Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[img]http://bp1.blogger.com/_X6SfstKQluk/RYl6Z2aPs4I/AAAAAAAAAAY/8hWMUxrkot4/s320/PCannunciation.jpg[/img]

Posted (edited)

sigh...get with the Holy Spirit program,Fr Brandolini.....well, cant please everyone
-------------
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - A decree by Pope Benedict allowing priests to say the old Latin Mass more frequently has drawn criticism within Catholic and Jewish ranks, with one Italian bishop saying he was "in mourning".

The decree, a nod to traditionalists which the Pope said was meant to heal divisions within the Church, was regarded by some as a blow to reforms introduced in the 1960s that promoted mass in local languages and understanding with non-Catholics.

"[b]I can't fight back the tears. This is the saddest moment in my life as a man, priest and bishop," [u]Luca Brandolini, of the liturgy commission of the Italian bishops' conference,[/u] told Rome daily La Repubblica in an interview on Sunday.

"It's a day of mourning, not just for me but for the many people who worked for the Second Vatican Council. A reform for which many people worked, with great sacrifice and only inspired by the desire to renew the Church, has now been cancelled."[/b]

The Pope, in a letter to bishops on Saturday, rejected criticism that his move could split Catholics and reverse the reforms of the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965).

Some Jewish leaders have sharply criticised the decree, which revives a passage from the old Latin prayer book for Good Friday calling for Jews to be converted. Others, however, took a more measured tone and called for clarification.

"I think there are those who have interpreted it in an extremely alarmist fashion," Rabbi David Rosen of the American Jewish Committee (AJC) told Reuters.

"That doesn't mean that there aren't things that need clarification but there is no question of Pope Benedict's commitment to respectful relations with the Jewish people."

(Additional reporting by Tom Heneghan in Paris, Avida Landau in Jerusalem)

Edited by EJames
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1331975' date='Jul 17 2007, 01:20 AM']Some further tidbits to add to the above post:
[i]"It would be false to identify this liturgical renewal with the reform of rites decided on by Vatican II."[/i] - Fr. Joseph Gelineau, Demain la liturgie

[i]“The preconciliar liturgical movement as well as the manifest intentions of Sacrosanctum Concilium have in large part been frustrated by powerful contrary forces, which could be described as bureaucratic, philistine and secularist...The effect has been to deprive the Catholic people of much of their liturgical heritage...The impoverishment of our liturgy after the Council is a fact not yet sufficiently admitted or understood, to which the necessary response must be a revival of the liturgical movement and the initiation of a cycle of reflection and reform.”[/i] - The Oxford Declaration
[i]"Unless we are blind, we must even state bluntly that what we see looks less like the hoped-for regeneration of Catholicism than its accelerated decomposition."[/i] - Fr. Louis Bouyer (yes, the celebrated theologian)
[i]"The Liturgical Reform has given origin to many abuses and led in a certain way to the disappearance of the respect due to the sacred."[/i] - Cardinal Edouard Gagnon, Offerten Situng - Roemisches, nov.dez. 1993, p. 35
"Liturgy degenerates into a 'show,' where one is tempted to make religion interesting with the help of silly changes in fashion...with momentary successes for the group of liturgical fabricators" - Cardinal Ratzinger, Introduction to Reform of the Roman Liturgy
[i]"The origin of the ailments of today's Church is in the rupture which was effected, after the Council, with the previous liturgical tradition."[/i] - Domenico Bartolucci[/quote]
[img]http://www.hotlinkfiles.com/files/139648_82dzc/Organic+Mass+Carton.jpg[/img]

Posted

From Fr Z's blog:

[quote]2003
[img]http://www.wdtprs.com/images/07_03_06_red_mater_before.JPG[/img]

2007
[img]http://www.wdtprs.com/images/07_03_06_red_mater_after.JPG[/img][/quote]

Booya!


[url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2007/07/cns-v-cwn-on-benedict-xvi-using-older-mass-in-private/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2007/07/cns-v-cwn-o...ass-in-private/[/url]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

More quotes for you guys. I'll try to create an organic progression. ;)

[quote]"That sound tradition may be retained, and yet the way remain open to legitimate progress, careful investigation is always to be made into each part of the liturgy which is to be revised. This investigation should be theological, historical, and pastoral. Also the general laws governing the structure and meaning of the liturgy must be studied in conjunction with the experience derived from recent liturgical reforms and from the indults conceded to various places. Finally, there must be no innovations unless the good of the Church genuinely and certainly requires them; and care must be taken that any new forms adopted should in some way grow organically from forms already existing."
Sacrosanctum Concilium 23


The authoritative commentary on Sacrosanctum Concilium elucidates this paragraph thus.

