Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I had an epiphany tonight when talking with my Protestant father about the latest Vatican document, then one that says he doesn't attend a church and that his ecclesial community doesn't provide a means of salvation. The epiphany was that while this document does provide a great starting point for actual ecumenical dialogue, it will mean a lot of very difficult, very emotional conversations from here on out for people like me who have families and close friends who don't like being told that what they believe is wrong.

Dad sees this definition as being arrogant, and sees no Scriptural support for the importance of apostolic succession. I think, though, that the objection is really more emotional than logical. He staked a lot on being right about Christianity, and shaking a foundational belief about the structure of that faith is hard to deal with. He kept saying he doesn't see much importance in the concept of apostolic tradition, and I finally whipped out Paul's exhortation that believers not accept a gospel other than that taught by Paul or the apostles. Then he brought up the fact that many Catholics over the centuries have preached heretical gospels ... and when I replied that there's a difference between someone who's Catholic preaching a heretical gospel and the church binding believers with a heretical gospel. Then he said we had to stop talking about it. Sigh.

Doing apologetics is so much easier when there aren't real people you love on the other end. Hopefully, though, we'll be able to talk about it at some point in the future, and I can gently bring up more support for apostolic succession, and the primacy of the See of Peter.

If y'all think about it, pray for me and others like me who are going to be on the front lines of defending these core Catholic beliefs, that we are gentle but firm in holding to truth.

Posted

[quote]Dad sees this definition as being arrogant...[/quote]

He believes that Christianity is the only right religion, right? Isn't this just as arrogant?

Posted

+

You did an awesome job, Terra. God is smiling and cheering! Prayers.

Posted

keep up the good fight

Jesus said that he will split fathers and sons etc.

Posted

I've been discussing this on another (Protestant) forum, and most everyone reacted negatively to the document, or at least had some reservations about it. I tried to explain the teaching of the Church in context, but as the discussion went on, I had to make the point that this is what the Church believes. It is an exclusive teaching, much like her exclusive belief in Christ as the one Savior of the world, or the Bible as the only text inspired by God. Our Lord established one Church, and this Church is identified exclusively with the Catholic Church.

I can understand how they see this teaching, and how maybe they are somewhat offended. After trying to explain what the document does NOT mean (which is almost as important as what it does mean), I just had to accept their reaction. How many times does Our Lord talk about how he came to set one against another, how the Cross is a scandal to the Jews and folly to the Greeks, how anyone who does not hate his own brother cannot be his disciple. There comes a point where we just have to accept the "scandal" of the faith, and not try to hide or soften it (but still presenting it with charity and understanding).

As far as the family thing, I think that family members are probably the least likely be the cause of someone's conversion. Even Our Lord was not accepted as a prophet in his hometown (Mark 6:4). The best thing a family member can do is be a positive witness with their lives, and be there on a personal level. That's a seed that hopefully someone else can water.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1327835' date='Jul 13 2007, 11:21 PM']I've been discussing this on another (Protestant) forum, and most everyone reacted negatively to the document, or at least had some reservations about it. I tried to explain the teaching of the Church in context, but as the discussion went on, I had to make the point that this is what the Church believes. It is an exclusive teaching, much like her exclusive belief in Christ as the one Savior of the world, or the Bible as the only text inspired by God. Our Lord established one Church, and this Church is identified exclusively with the Catholic Church.

I can understand how they see this teaching, and how maybe they are somewhat offended. After trying to explain what the document does NOT mean (which is almost as important as what it does mean), I just had to accept their reaction. How many times does Our Lord talk about how he came to set one against another, how the Cross is a scandal to the Jews and folly to the Greeks, how anyone who does not hate his own brother cannot be his disciple. There comes a point where we just have to accept the "scandal" of the faith, and not try to hide or soften it (but still presenting it with charity and understanding).

