Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

catholicinsd
Posted

South Dakota is gearing up to execute its first person in over six decades. We, as members of the Culture of Life, and the Holy Catholic Christian Church, can't allow this sinful abomination to our God occur.

Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1312656' date='Jul 4 2007, 07:33 PM']South Dakota is gearing up to execute its first person in over six decades. We, as members of the Culture of Life, and the Holy Catholic Christian Church, can't allow this sinful abomination to our God occur.[/quote]

Considering that the CCC does not totally exclude the death penalty, please post details and explain in a logical way (as opoosed to relying on emotonally charged buzzwords) why this particular case this is a sinful abomination.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Lord have mercy on his soul.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1312656' date='Jul 4 2007, 06:33 PM']South Dakota is gearing up to execute its first person in over six decades. We, as members of the Culture of Life, and the Holy Catholic Christian Church, can't allow this sinful abomination to our God occur.[/quote]
If he's proven guilty without a doubt and that is the punishment for the crime, then I support it.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1312665' date='Jul 4 2007, 06:42 PM']Lord have mercy on his soul.[/quote]

Amen

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1312664' date='Jul 4 2007, 08:41 PM']Considering that the CCC does not totally exclude the death penalty, please post details and explain in a logical way (as opoosed to relying on emotonally charged buzzwords) why this particular case this is a sinful abomination.[/quote]


Um... Thou Shall Not Kill?

Norseman82
Posted (edited)

[quote name='chelsea' post='1312717' date='Jul 4 2007, 08:53 PM']Um... Thou Shall Not Kill?[/quote]

Oh please...spare me the simple-Simon misinformed 15-second theologically ignorant soundbites taken out of context.

"Thou shall not kill" refers to murder, not self-defense or capital punishment. Remember, the same God Who said "Thou shall not kill" also mandated capital punishment for certain offenses. And on paper, the church does not totally oppose capital punishment.

And I'm still waiting for what conditions make it a sinful abomination [i]in this particlar case[/i]. Was there prosecutorial misconduct? Evidence that the person did not commit the crime? Was the person mentally incompetent? Incompetent legal representation?

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1312729' date='Jul 4 2007, 10:26 PM']Oh please...spare me the simple-Simon misinformed 15-second theologically ignorant soundbites taken out of context.

"Thou shall not kill" refers to murder, not self-defense or capital punishment. Remember, the same God Who said "Thou shall not kill" also mandated capital punishment for certain offenses. And on paper, the church does not totally oppose capital punishment.[/quote]

take it up in the debate forum. This thread is for prayers.

Norseman82
Posted (edited)

[quote name='chelsea' post='1312732' date='Jul 4 2007, 09:28 PM']take it up in the debate forum. This thread is for prayers.[/quote]

The "Prayer Room" section is for prayers. I can more effectively pray for someone to be spared the death penalty if I know why he should be spared.

Edited by Norseman82
Totus Tuus
Posted

We have to recognize the difference between "theological opinion" and "doctrine". The Magisterial teaching on Capital Punishment can be found in the Catechism, and it says that capital punishment is not intrinsically evil. The theological opinion on the subject, most evident in the words of Pope John Paul II, is that capital punishment is no longer necessary in our culture, because we have the means to incarcerate people for life. But, as it is not intrinsically evil, resorting to the death penalty is not condemnable in most cases.


That said, I do pray for this man's soul. :sign:

Posted

My understanding is that the death penalty is only to be used in circumstances where the felon is unequivocally guilty and would pose some sort of immediate threat to the community/nation that he/she would be incarcerated in. For instance, if we were to capture and convict Osama Bin Laden, could we really expect to keep in behind bars? Wouldn't that jail-site be a magnet for terrorists attempting to free their leader? Therefore, an argument could be made for putting him to death. But, as JP2 (and the Catechism) points out, such cases are the VAST minority and, as such, implimenting the death penalty in most cases is unjust and not morally permissible.

Am I wrong here?

Posted

Lord have mercy on his soul.

