are called to participate in the subjective redemption. It is in this that Catholics understand the value of suffering and penance. Not sure if I'm on the right track here, but hopefully we can continue this discussion. Is this along the lines of what you're interested in? Cheers!
The Joey-O Posted June 24, 2007 Author Posted June 24, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1300378' date='Jun 24 2007, 12:51 AM']I have never heard of Aquinas' understanding of the Beatific Vision being described as an atonement model. Historically the discussion of the Atonement as a sort of autonomous branch of Theology is something particular to Protestant Theology. Certainly Aquinas does articulate something that can be considered an atonement model. My understanding is that Thomas' treatment can be in large part described as a satisfaction model; something perhaps like penal-substitution but less juridical. But it is important to remember that in Catholic Theology Christ's Atonement is understood in a multifaceted way and no single model of the Atonement ought to be given a place which obscures other important dimensions. So I would say that for Thomas, as for Roman Catholic Theology in general, there is no single theory of the Atonement that can be called "the Catholic atonement model" (although it is surely possible for an atonement theory to be incompatible with Catholic teaching). As a starting point in linking Thomas' insights on the Beatific Vision with what we would call “Atonement Theory” I would highlight the centrality of the Pascal Mystery in the Catholic understanding. Our Redemption, sanctification and future glorification are based on the salvific work of Christ in His Incarnation, Life, Passion, Death, Resurrection and Ascension seen as an integrated and plenary act through which we are reconciled to God and elevated to share in the Divine Life. It is in this sort of context that the various facets of the Atonement are seen as coexisting in a seamlessly integral way. Another point related to your question is that for Thomas (as for Catholic Theology in general), the impetus of Christ's salvific work and the Atonement, is first and foremost the elevation of man to supernatural life and glory. It is restorative and gracious in a superabundant manner. In contrast to this the theology of the Protestant reformers may be characterized as focused on a juridical attitude in which man's sinful nature and objective guilt must be atoned for in the face of Divine Justice. I'm not suggesting that satisfaction for sin in the face of Divine Justice is not a central aspect of the Catholic understanding, but it is understood according to a different paradigm. Another point which may highlight some of the difference between Catholic and Protestant Theology is that essential to the Catholic understanding is the idea of co-redemption. Christ's redeptive act extends through His Mystical Body in history and Christians are called to participate in the subjective redemption. It is in this that Catholics understand the value of suffering and penance. Not sure if I'm on the right track here, but hopefully we can continue this discussion. Is this along the lines of what you're interested in? Cheers![/quote] Wow! Thanks for the quick reply! This is what I'm looking for. I understand that atonement theology is, at least, a more popular discussion in Protestant circles and that Catholic theology, as it is usually formulated, doesn't perfectly line up in a traditional protestant discussion of atonement theology. I want to write a paper that compares atonement models, because, along similar lines to what you have said, I believe that every model has strengths and weeknesses. There are atonement "themes" (for lack of a better word) in Orthodox and Catholic traditions that remind me atonement models. I want to talk about these in my paper as well as the more traditional Protestant ones. With that said, it seems somewhat legitimate to classify Thomas' understanding of the beatific vision or just beatification, in general, as an atonement. It is a far more conceptual model than the usual ones, but it seems to be a model nonetheless. I would also say that the Orthodox's understanding of Deification could be described as a type of atonement model. The issue I'm having is that both of these models seem to describe sanctification and the work of the Spirit, as opposed to justification and the work of the Son. This leads me to question whether or not I'm correct in calling them "atonement models".
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now