Snarf Posted June 23, 2007 Posted June 23, 2007 Salve, amici. It’s been over a year since I’ve posted here, and that was with a rather odd post I must confess. I was in a usual state of mind at the time, that being one of dysfunction. Right now my mind is functioning well, but if I dare to bifurcate mind and spirit then I’d have to confess that the latter is in tatters. I don’t know if many or any of you remember me. I came here to receive input on my “heretical” ideas of Christian metaphysics. I consider myself a Catholic in many ways while conceding that I am outside the confines of a select number of doctrines. The overbearing response I received here was that I feel compelled by “pride” to hold my own heresies. I guess that line of reason goes that I hold my own mind to be superior to the collective minds of Holy Mother Church, a charge to which I plead innocent. My deal is this. I like to be taken seriously by both the spiritual and scientific camps, and it is very humbling and at times humiliating when I see that the two are at times immiscible. Yes, there are axioms that Logos cannot contradict science because Logos begets both faith and reason and thus they are interchangeable with sufficient understanding, or something like that. But in practical terms, I see Catholicism (a faith I was raised to love and cherish) and faith at large to be severely vulnerable to the onslaught posed by the secular camps. Hear any of these names recently? Dawkins, Dennet, Harris, Penn, Teller, &c.? Religion is being attacked. I have my own convictions, but it tears me up to see them met among my brethren (accept they me or not) by adamant silence. When I tell people I’m Catholic, no matter how fallacious you regard that statement, people intimate that I should be embarrassed to be associated with a money engine administrated by a Renaissance-era Disneyland. I’m not swayed. I see past that, I see into it, and I’m moved as nothing secular can move me. The Church is something I love and for which I’d give my life. What hurts, though, is that She is in a very awkward position when it comes to revising integral beliefs that are incoherent with reality. I think that Her positions serve historical purpose and I do not fault Her for having maintained them. I see her in pains to ever have to change, were it up to me She would never have to. But it’s not up to me. She will indeed have a hard time as modernity progresses. I have my own beliefs as to how Her doctrines could be rectified. I would love to be demonstrably wrong that I may again be fully embraced, but at this point of time my conscience—and not my pride—forbid me from stepping down. I am not vociferous nor proselytizing about it, the book I authored being mainly a letter to myself. To get more to where I’m at right now, I’ve been strongly attacked for my views. I posted videos on YouTube that have garnered a fair amount of attention, especially my response to the New Atheism Movement. More stirringly, though, I’ve found myself in what I know to be a detrimental relationship with a woman who lacks faith. I’ve subtly tried on her and she’s been patient, but in the same light she’s tried to convert me to what she perceives as perfect incredulity. I cannot in good conscience take Communion because of the nature of our relationship, and thus I have no incentive to attend mass. I lament this while taking no recourse, such is the failure of my humanity. Without mass I have no palpable foothold on the spiritual community I adore, and thus my faith is, in somewhat ironic terms, in limbo. I believe in God. I believe in the necessity and general authority of Holy Mother Church. Why this matters to me is that what keeps my faith alive is my abounding recognition that the universe is somehow teleological. I would not be alive were it not for the seemingly telos-oriented slips of fate in my life. Statistically speaking, there’s an overbearing possibility that I will take my own life eventually. I’ve come to peace with this, although I certainly don’t feel like giving up just yet. It might make good sense for me to do so. My life doesn’t lack direction, it’s merely going into an unsavory one. I’ve come to realize that the nebulous doctrine of hell only makes sense when one equates hell with oblivion. I have several reasons for believing this, but above all the concept of everlasting perdition is asinine. I do believe in Hell, yes—it’s oblivion. Conceding that I’m