"Reforms should correspond to the traditional laws of the structure and mind of the Liturgy. They should flow organically from the forms or rites which already exist, lest they be so different from present forms that they resemble new creations... Innovations should be such as required by a true and certain usefulness for the Church lest, from mere love of novelty, sacred rites venerated and used for centuries by our forefathers be needlessly rejected or the Sacred Liturgy be treated as if it were merely a field for experimentation."
The Commentary on the Constitution and on the Instruction on the Sacred Liturgy, Benzinger Brothers, New York

1965, pp. 87-88[/quote]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote]“What we previously knew only in theory has become for us a practical experience: the Church stands and falls with the Liturgy. When the adoration of the divine Trinity declines, when the faith is no longer appears in its fullness in the Liturgy of the Church, when man's words, his thoughts, his intentions are suffocating him, then faith will have lost the place where it is expressed and where it dwells. For that reason, the true celebration of the Sacred Liturgy is the centre of any renewal of the Church whatever.” – Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger

"A sizeable party of Catholic liturgists seems to have practically arrived at the conclusion that Luther, rather than Trent, was substantially right in the sixteenth century debate...one can detect much the same position in the post-conciliar discussions on the priesthood...[He refers also to theologians who share Luther’s opinion that it is] "the most appalling horror and a damnable impiety to speak of the sacrifice of the Mass....
It is only against this background of the effective denial of the authority of Trent, that the bitterness of the struggle against allowing the celebration of Mass according to the 1962 Missal, after the liturgical reform, can be understood. The possibility of so celebrating constitutes the strongest, and thus (for them) the most intolerable contradiction of the opinion of those who believe that the faith in the Eucharist formulated by Trent has lost its value....
The serious nature of these theories comes from the fact that frequently they pass immediately into practice. The thesis according to which it is the community itself which is the subject of the Liturgy, serves as an authorisation to manipulate the Liturgy according to each individual’s understanding of it. So-called new discoveries and the forms which follow from them, are diffused with an astonishing rapidity and with a degree of conformity which has long ceased to exist where the norms of ecclesiastical authority are concerned. Theories, in the area of the Liturgy, are transformed rapidly today into practice, and practice, in turn, creates or destroys ways of behaving and thinking....Trent did not make a mistake, it leant for support on the solid foundation of the Tradition of the Church. It remains a trustworthy standard"
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, July 2001 Fontgombault Liturgical Conference

"One thing should be clear: the Liturgy must not be a terrain for experimenting with theological hypotheses. Too rapidly, in these last decades, the ideas of experts have entered into liturgical practice, often also by-passing ecclesiastical authority, through the channel of commissions which have been able to diffuse at an international level their “consensus of the moment”, and practically turn it into laws for liturgical activity. The Liturgy derives its greatness from what it is, not from what we make of it. Our participation is, of course, necessary, but as a means of inserting ourselves humbly into the spirit of the Liturgy, and of serving Him Who is the true subject of the Liturgy: Jesus Christ. The Liturgy is not an expression of the consciousness of a community which, in any case, is diffuse and changing. It is revelation received in faith ind prayer, and its measure is consequently the faith of the Church, in which revelation is received."
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, July 2001 Fontgombault Liturgical Conference

"It seems to me indispensable to continue to offer the opportunity to celebrate according to the old Missal, as a sign of the enduring identity of the Church. This is for me the basic reason: what was up until 1969 the Liturgy of the Church, for all of us the most holy thing there was, can not become after 1969 – with incredibly positivistic decision – the most unacceptable thing. If we want to be credible, even with being modern as a slogan, we absolutely have to recognise that what was fundamental before 1969 remains fundamental afterwards: the realm of the sacral is the same, the Liturgy is the same...this Missal of the Church should offer a point of reference, and should become a refuge for those faithful who, in their own parish, no longer find a Liturgy genuinely celebrated in accordance with the texts authorised by the Church. There is no doubt, on the one hand, that a venerable rite such as the Roman rite in use up to 1969 is a rite of the Church, it belongs to the Church, is one of the treasures of the Church, and ought therefore to be preserved in the Church."
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, July 2001 Fontgombault Liturgical Conference


