Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

M.Sigga,

Actually, I haven't read his books, or any of Limbaugh's for that matter. It was kind of a joke, though. I would pray that no one acted solely upon their words for there are many points of disagreement with their views as well. I meant it in jest (although I admit I listen to their programs regularly). :)

Posted

Norseman,

I apologize if I offended you. My outburst was not directed towards you as much as it was the 50% of American Catholics that vote pro-choice. I do apologize. Although, while I can certainly understand the condition of people that you mention, I highly doubt that 50% of American Catholics are voting pro-choice because they're in the social state that you describe. In fact, I could name many of my own Catholic, collegiate, friends who vote democrat (one of which worked on staff for Bill Graham's short-lived presidential run).

It really is a shame.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Kerry is pro-abort, and Bishop Burke of St. Louis has already said that Kerry cannot receive Communion in his diocese.

Posted

Norseman,

I apologize if I offended you. My outburst was not directed towards you as much as it was the 50% of American Catholics that vote pro-choice. I do apologize. Although, while I can certainly understand the condition of people that you mention, I highly doubt that 50% of American Catholics are voting pro-choice because they're in the social state that you describe. In fact, I could name many of my own Catholic, collegiate, friends who vote democrat (one of which worked on staff for Bill Graham's short-lived presidential run).

It really is a shame.

No problem! I know that a significant portion of the Catholics who don't vote pro-life are actually well off and that they just ignore church teachings left and right, and for those I also am - how shall I put this charitably - "frustrated" and biting my tongue.

But there are some who are stuck in really terrible straits that we need to reach out to if we want to earn their vote.

Here is another scenario that actually happened in Illinois, and this now includes the church's stance on the death penalty, and it actually helped move me toward the "it should only be used in rarest of instances" position. There was a death row inmate named Rolando Cruz that was basically railroaded for a murder and an expose revaled mush prosecutorial and police misconduct in the case to the point that any thinking person could see that the wrong man was in prison. But this county prosecutor (we call them states attorney) kept on resisiting and even pursued another conviction when the judge threw out the old conviction. (Luckily, he never succeeded). This states attorney later ran for and won two terms as Illinois attorney general, but was defeated in 2002 when he ran for governor. And yes, I did vote for him, even though his past actions in the case disturbed me. This guy was anti-abortion through and through, but what happens when one life issue conflicts with another? Just another thing to throw in the mix.

hyperdulia again
Posted

"Christians" who put "Catholic" in quotes as if the appellation belongs to them, disturb me.

Posted (edited)

:huh:

Catholics = against abortion, always

Kerry = openly pro-choice

Supporting others choice = accessory to fact

Here is a good link from the people at EWTN about our responsibility as catholics:

EWTN - Moral Duties Concering Voting

Edited by Oik
Posted

Instead of issuing statements about Duties of Voting I wish the Church would just endorse a candidate/political party and make it easier for confused Democrats like myself instead of "Beating Around The Bush" (pun intended). Archbishop Hannan is starting to lean this way because he understands that people need verbal confirmation from a bishop because priests will have a variety of different positions based on who you talk too.

Posted (edited)

1)  If you learned a lesson from history, it is precisely BECAUSE people were desparate economically that the Nazis rose to power.

2) I'm not talking about urban renewal or college scholarships here.  I'm referring to the elderly lady who has to choose between food, medicine, and heat when the temperature is below zero.  I'm referring to the father and mother whose child needs expensive medical care for a serious condition and if they're out of work the child may not get it and may die either now or later due to complications and who may be left homeless.  Being out of a job is NOT something to take lightly.

3)  It was asked why people vote for pro-choice candidates, I gave an answer - not that I approve of it, I'm just stating political REALITY.  The REALITY we face is that people vote on the economy when the economy is bad for them.  If you don't like the reality, try to change it.  And it's not going to change simply by making statements like "How sad for them" to people who are one week away from being thrown out of the streets or about to max out on their health insurance maximum for a sick kid while the people who make such comments are warm and snug and in comfortable homes in southern states like Texas which hardly ever see below zero temperatures.  Such attitudes are callous and shocking and such a mindset is why I have a hard time associating with one Catholic group in particular. 

As Catholics and pro-lifers we have to do a better job.

And before anyone accuses me of being a closet liberal Democrat, I do intend to vote for Bush (I just hope that the rumor that he intends to dump Cheney for Giuliani is just that - a rumor).

ok, let me make it clear that I AM PRO-LIFE. This is also the first year i can vote in the pres. election, i consider myself 'Indy" but i'm registered republican. I was thinking about this issue earlier today almost along the same lines Norseman was. I'm in a human development class right now and it appears that most ( a generalization here, but i'm sure it's a ligit one) women choose to abort because of economical reasons (not saying that justifies anything, just a fact) and low income mothers recieve less pre/postnatal care =$$$. i dunno maybe its a naive assumption , but doesn't it make more sense to improve the economy for people in that situation so there are FEWER abortions first, before we can make it illegal. I don't know if that made any sense or not, but at the time it did. :wacko:

on the other hand, even Jesus said we're always going to have poor people.

"As Catholics and pro-lifers we have to do a better job."

man have you hit the nail on the head with that one!

Edited by hopeful1
Posted

btw, just a haunch, but most of the people who voted for Kerry and checked "Catholic" are probably just catholic for the bragging rights.

Not that i can judge their souls.

Posted

I agree with M. Sigga in the aspect That I think we need some more parties, although I would have to think about actually having a catholic party of sorts. I don't see the US getting a new party without major government reform (yeah right!). I consider myself an independant and I really only see politics and political action as a way to further God's Truth. If it doesn't, I don't support it. If I had to absolutely classify myself, I would say that I politically fall in to the moderate category with a strong leaning toward conservative, however I loathe politics, I refuse to say that I am political.

And, I will vote for Bush.

Posted

btw, just a haunch, but most of the people who voted for Kerry and checked "Catholic" are probably just catholic for the bragging rights.

Not that i can judge their souls.

I agree.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...