Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Eastern Catholic Vs. Eastern Orthodox


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1349725' date='Aug 4 2007, 04:06 PM']Era is totally on the money here. All doctrines that are clarified by Ecumenical Council are expressions of the Universal and Extraordinary Magesterium, and are therefore binding upon ALL the faithful -- whether they be East or West. There is no room to negotiate this point. If the East applies that rule to the first 7 councils, they must also apply it to all following councils.[/quote]
Interestingly, small excerpts of the working document (discussed last year in Belgrade) of the official Joint International Commission for the Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church have been released (due to an objection made by the Russian delegation), and the document says that: "an [i]Ecumenical Council[/i] in the strong sense became impossible," but "both Churches continued to hold [i]general[/i] councils gathering together the bishops of local Churches in communion with the See of Rome or the See of Constantinople" [[i]The Ecclesiological and Canonical Consequences of the Sacramental Nature of the Church: Conciliarity and Authority in the Church[/i], paragraph 45].

Apparently Rome is willing to negotiate on this issue, while some members of the lay faithful in the Roman Church are not.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1349736' date='Aug 4 2007, 04:25 PM']That is incorrect. By that reasoning, Chalcedon could not be recognized as an Ecumenical Council since the Oriental Orthodox did not accept it.

The universal Church continues to exist even though there are particular Churches and ecclesial communities living apart from her. She remains always the universal Church, and she can never cease to be the universal Church. This was the clarification of the recent document from the Vatican, which affirmed that the Church spoken of in the creed truly "subsists" in the Catholic Church.

Pope John XXIII explicitly designated the Second Vatican Council as an Ecumenical Council at his opening address, and also referred to the previous 13 Councils as Ecumenical Councils[/quote]
Well, do you really care what the Oriental Orthodox think about Chalcedon? After all, in the past they held that Pope Leo openly taught heresy in his tome delivered at the council, while the Eastern Orthodox revere him as a God-inspired Church Father.

Besides, more recent scholarship from the joint commission for dialogue between the Eastern Orthodox Church and the Oriental Orthodox Church has shown that the Miaphysites actually do teach the same thing as the Chalcedonians in connection with the incarnation.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349739' date='Aug 4 2007, 06:29 PM']Interestingly, small excerpts of the working document (discussed last year in Belgrade) of the official Joint International Commission for the Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church have been released (due to an objection made by the Russian delegation), and the document says that: "an [i]Ecumenical Council[/i] in the strong sense became impossible," but "both Churches continued to hold [i]general[/i] councils gathering together the bishops of local Churches in communion with the See of Rome or the See of Constantinople" [[i]The Ecclesiological and Canonical Consequences of the Sacramental Nature of the Church: Conciliarity and Authority in the Church[/i], paragraph 45].

Apparently Rome is willing to negotiate on this issue, while some members of the lay faithful in the Roman Church are not.[/quote]
A theological commission is not the Magisterium. If someone is not going to accept the Second Vatican Council and its predecessors as Ecumenical Councils, then they are contradicting the understanding of the Church that they are Ecumenical Councils. If you look at the citation footnotes of Church documents, for example, they refer to the Second Vatican Council as the "Second Vatican Ecumenical Council." Pope John XXIII expressly stated that it was an Ecumenical Council when it started, and Pope Paul VI also stated that it was an Ecumenical Council when it ended:

[quote]While we close the ecumenical council, we are honoring Mary Most Holy, the mother of Christ, and consequently, as we declared on another occasion, the mother of God and our spiritual mother.

[url="http://www.vatican.net/holy_father/paul_vi/homilies/1965/documents/hf_p-vi_hom_19651208_epilogo-concilio-immacolata_en.html"]http://www.vatican.net/holy_father/paul_vi...acolata_en.html[/url][/quote]
[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349744' date='Aug 4 2007, 06:35 PM']Well, do you really care what the Oriental Orthodox think about Chalcedon? After all, in the past they held that Pope Leo openly taught heresy in his tome delivered at the council, while the Eastern Orthodox revere him as a God-inspired Church Father.[/quote]
My point is that the rejection of Chalcedon by the Oriental Orthodox did not affect the status of the Council as an Ecumenical Council. The Church continued to exist even without the full communion of those particular Churches. The same has been true since the separation of most of the East from the West. The universal Church continues to subsist in the Catholic Church, and the separation of the particular Eastern Churches do not affect her authority to call Ecumenical Councils, and she has called fourteen of them since the separation.

