Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vicious dog ownership  

27 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

OK, so I'm doing research on this and thought it might make for an interesting discussion. Thoughts? Comments?

Posted (edited)

I spent 2 yrs in a Pre-Vet program and have worked with animals practically all my life. I do believe that certain breeds should have restriction placed upon them which are dependent upon the background of the owner. Sadly many dog breeds, like pitbulls, have had their reputations ruined because of their owners training to be vicious and to fight. It's horrible to see what it has done to those dogs. I've seen pitbulls after fights and its horrible to see. It's sad to see what people have managed to do to animals. I've known several pitbulls who were completely sweet, adorable, and good tempered. It all comes back to the owner and how the animal is trained. I don't believe that breeds should be banned but I do believe that who the dog belongs to should be regulated.

Edited by StColette
Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1309519' date='Jul 2 2007, 02:14 PM']I spent 2 yrs in a Pre-Vet program and have worked with animals practically all my life. I do believe that certain breeds should have restriction placed upon them which are dependent upon the background of the owner. Sadly many dog breeds, like pitbulls, have had their reputations ruined because of their owners training to be vicious and to fight. It's horrible to see what it has done to those dogs. I've seen pitbulls after fights and its horrible to see. It's sad to see what people have managed to do to animals. I've known several pitbulls who were completely sweet, adorable, and good tempered. It all comes back to the owner and how the animal is trained. I don't believe that breeds should be banned but I do believe that who the dog belongs to should be regulated.[/quote]
I totally agree that training has a lot to do with the temperament of a dog ... I knew a guy who had some ferocious Dobermans, but he encouraged them to be mean and tough.

Totus Tuus
Posted

I don't think it's anyone's business what type of dog you own. But yes, I think it's pretty much a scientific fact that certain breeds (think pit bull) are more vicious than others. I have "met" pit bulls that were happy-go-lucky, but the fact is that it's in their blood to turn on people, even their masters.

goldenchild17
Posted

I don't know if any dog breed should be banned because of that alone. But I also don't think people outside of the owner(s) should have to be subjected to any dog that they feel is dangerous (and many would say have good reason to think so). If someone wanted such a dog, and kept it to themself and away from company/neighbors etc. then I don't really see a problem with it.

Red Knight
Posted

Some breeds do no make good pets. That doesn't mean people shouldn't own them though. I'll have to find the statistic somewhere, but I heard many times in the past that more people are bit by poodles than pit bulls. The issue is that, using pit bulls as an example, it isn't always the breed itself, but how the breeder chose to breed his animals. A "responsible" breeder will monitor the aggresiveness of his/her animals and not breed overly aggressive animals. That being said, many breeders will breed specifically for aggression if fighting dogs is the desire.

If you are shopping for a new dog, do your research, not only on the breed you are thinking of, but of the breeder, and the lineage of the dog you are thinking of buying.

I myself am looking to buy a [url="http://www.akc.org/breeds/scottish_deerhound/index.cfm"]Scottish Deerhound[/url]

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I think pit bulls should be banned. Since you can't control the people who buy them, you need to control the breed. Their level of agression is simply too dangerous for the general population to deal with, and in spite of training ,they are known for turning on their owners.

Poodles are yappy hunting dogs with an attitude and the jumpiness of terrier. I'll stick with St Bernards, Belgian Shephards, and Collies.

Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1309611' date='Jul 2 2007, 03:30 PM']I don't think it's anyone's business what type of dog you own. But yes, I think it's pretty much a scientific fact that certain breeds (think pit bull) are more vicious than others. I have "met" pit bulls that were happy-go-lucky, but the fact is that it's in their blood to turn on people, even their masters.[/quote]

Actually it's not a scientific fact that certain breeds are more vicious. Certain breeds are easier to train to act as such because of the what the breed is for. Pit bulls and other such types dogs have an instinct to protect and guard. Now this instinct can be turned in the wrong direction. What's bad is that Pit bulls as well as other large breeds can do a lot more damage to people because of their size and strength if they are trained to act as they really shouldn't.

desertwoman
Posted

I'm a dog lover, and I don't want to see any dog breeds banned because of the actions of their owners. Its a tuffy especially since a woman was bitten by over 90percent of her body by pit bulls because they got out of the fence. Imagine that happening to a child. My word.

