Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Catholicism: Liberal, Conservative ... Or Radical?


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.vox-nova.com/2007/06/is-vox-nova-liberal-is-catholicism.html"]Post by Michael Joseph on Vox Nova[/url]
It's long so slightly abbreviated (and emphasis added) below, but this has direct relevance to many conversations we've had here:
[quote]The implications of Benedict's invocation of the divinely effected caritas and the revealed communio personarum? To capitalize the supernatural character of Christian human action set ablaze by divine grace. [i]Simply put, to witness acts of charity is not merely to witness acts of moral virtue or natural goodness, but to witness the transformative power of the emanating love of the Godhead: Father, Son and Spirit. [/i]Hence, the utterly unique and unanticipated nature of Christianity in the world: humanity in its totality is called to participate in the divine nature. If I may be so brash as to combine Eastern and Western themes, Christians are deified by grace due to their participation in the divinity of Christ and to the self-determining character of their graced actions. Deification of person and act.
...
It is my conviction--and Pope Benedict XVI's many writings on law, society and politics confirm this--that Catholic perspectives on culture, society and politics will relentlessly challenge a world that has been interrupted by the advent of salvation in Jesus Christ. [i]Something unexpected, something unanticipated, something foreign ought to be perceived by the world when Christians engage it with agape-caritas instead of conventionality-duty.[/i] And let me be frank: before a Christian can carry out such a glorious task, a Christian's mind and heart must be initially and continually transformed and renewed by the very same agape-caritas that is to be present to the world through that Christian's actions. This is a daunting and frightening prospect for the Christian, even after conversion, for this transformation and renewal never ceases as we plunge deeper and deeper into the mystery of divine love. [i]Agape-caritas challenges our prevailing notions of love and, when extended into our actions in society, it challenges our prevailing notions of justice, shattering the simplistic reasonings and categories we cling to in our outlook of mundane tasks such as politics[/i].

This is why I feel ashamed when I see fellow Catholics not recognizing this radical work of agape-caritas and its transforming effects. But I ask myself, does not such wildly simplistic reasoning embody that tension that occurs when the Christian mind has not fully been transformed and renewed by divine grace? I believe this question is worth asking because to label radical Catholicism as "liberal" is: 1. Not an argument in itself (reason); 2. A failure to register the attempt to reflect upon the application of agape-caritas through action in society (faith). [b]We must recognize that radical Catholic living is not the result of sheer political musing but of a strong embrace of the radical demand of the Gospel, which penetrates to every level of human action.[/b] To label its views as "liberal" or even as "conservative" is to betray one's inability to recognize the transforming power of God.

Does this mean that social response will be uniform, monolithic and predictable among Christians? Well, does conversion to Christian faith entail the annihilation of the self and its self-determining actions? "No" to both questions. However, just as a non-Christian may easily find a Christian to be fanatically or irrationally "conservative," a Christian who does not permit grace to transform his entire social outlook may find another Christian's social outlook to be, well, "liberal." It is true, there are many Catholics who permit "conservative" or "liberal" political persuasion to shape the expression of their faith in social matters (to name two clerics who clearly exhibit this trait are Fr. Richard John Neuhaus and Fr. Ernesto Cardenal), and perhaps in this case the labels are appropriate for their secularizing tendencies. [b]But truth be told, the most evident Catholic faith is not conservative or liberal; it is radical, as it should be.[/b] This is not some overly romantic depiction of the faith, for the saints and servants of God testify to its reality...Francis...Ignatius of Antioch...Thomas More...Mother Teresa...Dorothy Day...Vincent de Paul. Only those who have been truly transformed by grace will be able to recognize this radicality. The rest, sadly, will see only conservative or liberal motives in those who practice the Gospel in our contemporary setting and will see only distant and admirable heroes in the saints of the past.

My point in all this? Catholic social doctrine, while it at times resembles certain "conservative" (e.g. pro-life) and certain "liberal" positions (e.g. just distribution of goods), its foundation, meaning and effect is not coextensive with either camp. [b]There is no such thing as the "Catholic Right" or the "Catholic Left" because Catholicism is radical. Anything else is phony. Catholicism is disturbing. It is transforming. And rightly so, for the world knows nothing more radical than a God who so loved the world that His Son became flesh and dwelt among us. [/b]Those Christians who cannot perceive the radical consequences of Christ's interrupting Incarnation, non-violent surrender to Death, and death-defying Resurrection for the social sphere must ask themselves if they are fully permitting the Holy Spirit to transform and renew their minds.

