N/A Gone Posted July 15, 2007 Posted July 15, 2007 Im hoping I catch some of the experts here, but I have been in a discussion on a popular sports forum about the letter from the vatican and the ecclesiological aspects of it. A guy who is greek orthodox joined in and we have had some fruitful talks, but there was something he wrote that I really dont know how to respond. [quote]You are right in saying that the split between the Roman Catholic and the Eastern Orthodox churches is largely political. I believe there are some differences in worship as well but I am not very well versed in the exact traditions of the Roman Catholic church, however there isn't that gulf that there is between the "old" Christian denominations and Protestantism, I think alot of that is the importance that we place on the tradition of the church, as you said the Church was not able to be a public organisation at first so not everything is in the Bible. The Bible itself was written by the same men who theoretically, all Orthodox and Roman Catholic people could trace their "spiritual ancestry" back to. Anyway getting back on track, I think the political nature of the early Church can't be assumed away when examing issues like the importance of the Holy See vis a vis the Ecumenical Patriarchate. Constantinople was not in existence at the time the Church began, but (I have read this somewhere, but cannot find the source, if I come across it I will quote it) when St Constantine founded New Rome (Constantinople) it was meant to replace Rome and to become a capital for the Christian Empire untainted by Rome's pagan past. It is therefore not a stretch to conlude that Constantinople was to be the premier position. A "New Rome" in every sense of the word. Also my understanding (and how I have always seen this) is that the Orthodox do not reject the Pope or the Holy See, but they do acknowledge the schism, ie. They do recognise the Pope as one of the Patriarchs in a theoretical sense but not in a practical sense since this schism. Also it is difficult to talk about who split from who in the early days of the Church and the Christian Empire, after all there were many disagreements in the early days (Arianism, Iconoclasm etc) issues were solved by the Ecumenical Council's but they required all the Patriarchs to be involved when the main Patriarchs split from themselves who can determine who has strayed from the true path? Anyway, my understaning and my study of the history is incomplete, so I am sure you can raise some ideas I was unaware of or had not even thought of.[/quote] Any help with how to respond would be great. I love patristics, so I spend time reading that. And being a former protestant my research is on those relations. So I am raw in the Eastern/Western issues.
adt6247 Posted July 16, 2007 Posted July 16, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1330003' date='Jul 15 2007, 08:33 PM']Constantinople was not in existence at the time the Church began, but (I have read this somewhere, but cannot find the source, if I come across it I will quote it) when St Constantine founded New Rome (Constantinople) it was meant to replace Rome and to become a capital for the Christian Empire untainted by Rome's pagan past. It is therefore not a stretch to conlude that Constantinople was to be the premier position. A "New Rome" in every sense of the word.[/quote] Whether or not it was the new capital of the Roman empire, and even if Constantine wished it to replace Rome, the authority above the other patriarchates associated with the See of Rome is not because it is Rome, but because it is the See of Peter and Paul. Peter was first of the apostles because Christ made him so. When the papacy moved to France, the pope still held the See of Peter, even though he was not physically in Rome. No see can ever outrank the See of Peter.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now