Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Catholics Vestments


Recommended Posts

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

That thread below on "Non SRI-Investments" inspired me to create this thread in order to discuss an article I recently read about Roman Catholic vestments. I found it to be quite interesting.

[url="http://thenewliturgicalmovement.blogspot.com/2006/07/on-origin-and-development-of-vestments.html"]http://thenewliturgicalmovement.blogspot.c...-vestments.html[/url]

So on what side of the fence does everyone fall? Romano-Gothic? The fiddleback style? :drool:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I actually quite like this peculiar medieval style with all the folds and stuff.

[img]http://www.execulink.com/~dtribe/blog/massmartin.jpg[/img]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

This picture is phly too.

[img]http://www.execulink.com/~dtribe/blog/vestments2.jpg[/img]

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1322192' date='Jul 10 2007, 08:50 AM']I actually quite like this peculiar medieval style with all the folds and stuff.[/quote]
Unlike most trads I know, I actually prefer the conical gothic vestments, but not the newer styles (which aren't that conical; more like a circle with a hole cut in the top). Although, more important than style is the quality of the fabrics and tailoring. For the roman fiddle-back style, one can use heavier, stiffer fabrics, gold and silver threading, etc. because this sort of thing doesn't restrict his arm movements. I do like the flow of a really beautiful gothic conical chasuble. I've seen some made of fine hand-woven silk damask... it can be breathtaking.

I also think too much attention is paid to the top layer of the vestments, however. I'm a big fan of really high-quality cassocks, and fine albs. Our priest has this beautiful linen alb that has intricate hand embroidered lace on the sleeves and from the knee to his ankles.

I also don't understand why certain vestments fell out of fashion in the new mass, such as the chalice veil (I've only seen three priests use this in the new mass), biretta, maniple, burse, and amice.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1322329' date='Jul 10 2007, 09:27 AM']Unlike most trads I know, I actually prefer the conical gothic vestments, but not the newer styles (which aren't that conical; more like a circle with a hole cut in the top). Although, more important than style is the quality of the fabrics and tailoring. For the roman fiddle-back style, one can use heavier, stiffer fabrics, gold and silver threading, etc. because this sort of thing doesn't restrict his arm movements. I do like the flow of a really beautiful gothic conical chasuble. I've seen some made of fine hand-woven silk damask... it can be breathtaking.

I also think too much attention is paid to the top layer of the vestments, however. I'm a big fan of really high-quality cassocks, and fine albs. Our priest has this beautiful linen alb that has intricate hand embroidered lace on the sleeves and from the knee to his ankles.

I also don't understand why certain vestments fell out of fashion in the new mass, such as the chalice veil (I've only seen three priests use this in the new mass), biretta, maniple, burse, and amice.[/quote]
Yes!! I'm hoping that the wider use of the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i] will encourage priests to adopt the most edifying and expressive vestments that our tradition has to offer.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1322332' date='Jul 10 2007, 11:34 AM']Yes!! I'm hoping that the wider use of the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i] will encourage priests to adopt the most edifying and expressive vestments that our tradition has to offer.[/quote]
This is my hope, too. I honestly don't think that the two different forms of the Latin rite will exist in 100 years; I pray that they converge in a way that is pleasing to God. Hopefully, the [i]Novus Ordo[/i] will evolve into the mass that [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i] actually called for...

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1322340' date='Jul 10 2007, 09:43 AM']This is my hope, too. I honestly don't think that the two different forms of the Latin rite will exist in 100 years; I pray that they converge in a way that is pleasing to God. Hopefully, the [i]Novus Ordo[/i] will evolve into the mass that [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i] actually called for...[/quote]
The view (and hope) that I've expressed in some other threads is that the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i] and the [i]forma ordinaria[/i] both implement Sacrosanctum Concillium in their own way (in the case of the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i] I see very little actual changes) and that the two forms coexist in a way analogous to the Low Mass and High Mass of the TLM. I've explained my fantasy in more detail on other threads. To be honest I don't like the idea of tweaking the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i] at all. I believe that by maintaining this form in its solemn high expression, and by joining it to the solemnized [i]forma ordinaria[/i] in the sense of two forms of one rite (like Low and High sort of), the problems that people wanted to rememedy for both Liturgies will all but be solved.