probably not Paradise material, I’ve had to face the fact that not only will I die, but I will be erased of sentience. Not only will I cease to exist, but I’ll lack the brief moment of solace in being told “it’s over now, Seth.” That’s what I see as the worst part about hell: oblivion never affords the opportunity to revel in non-existence. So, I wonder how it’s all going to end. It plagues me constantly, and I lack the comfort of a loving Church to tell me it’s all going to be okay. I feel like I’d be best to quit life as I know it and join a hermitage for a few months, maybe several, just to get my spirituality back. I’ve always been a very spiritual creature, but now I’m just lost. I’d love to live virtuously, but I share Augustine’s onetime sentiment that I don’t need chastity quite yet. I’d love to be in full communion with the Church, but my conscience won’t allow it. I’d love to start out by at least making a better person of myself in terms of my practical situation, but I lack the strength. I’ve had Camus’ [i]Le Mythe de Sisyphe[/i] in French in my backpack for about a year, I just can’t bear to finish it. The first chapter had him say that “nobody ever died from the ontological argument”, honing his statement “Il n’y a qu’un problème philosophique vraiment sérieux—c’est le suicide.” I am a thinking creature. There were times when I almost killed myself just to see where I would go or not go, but my sense of teleology forbad it. Or, fate’s telos interfered. With no intent to be crass, moments before beginning to write this, I was [mod]mature content, nothing personal - L_D[/mod] [i]embracing[/i] my aforementioned partner and a contemporary song came up screaming that old dictum of Nietzche’s. It gave for an odd moment of reflection. I don’t think that God is dead. I just wish I could remember how to feel His presence again.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 23, 2007 Posted June 23, 2007 [url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHjFxJVeCQs&feature=active_sharing"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHjFxJVeCQs...=active_sharing[/url]
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 23, 2007 Posted June 23, 2007 Snarf! I was just thinking about you the other day and wondering what you've been up to... *sigh* I've missed your presence on this board. Hopefully we'll be able to rap some time. Sorry for such a trivial response to so serious a post, I'm just still stewing over the things you've said. Cheers mate!
Seven77 Posted June 23, 2007 Posted June 23, 2007 You lack the strength? That's perfect! He can begin working in you. You're a complete wreck. He likes to salvage! Misery and Mercy go together. Miseri[u]cor[/u]dia= a heart for the miserable
Theologian in Training Posted June 23, 2007 Posted June 23, 2007 You might do well, to reflect on tomorrow's reading. It is when we hit rock bottom, when we realize we are weak and we cannot do it alone, that we realize we need help, we need assistance, when we see Christ's bloodied hand reaching out for us from the cross, saying: "Come, follow me." Reading 1 2 Cor 12:1-10 Brothers and sisters: I must boast; not that it is profitable, but I will go on to visions and revelations of the Lord. I know a man in Christ who, fourteen years ago (whether in the body or out of the body I do not know, God knows), was caught up to the third heaven. And I know that this man (whether in the body or out of the body I do not know, God knows) was caught up into Paradise and heard ineffable things, which no one may utter. About this man I will boast, but about myself I will not boast, except about my weaknesses. Although if I should wish to boast, I would not be foolish, for I would be telling the truth. But I refrain, so that no one may think more of me than what he sees in me or hears from me because of the abundance of the revelations. Therefore, that I might not become too elated, a thorn in the flesh was given to me, an angel of Satan, to beat me, to keep me from being too elated. Three times I begged the Lord about this, that it might leave me, but he said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for power is made perfect in weakness.” I will rather boast most gladly of my weaknesses, in order that the power of Christ may dwell with me. Therefore, I am content with weaknesses, insults, hardships, persecutions, and constraints, for the sake of Christ; for when I am weak, then I am strong.
