Maria_Faustina Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 I have several questions about the devil/Hell, and they're all kind of connected, so I have to post them all here. (I know it says post one question at a time.. but then I would take up half the posts on the board). I'll try to put them in a logical order, and to make sense. -What exactly is the devil? The story about the devil having formerly been an angel named Lucifer, who fell when he turned against God, is mentioned in Isaiah 14:12-15, for example. The name "Lucifer" is mentioned some other places, mostly in the Old Testament (but as the translation of the name: "morning star", usually)--so the devil seems to be a soul in these cases. Does the Church regard Isaiah's description as what actually happened, or just a poetic way of saying it? (And if it is true, that the devil was originally in heaven but fell, when was this? Not an exact year or anything but humans being born in a state of sin started with what is represented as the fall of Adam and Eve in the Garden. That is simply then the time when we started being tempted to do evil--not when the devil started existed...that wouldn't make sense. So his fall and/or the beginning of his existence would have had to have been before the fall of men. -If the devil did in fact fell from Heaven to Hell (if not, ignore this question), is he then a prisoner of Hell? This is suggested in Dante's [i]Inferno[/i]; of course, but I'm not saying Dante knew exactly what he was talking about. Satan is referred to as "Prince of Darkness", etc., which makes it sound more like he is in charge rather than captive. -Also, souls in hell can't be prayed for, correct? If a soul had any chance of redemption, and so be worth praying for, it would be in Purgatory. I asked all this was because for some reason I just wondered one day--this is going to sound really strange, honestly--if you could pray for the dEVil. I don't know, it's my/the whole thing with wanting eVERyone to have the joy of being with God in Heaven... and I was wondering why, if he was once a soul too (again, this depends on whether the fallen Lucifer story is accurate), he couldn't have redemption as well. I guess since he at one point turned his back on God once and for all, this sets his fate forever? And plus, I suppose that if the devil was brought back to God, then that would kind of change the whole state of the world--men would no longer be tempted... but since they are always selfish by nature... the devil could never be brought back, because men would never be willing to give up their selfish desires and such...? (Surprisingly, these are not all my questions about the devil. It would get more confusing if I posted them too. And excuse all the rambling.. I've kind of confused myself while writing this ).
Thy Geekdom Come Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1319343' date='Jul 8 2007, 11:21 PM']I have several questions about the devil/Hell, and they're all kind of connected, so I have to post them all here. (I know it says post one question at a time.. but then I would take up half the posts on the board). I'll try to put them in a logical order, and to make sense. -What exactly is the devil? The story about the devil having formerly been an angel named Lucifer, who fell when he turned against God, is mentioned in Isaiah 14:12-15, for example. The name "Lucifer" is mentioned some other places, mostly in the Old Testament (but as the translation of the name: "morning star", usually)--so the devil seems to be a soul in these cases. Does the Church regard Isaiah's description as what actually happened, or just a poetic way of saying it? (And if it is true, that the devil was originally in heaven but fell, when was this? Not an exact year or anything but humans being born in a state of sin started with what is represented as the fall of Adam and Eve in the Garden. That is simply then the time when we started being tempted to do evil--not when the devil started existed...that wouldn't make sense. So his fall and/or the beginning of his existence would have had to have been before the fall of men.[/quote] There are different interpretations about most Biblical passages, so I'm not going to rely too much on that. What I will say is what the Church has said: Satan, the devil, Lucifer, Beelzebub, etc. are all the same person. He is an angel and he remains an angel as far as his nature (i.e. if we were to classify his "species," he'd still be an angel) he's just become a bad angel, a fallen angel. Now, the tradition (lower-case, non-binding "tradition" as opposed to upper-case, binding "Tradition") of the Church has always been that God told the angels that He was going to make man and become human, and that some of the angels, out of pride, refused to serve a human, even God incarnate. They rebelled and were, of course, cast out of heaven. The devil (and all angels, fallen or otherwise) was created before man or at the same time as man, so yes, he existed before the Fall of man. [quote]-If the devil did in fact fell from Heaven to Hell (if not, ignore this question), is he then a prisoner of Hell? This is suggested in Dante's [i]Inferno[/i]; of course, but I'm not saying Dante knew exactly what he was talking about. Satan is referred to as "Prince of Darkness", etc., which makes it sound more like he is in charge rather than captive.