GodChild Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 I'm in a bit of a pickle as I have just learned ... today actually, whilst talking with someone at the Cathedral, that my understanding of the Holy Trinity is in actuality a heresy known as modalism i've spent the afternoon reading 'apologetics' about the correct understanding of the Trinity, but honestly, Im just not getting it. I always believed the 'trinity' was god the father .... his salvation incarnate was 'Jesus' and his spirit, is the 'Holy Spirit' - but at all tims the ONE person. Apparently that is modalism, a heresy in the Church .... and God is three 'distinct' ppl all joined together as one .... I'm having trouble understanding that, kind of like three people (like siamese twins) conjoined at the head lol .... like I said before, I have done some reading of apologetics on this issue, admittedly only several hours worth as I just learned this today .... but I was wondering if some ppl could explain what the apologetists are saying in laymans terms. It might help me understand better, cause some apologist writers are a language unto themselves Thankyou
Hirsap Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 The mystery of the Blessed Trinity is the most difficult one to try and understand. I'll offer a bit of input, hopefully others will go further: 1) There are three distinct Person's ''in'' God, so to speak. It is not like these Three Persons = God when 'added' together, but each are fully God. 2) We use the term PERSON for lack of a better word, and we do not use it in exactly the same sense as we speak of different human persons. We use the term person by way of analogy, to help us understand the incomprehensible. 3) Each are fully God, possessing the Divine Nature, and are utterly co-equal. There is no greater and lesser. 4) How then, are the Person's distinguishable from each other, if each are fully God? The answer, as I have read in MY CATHOLIC FAITH by Bishop LaRavoire Morrow, lies in their [i]origin[/i], their respective 'place' in the Relationship of Love that is the Triune God. The Second Person (the Son) proceeds from the First Person (the Father), and the Third Person (the Holy Spirit) proceeds from the First and Second. But how to we make sense of processions? Theologians assert that God, in Being infinitely perfect, knows Himself in an infinitely perfect way. (This is opposed to the imperfect ideas humans have. We have an idea of something, but that idea is simply an idea, and not the thing itself existing in reality). Whereas with God, His Knowledge of Himself, is one with Himself. God's knowledge and Wisdom is Himself. This Wisdom of God is the Second Person, who is begotten as a Father begets a Son (by way of generation). We call this Person the Logos, the Word, since He is the Wisdom and God's knowledge of Himself. These two Divine Persons, 'look' to each other, and love with an infinite love. This infinite love that transpires between them is the Third Divine Person, the Holy Spirit.
KnightofChrist Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 Well you must first understand you will never understand the Holy Trinity. [img]http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e34/TheVoodookilla/Phatmass/Trinity.jpg[/img] God is three Persons in One Being. The Father is not the Son, the Son is not the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit is not the Father. The Father is distinguishable from the Son, the Son is distinguishable from the Holy Spirit; and the Holy Spirit is distinguishable from the Father. However the Father is God, nothing less, and the Son is God, nothing less, and the Holy Spirit is God, and God is essentially one.
adt6247 Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1334589' date='Jul 19 2007, 09:04 AM']God is three Persons in One Being.[/quote] "One being" is a really poor translation, as it is vague. It can imply unity of action, unity of location, unity of mind, etc. or all of those together. The problem is, it is not specific, and one unity is expressed in the [i]Credo[/i] specifically which one may or may not derive from "one being". The correct phrase should be "one in substance". That's what [i]consubstantialem[/i] (consubstantial) means. The new ICEL translations of the Novus Ordo Missae reflect this, and hopefully will be promulgated soon in English-speaking countries. Think of it this way - to create is to make a distinctly new creation of lower order and dignity to oneself. To beget is to generate a new being of the same nature. When man begets, his nature is man, and thus the child also has the nature of man. When God begets, his nature is the one true God and creator, thus any being he begets is also of nature "one true God and creator". Thus, the Father begets the Son, and the son is of the same substance, and same nature as the Father, and thus is also God. The love from the Father to the Son is so profound, that it begets a third person, the Holy Spirit, who is also of the same substance, and same nature. Oversimplification, yes, but we need to simplify and use analogies to understand God.