Pontifex Posted June 23, 2007 Posted June 23, 2007 Peace in Christ. I want to comment on two things, one your position that the Church and Modernity do not match or that the Church cannot keep up with the fast paced changes of modernity and two your relationship and its fruits. First of all, the Church must grow and develope. As Cardinal Newman explained, the Church is like a plant that grows and changes. It must be pruned, clipped, watered, etc. He also said that to live is to change and to live well is to change often. The swift movements of modernity are no match for the timeless. It's not a question of the Church keeping up with modernity but coming to the realization that modernity will never reach the Church without the highest level of reason, which is faith. It is by faith that we believe that the Holy Spirit is the forming influence upon Church structure through weak and frail human beings. It is by faith that we believe that the keys of the Kingdom have been given to Peter (a professional screw up, haha) and his sucessors. It is by faith that we believe that the sacraments are charged with the power of Christ which mold and shape us above and beyond any itellectual construct. It is by faith that we believe that the simple elements of bread and wine become our intimate conncection with Jesus and create and eternal burning in our hearts. I pray that you embrace the Church that you love through faith. I pray that you plunge yourself head first into the mystery of the salvific plan of salvation as revealed in His Church. Secondly, your relationship should be judged by its' fruits. If it leads you to a place of emptiness, solitude and despair your intellect as well as your heart should tell you to change your situation. God's speed. Pontifex
Mary-Kathryn Posted June 23, 2007 Posted June 23, 2007 Snarf sweetie, I'm going to assume that you are a grown young man correct? While I'm not familiar with you and everything you are saying there are a few things coming through to me. You have to stop caring so much about what unbelievers say. They are out there by the the bundles these days. When they run into Catholics it makes them uneasy/angry/defiant and you want to know why? Because they are facing what they should be and aren't. So of course you are going to face ridicule and unpleasant words and at times reasoning that seems well, reasonable. You need to ask yourself why you let yourself become so deeply involved with someone who doesn't have a faith. Why you let yourself be set up for this kind of deep pain. How you're going to work through this without giving up who you are and what you believe. How you're going to come out of this without being so battle-scarred because that is not what a true relationship is. You don't lose yourself and you don't fight to keep your beliefs. I think you need to stop putting so many layers between you and God, and you and His Church. You can think this thing to death and be no closer to God. Who said science and God have to conflict? Look up John Paul II and his speeches on science, it may just surprise you. When I lived in Arizona there was a Vatican priest who was assigned to a university there as an astronomer. You don't give up your brain when you are a Catholic. Thats why The Church has this thing called "faith and reason". But what I sense in you is a fear to trust in this faith of yours. Just for awhile, stop listening to all the voices around you. They are ripping you apart. Listen to John Paul and Benedict. These men have tremendous amounts of wisdom and reasoning. Others may know those who had great scientific or minds of reasoning? Just consider going to a simple Mass once a week if you don't already. This is mother's instinct, and I hope you'll give it some consideration. I just want you to stop hurting.
Snarf Posted July 5, 2007 Author Posted July 5, 2007 Hey hey. I appreciate the sentiments, all. I guess I should explain my paradox after having thought for a few weeks more. I apologize if my unedited closing struck some as lewd, that wasn't what I was intending but I'm sorry if I offended. I try to be very empirical. I think there's something about faith and how it varies from person to person that I'd like to call rational credulity. I'd sum it up by saying that with it being ambiguous for many people whether or not God exists, the tipping point should come with personal experience generally relating to statistical probability. This personal experience wouldn't prove anything at an objective level, but at the subjective and personal level it would be rational. For example, if one person led a normal life then won a major lottery prize two weeks in a row, the statistical nature of that would give a subjective case for faith moreso than if the person didn't have those experiences. Objective proof? Not really, law of averages dictates that it would probably happen sometime if enough people play the lottery. But for that one person, it'd definitely stir some thoughts. For much of my life, I have been a huge benefactor of this rational credulity. I know the proofs of God's existence and I've made some of my own (one of them has something of a YouTube following), but what actually sticks is my personal history. On multiple occasions I've come within inches or minutes of death to the point that providence seems to be the only culprit for my survival. The funny thing about it is that most of these events took place when my faith wasn't really in question, the machinations of the cosmos were singing to the choir. The last major divine intervention took place in February 2005, closing a bad situation that could have easily ended in multiple deaths including my own. The lasting effect of the episode itself, though, was that my life as I knew it was thrown off the rails and perhaps ruined. I was derailed from a bright future and lost the majority of my friends, generally to no fault but my own. Naturally, I'm pretty angry that this has happened to me. In one sense I was incredibly relieved that things happened as they did--I'd rather give up my life than endanger that of another--but now that I've told my tale I feel like a redundancy for continuing to live. As bleak as my outlook is, I haven't given up on my future. It's just that since then, my divine umbilical cord has been severed and even with these intense memories I'm doubting that I'll have an afterlife. The idea that I will simply cease to exist, despite my awareness of stoicism and existentialism, doesn't bode well with my rationalism. Oblivion now is no different in the long run from oblivion in sixty years. Even without my old bouts of depression, which thankfully have left for the most part, I'm alive merely as a favor to my loved ones. I've heard the aphorism "God never wastes a miracle", I just wonder what purpose it all serves.