As far as the family thing, I think that family members are probably the least likely be the cause of someone's conversion. Even Our Lord was not accepted as a prophet in his hometown (Mark 6:4). The best thing a family member can do is be a positive witness with their lives, and be there on a personal level. That's a seed that hopefully someone else can water.[/quote]
Right on.

(I was going to elaborate, but then I realized I was just echoing everything you said. :mellow: )

Posted

[quote]Doing apologetics is so much easier when there aren't real people you love on the other end.[/quote]

well era stole my comment about Jesus not being accepted by his closest family and friends, but its really true. my family is catholic and its still impossible to talk about the Church, because they see me as being too legalistic, and "know-it-all" about Church teaching (everyone knows how scrupulous it is to go to Mass on Holy Days of Obligation :rolleyes: :P:)

so i feel ya, terra, i do :sadwalk:

Posted

I still can't figure out why everybody is so offended when the Pope says this. The Catholic Church has always taught this, I'm not sure why its becoming so offensive all of a sudden.

Muslims get up in American mosques every Friday and chant "death to America" and no one cares. The Pope says all religions are inferior to Catholicism and suddenly we get all wound up about it. Anti-Catholicism is the last acceptable form of discrimination in America.

Posted

Yeah, I thought it was interesting that Protestant churches think it's okay to think that we're all going to burn in fiery damnation for all of eternity by virtue of our being Catholic, but raise such an outcry over this document. I haven't read it all, but it doesn't sound like we're saying THEY'RE all going to burn in eternal hellfire. At least we're not being hostile.

As far as evangelizing family...yeah. I have to say you're right. The worst part for me is that my mom not only doesn't understand why I find it necessary to go to daily Mass (though she's accepted it over the years), but she herself is more of a liberal Catholic...she scoffs at the idea of orthodoxy, which she calls "blind obedience," and engages in all sorts of new age-y things like enneagrams and won't hear any arguments against them. I think though that I might have broken through at least one wall by getting her to understand that it's both out of deep love for her and for God that I insist on calling her out (as charitably as I can) and asking her to listen to me. I think it also helps that I'm working toward a theology degree and she's finally able to recognize that her daughter might know more about something than she does, since age doesn't necessarily bring absolute knowledge. (It's a common Korean belief, heh. It's completely unacceptable in Korean culture to ever question an elder.)

I think that's vital...even though in the back of their minds they know we say these things out of love for them and not for winning arguments, they can forget in the heat of an argument, and so it's important to press the point repeatedly, that it's deep love for God and the individual that drives us to bring up this topic that brings both parties pain so often.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1328012' date='Jul 14 2007, 01:37 AM']I still can't figure out why everybody is so offended when the Pope says this. The Catholic Church has always taught this, I'm not sure why its becoming so offensive all of a sudden.

Muslims get up in American mosques every Friday and chant "death to America" and no one cares. The Pope says all religions are inferior to Catholicism and suddenly we get all wound up about it. Anti-Catholicism is the last acceptable form of discrimination in America.[/quote]
speaking for my Dad, he's [i]never[/i] been a fan of the teaching, but this brings it to the forefront as an issue. It's the re-assertion that's galling.

And I was not aware that chanting "death to America" was being chanted in American mosques every Friday. Care to provide some documentation?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1327768' date='Jul 13 2007, 11:01 PM']I had an epiphany tonight when talking with my Protestant father about the latest Vatican document, then one that says he doesn't attend a church and that his ecclesial community doesn't provide a means of salvation. The epiphany was that while this document does provide a great starting point for actual ecumenical dialogue, it will mean a lot of very difficult, very emotional conversations from here on out for people like me who have families and close friends who don't like being told that what they believe is wrong.

