Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

A Not-so-serious Question


Recommended Posts

TheOliverOrder88
Posted

This here is my second thread on confession...

I promise this is less serious and more of just technicality.

I am thinking about going to confession at a church that is purely Tridentine. In fact its Saint Francis DeSalles in South County, Saint Louis, MO. My reasonings include wanting a different surrounding, encountering more "hardcore" priests rather than the ones that inhabit my parish. My pastor is fine, but maybe once in a while I want more substance.... not that forgiveness is not fulfilling.... but...

My question is this: I am assuming the Sacrament of Penance is NOT in Latin, I think that would be silly. I am also assuming that due to their orthodox-ness in regards to liturgy, that the sacrament will be more... eh... old-school.... for lack of a better term. Like all the you know, "Bless me Father for I have sinned, its been 8,999 years since my last confession..." all that jazz I mean. Normally, I would just go into the confession and the priest initiate confession, but not I. Would I just need to brush up on my old-school Confessions?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Aside from the possibility that you may eventually learn why "old school" Confession practices weren't very effective (too much emphasis on what you did rather than why, effectively avoiding confrontation with your heart... of course, I'm generalizing, and this priest may be very good), I think Confession maintained the same structure. You can always tell the priest that you've never been to Confession there.

I went to a different, more traditional, parish for my last Confession and felt like I stumbled through the whole thing. It was kinda funny :) I couldn't tell if anyone was inside because the confessional was behind me, so I kept turning around hoping to catch someone leaving, but every time I looked it seemed like someone was entering. So after about 30 minutes, I went back there, knelt down and tried to start, but it just didn't feel right with the screen closed. So I interrupted, "Is it allright if I open this?" After he recognized me (because he was walking through the sanctuary earlier while I was praying), he inquired, "So, you've been over there praying for 30 minutes. What were you praying about?" It was almost like he was making fun of me for praying for so long, but I think he was just curious if I was nervous or if that's part of my Confession routine... like a batter stepping up to plate. But, of course, most of that time I was just waiting to make sure nobody was inside the confessional before I wandered over there.

But it was all cool and even though he gave me a standard "3 Our Fathers" or something, he did have some good advice and asked some good questions. As long as your heart is in the right place, you really can't screw it up :)

Church Punk
Posted (edited)

I went to confession before the Tridentine Mass for the first time with the "Old School" priest this past weekend. It was nothing different than my usual confession. Father gave me such a great encouragement and guidance to perserver. Then the different and cool part was he gave the absolution in latin which I really liked.

I dont know if the priest would still be of old school confessional mentality (focusing on the sins), as opposed to being open and loving to help you in your situations. I guess it will just depend on the priest.


Note: Edited for Grammar

Edited by Church Punk
missionarybelle
Posted

um, what is "old-school" way to go to confession? you mentioned the "bless me father for I've sinned..." as being old school, I've always said that. I didn't really know there was a different thing to say. I'm just curious as to a different way to start your confession.

Posted

Who says you can't let the priest welcome you, then reply "Bless me Father, for I have sinned. It has been one week since my last confession..." As a matter of fact, I wouldn't be surprised if the average priest wouldn't recognize you for being more desirous of a firmer confession than someone who enters the confessional with a "Hiya Father..."

With that said, other than hearing "Ego te absolvo", what do you desire to get out of this? A meatier penance? Better advice on spiritual combat? Some firmer spiritual guidance? All these things are honorable goals that I myself looked for.

I have not gone to the local Indult parish to confess yet as I haven't been in the neighborhood, and I would rather smash my good hand with a hammer than walk into a schismatic parish for an invalid confession. So, I can't help you with Old School / New School.

Even so, I've confessed in a good number of parishes, by many priests. Some experiences were good, some were bad. So this is the advice I'd give from my own experiences.

First, you have every right to find for yourself a good confessor. Look for one and perhaps even search systematically through the parishes in your diocese until you are satisfied. This is not just for absolution, but also repentance of the sin and avoidance of future sins. If the Indult parish leads you to greater holiness, God be praised. If not, keep looking.