[/quote] Satan is forever in hell, that is, he is forever cut off from God. However, he still can tempt people, and so can his devils. [quote]-Also, souls in hell can't be prayed for, correct? If a soul had any chance of redemption, and so be worth praying for, it would be in Purgatory.[/quote] Yep. Souls that choose hell by sinning mortally cannot reverse that decision after death. [quote]I asked all this was because for some reason I just wondered one day--this is going to sound really strange, honestly--if you could pray for the dEVil. I don't know, it's my/the whole thing with wanting eVERyone to have the joy of being with God in Heaven... and I was wondering why, if he was once a soul too (again, this depends on whether the fallen Lucifer story is accurate), he couldn't have redemption as well. I guess since he at one point turned his back on God once and for all, this sets his fate forever? And plus, I suppose that if the devil was brought back to God, then that would kind of change the whole state of the world--men would no longer be tempted... but since they are always selfish by nature... the devil could never be brought back, because men would never be willing to give up their selfish desires and such...?[/quote] The devil hates God. Angels, unlike us, are not bound by time. They are outside of our time. That means that they don't have a "before" and "after," so they can't really change their minds "later," since, for them, there is no "later." He made a choice to hate God and that is his choice for all time. [quote](Surprisingly, these are not all my questions about the devil. It would get more confusing if I posted them too. And excuse all the rambling.. I've kind of confused myself while writing this ).[/quote] What I would recommend is that you try not to focus too much on the devil. The more we focus on him, the more we kind of slip into a depression that allows him to work. We don't want him to have control, so it's best only to ask questions about him as they come up, rather than to focus on learning all about him. God bless, Micah
LouisvilleFan Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1319343' date='Jul 9 2007, 12:21 AM']-Also, souls in hell can't be prayed for, correct? If a soul had any chance of redemption, and so be worth praying for, it would be in Purgatory.[/quote] You [i]can[/i] pray for them because we pray for those who have passed away all the time. What we don't know is what state they're in. Our prayers can only help heal those in Purgatory. [quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1319343' date='Jul 9 2007, 12:21 AM']I asked all this was because for some reason I just wondered one day--this is going to sound really strange, honestly--if you could pray for the dEVil. I don't know, it's my/the whole thing with wanting eVERyone to have the joy of being with God in Heaven... and I was wondering why, if he was once a soul too (again, this depends on whether the fallen Lucifer story is accurate), he couldn't have redemption as well.[/quote] Only humans have souls. Angels, animals, plants, etc. do not have souls. The story about Lucifer being tossed from Heaven is generally what happened. A similar story appears in Revelation, when Satan takes a third of the stars down with him after St. Michael kicks his butt out of Heaven. What we don't know are the exact circumstances leading to Lucifer's pride causing him to be expelled from God's presence, but I've also heard the tradition that Raphael told. One additional part I heard was that God's Love demanded that the angels He created have the opportunity for free will, to choose to serve God. So in revealing the Creation, that opportunity was granted, and obviously there was rebellion. The good news is, since all this occured outside of time, it also means that the heavenly angels serve God perfectly because it's impossible for them to do otherwise. Edited July 9, 2007 by LouisvilleFan
Thy Geekdom Come Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1321003' date='Jul 9 2007, 05:52 PM']You [i]can[/i] pray for them because we pray for those who have passed away all the time. What we don't know is what state they're in. Our prayers can only help heal those in Purgatory.[/quote] I'd like to clarify that: those in hell cannot benefit from our prayers, and so (in a sense) we can't pray for them, but we also can't assume that anyone (even Hitler) is in hell, so we are bound to pray for all of the dead with the hope that they did not go to hell (although, if they did, they would not be helped by our prayers).