Catholicism in its full scope is not comfortable to either the "conservative" or "liberal" mindset, so why do some Catholics still resort to such labels in the first place? I understand that it is much easier for many Christians to remain within the comfort and convenience of categorical binomials than to allow the Holy Spirit to transform and renew. I've been there. Still am in many respects. I was tempted to write Pope Benedict XVI off as a "liberal," and before that retreat I probably would have, just as I would have written off many contributors of Vox Nova. But with a little study and a lot prayer, I am beginning to see that Catholicism ought to shake us up a bit, especially in our social awareness. If this is not happening, then something is wrong. I invite you to pray with me that you and I will always be receptive to the challenge of the Gospel.

Still not convinced? Still feel like "conservative Catholic" or "liberal Catholic" are honest or intelligent labels for those who embrace the fullness of the Gospel? Perhaps the voices of three diverse Catholic thinkers who have respectively been labeled "conservative," "moderate" and "liberal" may help us understand that "radical" is the appropriate adjective for Catholic action.

[i]Dietrich von Hildebrand[/i]
With the labels conservative and progressive they are in fact requiring the faithful to choose between opposition to any renewal, opposition even to the elimination of things that have crept into the Church because of human frailty (e.g., legalism, abstractionism, external pressure in questions of conscience, grave abuses of authority in monasteries) and a change, a "progress" in the Catholic faith which can only mean its abandonment.

[i]These are false alternatives. For there is a third choice, which welcomes the official decisions of the Vatican Council but at the same time emphatically rejects the secularizing interpretations given them by many so-called progressive theologians and laymen.

This third choice is based on the unshakeable faith in Christ and in the infallible magisterium of His Holy Church. It takes it for granted that there is no room for change in the divinely revealed doctrine of the Church.[/i]

This position maintains thatt there is a radical difference between the kingdom of Christ and the saeculum (world); it takes into account the struggle between the spirit of Christ and the spirit of Satan through all the centuries past and to come, until the end of the world. It believes that Christ's words are as valid today as in any former time: "Had you been of the world, the world would love its own; but as you are not of the world, as I have chosen you out of the world, the world hates you."

This is simply the Catholic position, without further qualification. It rejoices in any renewal that enlarges the establishment of all things Christ--the instaurare omnia in Christo--and that brings the light of Christ to added domains of life. This is in fact a specific encouragement to Catholics to confront all things with the Spirit and Truth of Christ--in season and out of season--regardless of the spirit of the present age or any past age.

(Trojan Horse in the City of God)

[i]Hans Urs von Balthasar[/i]
Whoever tries today, in obedience to God's word, to say something about God and man has to negotiate the narrow path between two forms of titanism.

But the Lamb of God walked the narrow way and, by telling us to follow him along it, gave us the hope of avoiding all forms of human titanism. Neither the conservatives nor the progressives can bear the fragmentariness of existence in time. They offer formulas for how the fragment can be made a whole; perhaps it is even seen as a whole itself. The dynamic progressives seek to harness the social program of the prophets and of the Sermon on the Mount as a dynamic force to change society, while the conservatives see the hieratic and hierarchic forms founded by Christ as timelessly and finally informing the frail material of the world.

[i]The "program" of the Lamb, true to the earth by being truly humilis (i.e., close to the humus), can be popular with neither right nor left. It cannot be built into earthly programs; it does not offer enough for them and it cannot be exploited. If you use it as a front, it looks fine and possibly has propaganda value, but the misconception cannot be hidden forever.[/i]

(A Theological Anthropology)

[i]Joe Holland[/i]
The classic secular Left has rightly perceived the great drive toward social destruction at the heart of modern civilization. But it has generally failed to perceive the destructive blocking of divine creativity, which flows from an ever-deepening "progressive" secularization of society. The classic Left thus challenges social destruction, but cuts itself off from the religious root of creativity.

As a result, its efforts to stop the destruction often prove sterile, and sometimes even compound the crisis. The flat vision of secular scientific socialism, or of a secular scientific state as the key to the future, feeds the loss of cultural creativity.

The situation on the classic religious Right is just the opposite, with the same unfortunate result. For the religious Right, the main problem is secularization. It correctly sees the whole "progressive" movement as deepening secularization and therfore cutting itself off from the divine root. But the religious Right fails to understand the prophetic side of the divine, and winds up defending the very social destruction that the Left fights against.

The Right tries to retrieve an authoritarian, patriarchal, militaristic society tied this time to powerful modern technology. It apeals to a divine image, but that divine image is no longer the living God of justice and peace. It is rather a war god, a god of oppression, an idol. This idol in turn provides religious legitimacy for demonic destruction.

Thus on one side the secular Left often makes of secularization its own idol and cuts itself off from the divine root of human creativity. On the other side, the religious Right holds high the principle of religous transcendence, but often allows a false god to unleash the demonic.

The complete task is to link faith energies with energies of justice and peace in service of the Living God and social transformation. Faith and justice need to become as one flesh in service of both. The secular hunger for justice from the Left needs to find its deeper root in spirituality. The spiritual hunger of the Right needs to find God's true face in justice and peace.