Second, you will likely find a better confessor in a parish that unabashedly posts times of confession on their website, bulletin, front sign, etc. Also, the more times available generally means the priest(s) take the sacrament more seriously.

Third, look at the lines. Generally, the longer the line, the more those people appreciate confession and the wisdom of the confessor. For further information, refer to "Cure d'Ars".

Fourth, look for a newer priest. In the past five years or so, while the quantity has been paltry, the quality of ordained priests has risen significantly. After all, these are the ones that took the Orders even when the general public wanted to stone anyone with a collar. Also, the seminaries are cleaning their acts up, albeit slowly in places. Most of all, many of the newly ordained priests have experienced the ministry of spiritual direction firsthand during seminary and often continue into their priesthood. As such, they feel more free to give direction to others than a priest who has had very little direction or hasn't received it in a long time.

Fifth, consider looking for Priests Religious for confession. On average I have found them to be more willing to challenge me with something more than "three Hail Mary's". Even the easier ones have meant something more, like "five Our Fathers, slowly, and contemplate each for each of Our Lord's five wounds" or "one Hail Mary for each of her seven sorrows." This isn't to say diocesan priests can't dole out just as well. I've had one Priest Secular in particular...

Sixth, don't be shy. Confessing a laundry list will lead to a far less satisfying confession than confessing with palpable sorrow for those sins. The priest has a better handle on the situation before him, and can guide you better with the greater insight of your situation. Even a light penance with good spiritual guidance can lead to greater healing than a rigorous penance and a terse absolution.

I hope this is helpful for you, and I kinda wish I had this advice twelve years ago.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Awesome post! I haven't put much effort into finding a confessor, but I'm going to give the local Dominican parish a couple more tries. It's a religious order [i]and[/i] they have Confession every day and twice on Saturday. The one priest I've been to gave me three Our Father's, which in Old School Confession means you're about a 7 on the Holiness Scale. That's in the Baltimore Catechism, I'm sure.

[quote name='Dismas' post='1304735' date='Jun 28 2007, 09:04 PM']I have not gone to the local Indult parish to confess yet as I haven't been in the neighborhood, and I would rather smash my good hand with a hammer than walk into a schismatic parish for an invalid confession.[/quote]

Could you clarify this part? Being an Indult parish implies they aren't in schism. And if I'm not mistaken, a schismatic bishop/priest still offers valid sacraments. Did you mean illicit? Like, it would be illicit for a Catholic to receive Confession or Anointing from an Orthodox priest under regular circumstances, but in the case of near death, the sacrament is valid and would be fine to receive if a Catholic priest weren't available.

It's good to know these things... like when you're driving through Romania, I guess. :)

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='TheOliverOrder88' post='1300220' date='Jun 23 2007, 02:04 PM']This here is my second thread on confession...

I promise this is less serious and more of just technicality.

I am thinking about going to confession at a church that is purely Tridentine. In fact its Saint Francis DeSalles in South County, Saint Louis, MO. My reasonings include wanting a different surrounding, encountering more "hardcore" priests rather than the ones that inhabit my parish. My pastor is fine, but maybe once in a while I want more substance.... not that forgiveness is not fulfilling.... but...

My question is this: I am assuming the Sacrament of Penance is NOT in Latin, I think that would be silly. I am also assuming that due to their orthodox-ness in regards to liturgy, that the sacrament will be more... eh... old-school.... for lack of a better term. Like all the you know, "Bless me Father for I have sinned, its been 8,999 years since my last confession..." all that jazz I mean. Normally, I would just go into the confession and the priest initiate confession, but not I. Would I just need to brush up on my old-school Confessions?[/quote]

