aalpha1989 Posted July 24, 2007 Posted July 24, 2007 Last week I took a class on the book 'Miracles' by C.S. Lewis. The professor was Fr. Fessio (who awed me by the way...I had never met an orthodox Jesuit before), and he gave his theory of life after death. We know that God is outside of time. We know that in going to heaven we are going to be with God. Therefore we are outside of time after our death. Purgatory, then, can only be conceived (as our brains cannot conceive anything truly outside of time) as an instant purification in fire and penance at our encountering God who is fully Himself. When we see how our sins have hurt Him and how beautiful He truly is, we are pained more deeply than we can imagine because of all our sins on Earth. This pain is purgatory, and then we are admitted into Heaven. This is roughly what Fr. Fessio said he believes. Also he said that Old Testament figures after death did not 'wait' for Christ's death and resurrection because they left this time as well as this physical world. Also, because Christ is the 'firstfruits of creation' he always was and his salvation was retroactive. Father also said that when we die and go to Heaven we encounter the Final Judgement as well as anyone who will ever die simply because it is outside of time, and also we will not 'wait' for our bodies until the end of time either. Does all that check out with you guys? Should I clarify? What do you think? Before having this class I had my own theory. I now believe Fr. Fessio's because it makes more sense than mine. My own theory before this class had been this. I knew that God is outside of time, and that Heaven is complete communion with God. However, I had always been taught that the Final Judgement was at the end of time and that we would receive our bodies back at the end of time. Knowing that this IS true, I came to this conclusion. I concluded that the Heaven we enter at death is not the fullness of Heaven that we will enter at the end of time. This was based on the knowledge that there are different 'levels' of heaven, different degrees of ecstasy. I believed that we would enter a higher degree of ecstasy after hte end of time and that we were never truly outside of time until time was ended. Fr. Fessio's theory makes more sense and I now follow that train of thought. Give opinions. Danke! Jonathan
Pennypacker11 Posted July 25, 2007 Posted July 25, 2007 This position is strikingly similar to Rahner and his rejection of the intermediate state (meaning some [i]time[/i] in which we have no body but during which our soul enjoys the beatific vision). Rahner provides an almost identical account of purgatory and the Resurrection of the Body (Balthasar is not as explicit but shows sympathies with parts of this as well). As far as I know it is a viable explanation of the [i]mystery[/i] of the afterlife, but one which Ratzinger did not endorse as the head of the CDF.
aalpha1989 Posted July 25, 2007 Author Posted July 25, 2007 [quote name='Pennypacker11' post='1340633' date='Jul 25 2007, 04:21 PM']This position is strikingly similar to Rahner and his rejection of the intermediate state (meaning some [i]time[/i] in which we have no body but during which our soul enjoys the beatific vision). Rahner provides an almost identical account of purgatory and the Resurrection of the Body (Balthasar is not as explicit but shows sympathies with parts of this as well). As far as I know it is a viable explanation of the [i]mystery[/i] of the afterlife, but one which Ratzinger did not endorse as the head of the CDF.[/quote] Hm. I kinda figured Fessio would take after Ratzinger because he studied with him in the early '70's....
aalpha1989 Posted July 27, 2007 Author Posted July 27, 2007 *bump* !!! this stuff interests me i'd like people to talk about it... of course if we are all too busy spamming that's fine too... i know there's a couple serious topics out there and i can't FORCE people to talk about it....*sigh*....
Pennypacker11 Posted July 27, 2007 Posted July 27, 2007 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1342025' date='Jul 26 2007, 11:36 PM']*bump* !!! this stuff interests me i'd like people to talk about it... of course if we are all too busy spamming that's fine too... i know there's a couple serious topics out there and i can't FORCE people to talk about it....*sigh*....[/quote] For the perspective of the CDF, I recommend that you read [i]De quibusdam quaestionibus actualibus circa eschatologiam[/i]. If you can't find it online it is translated in the [i]Irish Theological Quarterly[/i] 58 (1992): 209-243. The major question that is raised by Fr. Fessio's opinion is that of the intermediate state, a question which revolves around the wider question of 'time' after death. By 'intermediate state' I mean some period of [i]time[/i] in between one's death and the final judgment/general resurrection. The existence of such a state was affirmed by Benedict XII in his constitution [i]Benedictus Deus[/i] of 1336. The major question for interpreters of this papal document however, is whether Benedict affirms the intermediate state for its own sake or as a means to affirm the value of the Resurrected Body. Two major issues have lead various theologians to rejection the existence of a [i]time[/i] during which one is purified or is waiting for the resurrected body: 1) The notion that just as the body needs the soul function, the soul needs a body. Thus, the idea of a soul, which is in the [i]forma corporis[/i], existing blissfully without the body is simply incompatible with our experience and what we know about the human person. Personally, I think this position comes from a healthy defense of our corporeality and the value of the resurrection in our salvation, but goes to far. 2) After we die, we are outside of time and thus it is senseless to speak of an intermediate temporal state (such speak would blend with mythology). I have more sympathies with this, but I think that we have created a false dilemma by valuing our own ability to reason to highly. Rahner (and Fessio in your presentation) admit that we cannot conceive of anything outside of our own temporal existence; no matter how many analogies one gives, we cannot conceive of timelessness or non-time. Yet, then why accept our inability and then conceive of purgatory as 'instantaneous' (or in the midst of our death?) and 'immediate' life in our resurrected body if we cannot conceive of non-time? Here is where I take an even more apophatic (and Balthasarian turn). Why not accept that Eternity, rather than being pure stasis, will have something analogous to, but beyond our conception of time (just as non-time is beyond our conception)? When we as finite beings behold the Triune God, Infinite Beauty in the beatific vision, will we grasp this Infinitude all at once? Will we not joyfully plumb the depths of God for eternity (similar to Gregory of Nyssa's conception)? Obviously I am talking here in analogy and metaphor (the only way we can speak of these things). However, I believe that envisioning some sort of dynamic 'supra-time' is more helpful than a static 'non-time' when trying to describe our eternal encounter with the Triune God of Love.
aalpha1989 Posted August 3, 2007 Author Posted August 3, 2007 Thank you very much I will look deeper into this....
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now