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1313004' date='Jul 4 2007, 11:38 PM']My understanding is that the death penalty is only to be used in circumstances where the felon is unequivocally guilty and would pose some sort of immediate threat to the community/nation that he/she would be incarcerated in. For instance, if we were to capture and convict Osama Bin Laden, could we really expect to keep in behind bars? Wouldn't that jail-site be a magnet for terrorists attempting to free their leader? Therefore, an argument could be made for putting him to death. But, as JP2 (and the Catechism) points out, such cases are the VAST minority and, as such, implimenting the death penalty in most cases is unjust and not morally permissible.

Am I wrong here?[/quote]

No you're pretty much right.

catholicinsd
Posted

It is an abombmination to our Creator, should we decide when decide that one's must end simply because that is what human law states.

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1313243' date='Jul 5 2007, 12:07 AM']It is an abomination to our Creator, should we decide when decide that one's must end simply because that is what human law states.[/quote]

Once again, this is not what the Holy Mother Church teaches. Are you claiming to know better?

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1313247' date='Jul 5 2007, 02:10 AM']Once again, this is not what the Holy Mother Church teaches. Are you claiming to know better?[/quote]

Our Church teaches every clearly, that the decision to end Life is God's alone.

Deus te Amat
Posted

Wrong.

the pope has said that capital punishment is acceptable in cases of [i]extreme necessity[/i]

Deus te Amat
Posted

[quote]The Catechism (1997) #2267 says, in part, “... the traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor....”

“Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm ... the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity are very rare, if not practically non-existent” (CCC # 2267).[/quote]

Article

Posted

[quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1313260' date='Jul 5 2007, 03:23 AM']<a href="http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Periodicals/Dossier/9-10-98/article2.html" target="_blank">Article</a>[/quote]

Exactly what I said a few posts ago. The cases where this punishment can be morally justified are very rare. Thus, all other applications would be state-sponsored murder and, thus, the abomination that Catholicinsd is referring to.

Totus Tuus
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1313004' date='Jul 4 2007, 11:38 PM']My understanding is that the death penalty is only to be used in circumstances where the felon is unequivocally guilty and would pose some sort of immediate threat to the community/nation that he/she would be incarcerated in. For instance, if we were to capture and convict Osama Bin Laden, could we really expect to keep in behind bars? Wouldn't that jail-site be a magnet for terrorists attempting to free their leader? Therefore, an argument could be made for putting him to death. But, as JP2 (and the Catechism) points out, such cases are the VAST minority and, as such, implimenting the death penalty in most cases is unjust and not morally permissible.

Am I wrong here?[/quote]


This is what the Catechism says:

[quote name='CCC']2267 The traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude, presupposing full ascertainment of the identity and responsibility of the offender, recourse to the death penalty, when this is the only practicable way to defend the lives of human beings effectively against the aggressor.
"If, instead, bloodless means are sufficient to defend against the aggressor and to protect the safety of persons, public authority should limit itself to such means, because they better correspond to the concrete conditions of the common good and are more in conformity to the dignity of the human person.
"Today, in fact, given the means at the State's disposal to effectively repress crime by rendering inoffensive the one who has committed it, without depriving him definitively of the possibility of redeeming himself, cases of absolute necessity for suppression of the offender 'today ... are very rare, if not practically non-existent.' [68][/quote]

So we can see at least two criteria which must be met for the death penalty to be imposed:

1. Full ascertainment of the [i]identity[/i] and [i]responsibility[/i] of the offender,
2. Only to be used when it is the [i]only practicable way[/i] to defend the lives of human beings effectively against the aggressor.


[quote name='catholicinsd']It is an abombmination to our Creator, should we decide when decide that one's must end simply because that is what human law states.[/quote]

Considering the Church teaches otherwise, it is not smart to make this claim. When we don't understand the reasons why the Church teaches something, we have to have faith that she knows better than we do (as we call her "Holy Mother Church", and Mother knows best ;) ), and strive to understand her reasoning.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...