Posted

The Catholic participants at the international commission (including the co-chairman Cardinal Kasper) have been appointed by Rome. In other words, they officially represent the Roman Magisterium in the talks, which are meant to restore communion between the Roman Church and the Orthodox Church.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1349749' date='Aug 4 2007, 04:46 PM']My point is that the rejection of Chalcedon by the Oriental Orthodox did not affect the status of the Council as an Ecumenical Council. The Church continued to exist even without the full communion of those particular Churches. The same has been true since the separation of most of the East from the West. The universal Church continues to subsist in the Catholic Church, and the separation of the particular Eastern Churches do not affect her authority to call Ecumenical Councils, and she has called fourteen of them since the separation.[/quote]
I know what your point is, but I do not think that Rome agrees with you. The Pope himself, while visiting the Ecumenical Patriarch, spoke about the Seven Ecumenical Councils, and said that "Orthodox and Catholics alike acknowledge [them] as authoritative for the faith and discipline of the Church" [Pope Benedict XVI, [i]Address of the Holy Father at the Patriarchal Cathedral of Saint George in the Phanar[/i], 29 November 2006].

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349751' date='Aug 4 2007, 06:50 PM']The Catholic participants at the international commission (including the co-chairman Cardinal Kasper) have been appointed by Rome. In other words, they officially represent the Roman Magisterium in the talks, which are meant to restore communion between the Roman Church and the Orthodox Church.[/quote]
Even if there are representatives of the Church in the commission, the documents of the commission are not part of the Magisterium. The representatives are members of the commission to explore questions of theology on behalf of the Church; but the teaching of the Church is distinct from theological speculation. Church teaching is authoritative and universal, whereas theology is speculative and is only the opinion of the theologians who propose it, who are always in obedience to the final judgment of the Church.

If the Church would ever teach that they were not Ecumenical Councils, then I would obey without question. And I don't even have a problem with theologians asking the question whether they can be seen as general Councils, as long as they only ask and do not state it as fact. But every public teaching of the Church acknowledges them as Ecumenical Councils, and so all Catholics must accept them as Ecumenical Councils.

Posted

The commission speaks for and represents the Roman Magisterium in these talks, just as the Orthodox members of the commission truly speak for their Churches, otherwise the talks are completely pointless.

I -- of course -- trust that Pope Benedict knows what he is doing.

Posted

Pope Benedict has also recognized the Second Vatican Council as an Ecumenical Council. For example:

[quote]The Fathers of the Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, in the Pastoral Constitution Gaudium et Spes, pointed out that ''not everything automatically becomes permissible between hostile parties once war has regrettably commenced''.

[url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/messages/peace/documents/hf_ben-xvi_mes_20051213_xxxix-world-day-peace_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict...y-peace_en.html[/url][/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1349759' date='Aug 4 2007, 05:08 PM']If the Church would ever teach that they were not Ecumenical Councils, then I would obey without question. And I don't even have a problem with theologians asking the question whether they can be seen as general Councils. But every public teaching of the Church acknowledges them as Ecumenical Councils, and so all Catholics must accept them as Ecumenical Councils.[/quote]
Your comment pleases me greatly.

That said, the Eastern Catholic Churches -- like the Melkites -- teach that the Western synods held after the 11th century are not ecumenical in the true sense of that word, and that is why we do not feel obliged to follow them. Nevertheless, Latin Catholics are bound to accept the synods of their particular Church.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1349769' date='Aug 4 2007, 05:15 PM']Pope Benedict has also recognized the Second Vatican Council as an Ecumenical Council. For example:[/quote]
Well, perhaps he is being duplicitous, but I sincerely doubt that.

Simply calling a general council of the West ecumenical does not make it ecumenical, any more than Easterners calling the Palamite Councils of the 14th century ecumenical makes them ecumenical.