I say if you live in a heavy populated area, that they are not encouraged, but if you so choose to have one and the dog has an incident whether with a human or another animal, then the owner will face serious charges.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I take more issue with the owner of the dog than the breed of the dog itself.

I want a corgi! :love:

[img]http://www1.istockphoto.com/file_thumbview_approve/2987708/2/istockphoto_2987708_cardigan_welsh_corgijpg[/img]

Posted

I want a dog too ... but now is definitely not the right time. :ohno:

Posted

I have handled dogs for over 25 years and the truth of the matter is that certain breeds are bred to be more agressive. Pit Bulls are crosses of Staffordshire and other Bull Terriers bred to fight in a dog pit, thus the name pit bull. They are not even an AKC recognized breed. When generation upon generation are bred for the same aggressive traits then it becomes a part of their nature to be agressive. This is not to say that there are not wonderful pit bulls but you have to keep in the back of your mind that you are dealing with a dog bred for aggression. I would never permit a child around one no matter how docile it is because it is in that dog's nature

That was not the question asked however. Owners have the greatest effect as to the behavior of the dog. Some are more competant then others.

I do not see how you could regulate who should own a particular breed but you can control animals that has displayed aggressive tendancies and work with the owner and dog.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

I picked:
[u]"Dog ownership should not be regulated at all."[/u]

but, I am not a fan of any government regulation at all

Posted

I would tend to agree except that animals that have displayed aggression are a safety concern for the whole community.

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1309857' date='Jul 2 2007, 05:21 PM']the truth of the matter is that certain breeds are bred to be more agressive.[/quote]

i can't testify to breeding for temperment, but i do know that pit bulls are bred to literally be more "dangerous" physically. unlike most dogs, their jaw muscles are connected to the back of their skulls, thereby making them have a stronger bite, that can break bones, etc etc. useful in a (evil :maddest: ) dogfight, but terribly scary when thinking about harm to a child, or really any person :unsure:

Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1309877' date='Jul 2 2007, 06:35 PM']I picked:
[u]"Dog ownership should not be regulated at all."[/u]

but, I am not a fan of any government regulation at all[/quote]
Ditto.

I'm against government regulation of dog ownership for many of the same reasons I am against government regulation of gun ownership. (Though I'll concede there's nothing in the Constitution directly stating "the right to own dogs shall not be infringed.")

Yes, obviously some breeds of dogs are more dangerous than others, but most dog owners are aware of this, and should be allowed to make their own choice. (And even animals considered "non-dangerous" can be capable of inflicting serious harm on human beings, particularly small children.)
Banning breeds of dog for private ownership smacks of the whole "nanny-state" mentality, imho.
What kind of animals someone keeps on his own property is his own business, so long as they are kept securely chained/fenced.
Of course, there can be laws regulating what animals people may have with them in public areas, and if an animal causes death or injury to another person, the owner should be held legally responsible.

I think there are too many government regulations "protecting people from themselves."

rollingcatholic
Posted

Airedales should be banned. Or at least have the Gremlin rule about never getting them wet.

Posted

[quote name='RC _' post='1310245' date='Jul 2 2007, 09:28 PM']Airedales should be banned. Or at least have the Gremlin rule about never getting them wet.[/quote]
What happens when they get wet?

:unsure:

rollingcatholic
Posted

The worst wet dog smell ever. Bad enough to peel paint off a car.

Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1309877' date='Jul 2 2007, 06:35 PM']I picked:
[u]"Dog ownership should not be regulated at all."[/u]

but, I am not a fan of any government regulation at all[/quote]
I agree, but I think there needs to be full liability for people who knowingly assume the risk of having a dangerous dog on their premises. No regulation means people need to actually take responsibility for the dangers they keep on their property, including animals.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...