Maria_Faustina Posted July 10, 2007 Author Posted July 10, 2007 Thanks to everyone that responded, I understand a lot more now. [quote]What I would recommend is that you try not to focus too much on the devil. The more we focus on him, the more we kind of slip into a depression that allows him to work. We don't want him to have control, so it's best only to ask questions about him as they come up, rather than to focus on learning all about him.[/quote] Yes, I was hoping it wouldn't seem like I dO focus on the devil a lot... I know exactly how that is, actually, and come to think of it, what you said would explain a certain past depression (quite a while ago, don't worry about it)... anyways, I certainly know now why we shouldn't. I just figured that since he is in fact real, and temptations from him dO exist, then I should at least try to understand why... I think that would help avoid sin more, if we know what we're looking out for. Being ignorant of his nature and doings would not be to our advantage. And my questions are more of just an innocent curiosity about fActs... what you said about asking questions as they come up is what had happened, really... I'm just still a bit shy to post on here, I admit, and that's why all the questions built up. (I don't mean to be defending myself so much.... you aRe right). So, to ask 2 other questions (but I promise I'm done after this), that dID just come up recently. -So then.. the devil tempts us because... okay, I don't know exactly why. Because he can? Because he hates God and so doesn't wAnt anyone praising Him? It's not just sadism or anything like that, is it. -Also, fact-wise: Heaven and hell are not exact places, obviously. They are the state of our eternal souls. So hell is the state of our eternal soul if we are not with God. Oh... I think I may have just answered my own question. But to make sure: of course God did not create hell; He simply gave us and angels free will, and eternal souls. Therefore hell exists for us when we make the choice to go against Him forever?
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1323193' date='Jul 10 2007, 05:44 PM']-So then.. the devil tempts us because... okay, I don't know exactly why. Because he can? Because he hates God and so doesn't wAnt anyone praising Him? It's not just sadism or anything like that, is it.[/quote] He hates God, and he hates us, because God loves us, and because we are created in God's image and likeness.
abercius24 Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 (edited) By the way, I just want to say ditto to everything everyone has posted so far. Great job! [quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1323193' date='Jul 10 2007, 04:44 PM']So, to ask 2 other questions (but I promise I'm done after this), that dID just come up recently. -So then.. the devil tempts us because... okay, I don't know exactly why. Because he can? Because he hates God and so doesn't wAnt anyone praising Him? It's not just sadism or anything like that, is it.[/quote] Louisvillefan was pointing you in an excellent direction with the Book of Revelation. The particular passage that applies here is Revelation 11:19 - 12:18: "19 Then God's temple in heaven was opened, and the ark of his covenant could be seen in the temple. There were flashes of lightning, rumblings, and peals of thunder, an earthquake, and a violent hailstorm. 1 A great sign appeared in the sky, a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars. 2 She was with child and wailed aloud in pain as she labored to give birth. 3 Then another sign appeared in the sky; it was a huge red dragon, with seven heads and ten horns, and on its heads were seven diadems. 4 Its tail swept away a third of the stars in the sky and hurled them down to the earth. Then the dragon stood before the woman about to give birth, to devour her child when she gave birth. 5 She gave birth to a son, a male child, destined to rule all the nations with an iron rod. Her child was caught up to God and his throne. 6 The woman herself fled into the desert where she had a place prepared by God, that there she might be taken care of for twelve hundred and sixty days. 7 Then war broke out in heaven; Michael and his angels battled against the dragon. The dragon and its angels fought back, 8 but they did not prevail and there was no longer any place for them in heaven. 9 The huge dragon, the ancient serpent, who is called the Devil and Satan, who deceived the whole world, was thrown down to earth, and its angels were thrown down with it. 10 Then I heard a loud voice in heaven say: "Now have salvation and power come, and the kingdom of our God and the authority of his Anointed. For the accuser of our brothers is cast out, who accuses them before our God day and night. 11 They conquered him by the blood of the Lamb and by the word of their testimony; love for life did not deter them from death. 12 Therefore, rejoice, you heavens, and you who dwell in them. But woe to you, earth and sea, for the Devil has come down to you in great fury, for he knows he has but a short time." 13 When the dragon saw that it had been thrown down to the earth, it pursued the woman who had given birth to the male child. 