Anastasia13 Posted July 5, 2007 Posted July 5, 2007 (edited) I remember you. Where have you been? How have you been? Edited July 5, 2007 by Light and Truth
Snarf Posted July 8, 2007 Author Posted July 8, 2007 Mostly I've just been working this past year. This year I realized that I was probably closer to the form of happiness than ever before in my life, but that too faded. Are you a student of Yale? Lux et Veritas is their motto, if I remember correctly.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 8, 2007 Posted July 8, 2007 Quid est happiness?—Felicity, gaiety, joy, contentment, pleasure, fulfillment, beatitude, bliss, well-being, cheer, euphoria, blessedness, paradise, jollity, satisfaction, rapture, mirth, serenity, heaven. My question is serious. Quid est happiness? The reason I ask is because you mentioned it and I find it to be an interesting subject of discussion. It might be cool to discuss 'quid est veritas' as well. You're so cool dude.
Snarf Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 The subject of defining happiness is something that terrifies me. The reason why is that when I think about it, I realize that I'm not the kind of person in whom something will "click" and all the of the sudden I'll feel opiated. When I was a wee lad, I'd have these fixations where I thought this very thing would happen--if I had a girlfriend I'd be happy, if I were popular I'd be happy, if I were skinny I'd be happy, et cetera. As these things came to pass, I began to notice a pattern of non-fruition. I've had intense religious catharsis, especially during my strict Lenten observances in the past*, but even in the most beatific of joys that came from this I'd never call it happiness. I remember one time at Philmont when I was 16, I was in an extreme endorphin rush from having exhausted every muscle in my body. I posed myself on a cliff face with a drop of hundreds of feet on three sides of me, and I realized that I'd be best to just fall off right then. I had no intent to jump in the least, I just new that I'd never again be at that physical, emotional, and religious peek and that it'd be my perfect ending. So, these days I'm afraid to ever call myself happy. I have a premonition that I'd die soon after reaching the point where I can say "I am happy", but that might just be Coeternalist superstition. The truth is that I was so anhedonic growing up--my first memory of considering suicide WAS ON MY FOURTH BIRTHDAY--that I was developmentally wired so as to be incapable of achieving happiness as a full-grown adult. Nevertheless, it falls upon me to strive toward virtue and contentment. I would love to serve others in my best capacity, but I know not what that is. I have a suspicion that my calling is academia, but who knows. I realize I cannot live for my own happiness, so I may as well live for something greater. I think I would love to become a priest, but as it stands I think you'd agree that the priesthood doesn't want me at this point. And we all know Augustine's lament--give me purity, but not quite yet. *I tried to observe Lent strictly this year, but the pervasive temptations that I had as never before prevented me from being as strong as I wanted.
toledo_jesus Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 hard situation. it'll take a lot of strength on your part to fix things and get back to being a heretic rather than an unbeliever. You probably know the practical steps to take to once more be in line with Church teaching. Nix the vixen. Or at least convince her of the need to refrain from whatever it is you two do now. That's the end result, you can do it in as abrupt or as sensitive a fashion as you deem appropriate. You'll most likely have to choose between your spiritual well-being and her telling you that you are all sorts of nasty things for "rejecting" her or "using" her. She'll be pretty hurt and won't easily understand, but you'll also find out a whole lot about who she really is...odds are you'll lose her. I was in the same boat once, but I got lucky and things worked out. I'm not a very good Catholic, but I never miss Mass even if I can't receive Communion. Laying my earthly cares down and diminishing myself helps me to maintain something resembling a relationship with God. So go to Mass, and Confession too. You may find strength to make the changes in your life for which you obviously recognize the need.