Dad sees this definition as being arrogant, and sees no Scriptural support for the importance of apostolic succession. I think, though, that the objection is really more emotional than logical. He staked a lot on being right about Christianity, and shaking a foundational belief about the structure of that faith is hard to deal with. He kept saying he doesn't see much importance in the concept of apostolic tradition, and I finally whipped out Paul's exhortation that believers not accept a gospel other than that taught by Paul or the apostles. Then he brought up the fact that many Catholics over the centuries have preached heretical gospels ... and when I replied that there's a difference between someone who's Catholic preaching a heretical gospel and the church binding believers with a heretical gospel. Then he said we had to stop talking about it. Sigh.

Doing apologetics is so much easier when there aren't real people you love on the other end. Hopefully, though, we'll be able to talk about it at some point in the future, and I can gently bring up more support for apostolic succession, and the primacy of the See of Peter.

If y'all think about it, pray for me and others like me who are going to be on the front lines of defending these core Catholic beliefs, that we are gentle but firm in holding to truth.[/quote]
Yeah, it's definitely hard to do. I don't think that the document said that ecclesial communities don't have means to salvation, but rather that it said they don't have [i]all[/i] the means to salvation, which usually translates into sacraments. They have Baptism, of course, which they don't need apostolic succession for, and their intention is more often than not very similar to Catholic intention. I don't think the document was meaning to say quite what a lot of people are trying to make it say.

It's going to be hard for me, too. I just took a job in a mostly Protestant part of the country and most of my youth have Protestant friends. Some of them are dating Protestants. You get the picture.

I think that clarification is the best service we can render now. So many people have misunderstandings of the Church. We can either shoot down their arguments (regardless of whether or not their arguments are even truly opposed to Catholicism) or we can show that their arguments aren't really against the Church's true teaching (which is often the case). In this case, I wouldn't start by arguing about who does or does not have the full means of salvation, apostolic succession, or anything like that...I would start by clarifying that the document isn't saying that non-Catholics are all damned or that their belief systems are entirely wrong, it's just saying that they're missing something. Most Protestants, I think, would be willing to admit that their ecclesial communities aren't entirely accurate (ELCA: "our community pays for abortions for female pastors," Presbyterian: "our community is run by elders who often disagree," etc.). For Protestants, afterall, there isn't always a clear right or wrong in terms of doctrine...many things are up for opinion. They wouldn't object so much to the notion that they are missing some things nearly so much as they would object to the Catholic Church's claim to have it all. So after clarifying that the Church is saying that they are missing some things, I wouldn't jump strait to the Church's claims about herself...rather, I would talk about how Christ did have it all right and the early Church did have it all right...once they realize that someone actually [i]is[/i] supposed to have it all right, they might be more willing to look at the Catholic Church and consider that we might be the ones who do have it all right.

At least, that would be my strategy.

Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1327909' date='Jul 14 2007, 02:07 AM']my family is catholic and its still impossible to talk about the Church, because they see me as being too legalistic, and "know-it-all" about Church teaching (everyone knows how scrupulous it is to go to Mass on Holy Days of Obligation :rolleyes: :P:)[/quote]


[quote name='jiyoung' post='1328056' date='Jul 14 2007, 04:41 AM']The worst part for me is that my mom not only doesn't understand why I find it necessary to go to daily Mass (though she's accepted it over the years), but she herself is more of a liberal Catholic...she scoffs at the idea of orthodoxy, which she calls "blind obedience," and engages in all sorts of new age-y things like enneagrams and won't hear any arguments against them.[/quote]

Sounds like we're in the same boat here. My mother, God bless her soul, is becoming more and more Protestant every day. She reads Protestant books (despite the fact that I have offered and continue to suggest many awesome, touching Catholic books), watches Protestant TV (despite the fact that she has access to EWTN) and attends Protestant retreats/conferences, most notably the Women of Faith thing (despite the fact that our home parish offers a few beautiful retreats for parents and older-folk like her). She routinely bashes or outright refuses to agree with Church teachings such as the existence of purgatory, the need for (and Biblical support of) the Sacrament of Reconciliation, and the need for a Pope. When I try to point out the facts and give her information (or books to read on the subject), she usually retreats to the "I'm such-and-such years old...I've been Catholic longer than you've been alive...I went to Catholic school (taught by Jesuits... :idontknow: )...I know the answers." It's so sad because, yes, she loves Jesus so much, but yet she doesn't realize that she is settling for a less-than-perfect relationship with Him. She doesn't see that it is only in the Catholic Church that she will be able to live fully and totally in the love He has planned for His children, with the Sacraments, with Mass, with Our Lady.

