N/A Gone Posted July 21, 2007 Posted July 21, 2007 Yea, Im gonna get this book. You helped me with the FUS distance talk, and your husband seems to have a real passion that he shows in this book. That is awesome!!!
Didacus Posted August 20, 2007 Posted August 20, 2007 First, let me apologize for taking so long to get back on this thread. It actually took me quite some effort just finding it again. Now on with my comments: Chapter 7, P.54; “Imagine a doctor prescribing painkillers to a man with a broken leg… yet never performing surgery.” This is an excellent parallel and accurate comparison. Reading through this chapter makes me recall Augustine’s words “All men regret their misery, but none regret having lived.” P.60; You mention “One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest” That’s an excellent movie. I would recommend anyone to watch it at least twice. Chapter 8, P.67; “Make no mistake, our word is a powerful thing. It is the foundation on which actions are built and the fruit of all human thought that is right and just.” This could be the foundation of a philosophical debate. Our word being powerful – agreed. But it seems that a word will be amongst the fruits of human thoughts that is right and just, but a word will be the fruit of a wicked thought as well. A wicked thought would have a wicked fruit of course. Both are possible, but you do not make an allusion to this distinction. Also, I would question a word being the foundation of actions, since pronouncing a word is an action in itself. Actions, including words, are founded by our thoughts. Rather I would say words, as a specific action, is the mirror/window of our thoughts permitting others to see into our thoughts wicked or just. P.76; “If my story is any illustration, conversion can be a long, stubborn process.” Yours and mine alike bro. Chapter 9, P.77; “Nor even, “nor faith”” Little typo there I believe. Chapter 10, P.80; “If marriage is not corrupted and mocked and eventually destroyed, society will always be held by its merits.” This is a brilliant way to express one of the most profound truths that is most adamantly being attacked by our modern age. At this point I noted again that the relation in your book with all these occurrences and opinions seem distant from your father. Its difficult to know how it all relates, but keep in mind this is only my perception of things as a first time reader. Chapter 11, p.90; “No. Tendencies and temptations do not define us, even if they are part of our genetic inheritance. Our choices define us.” Reference; Titus, 2:7-8 And there is summed up the entire same-sex debate; those who admit their weakness and try to fight against it, and those who succumb to their weakness and embrace it. It applies to any sin as well of course, but none the many more evident in our day and age as permissive sexuality. Chapter 14, P.108; “But a full understanding of the Eternal deepens both one’s faith and love of others.” I would add to this a comment stating that the deepening is not a mere sentiment or emotion, but very real. Almost a state of the soul in and of itself. Chapter 16, P.118; “If you take nothing else away from this writing, I ask that you reflect on this one simple prayer: Show me your Truth. Humble hearts approaching the throne of God have never been denied.” Done. In that I trust, just as you. Chapter 16, P.119: “I recognize there nothing profound not inheritently unique about my story.” When the then cardinal Josef Ratzinger was asked how many paths there exists to enter heaven, he replied spontaneously “As many as there are people on the face of the earth.” What I believe you are trying to portray is humility; your own. And through your book it is self evident. But yet we are all unique, and every hair on our heads counted. Epilogue, P.121; “(The media’s gradual substitution of the term ‘sex worker’ for ‘prostitute’ is a telling sign.)” Tell me about it, there is currently a federal bill in the queue in Canada to legalize prostitution. Guess what terms they use? Epilogue, P. 125; “Kids aren’t stupid, if they want cant give them satisfactory answers, they will look elsewhere.” Perfectly noted. My kids growing up is one if not THE most important reason why I started learning more and more, as much as I can about Catholicism – because I realized I could not give those satisfactory answers, and desperately needed to. My children’s future lay in the balance. Been learning ever since, and still looking for replies to those tough questions. But the replies I want to give them, that I OWE them, are the real answers, not a mickey-mouse made up thing that may or may not make sense. And those can only be found deep into Catholic doctrine. Overall I say you have an excellent book, well written, with a lot of ideas being portrayed but it is sometimes difficult to see were you are going or how all this relates, especially to your father. Though you return to the subject, the links are tough to figure at times. I will be printing out your book and adding it to my library, along with some written comments on my part similar to those I posted here. I think you have a great future as a writer, playwright and as an artist in general. Keep up the fight, and keep the faith. I will post a brief summary of my thoughts in a week or so. PS: you should try to open your own account on phatmass rather than high jacking your wife’s screen-name. *smirk*
kateri05 Posted August 22, 2007 Author Posted August 22, 2007 he's too lazy to have his own phatmass account :-p
PapaHilarious Posted August 28, 2007 Posted August 28, 2007 [quote name='kateri05' post='1367657' date='Aug 21 2007, 11:18 PM']he's too lazy to have his own phatmass account :-p[/quote] who's too lazy now?
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 28, 2007 Posted August 28, 2007 Whoa... looks like somebody was proved wrong. Welcome to PhatMass PapaHilarious!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now