There are a number of orthodox pre-vatican II missals that you can consult regarding a proper confession, and a number of places online that I could send you links for if you wanted in an email or something. Maybe I've always done it the "old-school" way, but when I started going to the Tridentine Mass I didn't do anything different with my confession. Sometimes my priests will ask me to go into more detail regarding this or that sin, but other than that I think the general format is the same, at least for your part.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Church Punk' post='1302293' date='Jun 26 2007, 02:30 PM']I dont know if the priest would still be of old school confessional mentality (focusing on the sins), as opposed to being open and loving to help you in your situations.[/quote]

Not intending to start any trouble, and not suggesting that a priest shouldn't be loving, but a priest's primary job is to be a priest and give you the sacraments, his work as a psychologist is only secondary.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1305502' date='Jun 29 2007, 10:46 AM']Awesome post! I haven't put much effort into finding a confessor, but I'm going to give the local Dominican parish a couple more tries. It's a religious order [i]and[/i] they have Confession every day and twice on Saturday. The one priest I've been to gave me three Our Father's, which in Old School Confession means you're about a 7 on the Holiness Scale. That's in the Baltimore Catechism, I'm sure.
Could you clarify this part? Being an Indult parish implies they aren't in schism. And if I'm not mistaken, a schismatic bishop/priest still offers valid sacraments. Did you mean illicit? Like, it would be illicit for a Catholic to receive Confession or Anointing from an Orthodox priest under regular circumstances, but in the case of near death, the sacrament is valid and would be fine to receive if a Catholic priest weren't available.

It's good to know these things... like when you're driving through Romania, I guess. :)[/quote]

I'm sure he meant that he would go to the indult but hasn't been in that area lately, and that there must be a second "old-school" church somewhere that is in "schism". This is the church he won't go to for confession. And yes it is valid but illicit, but wouldn't it be a tad bit contradictory to undergo "sin" in order to recieve absolution for your sins?

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Dismas' post='1304735' date='Jun 28 2007, 8:04 PM']I have not gone to the local Indult parish to confess yet as I haven't been in the neighborhood, and I would rather smash my good hand with a hammer than walk into a schismatic parish for an invalid confession. So, I can't help you with Old School / New School.[/quote]

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1305502' date='Jun 29 2007, 11:46 AM']Could you clarify this part? Being an Indult parish implies they aren't in schism. And if I'm not mistaken, a schismatic bishop/priest still offers valid sacraments. Did you mean illicit? Like, it would be illicit for a Catholic to receive Confession or Anointing from an Orthodox priest under regular circumstances, but in the case of near death, the sacrament is valid and would be fine to receive if a Catholic priest weren't available.

It's good to know these things... like when you're driving through Romania, I guess. :)[/quote]

Sorry. I have no problem with Indult parishes or Indult Mass. I am actually looking forward to the coming Motu Proprio as a further "Reform of the Reform", even though I may not necessarily partake of the TLM.

As for schism, I was referring to those parishes that function illicitly.

My apologies for any confusion.

[Edit:] Also, I'd like to state that my archdiocese has had an Indult Mass available to the faithful since February 23, 1985.

Edited by Dismas
Posted

I went to confession with an FSSP priest once when I was in Poland, and to be honest I rather thought that it was pretty much exactly the same as any other confession--I think it depends more on the priest than on "old school"/"new school." Some priests will start it off themselves and sometimes you will say the whole "bless me father..." spiel. In both though actually I've found that the priest, once he's sensed that you're there, will start off with the sign of the Cross and then you'll go along your merry way. And then he'll usually say the words of absolution in Latin, but that's the only difference I've personally seen.

But my best confessions have been with priests who, while very orthodox and conservative, say the NO rather than the TLM and absolve me in English--this is most likely because I've gone to them regularly over the course of a couple years and they've gotten a handle on my personality and my weaknesses. And I think my penances from them were actually much "harsher" than the FSSP priest--that priest told me to read a certain bible passage, while my priests at home usually give me a rosary for penance--one priest is known to have a basket full of rosaries to hand out in case someone says he doesn't have a rosary to pray. I'm almost startled now when I'm given three Hail Marys or something. But even then, it's quality rather than quantity--three Hail Marys said in perfect contrition is better than three rosaries said half-heartedly.

