missionarybelle Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 from what I understand, Ultramontanism has it's roots in a good thing. however, has the meaning of the word changed as time has passed? I guess my main question would be, would it be unwise to refer to yourself as an ultramonanist today? I think it means that you believe in papal supremacy above that of the bishops and individuals in the church. am I correct?
Pio Nono Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 JMJ 7/12 - Fourteenth Thursday missionarybelle, I would dispute whether ultramontanism had its roots in a good thing. It came out of the French episcopate (hence, ultra [beyond] montane [the mountains]), who were trying to assert complete Papal power over French governmental power. It would have been fine if they just wanted the State to stay out of Church affairs, but the problem is that the proponents wanted the Church deeply involved in State affairs, like it was before the Revolution...which would have meant MUCH more money and power for the French bishops. It also has its roots in a very modern, American notion of liberalism - those highest "up the chain" should have more power than those under them (for example, in modern liberal philosophy, the federal government should have more power than the states, but in modern conservative philosophy, it is the other way around). Under this system, the Pope kind of becomes the "king" of the Church and the world. Historically, that's been a very bad thing (hence, Boniface VIII, Innocent VIII, Sixtus IV, Alexander VI...a notable exception was Bl. Innocent III). Also, this notion is not found in the traditions of our fathers. Popes as late as Gregory the Great would never claim to be what the ultramontanists want them to be. Just to note, too, that I'm not tipping my hat to conciliarism - when the Church is run by Councils instead of Popes, people tend to get burned alive (cf. Jan Hus). I would seriously resist the temptation to adhere to a strict ultramontanism, since the Church has never really embraced that philosophy herself. Read [i]Dei Filius[/i] and [i]Pastor Aeternus[/i] of Vatican I, and [i]Lumen Gentium[/i] of Vatican II, to get an idea of the correct balance between the Pope and the college of bishops in the Church. Hope that helps. Yours, Pio Nono
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now