Ash Wednesday Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 Justin, I don't have time at the moment to go into a lengthy discussion but I'm going to assume that you also read the New Testament. In John 9, when the disciples asked Jesus if a man's blindness was a consequence of his or his parents sins, Jesus told them that it was NOT as a consequence of their sins. Rather Jesus healed the blind man for the glory of God. It is believed that AIDS came from wild chimps, and scientists have even suggested that it's possible that humans had contracted it on occasion prior to the first documented case (the 1950s) but it would not have become the epidemic that it is now had it not been for the sexual promiscuity, sharing drug needles and lack of knowledge regarding blood transfusions. Even if alternative conspiracy theories about the virus being man-made were true, again it's the same scenario. The idea that God somehow is responsible when in fact the epidemic came about through man's own doing just doesn't add up. But hey, if you think that children orphaned by AIDS or innocent people receiving botched blood transfusions are somehow being punished by God, then I guess that's your business. I certainly pity you and anyone else that shares the same vision of God.
Justin86 Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 (edited) Oh, and I'm kind of against alot of HIV/AIDS research since a cure seems so unpromising and quite frankly there are worse diseases out there that we can cure. We'd could have the cure for cancer right now if it weren't for the money and research spent on AIDS. Edited July 12, 2007 by Justin86
Ash Wednesday Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 By your logic, then, are people that get cancer also being punished by God?
Ash Wednesday Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1325632' date='Jul 12 2007, 10:45 AM']And its not necessarily that God "punishes" the 2nd generations of a people, but the they have to pay for the sins of their parents, or they have to live with the sins of the parents. Like a child who contracts HIV/AIDS from a parent. Like poor parents past down their poverty to their children so too can the consequence and effects of sin. Adam and Eve are a prefect example of this.[/quote] Now this I can agree with in a way, because I do agree that what we do affects everyone -- I just don't view God as zapping someone with his finger and "For your deviance, I'm giving you a dosage of AIDS. You LOSE!" The logic that God always punishes sin and rewards good on this earth doesn't add up to me, however. Not when you see good hearted people in disease and poverty and rich people living in health and hedonism.
KnightofChrist Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 The best guy ever was put on a cross, its all a result of original sin... God has laid out a manual of how to live, the Church the bible... the same is true if I go buy a car, the manual says to put unleaded gas in the tank but I can put "Smell Number 5", sure it may smell better but the engine wont run. God doesn't make the manual because "HE SAYS SO" its because there are consequence and effects of sin.
KnightofChrist Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1325641' date='Jul 12 2007, 09:58 AM']By your logic, then, are people that get cancer also being punished by God?[/quote] Punished? Perhaps not, but cancer is a consequence and effect of original sin. I would add smoking can cause cancer, smoke is not natural for the lungs.
Ash Wednesday Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 Yes, but generally, kids that get leukemia don't smoke.
KnightofChrist Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 No... they do not... but if had it not been for original sin, there would be no leukemia.
Ash Wednesday Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1325659' date='Jul 12 2007, 11:24 AM']No... they do not... but if had it not been for original sin, there would be no leukemia.[/quote] Indeed.... I have never gotten the whole concept of certain things like this happening because Adam and Eve screwed up. Original Sin is something that I assent to, of course, but I can't always get my head around it and I probably never will.
tojo Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='Justin86' post='1325591' date='Jul 12 2007, 08:21 AM']This was my first thought too. I mean what kind of side effects would something that tears pieces of my cells apart have? Perhaps alot of people are going to hate me for saying this but I really do think that HIV/AIDS is God's way of punishing the world for the increase in fornication. We're not going to be able to cure it.[/quote] [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1325629' date='Jul 12 2007, 10:35 AM']God also punishes whole generations of people because of one generation. Now if He punishes babies now because the sins of the parents is unknown but possible. I think its more along the lines of a parent telling a child not to put keys in a electric outlet. Gods commands are not just because, but for our own good. God says not to have sex before marriage, well if we disobey we can get shocked and any one that we touch.[/quote] Oh my goodness. May God have mercy on your souls. My uncle contracted HIV in the 1980's from his factor-8 injections he received from his mother almost daily for treatment of his hemophilia, a genetic blood disorder. He was diagnosed at the age of 8. I supposed God punished my family with hemophilia? And then the hemophiliacs in my family with HIV? The level of disgust I feel right now cannot be expressed.
KnightofChrist Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 (edited) I did not mean to offend, I later tried to better explain my point. Again hemophilia and HIV exist because of original sin, had Adam and Eve not disobeyed God, disease would not exist. But because they did sin, the effect of their sin has been past down to every generation. Perhaps the word "punishment" is the wrong word, but because of original sin God has allowed pain and disease where otherwise He would not have had Adam and Eve obeyed. Edited July 12, 2007 by KnightofChrist
Aloysius Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 it's not so much the punishment of God, as it is the effects of sin. and the effects of sin are often talked about in terms of "punishment from God"... but it's inaccurate when considering all the innocent people who are effected by it. HIV is clearly the effects of sin, in some way how all disease is the effects of sin (or could also be worded "punishments for original sin") and in some ways in how it is related to the ways it is most often spread and those specific sins, but that does not mean that everyone who contracts it is guilty of the sin. there is a parallel between what HIV is to mankind, and what the effects of original sin itself are. In this way there is a powerful moral lesson to consider whilst not making wildishly outlandish statements that make it seem as if God is directly punishing this or that baby who contracts it through genetics or this or that person who contracts it through accident. It's the effects of sin, sin effects people whether or not they are culpable for sin; sin causes bad things to happen to all sorts of people... like how the sin of drunk driving gets random unrelated children run over.
Ash Wednesday Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 The area where I took issue with isn't AIDS as a consequence of original sin, but rather Justin's idea that it's a direct punishment from God. Would love to discuss more but off to the gym!
KnightofChrist Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1325728' date='Jul 12 2007, 10:52 AM']it's not so much the punishment of God, as it is the effects of sin. and the effects of sin are often talked about in terms of "punishment from God"... but it's inaccurate when considering all the innocent people who are effected by it. HIV is clearly the effects of sin, in some way how all disease is the effects of sin (or could also be worded "punishments for original sin") and in some ways in how it is related to the ways it is most often spread and those specific sins, but that does not mean that everyone who contracts it is guilty of the sin. there is a parallel between what HIV is to mankind, and what the effects of original sin itself are. In this way there is a powerful moral lesson to consider whilst not making wildishly outlandish statements that make it seem as if God is directly punishing this or that baby who contracts it through genetics or this or that person who contracts it through accident. It's the effects of sin, sin effects people whether or not they are culpable for sin; sin causes bad things to happen to all sorts of people... like how the sin of drunk driving gets random unrelated children run over.[/quote] You said it better than I did...
Seven77 Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [mod]the debate ends here. this thread was never intended to be a debate. for that, please start one 'cause the next post of debate nature gets moved.-777[/mod]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now