Andreas E. Posted June 19, 2007 Posted June 19, 2007 I am still seriously looking into converting to Catholicism (from a hodgepodge of Protestant traditions.) I do understand the need for purgatory as I am sure that at the moment of anyone's death there is still some residual sin that needs to be taken care of. However, purgatory can't take long, as "to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord." One thing I do have a problem with are indulgences. I read an explanation for this on some other Catholic website that even though God forgives our sins, there is still punishment which the indulgences can take care of. Thinking about it, this would make God unjust and the crucifiction irrelevant. Jesus has already taken the punishment for our sins, which is why God has forgiven and will forgive them in the first place, if we ask Him. Why would we need to pay for them again? Also, with indulgences, God would favor people based on their wealth, as a poor person would not be able to afford whatever amount the Church sets for any specific indulgence. If I remember correctly, this is one of the main doctrines Luther preached against when Tetzel came trough town trying to sell them to raise funds for St. Peter's. "Wenn das Geld im Kasten klingt, die Seele in den Himmel springt." Am I not understanding this correctly? As far as I know, indulgences are still offered today. Why?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted June 20, 2007 Posted June 20, 2007 Thank you for your very thoughtful question. In order to understand indulgences, we need to understand the nature of salvation. Martin Luther claimed that faith alone saved. He said that it is faith which saves, but good works also come from faith. The Catholic Church teaches differently: faith-lived-out saves. The difference makes sense. For Lutheranism, there is no need to be completely pure in heaven; we're just covered over with Christ's righteousness. For Catholicism, Christ actually makes us righteous, but like any change, it requires some sort of action. To be made righteous, we have to try to live out the faith, not just have faith. Even though Christ suffered and died for us and the price is completely paid by His death, we still need to be able to accept that sacrifice so that we will be filled with His grace and able to enter heaven. When we die in an imperfect state (as most do, probably even most saints), we can't enter heaven until we are completely open to grace. Picture it this way, you're in a hot air balloon, trying to reach the sky. Now, a hot air balloon has two things to keep it down on the ground: ropes and sandbags. When you go to confession, you cut the ropes and start to hover a bit, but you're still being weighed down. As you begin to conform your life to Christ's, that is, you try to be like Him by praying as He prayed, by living in virtue, but offering up sufferings, etc., you start removing those sand bags and getting higher and higher in the hot air balloon. That's just because the hot air can only lift you up as much as you'll let it. Likewise, the Holy Spirit (not to say that He's full of hot air) can only bring you as close to God as you'll allow. When you're in a hot air balloon, you have to make an effort to lift the sandbags. They're heavy and it's not that pleasant, but you offer up that pain, you're willing to do it because you'll be able to float higher and higher the more you let out. It's not that by doing all that work, you're lifting yourself up (afterall, it's the Holy Spirit that's lifting you up; you're just cooperating), but that by cooperating with the Holy Spirit, you're able to participate in God's work of redeeming you. When a person dies without being as close to God as possible, they still need to release those sandbags. The soul is still attached to sin...it wants to be in the body again so it can enjoy sin, but it also has grace in it and that grace allows it to keep going further and further, dropping those sandbags that are weighing it down. Another way of seeing it is a wound. When you are injured with sin, God removes the bullet, but the wound remains and needs healing. When a person dies before all that healing happens, they need to be healed further. They need to be "purged" (the world purgatory comes from the Latin word for "a place where one becomes clean"). Now, to the indulgences. An indulgence is when a person on earth helps a person get one of those sandbags out of the hot air balloon. The Church has the power to do that, because the Church has been given all of Christ's authority. We're in the Church and so are those in purgatory (and those in heaven). We can help them get through purgatory by offering our virtues, prayers, deeds, sacrifices, etc., for their advancement. Unfortunately, some people have abused indulgences. It used to be the case that a person could give alms as an indulgence (which makes sense, to some extent, because you're giving to the poor on behalf of someone else, and that is a sacrifice). The problem comes when the extremely wealthy try to get an indulgence by paying some small part of a fortune. For them, it wasn't really a sacrifice, and they didn't think of it as one, either. They thought of it is a way to pay their way into heaven without accepting Christ's offering (in other words, they thought they could keep on sinning as much as they pleased, as long as they were paid up, which is a form of a heresy known as Pelagianism). Martin Luther was right about one thing: selling indulgences is wrong. Almsgiving is different from buying and selling. Unfortunately, Luther also went too far in the opposite direction. He saw that Fr. Tetzel was telling people that they didn't need to have faith, only a big wallet. He then said that, in fact, the only thing you need is faith. Both Luther and Tetzel were wrong. You need faith, but you also need to live out the faith so that you can receive the gifts that come from faith. When faith is lived out, it makes us more like Christ so that we can enter heaven. On earth, it's a battle between desiring sin and desiring God. In purgatory, you can no longer sin, so God washes you of sinful desires and allows the whole Church to help. That way, we all become perfect. If I've not been perfectly clear, please send me a private message and I will try to clarify. This is one of the biggest and most complex differences between Catholicism and non-Catholic Christianity, but it was also the subject of my thesis, so I'll be happy to help sort it out. God bless, Raphael
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now