My father is a historian who, though he is making strides in the right direction, still falls prey to the minimalist attitude of Catholicism and Christianity, breaking the religion down to "love thy neighbor" and then saying that all other religions have that within them. He also has a lot of beef with the Church because of the horrific things that some of her members have done throughout history. Despite all of this, though, He doesn't have any doctrinal-beefs with the Church and continues to love the Sacraments, particularly the Sacrament of Reconciliation.

We must continue to pray for the conversion of our family members. It should be the first thing on our to-do list of prayers.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1327768' date='Jul 14 2007, 05:01 AM']I had an epiphany tonight when talking with my Protestant father about the latest Vatican document, then one that says he doesn't attend a church and that his ecclesial community doesn't provide a means of salvation. The epiphany was that while this document does provide a great starting point for actual ecumenical dialogue, it will mean a lot of very difficult, very emotional conversations from here on out for people like me who have families and close friends who don't like being told that what they believe is wrong.

Dad sees this definition as being arrogant, and sees no Scriptural support for the importance of apostolic succession. I think, though, that the objection is really more emotional than logical. He staked a lot on being right about Christianity, and shaking a foundational belief about the structure of that faith is hard to deal with. He kept saying he doesn't see much importance in the concept of apostolic tradition, and I finally whipped out Paul's exhortation that believers not accept a gospel other than that taught by Paul or the apostles. Then he brought up the fact that many Catholics over the centuries have preached heretical gospels ... and when I replied that there's a difference between someone who's Catholic preaching a heretical gospel and the church binding believers with a heretical gospel. Then he said we had to stop talking about it. Sigh.

Doing apologetics is so much easier when there aren't real people you love on the other end. Hopefully, though, we'll be able to talk about it at some point in the future, and I can gently bring up more support for apostolic succession, and the primacy of the See of Peter.

If y'all think about it, pray for me and others like me who are going to be on the front lines of defending these core Catholic beliefs, that we are gentle but firm in holding to truth.[/quote]

You have my prayers. Sounds like me & my sister, in a way. At least, she's rather upset by the document, though I trained to explain it to her. So we keep praying. :)

I think kujo said it best: [quote]We must continue to pray for the conversion of our family members. It should be the first thing on our to-do list of prayers.[/quote]

Posted

The second reading in the Office of Readings in the Liturgy of the Hours for Tuesday had this to offer. This fits right in with the topic . . . it is amazing how many times I've found readings that have immediate applicability

Tuesday 14th Week of Ordinary Time
July 10, 2007

Reading From a discourse on the psalms by Saint Augustine, bishop

[color="#0000FF"][center]Whether they like it or not, those who are outside the church are our brothers[/center][/color]