So basically, I say follow Dismas' advice, look for a priest who's a good confessor, not "hardcore Tridentine" or anything, because that's not the best indicator of a good confessor.

TheOliverOrder88
Posted

Well, taking this all in to consideration.

I might as well just once go to this particular Tridentine parish only to try it out. They have confession before every weekday Mass (or just before every Mass period) so maybe this is an indication of their fervor for the sacrament.

To put more into context... I will be entering the seminary in the fall and I'm "holding out" until then when they give me a spiritual director/confessor there. (Well, I sort of had one but as I said before, I think I am done with him)

AND... I'll going to a Steubenville conference and due to my experiences before, I would rather be all "penanced" up beforehand.

Thanks for the advice and the clarification...

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1305547' date='Jun 29 2007, 09:59 AM']And yes it is valid but illicit,[/quote]

actually, i had heard that schismatic confession wouldn't be valid since, the priest is forgiving you not only in the name of Christ, but also of His Church, and since the schismatic priest is not in full communion with the Church, he wouldn't have the power to reconcile you to same Church.

so i've heard. does anyone know more about this? :idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1316245' date='Jul 7 2007, 12:24 AM']actually, i had heard that schismatic confession wouldn't be valid since, the priest is forgiving you not only in the name of Christ, but also of His Church, and since the schismatic priest is not in full communion with the Church, he wouldn't have the power to reconcile you to same Church.

so i've heard. does anyone know more about this? :idontknow:[/quote]

Yeah, I think a priest has to have jurisdiction from the Bishop who has jurisdiction from the Pope to validly hear confessions.

Posted

oh good. i love when i'm not crazy ^_^ thanks st.thomas!

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

Hmm... a lot of "I heard's" and "I think's" doesn't convince me. Not that it matters much on a practical level since most of us are in the U.S. where a Catholic priest and regular Confession times are easy enough to find in most areas, but my understanding is that the validity of the sacrament depends upon the validity of the priest's ordination.

However, I do know for a fact that when it comes to a priest performing exorcisms, that duty [i]does[/i] rely upon the authority to do so given by their bishop and that authority applies only within the bishop's diocese. So it's interesting that Confession may work in a similar fashion, except without the geographic restriction.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1316369' date='Jul 7 2007, 02:57 AM']Yeah, I think a priest has to have jurisdiction from the Bishop who has jurisdiction from the Pope to validly hear confessions.[/quote]
True, this would only go away under the concept of ecclesia supplet but I don't believe this concept applies in cases where there is another valid priest with jurisdiction that one can go to. So I guess it comes down to whether or not you believe there is a valid priest with jurisdiction within close enough distance for you.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1317167' date='Jul 7 2007, 07:32 PM']Hmm... a lot of "I heard's" and "I think's" doesn't convince me. Not that it matters much on a practical level since most of us are in the U.S. where a Catholic priest and regular Confession times are easy enough to find in most areas, but my understanding is that the validity of the sacrament depends upon the validity of the priest's ordination.

However, I do know for a fact that when it comes to a priest performing exorcisms, that duty [i]does[/i] rely upon the authority to do so given by their bishop and that authority applies only within the bishop's diocese. So it's interesting that Confession may work in a similar fashion, except without the geographic restriction.[/quote]

[quote][b]Baltimore Catechism No. 3:[/b]
Q. 729. Can the priest forgive all sins in the Sacrament of Penance?
A. The priest has the power to forgive all sins in the Sacrament of Penance, but he may not have the authority to forgive all. To forgive sins validly in the Sacrament of Penance, two things are required:

1. (1) The power to forgive sins which every priest receives at his ordination, and
2. (2) The right to use that power which must be given by the bishop, who authorizes the priest to hear confessions and pass judgment on the sins.
http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Catechism/3/l17.html#RTFToC3[/quote]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...