farglefeezlebut Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 This is an anology that helps me understand. Liquid water is water. It is H2O. It is not ice or steam, but it is fully water and there is nothing missing from it. Ice is water. It is H2O. It is not liquid water or steam, but it is fully water with nothing missing from it. Steam is water. It is H2O. It is not liquid water or ice, but it is fully water with nothing missing from it.
adt6247 Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 [quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1334630' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:34 AM']This is an anology that helps me understand. Liquid water is water. It is H2O. It is not ice or steam, but it is fully water and there is nothing missing from it. Ice is water. It is H2O. It is not liquid water or steam, but it is fully water with nothing missing from it. Steam is water. It is H2O. It is not liquid water or ice, but it is fully water with nothing missing from it.[/quote] This analogy falls apart. The only thing differentiating ice, steam, and liquid in the same substance is state. There is no distinction, as there is with the persons in the Trinity.
GodChild Posted July 19, 2007 Author Posted July 19, 2007 [quote]To beget is to generate a new being of the same nature. When man begets, his nature is man, and thus the child also has the nature of man. When God begets, his nature is the one true God and creator, thus any being he begets is also of nature "one true God and creator". Thus, the Father begets the Son, and the son is of the same substance, and same nature as the Father, and thus is also God. The love from the Father to the Son is so profound, that it begets a third person, the Holy Spirit, who is also of the same substance, and same nature.[/quote] So you mean God the Father had two children? If God the Father begot the Son and the Father and the Son begot the Holy Spirit... why does the 'begotting' stop there? Wouldn't that logically continue that if One begets another, and two beget another, then wouldnt three begot another? .... my line of thinking is that you say [quote]he love from the Father to the Son is so profound, that it begets a third person, the Holy Spirit, who is also of the same substance, and same nature[/quote] ... well wouldn't that mean that the love between three would further beget another? another question I have, is just how is my idea of the Trinity a heresy? I believe there is one God, the Father ... His salvation became incarnate (that is Jesus) and so that part of the Father that became incarnate is Jesus ... whilst the Holy Spirit is the central spirit of God ... i mean, if God is spirit, how is the Holy Spirit different? Is it an additional spirit to the father? so its three spirits all united as one? Im essentially not understanding the meaning of 'one' in the context of three 'distinguishable' persons
GodChild Posted July 19, 2007 Author Posted July 19, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' date='Jul 19 2007, 11:04 PM' post='1334589'] Well you must first understand you will never understand the Holy Trinity. [img]http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e34/TheVoodookilla/Phatmass/Trinity.jpg[/img] hmm, i dont think so .... I don't believe God reveals truths to ppl that are not meant to be understood ... if the trinity was revealed by God it would be so that it can be understood by people .... I'm not a big fan of the Church's 'mystery' arguments, its too easy to dismiss everything that's too hard to understand as "oh, thats a mystery, just take our word for it" - when God revealed the Trinity and made it known to ppl, it MUST be because it is comprehensible to people. At least thats my opinion, cause I don't believe God would reveal truths that can never be understood by people ... what would be the point
Starets Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1334657' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:37 AM']This analogy falls apart. The only thing differentiating ice, steam, and liquid in the same substance is state. There is no distinction, as there is with the persons in the Trinity.[/quote] Analogies inevitably misrepresent what they analogize. One fundamentalist apologist I read one time suggested the "Triple Point" of water as an analogy to God. Apparently under certain conditions of temperature and pressure, water can exist simultaneously in all three states. That might be at least a little better.