14 But the woman was given the two wings of the great eagle, so that she could fly to her place in the desert, where, far from the serpent, she was taken care of for a year, two years, and a half-year. 15 The serpent, however, spewed a torrent of water out of his mouth after the woman to sweep her away with the current. 16 But the earth helped the woman and opened its mouth and swallowed the flood that the dragon spewed out of its mouth. 17 Then the dragon became angry with the woman and went off to wage war against the rest of her offspring, those who keep God's commandments and bear witness to Jesus. 18 It took its position on the sand of the sea." (NAB) First of all, you must understand that the Book of Revelation speaks of the beginning and end of creation in a somewhat all-encompassing fashion, but it also gives you a view of those events on multiple levels -- some at an earthly level, but most at a heavenly level (I have heard it said by scholars that there are 8 levels). The basic idea is that while creation is occuring in our universe, related events are occuring in heaven. This part of the Book of Revelation speaks of what happened in heaven when God revealed His plan to make Mary the Queen of Heaven and the True Ark of the Covenant. It starts with the revealing of the Ark in the heavenly temple which is later seen to be "a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars." This woman is clearly a Heavenly Queen. We also see that this woman "was with child" and "gave birth to a son, a male child, destined to rule all the nations with an iron rod. Her child was caught up to God and his throne." The iron rod is a symbol of the Davidic King, and the only Davidic King who ascended to heaven to sit upon the throne of God was Our Lord Jesus Christ. This means that the Queen of Heaven revealed as the Ark of the Covenant is the Blessed Mother Mary. Notice her Crown of Twelve Stars. Stars represent the angels of heaven, which means God intended to place this lowly woman as the Queen of the Angels. During this revelation, though, Lucifer -- "the dragon, the ancient serpent, who is called the Devil and Satan" -- recruited 1/3 of the angels (the stars) to join his rebellion and subsequently "fall" from grace. Given the context it seems as those Lucifer and the fallen angels refused to serve beneath such a Queen and a God who would subjugate them to such a humble position. The Dragon also attempted to "devour" the woman's child, which tells us that Lucifer attempted to thwart God's plan to bring Christ into the World -- likely Satan's work to convince King Herod into killing all male children in Bethlehem. Mary and Jesus escaped King Herod's wrath and fled into Egypt (the Desert) for a time. We then see the War in Heaven when St. Michael the Archangel leads the other 2/3 angels against the Dragon and his fallen angels, forcing them out of heaven. In retaliation, the Devil decides to continue pursuing the Woman and her Child on earth, but isn't successful because she is helped by the faithful, who are symbolized by the earth (the land). Because the dragon is unsuccessful, He decides to cut his loses and "wage war against the rest of her offspring, those who keep God's commandments and bear witness to Jesus." The last verse tells us that Lucifer took his position upon the sand of the sea -- the sea being a symbol for non-believers and the sand being the edge of the earth, the earth again being a symbol of the faithful. This tells us that Lucifer would stand to wage war upon anyone who could be a believer, whether they are in the Church or not. Keep in mind, as well, that what is planned in heaven does eventually occur on earth, but not necessarily at the same time since there is no time in heaven. This is why Lucifer can fall from grace while planning an attack on Christ through Herod even before he has been thrown from heaven by St. Michael to later become the serpent who later tempts Eve. It's a mind bender, no doubt. Now, I won't say this interpretation is perfect or that it is anywhere near dogma. As the posts stated before, the Church teaches general ideas from this context. But there are elements of this passage from the Book of Revelation that are undeniable, and give a much clearer picture of what went on between God and the fallen angels. [quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1323193' date='Jul 10 2007, 04:44 PM']-Also, fact-wise: Heaven and hell are not exact places, obviously. They are the state of our eternal souls. So hell is the state of our eternal soul if we are not with God. Oh... I think I may have just answered my own question. But to make sure: of course God did not create hell; He simply gave us and angels free will, and eternal souls. Therefore hell exists for us when we make the choice to go against Him forever?[/quote] Yes, and our choice is sealed at our death whereas the angels choice was sealed in one instant -- likely in their choice to follow God's plan, which we see above became a big issue for Lucifer and the fallen angels. Edited July 11, 2007 by abercius24