"In my view there can be no doubt that a Liturgy of the Mass which has no offertory, with a multiplicity of Eucharistic Prayers and the almost complete abolition of use of the Roman canon, with a different calendar – with, for example, the abolition of the pre-Lenten period (from Septuagesima onward) – with a different set of readings from Sacred Scripture – that such a Liturgy, as I say, is a different rite; especially if we consider not only the origin but the appearance of the two liturgies: the orientation of the priest, the liturgical language, etc. An Orthodox friend told me that he finds more similarity between the old Roman Mass and his own Liturgy, than between that and the Masses usually celebrated today. Given the fact of these two rites, then the abolition of the old Roman rite would, as a matter of course, be illegitimate even if not illegal. As Cardinal Ratzinger has shown us, in its whole history the Church has never abolished a legitimate rite which was hallowed by Tradition....Every Catholic Christian has the right to fight for a form of prayer hallowed by his ancestors, by many saints, and by the entire Church for centuries...The hostility of some of the advocates of the new rite towards the old is the strongest argument in favour of maintaining it."
Professor Robert Spaemann, July 2001 Fontgombault Liturgical Conference[/quote]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote]"We must be far more resolute than heretofore in opposing rationalistic relativism, confusing claptrap and pastoral infantilism. These things degrade the Liturgy to the level of a parish tea party and the intelligibility of a popular newspaper. With this in mind we shall also have to examine the reforms already carried out..."
Spoken in 1975 and cited in The Ratzinger Report, p. 121

"Since I wrote those lines [cited above], other aspects which should have been guarded have been neglected; many treasures that were still intact have been squandered away."
The Ratzinger Report, p. 121


"The Liturgical Movement had in fact been attempting...to teach us to understand the Liturgy as a living network of tradition that had taken concrete form, that cannot be torn apart into little pieces, but that has to be seen and experienced as a living whole. Anyone who, like me, was moved by this perception in the time of the Liturgical Movement on the eve of the Second Vatican Council can only stand, deeply sorrowing, before the ruins of the very things they were concerned for."
Cardinal Ratzinger, Preface to Alcuin Reid's "The Organic Development of the Liturgy", Ignatius Press, 2005, p. 11.


"The question arises: Why has the implementation of the Council, in large parts of the Church, thus far been so difficult? Well, it all depends on the correct interpretation of the Council or - as we would say today - on its proper hermeneutics, the correct key to its interpretation and application. The problems in its implementation arose from the fact that two contrary hermeneutics came face to face and quarrelled with each other. One caused confusion, the other, silently but more and more visibly, bore and is bearing fruit.
On the one hand, there is an interpretation that I would call "a hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture"; it has frequently availed itself of the sympathies of the mass media, and also one trend of modern theology. On the other, there is the "hermeneutic of reform", of renewal in the continuity of the one subject-Church which the Lord has given to us. She is a subject which increases in time and develops, yet always remaining the same, the one subject of the journeying People of God. The hermeneutic of discontinuity risks ending in a split between the pre-conciliar Church and the post-conciliar Church."
Pope Benedict XVI, Address to the Roman Curia, December 22, 2005[/quote]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote]"In various parts of the Church abuses have occurred, leading to confusion with regard to sound faith and Catholic doctrine concerning this wonderful sacrament. At times one encounters an extremely reductive understanding of the Eucharistic mystery. Stripped of its sacrificial meaning, it is celebrated as if it were simply a fraternal banquet. Furthermore, the necessity of the ministerial priesthood, grounded in apostolic succession, is at times obscured and the sacramental nature of the Eucharist is reduced to its mere effectiveness as a form of proclamation. This has led here and there to ecumenical initiatives which, albeit well-intentioned, indulge in Eucharistic practices contrary to the discipline by which the Church expresses her faith. How can we not express profound grief at all this? The Eucharist is too great a gift to tolerate ambiguity and depreciation.
It is my hope that the present Encyclical Letter will effectively help to banish the dark clouds of unacceptable doctrine and practice, so that the Eucharist will continue to shine forth in all its radiant mystery."
Pope John Paul II, Ecclesia de Eucharistia, no. 10

"The official reform, however, poses a larger question. For if the Council's principles of reform were not faithfully respected by the Consilium established to implement them, or indeed by the liturgical books subsequently promulgated, we do not need simply to correct abuses of the modern rites, we also need to look again at the reform that yielded those rites."
Alcuin Reid, "Looking Again at the Liturgical Reform", April 19, 2006

"The new Missal is not so satisfactory. It has an artificial ring about it, as if scholars had first mapped it out in the abstract, and then gone to work with scissors and paste in a Roman parlour to produce a live organism. But do living organisms ever follow a neat scientific pattern?"
Dame Felicitas Corrigan, A Voice For All Time, p. 240, 1978