journeyman Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 I think I heard Neapolitan Ice Cream used once to try to explain this; and light passing through a prism; and there is always St. Patrick's use of the three leaf clover There is a wealth of material in the Directory which might help - this one link seems on point with your question: [url="http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/a63.htm"]A Defense of the Holy Trinity vs. Modalism[/url] Catholic Answers: The Trinity The Holy Trinity in the Old Testament: Part 2 The Trinity and Jehovah's Witnesses -- a non-Catholic source On the Trinity Excerpts and Quotes The Holy Trinity in the Old Testament: Part 1 An Explanation of the Trinity for Muslims -- a non-Catholic source Catholic Answers: The Trinity SDA and the Doctrine of the Trinity Is the Blessed Trinity a Pagan Concept? Defense of the Trinity: Against Muhammadans Holy Trinity The Trinity A Definition of the Trinity: The Athanasian Creed The Trinity in Nature The Trinity and Oneness Pentecostals The Blessed Trinity What Is God's Answer to Human Suffering? Personal Limitations and the Trinity Historical Introduction to Icons 290-292: Creation--Work of the Holy Trinity How to Defend the Doctrine of the Trinity The Trinity vs. Modalism The Holy Trinity: Biblical Proofs Frank Sheed on The Blessed Trinity The Trinity The Trinity and the Nature of God The Trinity Debate on the Trinity vs. Oneness The Trinity The Trinity and Modern Arians Islam, the Trinity, Koran, and Bible The Family as the Icon of the Holy Trinity Book Review: The Doctrine of the Trinity in the Theology of Gregory Palamas
KnightofChrist Posted July 19, 2007 Posted July 19, 2007 (edited) [quote name='GodChild' post='1335103' date='Jul 19 2007, 05:55 PM']hmm, i dont think so .... I don't believe God reveals truths to ppl that are not meant to be understood ... if the trinity was revealed by God it would be so that it can be understood by people .... I'm not a big fan of the Church's 'mystery' arguments, its too easy to dismiss everything that's too hard to understand as "oh, thats a mystery, just take our word for it" - when God revealed the Trinity and made it known to ppl, it MUST be because it is comprehensible to people. At least thats my opinion, cause I don't believe God would reveal truths that can never be understood by people ... what would be the point[/quote] Fan or not we will never until we are in heaven fully understand the Holy Trinity, and even then we do not know if this mystery will be explained. Is there more to understand, yes of course, theres thousands of books, but will you or anyone every understand it completely? I am sorry to say no, we can not. No one on earth has ever been able to understand it completely, well all but Christ. But again we can deeply study the revealed truths of the Holy Trinity, but in the end after has all been said and done, it will remain mystery, until the end of the age at least. Anyone that says they can explain it fully or understand it fully is not truthful to themselves or to others. I know that sounds bad but that is truth. Please some help me explain this better. Theres just enough truth revealed to allow us to know something of it and yet have faith for what remains a mystery. Edited July 19, 2007 by KnightofChrist
reyb Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 [indent]Is Holy Trinity a truly God's revealed doctrine or a man's doctrine? Why priest and bishop though guided by the power of the Holy Spirit cannot fully understand the Holy Trinity?[/indent]
Hirsap Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 (edited) [quote]hmm, i dont think so .... I don't believe God reveals truths to ppl that are not meant to be understood ... if the trinity was revealed by God it would be so that it can be understood by people .... I'm not a big fan of the Church's 'mystery' arguments, its too easy to dismiss everything that's too hard to understand as "oh, thats a mystery, just take our word for it" - when God revealed the Trinity and made it known to ppl, it MUST be because it is comprehensible to people. At least thats my opinion, cause I don't believe God would reveal truths that can never be understood by people ... what would be the point[/quote] The Holy Trinity is comprehensible insofar as it contains no contradictions. In this respect, mystery does not at all mean 'contrary to reason'. However, it is above reason, as it is a mystery. Faith in this mystery does not go contrary to reason. If faith was proven, it would not be faith. Edited July 20, 2007 by Hirsap
reyb Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1335181' date='Jul 19 2007, 09:07 PM']Do scientist fully understand the atom?[/quote] [indent]At least atom is not a mystery to them. [/indent]