P.S. - The first person to call the later Western synods ecumenical was St. Robert Bellarmine (and of course he was never a Pope), and he did so in his polemical works against Protestants.

Posted

I just wanted to pointed out a small addition to my previous post:

[quote]And I don't even have a problem with theologians asking the question whether they can be seen as general Councils, [b]as long as they only ask and do not state it as fact[/b].[/quote]
This is what I have a problem with. It's fine to ask the question. If we never asked questions, we would never have defined the faith. But it goes too far to say as a matter of fact that these Councils were not Ecumenical Councils, and that they do not require obedience from Eastern Catholics. The Church has acknowledged them as Ecumenical Councils, and the Fathers of the Councils themselves directed their teaching to the entire Church. The Popes have consistently recognized them as Ecumenical Councils. All Catholics must recognize them as Ecumenical Councils, because the Church does.

Posted

[quote name='peach_cube' post='1339202' date='Jul 23 2007, 08:13 PM']Besides Eastern Catholics recognizing the authority of the Pope and being in full communion with Rome, are there any theological differences between Eastern Catholics and Eastern Orthodox?[/quote]
There are, and should be, no differences doctrinally, spiritually, or liturgically between Eastern Catholics and Eastern Orthodox.

Personally, I subscribe to what is called the "Zoghby Initiative," which is a [i]Profession of Faith[/i] approved by the Melkite Catholic Holy Synod back in 1995:

[quote]1. I believe everything which Eastern Orthodoxy teaches.
2. I am in communion with the Bishop of Rome as the first among the bishops, according to the limits recognized by the Holy Fathers of the East during the first millennium, before the separation.[/quote]
God bless,
Todd

Posted

Era Might,

The ongoing de-Latinization of the Eastern Catholic Churches, which has the full support of Rome, is going to cause problems for some members of the Latin Church, who sadly tend to identify being Catholic with being Latin.

God bless,
Todd

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349779' date='Aug 4 2007, 07:21 PM']P.S. - The first person to call the later Western synods ecumenical was St. Robert Bellarmine, and he did so in his polemical works against Protestants.[/quote]
St. Robert Bellarmine wasn't born until 1542. The Ecumenical Council of Florence was held between 1438 and 1445, and called itself an Ecumenical Council:

[quote]Therefore we decree and declare, in every way and form as best we can, with the assent of the said emperor and patriarch and of all those in the present synod, that there exists a holy universal or ecumenical synod in this city of Ferrara, which is free and safe for all; and therefore it should be deemed and called such a synod by all, in which this holy business of union will be conducted without any quarrelsome contention but with all charity and, as we hope, will be brought by divine favour to a happy conclusion together with the other holy tasks for which the synod is known to have been instituted.

[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/FLORENCE.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/FLORENCE.HTM[/url][/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1349799' date='Aug 4 2007, 05:38 PM']St. Robert Bellarmine wasn't born until 1542. The Ecumenical Council of Florence was held between 1438 and 1445, and called itself an Ecumenical Council:[/quote]
I'm talking about all the other synods, which were added merely because of the canons attached to them.

As an Eastern Catholic I do not consider any of the fourteen Latin synods as ecumenical.

Now, as far as the Council of Florence is concerned, it teaches error on the filioque, because it makes the Son a cause ([i]aitia[/i]) in the procession ([i]ekporeusis[/i]) of origin of the Holy Spirit as person ([i]hypostasis[/i]), and so it involves a denial of the monarchy of the Father within the Godhead. Thus, Florence can never be accepted as truly ecumenical.

God bless,
Todd

Posted

Era,

Just to let you know, some of the sessions of the Council of Basel-Ferrara-Florence, which call themselves ecumenical, are not accepted as such by the Roman Church. Interestingly, the same type of thing happened at the Council of Constance, where some of the sessions are accepted as authoritative and others are rejected. It is a far more complex issue than you are making it out to be.

