Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

melporcristo
Posted

JMJT

How should we as Catholics tithe?
Should we give money to solid Catholic ministries over giving to our home parish that isn't that solid?
Should we give money to seminarians over giving money to our parish?

Thank you!
In Christ,
Melissa

Posted

JMJ
7/9 - Fourteenth Monday

melporcristo,

The fifth precept of the Church states that we are to assist the material needs of the Church as our means dictate. There is no further specification beyond that.

However, good philosophy tells us that I have more responsibilities to those closest to me, either by blood or by simple relation. Therefore, the first recipient of my money ought to be the parish I go to Mass at every Sunday. If this money is being misused (ie., embezzelment, funding anti-Catholic organizations, etc.), then I am absolved of this responsibility. If a priest is preaching non-truths or half-truths, it would seem to absolve me as well. Finally, if my parish is financially well-off and does not need my money, I would be fine donating it elsewhere.

So, I go to the next person/organization that I am responsible to. Am I a member of the Knights of Columbus? Perhaps my money should go to them. Is there some sort of special appeal from the diocese/other close organization? Maybe I should give to them. I have a friend who is paralyzed from a broken back; maybe I should give to a research organization that doesn't violate human dignity (ie., the Spinal Foundation, I believe). If someone close to me has a need, I should give to them.

What if none of these need money? The third circle is the Church at large. There are missionary groups and other organizations that are always in need of money. Peter's Pence would seem to fall in here as well.

So do you see how this operates? My first responsibility is to my family (parish), then to those close to me (ie., diocese), then to all people (the Church at large). Look at it as a series of concentric circles (an image painfully in fashion today) with you at the center.

Seminarians will probably hate me for this, but we get enough money from the diocese, priests, the Serra Club, and the Knights of Columbus to get by just fine. We'll take your money, but it should probably go to the Papal Foundation for the Care of Feral Roman Cats first. Hope this helps.

Yours,
Pio Nono

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...