adt6247 Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 [quote name='GodChild' post='1335100' date='Jul 19 2007, 07:49 PM']So you mean God the Father had two children? If God the Father begot the Son and the Father and the Son begot the Holy Spirit... why does the 'begotting' stop there? Wouldn't that logically continue that if One begets another, and two beget another, then wouldnt three begot another? .... my line of thinking is that you say ... well wouldn't that mean that the love between three would further beget another?[/quote] Honestly, I don't know. That has not been revealed. Theoretically, God could reveal it at a later dated. I assumed that in the creation of Christ and the Holy Spirit, God was complete. [quote name='GodChild' post='1335100' date='Jul 19 2007, 07:49 PM']another question I have, is just how is my idea of the Trinity a heresy? I believe there is one God, the Father ... His salvation became incarnate (that is Jesus) and so that part of the Father that became incarnate is Jesus ... whilst the Holy Spirit is the central spirit of God ... i mean, if God is spirit, how is the Holy Spirit different? Is it an additional spirit to the father? so its three spirits all united as one? Im essentially not understanding the meaning of 'one' in the context of three 'distinguishable' persons[/quote] I don't think your belief is necessarily heresy, but then, you haven't articulated it fully. I think you're still trying to articulate the nature of the Trinity. No analogy is perfect; we frankly do not understand enough to understand enough to fully grasp the Trinity. It is also a problem of infinite complexity, and our brains have neither infinite storage capacity nore infinite processing ability. First, Jesus is God's Word, not God's Salvation. The person of the Son would exist even if man were not fallen, and we did not need a savior, for Christ was made in the beginning with God. [quote][b]Gospel of John, chapter 1:[/b] 1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. 2 He was in the beginning with God; 3 all things were made through him, and without him was not anything made that was made. 4 In him was life, and the life was the light of men. ... 14 And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, full of grace and truth; we have beheld his glory, glory as of the only Son from the Father.[/quote] God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit are all of nature spirit (Chris also shares a human nature), as are the angels. Just because they are all spirit does not make them all God, otherwise the angels would be God too. [quote name='GodChild' post='1335103' date='Jul 19 2007, 07:55 PM']hmm, i dont think so .... I don't believe God reveals truths to ppl that are not meant to be understood ... if the trinity was revealed by God it would be so that it can be understood by people .... I'm not a big fan of the Church's 'mystery' arguments, its too easy to dismiss everything that's too hard to understand as "oh, thats a mystery, just take our word for it" - when God revealed the Trinity and made it known to ppl, it MUST be because it is comprehensible to people. At least thats my opinion, cause I don't believe God would reveal truths that can never be understood by people ... what would be the point[/quote] There's many things in life you will never understand. In physics, the Heizenburg Uncertainty Principal tells us that you can never know precisely the position and the velocity of an electron orbiting an atom -- the more you know about one, the less you know about the other. This is from the understanding that it is impossible to observe a system without altering it. Science, also, can never prove 100% the First Cause or Unmoved Mover that religious people call God. I believe Stephen Hawking said that we can never get too much detail about the nature of the big bang, or what happened before it, because that would require us to be able to observe it from outside, which is impossible since time travel is impossible, and there was no "outside" the big bang -- in the physical realm that WAS all of existence, so how can you be outside of existence? The point is, not all knowledge is knowable. There are also limitations on what the human brain can understand. I am a computer scientist, and one of the problems we run into in computer science is very large, complex applications, like let's say Microsoft Word. Word does so many things, and has so much code, it is beyond human comprehension. What does that mean? No one human can know how all of it works in detail. How was it written? It was compartmentalized, broken into abstract objects, and those were broken down, and those were broken down, until the individual objects were comprehensible. Then, different people were assigned groups of the objects. All everyone needs to know is how their objects work, and how their objects communicate with other objects. As I said before, the Trinity is a problem of infinite complexity. The human being cannot deal with all things of finite complexity, as I have demonstrated. Thus, infinite complexity is far beyond us. I hope this helps
