Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Need Advice From The Pham...


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Ok, so I like this girl I work with-she's cute, very religious and single-but there's a but...............she's not Catholic but Assembly of God. What do I do? Do I ask her out, or not even bother because she's not Catholic???

Thanks and God bless

Ricky

Edited by reelguy227
Posted

This was a funny thing that my son asked too! "Mom, if I find a girl and she's not catholic, can I still ask her out?"
So I will ask you what I asked him,
"Rick,what is the purpose of dating?" The whole purpose of dating is M>A>R>R>I>A>G>E> Correct? :scratchhead:
So, having said that and assuming that is true for you too,"I want to ask you the qualities you want in a spouse?" I am under the assumption that one of your qualities might be you want to remain Catholic ,correct?
So one of the thing you do on dates is talk,Right? This is one of the first topics you may want to bring up. You can find out where she stands,what she knows about being catholic,etc. Explain to her also the importance of it to you. It's a part of the process. I call it the process of elimination. Prioritize your list to that in which is most important qualities first. Then go from there. There are all sorts of things that can happen between here and the alter,if that is what God is calling you to,.... marriage. So,no you will not explode or end up an atheist if you ask her out. You may however gain a great freind or a life partner or better yet, knowing what you want in a spouse or what you do not want. :marriage:
If you are a serious Catholic,How could she resist? Huh?
Walk cautiously, but walk! :ninja: ...............and always have an answer for the joy that is in you! JC

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

OK to date her...but ya gotta convert her before you even think about getting serious. If she is dead-set against it...walk away.

My wife is AoG...I do NOT recommend it. I love her dearly, but the headaches, arguments, and problems the disparity of faiths causes are just overwhelming at times. Put all that on top of the normal marriage issues....yikes!

Posted

Date her. Not every person you date you marry. Heck I wentout with alot of guys, never inteneded to marry them. For that matter, I still do.
Go out and build up a good social life.

Posted

She asked me to this college bring a friend day thing at her church...should I go??? It kind of sounds like she's trying to pull me in so she can convert me or something, or maybe she really only wants me to come hang out. I don't know.

I should invite her to Adoration, "if I go to your church you go to mine", haha.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Aye - do the reciprocity thing!

Be prepared though - it'll be kinda of a shock to see her worship service. Bring earplugs too if you don't like loud music.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='reelguy227' post='1297641' date='Jun 18 2007, 10:40 AM']She asked me to this college bring a friend day thing at her church...should I go??? It kind of sounds like she's trying to pull me in so she can convert me or something, or maybe she really only wants me to come hang out. I don't know.

I should invite her to Adoration, "if I go to your church you go to mine", haha.[/quote]

Definitely reciprocate. She might decide not to date you if you are a faithful catholic.

Depends on how you define "date".
Are you gonna hang out or is it a definite "date"? Real dates are for thinking about marriage.

geetarplayer
Posted

If you are not willing to marry this girl, the most foolish thing you can do is to date her. I'm sorry, but the argument about getting experience with relationships, testing the waters, seeing what you like and dislike in a girl, etc... is ridiculous to me.

One thing I realized with the girl I was dating last year (affectionately known as "Mark's atheist girlfriend") is that my actions should correspond with my intentions. If I know that I am not going to marry this girl--and it was painfully obvious that I was not--then why am I dating her? If I am not going to commit myself to being the man in her life and always being there for her as her husband, then why am I sending that kind of signal by kissing her passionately and holding her? I was leading her on.

In regards to the whole matter of same faith different tradition, a friend of mine is currently involved in a situation such as this. However, he has been dating her for over a year, and the situation is not good, in my opinion. He freely attends non-Catholic worship services, Bible studies, and the like with her, but she has only attended Mass once (a year ago) and has not been back to our parish since. Also, she does not want her children to be raised Catholic, which really saddens him. Even though they know they are not fit to be married, they are dating right now. They get along fine, but he's told me that he always feels torn with her because she is, in a sense, very much against what he believes in.

-Mark

Posted

I was not Catholic when I met my husband and he was a strong Catholic. Now I am a Catholic youth minster.

So, ask her out. You will know quickly enough whether or not this is the one.

Posted

[quote]OK to date her...but ya gotta convert her before you even think about getting serious. If she is dead-set against it...walk away.[/quote]

I must disagree. You should not enter into a relationshisp with an intent to convert. A year ago when I was considering asking this girl out who was Lutheran and I really liked, my seminarian brother asked me "Is she Catholic?" and I said no, and then continued to say but maybe I could convert her. I totally believe he was right and this is just two opinions of seminarians.

But if you do attend the AOG worship service then yes invite her to the fullness of truth.

Posted

So what's the verdict here people? haha

homeschoolmom
Posted

You shouldn't date her with the intention of converting her (she shouldn't either, but she might be).
You will find out quickly if she sees you as a potential convert (she probably does)....

Posted

So should I date her or not? Maybe we should just date, not talk about religion and see where things go??

Posted

go on a date as friends and hang out.. there's nothing wrong with that.. and just pray to the holy spirit and next thing you know, she's catholic.. lol..

but seriously, just date her and get to know each other but dont get too serious unless you want a non-catholic wife.

Posted

How about pray about it???

Says the Catholic married to the Prot who's actually probably agnostic.

Posted

Ok, I'll ask her out. But I don't know if she'll want to....we'll see. I'll keep you guys posted on the situation.

Posted

[quote name='Wayne's World']Garth Algar: Uhm, Wayne? What do you do if every time you see this one incredible woman, you think you're gonna hurl?
Wayne Campbell: I say hurl. If you blow chunks and she comes back, she's yours. But if you spew and she bolts, then it was never meant to be.[/quote]

Posted

yeesh. where's uruviel when you NEED her?

Posted

[quote name='iggyjoan' post='1297769' date='Jun 18 2007, 01:32 PM']yeesh. where's uruviel when you NEED her?[/quote]
The bathroom.

Posted

Can I have some real advice please? Thank you

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...