Cow of Shame Posted July 24, 2007 Posted July 24, 2007 (edited) hey, good ta see ya. i'll have to actually read the whole post sometime. I appreciate the detail, though.... tick tick tick so many things to do Edited July 24, 2007 by Cow of Shame
farglefeezlebut Posted July 24, 2007 Posted July 24, 2007 *hugs* Seth, I will pray for you. Towards the end of her life St. Therese de Lisieux had NO sense of God's presence. But she trusted Him anyway. If you haven't read The Story of a Soul, then do. Therese is not a great intellectual Saint, although she's more intelligent than people give her credit for. But I have a feeling she's what you need. You feel incapable with loving God with all your mind now. That's ok. Just try to love Him with all your heart and all your soul and pray the rest will come. I'm not the best person to discuss theology with, but you have my prayers.
Snarf Posted July 27, 2007 Author Posted July 27, 2007 Ah, thank you all. It was referred to me by a monsignor years ago that I read Dark Night of the Soul, but he insisted that I'd get the most out of it if I read it in the original late-medieval Spanish. I'd love to do that, but I haven't found any good editions anywhere. Anyone know of one?
Cow of Shame Posted July 28, 2007 Posted July 28, 2007 [quote name='Snarf' post='1300012' date='Jun 22 2007, 10:31 PM']Right now my mind is functioning well, but if I dare to bifurcate mind and spirit then I’d have to confess that the latter is in tatters.[/quote] In my experience, that can throw a heck of a monkey wrench into your mental workings. Hope you keep the gears oiled. [quote name='Snarf' post='1300012' date='Jun 22 2007, 10:31 PM']The overbearing response I received here was that I feel compelled by “pride” to hold my own heresies.[/quote] Yeah...mostly 'cause you don't use little words. Look who was Mr. Vocabulary King! [quote name='Snarf' post='1300012' date='Jun 22 2007, 10:31 PM']When I tell people I’m Catholic, no matter how fallacious you regard that statement, people intimate that I should be embarrassed to be associated with a money engine administrated by a Renaissance-era Disneyland.[/quote] smells of elderberries to be in such an intelligent environment and feel like you have to sneak around & not vocalize your beliefs. Funny how academics can often assume you must be a moron if you're a Christian, even if you've proven yourself in scientific areas. [quote name='Snarf' post='1300012' date='Jun 22 2007, 10:31 PM']More stirringly, though, I’ve found myself in what I know to be a detrimental relationship with a woman who lacks faith.[/quote] Ouch. Religious compatibility should come first in a relationship, in my opinion. You don't have to be exactly same, but I personally would never want to find myself hooked to someone who isn't Christian. [quote name='Snarf' post='1300012' date='Jun 22 2007, 10:31 PM']I cannot in good conscience take Communion because of the nature of our relationship, and thus I have no incentive to attend mass. I lament this while taking no recourse, such is the failure of my humanity.[/quote] The first step is recognizing your problem. You obviously know the importance of your faith & see value in it's practice. You've overcome other personal problems, right? I'm sure you can work this one out as well. [quote name='Snarf' post='1300012' date='Jun 22 2007, 10:31 PM']My life doesn’t lack direction, it’s merely going into an unsavory one. *snip* Not only will I cease to exist, but I’ll lack the brief moment of solace in being told “it’s over now, Seth.” That’s what I see as the worst part about hell: oblivion never affords the opportunity to revel in non-existence.[/quote] No one's ever accused you of not being analytical. Perhaps if you lack the drive to help yourself, a spiritual director would be beneficial? [quote name='Snarf' post='1300012' date='Jun 22 2007, 10:31 PM']I’d love to start out by at least making a better person of myself in terms of my practical situation, but I lack the strength.[/quote] Then borrow some from someone else. No one said you gotta do it all alone. I'm guessing your female friend is providing strength in some areas in your life, while sapping it from others, specifically your spiritual well-being. [quote name='Snarf' post='1313263' date='Jul 5 2007, 03:25 AM']The lasting effect of the episode itself, though, was that [b]my life as I knew it[/b] was thrown off the rails and perhaps ruined. I was derailed from a bright future and lost the majority of my friends, generally to no fault but my own. Naturally, I'm pretty angry that this has happened to me.[/quote] True, that would really piss a person off. Now, I don't know any specifics 'cause you didn't give any in the post, but perhaps the path you were following wasn't the right owe, regardless of it's apparent 'brightness'. Not that you'll necessarily have more joy in the new path you are on, but that it's the one you're meant to be on. Of course, that's something that you'll hear a lot of Christians say to you, and frustrates the hell out of you. My apologies. [quote name='Snarf' post='1313263' date='Jul 5 2007, 03:25 AM']but now that I've told my tale I feel like a redundancy for continuing to live. As bleak as my outlook is, I haven't given up on my future.[/quote] Sounds like you're pretty conflicted. I'd say that your depression was rearing it's head again, but you claim that it's not, and that you still have hope.