We entreat you, brothers, as earnestly as we are able, to have charity, not only for one another, but also for those who are outside the Church. Of these some are still pagans, who have not yet made an act of faith in Christ. Others are separated, insofar as they are joined with us in professing faith in Christ, our head, but are yet divided from the unity of his body. My friends, we must grieve over these as over our brothers; and they will only cease to be so when they no longer say [i]our Father[/i].
The prophet refers to some men saying: When they say to you: [i]You are not our brothers, you are to tell them: You are our brothers[/i]. Consider whom he intended by these words. Were they the pagans? Hardly; for nowhere either in Scripture or in our traditional manner of speaking do we find them called our brothers. Nor could it refer to the Jews, who do not believe in Christ. Read Saint Paul and you will see that when he speaks of “brothers”, without any qualification, he refers always to Christians. For example, he says: [i]Why do you judge your brother or why do you despise your brother?[/i] And again: [i]You perform iniquity and common fraud, and this against your brothers. [/i]
Those then who tell us: [i]You are not our brothers[/i], are saying that we are pagans. That is why they want to baptise us again, claiming that we do not have what they can give. Hence their error of denying that we are their brothers. Why then did the prophet tell us: Say to them: [i]You are our brothers?[/i] It is because we acknowledge in them that which we do not repeat. By not recognising our baptism, they deny that we are their brothers; on the other hand, when we do not repeat their baptism but acknowledge it to be our own, we are saying to them: [i]You are our brothers. [/i]
If they say, “Why do you seek us? What do you want of us?” we should reply: [i]You are our brothers[/i]. They may say, “Leave us alone. We have nothing to do with you”. But we have everything to do with you, for we are one in our belief in Christ; and so we should be in one body, under one head.
And so, dear brothers, we entreat you on their behalf, in the name of the very source of our love, by whose milk we are nourished, and whose bread is our strength, in the name of Christ our Lord and his gentle love. For it is time now for us to show them great love and abundant compassion by praying to God for them. May he one day give them a clear mind to repent and to realise that they have nothing now but the sickness of their hatred, and the stronger they think they are, the weaker they become. We entreat you then to pray for them, for they are weak, given to the wisdom of the flesh, to fleshly and carnal things, but yet they are our brothers. They celebrate the same sacraments as we, not indeed with us, but still the same. They respond with the same Amen, not with us, but still the same. And so pour out your hearts for them in prayer to God.

geetarplayer
Posted

Tonight, while a bunch of my friends got together to discuss this document about the one true Church, my friend's Protestant girlfriend got a counter-attack message from the local [url="http://www.calvarychapel.com/"]Calvary Chapel[/url] about how the Church is really all Christians everywhere and something about "how Christ intended the Church to be", whatever that means.

I think it's pretty much over between him and her. They've been back and forth about this for a while.

-Mark

Posted

If the authority of the Church is in question, so is the authority of the documents promulgated by the Church.

IOW, if the Catholic Church is not the final arbiter and teacher of the Christian Faith, then the Bible is suspect too.

The Scripture proceeds [i]from[/i] the Church, not the other way around.

Posted

[quote name='journeyman' post='1328547' date='Jul 14 2007, 03:17 PM']The second reading in the Office of Readings in the Liturgy of the Hours for Tuesday had this to offer. This fits right in with the topic . . . it is amazing how many times I've found readings that have immediate applicability

Tuesday 14th Week of Ordinary Time
July 10, 2007

Reading From a discourse on the psalms by Saint Augustine, bishop

[color="#0000FF"][center]Whether they like it or not, those who are outside the church are our brothers[/center][/color]