adt6247 Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 [quote name='reyb' post='1335565' date='Jul 20 2007, 08:53 AM'][indent]At least atom is not a mystery to them. [/indent][/quote] Yes, it is. They even state that they can never know both the position and the velocity of the electron. It comes down to measurement of a system. All things we can observe are the result of chemical reactions, and thus the reaction of the electron clouds of one atom with another. Because of this, along with a whole bunch of funky math for proofs, we can defive that measurement of a system would, at the very least, have to modify either the position or the velocity of an electron, but not necessarily both. Thus, we can never know both. It is unknowable, because it is immeasurable. (to any other scientists here, I apologize at my over-simplification of this -- it's been a LONG time since I've taken physics)
reyb Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 [indent]It is written in 1 Cor 2:1-10[/indent] [color="#FF0000"][indent][indent]2:1 When I came to you, brothers, I did not come with eloquence or superior wisdom as I proclaimed to you the testimony about God. 2 For I resolved to know nothing while I was with you except Jesus Christ and him crucified. 3 I came to you in weakness and fear, and with much trembling. 4 My message and my preaching were not with wise and persuasive words, but with a demonstration of the Spirit's power, 5 so that your faith might not rest on men's wisdom, but on God's power. 6 We do, however, speak a message of wisdom among the mature, but not the wisdom of this age or of the rulers of this age, who are coming to nothing. 7 No, [b]we speak of God's secret wisdom, a wisdom that has been hidden and that God destined for our glory before time began[/b]. 8 None of the rulers of this age understood it, for if they had, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory. 9 However, as it is written: [/indent][/indent][/color] [color="#FF0000"][indent][indent]"No eye has seen, no ear has heard, no mind has conceived what God has prepared for those who love him"- 10 [b]but God has revealed it to us by his Spirit[/b]. [/indent][/indent][/color] --------------------------- [indent]Now, if God’s secret wisdom was revealed to Paul by the spirit of God, why then, there are still mysterious doctrine – the mystery of the Holy Trinity - in the Roman Catholic Church and other Trinitarian churches, considering they are blessed by the same Holy Spirit, I mean if they are really guided by the Holy Spirit?[/indent]
reyb Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1335574' date='Jul 20 2007, 08:19 AM']Yes, it is. They even state that they can never know both the position and the velocity of the electron. It comes down to measurement of a system. All things we can observe are the result of chemical reactions, and thus the reaction of the electron clouds of one atom with another. Because of this, along with a whole bunch of funky math for proofs, we can defive that measurement of a system would, at the very least, have to modify either the position or the velocity of an electron, but not necessarily both. Thus, we can never know both. It is unknowable, because it is immeasurable. (to any other scientists here, I apologize at my over-simplification of this -- it's been a LONG time since I've taken physics)[/quote] [indent]Well, what can I say. But, I only heard they do not fully understand about it and I never heard they say atom is this and that and then after that - is it still a mysterious atom. [/indent]
adt6247 Posted July 20, 2007 Posted July 20, 2007 [quote name='reyb' post='1335576' date='Jul 20 2007, 09:22 AM']Now, if God’s secret wisdom was revealed to Paul by the spirit of God, why then, there are still mysterious doctrine – the mystery of the Holy Trinity - in the Roman Catholic Church and other Trinitarian churches, considering they are blessed by the same Holy Spirit, I mean if they are really guided by the Holy Spirit?[/quote] It was revealed to him, and he understood the Holy Ghost as far as he could understand, not fully. He understood the same way we do -- through abstraction and metaphor. Do you really understand the intentions of the people that guide you? Do you know what is in their heart? Do you know what makes them "tick", per se? You do not need to understand fully to obey. You need to trust.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now