Cow of Shame Posted July 28, 2007 Posted July 28, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Snarf' post='1313263' date='Jul 5 2007, 03:25 AM']I've heard the aphorism "God never wastes a miracle", I just wonder what purpose it all serves.[/quote] The incredibly sucky thing is that you might not ever get a clear picture of the purpose...but you know that, at least mentally. [quote name='Snarf' post='1319918' date='Jul 9 2007, 04:01 AM']The subject of defining happiness is something that terrifies me. The reason why is that when I think about it, I realize that I'm not the kind of person in whom something will "click" and all the of the sudden I'll feel opiated.[/quote] Can't say I feel like I'm hopped-up-on-goofballs ecstatic either. I think most of us get by with a definition of 'happiness' that is closer to being satisfied with your current lot in life. Often it comes down to what you choose to focus on. When I ponder about the responsibilities in my life, the reduction in free time that I have, the fact that by most standards I wouldn't be considered a wildly successful person, that frankly I feel like I can't keep my head above water....can get you down a bit. What reason would I have to be happy? You have to take stock of what [i]is[/i] going well in your life. Health, family, a sense of humor, insane amounts of physical comfort (vs. most people in this world...food, shelter, etc), opportunities for high levels of education, so on & so forth. No, you're not going to scream with orgasmic pleasure over the fact that you live in a country where you can state your opinions without fear of being dragged bodily from your school room, but barring some more extreme cases, we all should be fairly 'happy' people in the US. [quote name='Snarf' post='1319918' date='Jul 9 2007, 04:01 AM']When I was a wee lad, I'd have these fixations where I thought this very thing would happen--if I had a girlfriend I'd be happy, if I were popular I'd be happy, if I were skinny I'd be happy, et cetera.[/quote] I think you're buying into all the hype. The commercialism. What all the advertisements & what society says that you need to have true happiness. According to IKEA, I need to have a well-organized lifestyle to have true happiness. According to Miller beer, I need to be physically fit, drink their beer, and subsequently surrounded by hot chickas. Personally, I have a hard time swallowing this one, but God says all we need is him. I want a second opinion. [quote name='Snarf' post='1319918' date='Jul 9 2007, 04:01 AM']Nevertheless, it falls upon me to strive toward virtue and contentment. I would love to serve others in my best capacity, but I know not what that is. I have a suspicion that my calling is academia, but who knows. I realize I cannot live for my own happiness, so I may as well live for something greater. I think I would love to become a priest, but as it stands I think you'd agree that the priesthood doesn't want me at this point.[/quote] Ya know, the Protestants do have one up on us with their focus on God's grace. We're good at the guilt trips, but you DO have to remember that you can't ever try hard enough in some areas. That God is the one who has to overcome our failings. It's all fine & good to say such things...practical applications are insanely hard. *shrug* I guess we just have to have faith in God's strength. Prayers, fasting, and honestly, it does help to have another spirit warrior (NOT Ramtha, though) to help keep us accountable. Edited July 28, 2007 by Cow of Shame
Snarf Posted August 10, 2007 Author Posted August 10, 2007 For the aforementioned reasons, we broke up after eleven months. No hard feelings between us, and we're ACTUALLY STILL FRIENDS. I'll just see how long that lasts.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now