Of course I believe that the forma ordinaria must include a wider use of Latin (but still some vernacular) as well as pride and place of Gregorian chant. It is hard to explain, but I can visualize in my mind how to two forms of the Roman Rite can really compliment and enrich each other but the way I envision this does not involve changing the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i]. It is by existing along side the solemn [i]forma ordinaria[/i] that this form is enriched, not be tweaks. If one were to ask the question "who's the daddy", the answer would be obvious enough in this case. The [i]forma ordinaria[/i] needs to breath in some of the ancient form in order to blossom into that which Sacrosanctum Concillium describes. In this form I believe it will bring a balance to the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i] that was apparently lacking in the days of silent low masses with people praying rosaries and all that. But a balance in virtue of it being one side of a single rite, not by some perverse melding of the forms.

Stupid? Interesting? Neither?

I mean, if in two or five hundred years the distinction between the forms vanishes that's fine. I'm just not comfortable with commitees and rogue pastors making stuff up as they go. That obviously didn't work when they tried in in the seventies and stuff.

Noel's angel
Posted

I thought the other thread said vestments too...I got all excited lol.

Posted

I like the vestment the Pope wears with a round clasp in the middle connecting the two sides. I don't know what it's called.

Noel's angel
Posted

[img]http://danielmitsui.tripod.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/jmechas2.jpg[/img]

Rather fancy methinks.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1322669' date='Jul 10 2007, 11:58 AM']I like the vestment the Pope wears with a round clasp in the middle connecting the two sides. I don't know what it's called.[/quote]
Yeah, the Pope has some style. :D:

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

Sorry for going off topic, but I've just seen something wonderful:

[img]http://www.gearlive.com/blogimages/popebenedictXVIcufflinks.jpg[/img]

Edited by Noel's angel
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1322712' date='Jul 10 2007, 12:17 PM']Sorry for going off topic, but I've just seen something wonderful:

[img]http://www.gearlive.com/blogimages/popebenedictXVIcufflinks.jpg[/img][/quote]
:shock:



:drool:

Noel's angel
Posted

I know! How amazingly amazing.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1322395' date='Jul 10 2007, 12:03 PM']Stupid? Interesting? Neither?[/quote]
I've had similar ideas. It's different than the differences between high and low masses, because in the extraordinary form, the Solemn High Mass is the norm. If you cut out the parts of the deacon and subdeacon, and transfer many of their duties to the MC, you have a [i]Missa Cantata[/i]. Cut out the singing, reduce the number of acolytes down to two or fewer, remove the incense, and you have a low mass. The relationship between the ordinary and extraordinary forms of the liturgy are too different to do this with.

Now, if one were to make some reforms to the ordinary form, this might work:
1) priest says it [i]ad orientum[/i]
2) Simplify the penitential rite so that there is only one option
3) Bring back the old offetory, because the new one is really lacking
4) Eliminate Eucharistic prayers 2, 3, and 4
5) Priest prays the canon silently
6) Ban all music by Marty Haugen, David Haas, and Dan Shute. Burn the Gather hymnal. Assign penalty of mortal sin to "Table of Plenty" and "Jerusalem my Destiny"

Ok, maybe I'm kidding about the last one. A little.

I agree with you, for the most part, about not touching the extraordinary form. Here's the only two changes I'd make, to bring them more in union:
1) change the extraordinary missal to use the same calendar as the ordinary form
2) add psalm and second reading

Those are two minor, minor changes to the old mass, and would ease its communion with the new. It also means that a priest that celebrates both rites doesn't have to write two separate sermons for a Sunday. I'm not saying the new calendar is perfect, but it does have more readings, and if you go to daily mass, that means a lot of bible, which is good. I'd keep the new calendar, but bring back a lot of the cool feast days and stuff from the old.

Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1322712' date='Jul 10 2007, 02:17 PM']Sorry for going off topic, but I've just seen something wonderful:[/quote]
That's very ON topic. I like it when priests wear cufflinks.

IrishSalesian
Posted

The Cufflinks is all well and good for fomal occasions, but just around the office i think is a bit much. The Priest os supposed to be working hard, interactiong with the people, not trying to be a fancy dresser.