God bless,
Todd

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349679' date='Aug 4 2007, 04:24 PM']Byzantine theologians do not make a distinction between mortal and venial sin in the same way that the Scholastics of the West do; instead, in the Eastern doctrinal tradition a man sins mortally when he fails to repent from his evil deeds (see Nicaea II, canon 5).[/quote]
How does one examine the conscience before the Mystery of Repentence in light of this?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349739' date='Aug 4 2007, 06:29 PM']Interestingly, small excerpts of the working document (discussed last year in Belgrade) of the official Joint International Commission for the Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church have been released (due to an objection made by the Russian delegation), and the document says that: "an [i]Ecumenical Council[/i] in the strong sense became impossible," but "both Churches continued to hold [i]general[/i] councils gathering together the bishops of local Churches in communion with the See of Rome or the See of Constantinople" [[i]The Ecclesiological and Canonical Consequences of the Sacramental Nature of the Church: Conciliarity and Authority in the Church[/i], paragraph 45].

Apparently Rome is willing to negotiate on this issue, while some members of the lay faithful in the Roman Church are not.[/quote]

These documents are political by their very nature and are not garnered with the seal of infallibility by any Catholic understanding. You should also remember this one document cannot measure up against the thousands of other documents supported by, not just the Pope, but all other Latin Bishops, that uniformly state the doctrines of all Ecumenical Councils are binding on the individual consciences of all faithful Catholics -- the Catechism of the Catholic Church is a good example. One political document is not anywhere likely to overturn the Ordinary and Universal teachings of the Church, which are infallible by their very nature. Furthermore, if the Pope conceded on this issue with the Orthodox, he would have a lot of apologizing to do to all those dissident theologians over the last 40 years who were silenced and censured for teachings contrary to the doctrines of the more recent Ecumenical Councils. What you propose is highly unlikely and sounds more like diplomat-speak and less like doctrinal negotiation. Besides, the phrase "strong sense" does not necessarily negate the binding nature of the more recent Councils. It may simply be a statement that we Westerners recognize a general lack of communal fellowship in our Councils when the Eastern Orthodox are not present. We suffer from their absence in that we are denied their unique perspectives and insights. Such would be more of a humble recognition of our temporal need for communion with the East, not necessarily a denial of our ability to continue as the Universal Church with or without the Orthodox.

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349754' date='Aug 4 2007, 07:01 PM']I know what your point is, but I do not think that Rome agrees with you. The Pope himself, while visiting the Ecumenical Patriarch, spoke about the Seven Ecumenical Councils, and said that "Orthodox and Catholics alike acknowledge [them] as authoritative for the faith and discipline of the Church" [Pope Benedict XVI, [i]Address of the Holy Father at the Patriarchal Cathedral of Saint George in the Phanar[/i], 29 November 2006].[/quote]

Yes, we do have that common understanding of the first 7 Councils which helps us identify with the Eastern Orthodox more than we do with Western Protestants. But we also differ on the remaining Councils in that the West holds those doctrines as binding upon the faithful. Read that statement again with that in mind. You will not find Luther's infamous "sola" (alone) in the Pope's statement.

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1349800' date='Aug 4 2007, 07:44 PM']Now, as far as the Council of Florence is concerned, it teaches error on the filioque, because it makes the Son a cause ([i]aitia[/i]) in the procession ([i]ekporeusis[/i]) of origin of the Holy Spirit as person ([i]hypostasis[/i]), and so it involves a denial of the monarchy of the Father within the Godhead. Thus, Florence can never be accepted as truly ecumenical.[/quote]

Our understanding is that the Orthodox Church misinterprets what was declared by the Filioque. We see little if no difference between our understanding of the Filioque and yours. Its more an element of symantics. By the way, when the Scriptures mention the Holy Spirit as the "Spirit of Christ", do you not find those passages at odds with your understanding of the Filioque? Romans 8:9 uses both phrases interchangably:

"But you are not in the flesh, but in the spirit, if so be that the Spirit of God dwell in you. Now if any man have not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of his."

How can Paul speak of Christ as claiming an ownership of the Holy Spirit similar to that of the Father if the Filioque is not correct?

(I hope this isn't too off topic. Sorry if it is.)

Steve S. -- Abercius24
CatholicQandA.com

Edited by abercius24

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...