"Until recent decades, ready obedience to all ecclesiastical authority was a distinctive feature of Catholic life. Very many monks and nuns, and indeed secular clergy and lay faithful, accepted the liturgical reforms following the Council in this spirit of obedience in spite of misgivings or even grave concerns. Whilst it is most probably true that such fearless, prompt and passionate obedience was motivated by virtue, it may also be true that the strength of this habit deafened our ears to the equivalent of the cry of the Lord God heard by Abraham when he was about to sacrifice his beloved son: "Do not lay your hand on the lad or do anything to him" (Genesis 22:12). Yet, even if this is true, in looking again at the liturgical reform I submit that we must be most sensitive, for exercising obedience in important matters so often involves profound suffering, and whether or not those who commanded such obedience were right to do so, and whether or not is should have been opposed, those who gave it did so in good faith, and their fidelity must be respected.
...
Some may see this policy as a reversal of the liturgical 'creativity' that was supposedly part of the Council's legitimate heritage in the field of liturgical reform. But in truth, beyond the options -- rather permissive options in some places -- the modern Roman Liturgy has never been a 'DIY' kit for liturgical planners and committees, regardless of what many, many professional liturgists have proliferated in recent decades. Rubrics still exist and they are still to be followed, for they guard the Church's most sacred mysteries which we celebrate in the Sacred Liturgy and they protect each of us from the exigencies and frailties of our clergy and of liturgy planners whose initiatives should not eclipse Him whom we worship."
Alcuin Reid, "Looking Again at the Liturgical Reform", April 19, 2006


"The Mass is the most solemn action of the sacred liturgy, which is itself the public worship of the Church. "Liturgy", says Pope John Paul II, "is never anyone's private property, be it of the celebrant or of the community in which the mysteries are celebrated. Priests who faithfully celebrate Mass according to the liturgical norms, and communities which conform to those norms, quietly but eloquently demonstrate their love for the Church" (Eccl. de Euch., 52). At the direction of Pope John Paul II, the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, in collaboration with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, issued the Instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum in March 2004 "precisely to bring out more clearly this deeper meaning of liturgical norms" (Eccl. de Euch., 52). It follows that individuals, whether they be priests or lay faithful, are not free to add or subtract any details in the approved rites of the celebration of the Holy Eucharist (cf Sacrosanctum Concilium, 22). A do-it-yourself mentality, an attitude of nobody-will-tell-me-what-to-do, or a defiant sting of if-you-do-not-like-my-Mass-you-can-go-to-another-parish, is not only against sound theology and ecclesiology, but also offends against common sense. Unfortunately, sometimes common sense is not very common, when we see a priest ignoring liturgical rules and installing creativity ­ in his case personal idiosyncracy ­ as the guide to the celebration of Holy Mass. Our faith guides us and our love of Jesus and of his Church safeguards us from taking such unwholesome liberties. Aware that we are only ministers, not masters of the mysteries of Christ (cf I Cor 4:1), we follow the approved liturgical books so that the people of God are respected and their faith nourished, and so that God is honoured and the Church is gradually being built up."
Cardinal Arinze, Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments, April 3, 2006[/quote]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

And finally..

