curtins Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 [quote name='Theoketos' post='1323818' date='Jul 11 2007, 12:12 AM']Well, It would be appropriate in one sense, though I am not sure they genuflect. They do more kissing of Icons from my understanding.[/quote] well even in a broad sense, should we treat it like God (ie as we would treat the eucharist in our own parish church) or is it just a piece of bread
thessalonian Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 Seems this is creating a bit of a stir out there in protestant land. Some observations. 1) I think it was Babe Ruth who said "It ain't braggin if you can do it". I would say "It ain't arrogant if you can prove it" and the Catholic Church can. 2) Seems like non-catholic howl when a Church says it is true. That leaves them with issues where they disagree with the Church. Ultimately the individual is the pillar and support of the truth in non-catholic communities. 3) They really should have no problem with the Pope saying that their religions are not the fullness of the truth since they all contradict eachother and don't claim any infallibility, other than the bible which depends on their interpretation, which is subject to error, by their own admission. Yet I have never met a protestant that claimed that some of what he preached was in error. (see #2 above).
missionarybelle Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 (edited) Because the Eastern Churches DO have a valid Eucharist, that means that Jesus is fully present, body, blodd, soul, and divinity. Thus, we should give him the highest reverence and respect. No matter which "house" he's in. just because he isn't in a Catholic church doesn't meant that He isn't Jesus. Edited July 11, 2007 by missionarybelle
cmotherofpirl Posted July 11, 2007 Author Posted July 11, 2007 Its not like we are saying anything new, we have been saying we are the only Church founded by Jesus Christ since uh, Jesus Christ.
IcePrincessKRS Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 [quote name='missionarybelle' post='1324152' date='Jul 11 2007, 10:32 AM']Because the Eastern Churches DO have a valid Eucharist, that means that Jesus is fully present, body, blodd, soul, and divinity. Thus, we should give him the highest reverence and respect. No matter which "house" he's in. just because he isn't in a Catholic church doesn't meant that He isn't Jesus.[/quote] I agree. I'd never thought of this question before, but now that its been brought up (and in light of Theoketos' response), what would the proper course of action be regarding showing reverence and respect to Christ in the Eucharist in "Oriental" Churches? I mean, if they do not genuflect would it be improper of us to do so in one of their Churches? Like, would they consider it wrong or rude? Because when you're in someone else's house you want to show them due respect as well (that, of course, shouldn't ever interfere with due respect to God), so...
cmotherofpirl Posted July 11, 2007 Author Posted July 11, 2007 Maybe we should get Appy to teach us a quick course??
IcePrincessKRS Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 lol I was just thinking our resident Byzantine Catholic should pop in and tell us!
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 I make the sign of the Cross when I drive by an Eastern Orthodox Church. I've seen Orthodox Christians bow and make the Eastern sign of the Cross in Roman Churches and once when an EO priest was showing me around his parish I genuflected and did the Western sign of the cross. It depends on the context though. If I was actually worshipping with an Eastern Orthodox congregation in a liturgical context I would do everything Eastern style (no genuflecting and no western sign of the cross), but of course a Roman Catholic should not feel free to just waltz in and worship at an Eastern Orthodox church. If someone was in such a situation, and the pastor or bishop allowed it, I would say to treat it the same as one would treat a Byzantine Catholic Liturgy. Ok, I have seen Eastern Catholics who do everything Eastern style at Roman Masses (no genuflecting, Easter sign of cross, bowing, etc) and I personally have a problem with this especially when the person obviously knows the correct gestures and things for the Mass. When in Rome do as the Romans do and when in Byzantium do as the Byzantines do. That is my take on the matter because I do not see even the smallest gestures to be extrinsic to the liturgy and the tradition that the liturgy embodies. The case of being shown around the parish by the EO priest is a little different because I was not participating in Liturgical prayer and the priest was relating to me as a Roman Catholic. In this latter case I would say there is no strict rule, it depends on the situation and all that.
Sojourner Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 We talked about this today in class ... my prof was a little giddy about it. He made a couple of comments with regard to ecumenical efforts and how this might affect them. First, he noted that by and large ecumenical efforts have been initiated from the Catholic side. I think that is telling, personally. Second, he noted that you can't have an authentic conversation about ecumenism without first clearly defining terms and goals. This document makes a clear statement about the Catholic definition of "church" and therefore paves the way for meaningful dialogue with non-Catholic communities. I thought this was a good point.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now