Posted

[quote name='IrishSalesian' post='1322915' date='Jul 10 2007, 03:44 PM']The Cufflinks is all well and good for formal occasions, but just around the office i think is a bit much. The Priest os supposed to be working hard, interactiong with the people, not trying to be a fancy dresser.[/quote]
The priests in my parish wear cufflinks whenever they wear a cassock, which translates at least to any time they celebrate mass.

I also tend to think that people dress too informally in office environments today. The only reason I dress casual is because I'd be laughed out of my workplace if I didn't. Less than a century ago, if you had an office job, it would be assumed you wore a suit and tie to the office. French cuffs are a little more formal than standard, but not at all uncommon in environments where everyone wears a suit.

I see no contradiction between dressing well and working hard. My spiritual director in college, a priest who dressed particularly well, taught me that dressing well is a way of showing respect to those around you, as is the way you address people, setting the table properly, and other parts of etiquette that have fallen into disuse in polite society.

IrishSalesian
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1322985' date='Jul 10 2007, 04:22 PM']The priests in my parish wear cufflinks whenever they wear a cassock, which translates at least to any time they celebrate mass.

I also tend to think that people dress too informally in office environments today. The only reason I dress casual is because I'd be laughed out of my workplace if I didn't. Less than a century ago, if you had an office job, it would be assumed you wore a suit and tie to the office. French cuffs are a little more formal than standard, but not at all uncommon in environments where everyone wears a suit.

I see no contradiction between dressing well and working hard. My spiritual director in college, a priest who dressed particularly well, taught me that dressing well is a way of showing respect to those around you, as is the way you address people, setting the table properly, and other parts of etiquette that have fallen into disuse in polite society.[/quote]

I agree with almost everything that you have stated. Although, I thin kit very important for the priest to emerse himself in the community in which he is serving. When I finish seminary I hope to be in a poor community, it is there that Spirtuality is high, and not taken for granted (im not saying that the wealthy aren't the same) Its just the way I feel, And with the Salesians, we tend to emerse ourselves with the children playing sports. I don't think that that would ho well with French Cuffs.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1322885' date='Jul 10 2007, 01:28 PM']I've had similar ideas. It's different than the differences between high and low masses, because in the extraordinary form, the Solemn High Mass is the norm. If you cut out the parts of the deacon and subdeacon, and transfer many of their duties to the MC, you have a [i]Missa Cantata[/i]. Cut out the singing, reduce the number of acolytes down to two or fewer, remove the incense, and you have a low mass. The relationship between the ordinary and extraordinary forms of the liturgy are too different to do this with.

Now, if one were to make some reforms to the ordinary form, this might work:
1) priest says it [i]ad orientum[/i]
2) Simplify the penitential rite so that there is only one option
3) Bring back the old offetory, because the new one is really lacking
4) Eliminate Eucharistic prayers 2, 3, and 4
5) Priest prays the canon silently
6) Ban all music by Marty Haugen, David Haas, and Dan Shute. Burn the Gather hymnal. Assign penalty of mortal sin to "Table of Plenty" and "Jerusalem my Destiny"

Ok, maybe I'm kidding about the last one. A little.

I agree with you, for the most part, about not touching the extraordinary form. Here's the only two changes I'd make, to bring them more in union:
1) change the extraordinary missal to use the same calendar as the ordinary form
2) add psalm and second reading

Those are two minor, minor changes to the old mass, and would ease its communion with the new. It also means that a priest that celebrates both rites doesn't have to write two separate sermons for a Sunday. I'm not saying the new calendar is perfect, but it does have more readings, and if you go to daily mass, that means a lot of bible, which is good. I'd keep the new calendar, but bring back a lot of the cool feast days and stuff from the old.[/quote]
That matches my dream exactly actually, (:woot:) although I would not consider reform #6 to be negotiable. hehe And the High Mass/Low Mass thing was simply an analogy for lack of a better way of explaining what ever it is I was trying to explain. I realize that the exact scenario is not the same. The reason I liked that as an analogy is because I was seeking the do away with any implications of two rites (which seems a common attitude). I would see the two forms as aspects of one rite in a way somewhat analogous to the Low Mass/High Mass distinction but in more ways different.
Now I must go and wish upon some stars...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...