We entreat you, brothers, as earnestly as we are able, to have charity, not only for one another, but also for those who are outside the Church. Of these some are still pagans, who have not yet made an act of faith in Christ. Others are separated, insofar as they are joined with us in professing faith in Christ, our head, but are yet divided from the unity of his body. My friends, we must grieve over these as over our brothers; and they will only cease to be so when they no longer say [i]our Father[/i].
The prophet refers to some men saying: When they say to you: [i]You are not our brothers, you are to tell them: You are our brothers[/i]. Consider whom he intended by these words. Were they the pagans? Hardly; for nowhere either in Scripture or in our traditional manner of speaking do we find them called our brothers. Nor could it refer to the Jews, who do not believe in Christ. Read Saint Paul and you will see that when he speaks of “brothers”, without any qualification, he refers always to Christians. For example, he says: [i]Why do you judge your brother or why do you despise your brother?[/i] And again: [i]You perform iniquity and common fraud, and this against your brothers. [/i]
Those then who tell us: [i]You are not our brothers[/i], are saying that we are pagans. That is why they want to baptise us again, claiming that we do not have what they can give. Hence their error of denying that we are their brothers. Why then did the prophet tell us: Say to them: [i]You are our brothers?[/i] It is because we acknowledge in them that which we do not repeat. By not recognising our baptism, they deny that we are their brothers; on the other hand, when we do not repeat their baptism but acknowledge it to be our own, we are saying to them: [i]You are our brothers. [/i]
If they say, “Why do you seek us? What do you want of us?” we should reply: [i]You are our brothers[/i]. They may say, “Leave us alone. We have nothing to do with you”. But we have everything to do with you, for we are one in our belief in Christ; and so we should be in one body, under one head.
And so, dear brothers, we entreat you on their behalf, in the name of the very source of our love, by whose milk we are nourished, and whose bread is our strength, in the name of Christ our Lord and his gentle love. For it is time now for us to show them great love and abundant compassion by praying to God for them. May he one day give them a clear mind to repent and to realise that they have nothing now but the sickness of their hatred, and the stronger they think they are, the weaker they become. We entreat you then to pray for them, for they are weak, given to the wisdom of the flesh, to fleshly and carnal things, but yet they are our brothers. They celebrate the same sacraments as we, not indeed with us, but still the same. They respond with the same Amen, not with us, but still the same. And so pour out your hearts for them in prayer to God.[/quote]
Wow ... you know, the more I read of the early fathers, esp. Augustine, the more I realize that there is nothing new under the sun. We fight the same battles now that our forefathers fought.

geetarplayer
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1329288' date='Jul 15 2007, 11:32 AM']Wow ... you know, the more I read of the early fathers, esp. Augustine, the more I realize that there is nothing new under the sun. We fight the same battles now that our forefathers fought.[/quote]
You said it!

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1329288' date='Jul 15 2007, 09:32 AM']Wow ... you know, the more I read of the early fathers, esp. Augustine, the more I realize that there is nothing new under the sun. We fight the same battles now that our forefathers fought.[/quote]

Yeah, go figure

I suspect that particular writing came out of the period of the Donatist heresy . . . from what I remember, they refused to recognize the Catholic sacraments - Augustine, however, recognized theirs under the theory that it was the sacrament that had efficacy, not the person performing it . . . but I'm a little hazy on heresies and how they were resolved

George Santayana:

'Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.'
Life of Reason, Reason in Common Sense, Scribner's, 1905, page 284"

all the more reason for good catechesis . . .

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1327768' date='Jul 13 2007, 11:01 PM']I had an epiphany tonight when talking with my Protestant father about the latest Vatican document, then one that says he doesn't attend a church and that his ecclesial community doesn't provide a means of salvation. The epiphany was that while this document does provide a great starting point for actual ecumenical dialogue, it will mean a lot of very difficult, very emotional conversations from here on out for people like me who have families and close friends who don't like being told that what they believe is wrong.

Dad sees this definition as being arrogant, and sees no Scriptural support for the importance of apostolic succession. I think, though, that the objection is really more emotional than logical. He staked a lot on being right about Christianity, and shaking a foundational belief about the structure of that faith is hard to deal with. He kept saying he doesn't see much importance in the concept of apostolic tradition, and I finally whipped out Paul's exhortation that believers not accept a gospel other than that taught by Paul or the apostles. Then he brought up the fact that many Catholics over the centuries have preached heretical gospels ... and when I replied that there's a difference between someone who's Catholic preaching a heretical gospel and the church binding believers with a heretical gospel. Then he said we had to stop talking about it. Sigh.

Doing apologetics is so much easier when there aren't real people you love on the other end. Hopefully, though, we'll be able to talk about it at some point in the future, and I can gently bring up more support for apostolic succession, and the primacy of the See of Peter.

If y'all think about it, pray for me and others like me who are going to be on the front lines of defending these core Catholic beliefs, that we are gentle but firm in holding to truth.[/quote]
:clap:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...