LouisvilleFan Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 [quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1323193' date='Jul 10 2007, 05:44 PM']-Also, fact-wise: Heaven and hell are not exact places, obviously. They are the state of our eternal souls. So hell is the state of our eternal soul if we are not with God. Oh... I think I may have just answered my own question. But to make sure: of course God did not create hell; He simply gave us and angels free will, and eternal souls. Therefore hell exists for us when we make the choice to go against Him forever?[/quote] I'm curious to hear some other thoughts on this. Maybe there's a difference between the Heaven that exists now and the New Creation that will come after Christ returns, but I've heard that since we will be resurrected with glorified bodies, that Heaven is/will be a physical world like this one.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1324649' date='Jul 11 2007, 05:40 PM']I'm curious to hear some other thoughts on this. Maybe there's a difference between the Heaven that exists now and the New Creation that will come after Christ returns, but I've heard that since we will be resurrected with glorified bodies, that Heaven is/will be a physical world like this one.[/quote] Well, this is only theological speculation (and I think that's about as much as you'll get from the Church on this matter), but I think that hell is like dying for all eternity. God gives two things to us: existence and life. Rocks exist, humans both exist and have life. He won't ever take away our existence, but He allows us to choose whether or not we will accept life from Him. There are two different kinds of life, natural and supernatural. When you are starving, you are in a sense dying on the natural order. When you are sinning mortally, you are dying on the supernatural order. I think that since hell is eternal death, it means to exist, but not to have life. What we do know is that we will all be resurrected, even the damned, but they will rise to a resurrection of condemnation. It seems to me that hell, on the natural order, would be like eternal thirst and starvation, as well as pain, and anything else they would experience while dying a death of being cut off from everything that gives life. This is caused because they would lack the source of life on the natural order. A supernatural parallel would be occuring also: the damned would be dying for all eternity on the inside, using minds, wills, and bodies against God, all the while knowing that they were rejecting the source of spiritual life, but their hatred of God would have grown so white hot that they would rather be apart from Him in agony for all eternity than be with Him. God, for His part, is infinitely just and infinitely merciful. I had this explained to me once, and I believe it makes good sense: God's justice and God's mercy are the same thing, just from different angles. We know that God loves everyone. If a person loves God and thinks about God (using the mind), chooses God (using the will), and serves God (using the body), then one's mind, will, and body get purified in life and in purgatory, "like gold tested in fire." That is how people get glorified. I pointed out mind, will, and body above in talking about hell...these three gifts are like muscles...if we use them for what they were made to be used for, they grow strong and get glorified...if we use them against their purpose, they atrophy and fall apart. Now, imagine God as a Being of intense, burning love (as He is). He wants to embrace everyone in the never-ending love of the Trinity. If you have allowed yourself to become like gold tested in fire, your impurities have been removed and you can get closer and closer to Him safely, because you've exercised your muscles. If you have let your muscles atrophy, you have not removed your impurities, and they will burn too hot in you and hurt you, so God, because He wishes to spare you (mercy), gives you what you deserve (justice) and throws you far away from Him, into the darkness, where you will be safe from His burning love, not because He is dangerous, but because you refused to exercise your mind, will, and body properly by using them for their purpose. Meanwhile, He embraces those who are willing to withstand the pain of imperfections being removed (those in purgatory, i.e. those who did not reject Him with mortal sin during their lives) and those who are already completely purified (the saints). In light of this, the Dark Night of the Soul, as well as the Cross, make perfect sense: we must embrace them and endure them in order to be purified. They are God's work in us; we have to cooperate in order for them to save us. Only love is powerful enough to keep us going. God bless, Micah
Lil Red Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1320385' date='Jul 9 2007, 09:58 AM']What I would recommend is that you try not to focus too much on the devil. The more we focus on him, the more we kind of slip into a depression that allows him to work. We don't want him to have control, so it's best only to ask questions about him as they come up, rather than to focus on learning all about him. God bless, Micah[/quote] i've heard it said (i think it was in [u]An Exorcist Tells His Story[/u]) that if you study the devil, you should study the angels twice as much.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1324688' date='Jul 11 2007, 06:22 PM']i've heard it said (i think it was in [u]An Exorcist Tells His Story[/u]) that if you study the devil, you should study the angels twice as much.[/quote] Yeah, Dr. Mark Miravalle at FUS says three times as much :, but the basic sentiment is still there. Focusing on dark things just opens too many bad doors.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now