[quote]"At this point, I believe we need a preliminary evaluation of what, in a certain sense, has deviated the process of post-conciliar and especially liturgical reform. The Council was a marvelous opportunity to prepare the Church for what awaited her in the contemporary world. Her spiritual renewal and overall reinvigoration could have become the impetus for a new epoch of evangelization. Modern developments offered immense opportunities; but things went differently. One wonders why it is that the Church was unable to make the most of the fruits of the Council for a full reawakening of ecclesial faith. Indeed, people appeared who interpreted the Council documents as a justification for counter-reformist attitudes, that is, the attitudes of those who took the reform to be a relaxation of regulations, which only weakened the Church and took her backward. Pope Paul VI complained that certain people exploited one or other Council teaching to “impede evangelization”. (Evangelii Nuntiandi 80)
I think that the general problem was an erroneous idea of the purpose of the Council. Indeed, speaking of the conciliar reforms, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger says: “The [Council] Fathers wanted to update the faith, indeed, to present it with its full impact. Instead, people gradually formed the idea that the reform consisted merely of throwing out the ballast, in other words, of divesting it so that in the end the reform did not appear to radicalize the faith but to dilute it”. (Il Sale della Terra [Salt of the Earth], p. 86)
This erroneous attitude gave rise to theological schools which, by downplaying the importance of Tradition and the ecclesial Magisterium in theological direction and research, have advanced confusing opinions.
...
More dangerous was the emergence of an erroneous or only partially true Eucharistic theology that was not in keeping with the Church’s teaching. “Lex orandi” is “lex credendi”, as we well know. Therefore, seeing an alarming diminishment in spirituality and Eucharistic devotion, and their negative effects on the Christian faith and witness in our time, the pope, as Successor of Peter, exercising his role of “strengthening the brethren” (Lk 22:32), promulgated Ecclesia de Eucharistia to effectively dispel “the dark clouds of unacceptable doctrine and practice, so that the Eucharist will continue to shine forth in all its radiant mystery”. (n. 10)
Furthermore, the pope considered necessary “a more specific document, including prescriptions of a juridical nature, on this very important subject”. (ibid. 52) He entrusted this task to the Congregations for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments and for the Doctrine of the Faith. The document Redemptionis Sacramentum, which the pope approved on March 19, 2004, is the result of their important work. I believe that those who toiled to make it possible deserve to be congratulated. Of course, the document’s main purpose was not to rewrite all the liturgical norms nor to offer a compendium of doctrine or a compete evaluation of what has or has not been achieved thus far. It is a continuation of what the pope wrote in his encyclical letter Ecclesia de Eucharistia and therefore has a very precise aim: to reenforce discipline concerning the ways to celebrate the Eucharist and to safeguard the nobility and dignity of this sacrament."
Archbishop Malcolm Ranjith, Secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, L’Osservatore Romano, July 21, 2004

"In 2003 Father Thomas Kocic published a book, "The Reform of the Reform? A Liturgical Debate: Reform or Return" (Ignatius Press 2003), which contains a detailed study of the status quaestionis including contributions from Father Adian Nichols OP, Monsignor Peter Elliott, Father Brian Harrison and others. I recommend it to you.
Proposals include the wide use of Latin, that the Roman Canon once again becomes the (sole) Canon of the Mass of the Roman rite, the replacement of the current offertory prayers with ones having a clear sacrificial theology, the restoration of the proper prayers of each Mass to their unedited form, the promotion of silence in the Liturgy, the return of many of the ritual gestures abolished in the Mass, and the return to the ancient Christian practice of priest and people facing east for what we now call the Liturgy of the Eucharist. Each proposal could engender much discussion and ultimately our present Holy Father or one of his successors must decide whether they are to be implemented. Certainly each of them would contribute to a renewal of a distinctively Catholic liturgical spirit in our worship.
One in particular, I submit, would do this quite effectively: namely, returning the celebration of the Liturgy of the Eucharist at Mass ad orientem. This practice -- which instantly destroys the horizontal idiom of entertainment that has crept into our psychology of worship and which re-asserts the essential God-centered and contemplative aspects of Catholic worship -- is permitted by the modern liturgical books and requires no permission or further official reform to adopt. It can be and is successfully used with the modern vernacular rites. I challenge you seriously to consider it as a real possibility for liturgical renewal and reform in the twenty first century. To that end I highly recommend Father Michael Lang's recent study of the question -- which carries a foreword by Cardinal Ratzinger -- Turning Towards the Lord: Orientation in Liturgical Prayer."
Alcuin Reid, "Looking Again at the Liturgical Reform", April 19, 2006


"Forty years after the end of the Second Vatican Council [which the author considers "an unprecedented pastoral failure"], the succession of Benedict XVI to the Throne of Peter inaugurates, nolens volens, a phase of transition for the Church, that is to say a process of exiting from the atypical state in which this Council had placed Her."
Beyond Vatican II? The Church at a New Crossroads


"I think that it is true to say -- especially in respect of the Liturgy -- that today the Church is at a new crossroads and that in many ways liturgical reform and renewal is moving beyond simply that which followed Vatican II."
Alcuin Reid, "Looking Again at the Liturgical Reform", April 19, 2006[/quote]

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote]"I can't fight back the tears. This is the saddest moment in my life as a man, priest and bishop," Luca Brandolini, of the liturgy commission of the Italian bishops' conference, told Rome daily La Repubblica in an interview on Sunday.[/quote]

Um, wow.

When you ask most people what the saddest moment in their life is -- usually they say "When my mother/father/friend/sibling/child died/when I was diagnosed with AIDS/cancer/when I lost my job with several children to feed on Christmas/when my house burnt down"

Not when the pope grants permission on something that was requested by the faithful.

How about a little perspective, buddy?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...