There are two seeds of creativity in the world--social engagement and spirituality. Similarly within the Christian community, these two movements have their echo--on one side the justice and peace movement, often developed in secular style; and on other side the prayer movement, often without social engagement.

It is sad when good people from both sides fail to see the other's complementary gift.

Is it the terrible sin of human pride on both sides which causes this division? Is it the pride of secularism on the Left--afraid of spiritual energies because they are not subject to rational control? And is it the pride of religiosity on the Right--afraid of the Spirit's prophetic power in the secular arena because it is not subject to religious control?

Thus we may speak of two criteria for guiding our path in the crisis which envelops us. The first criterion is openness to the creative transformation of our civilization. The second criterion is openness to the spiritual roots of creative energies. The classic secular Left fails the test of the second criterion. The classic religious Right fails the test of the first criterion.[/quote]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Good general message, but I believe he still betrays the kind of overly simplistic dichotomized approach that he had apparently intended to critique.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1339752' date='Jul 24 2007, 12:19 PM']Good general message, but I believe he still betrays the kind of overly simplistic dichotomized approach that he had apparently intended to critique.[/quote]
By creating a new dichotomy ... those who understand "radical" Catholicism and those who don't?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1339757' date='Jul 24 2007, 12:24 PM']By creating a new dichotomy ... those who understand "radical" Catholicism and those who don't?[/quote]
As I see it (after one cursory reading) the fundamental approach of the article, in my opinion, paints the Church in the image of American politics. Historically speaking the real dichotomy to consider is orthodoxy vs. heterodoxy. The liberal-conservative paradigm can blur this fact and in some sense validate heterodox agendas in that they are seen as little more than one end of a necessarily polar Church which is ever in the process of striving toward some kind of Hegelian synthesis.

The early discussion of "radical Catholicism" seemed somewhat restricted by the political motives as well.

Posted

Orthodox/Heterodox is an accurate dichotomy.
Liberal/Conservative really isn't. At least that's my understanding.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

But I must say I quite enjoyed the article! I regret coming off so critical from the start, there were just details of the sort indicated above which created an unresolved tension throughout the article for me.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1339771' date='Jul 24 2007, 12:44 PM']As I see it (after one cursory reading) the fundamental approach of the article, in my opinion, paints the Church in the image of American politics. Historically speaking the real dichotomy to consider is orthodoxy vs. heterodoxy. The liberal-conservative paradigm can blur this fact and in some sense validate heterodox agendas in that they are seen as little more than one end of a necessarily polar Church which is ever in the process of striving toward some kind of Hegelian synthesis.

The early discussion of "radical Catholicism" seemed somewhat restricted by the political motives as well.[/quote]
[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1339774' date='Jul 24 2007, 12:51 PM']But I must say I quite enjoyed the article! I regret coming off so critical from the start, there were just details of the sort indicated above which created an unresolved tension throughout the article for me.[/quote]
I agree with your assessment ... from my reading of it, it seemed he was attempting to pull away from describing Catholics as liberal or conservative in an American political sense (also a cursory reading on my part, hehe). We do that all too often, I think, which as you note does tend to obscure the tension we as Catholics [i]should[/i] be feeling between orthodoxy and heterodoxy.

Because of the nature of our culture, this is a difficult distinction to make, I think ... politics is central to our national identity, and I think we see ourselves at times first as participants in a political process rather than first as Catholics. That self-identification as political beings then carries into our understanding of ourselves as Catholics, and we sometimes focus our faith in alignment with our political ideologies rather than the other way around.

The interrelationship between politics and religion is a particularly difficult nut to crack, though ...

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1339793' date='Jul 24 2007, 01:27 PM']I agree with your assessment ... from my reading of it, it seemed he was attempting to pull away from describing Catholics as liberal or conservative in an American political sense (also a cursory reading on my part, hehe). We do that all too often, I think, which as you note does tend to obscure the tension we as Catholics [i]should[/i] be feeling between orthodoxy and heterodoxy.

Because of the nature of our culture, this is a difficult distinction to make, I think ... politics is central to our national identity, and I think we see ourselves at times first as participants in a political process rather than first as Catholics. That self-identification as political beings then carries into our understanding of ourselves as Catholics, and we sometimes focus our faith in alignment with our political ideologies rather than the other way around.

The interrelationship between politics and religion is a particularly difficult nut to crack, though ...[/quote]
That's an interesting way of looking at things. Thanks.
I'm sure I'm not alone when I say that one of the most frustrating things is when people automatically presume to throw you into some cliche category (as a Catholic that is) after they've heard about 1% of your perspective on Catholicism. It is a relentless problem for me. I'm not saying that I don't have to wage constant battle against such tendencies, but it seems like quite often I encounter people who are incapable of seeing people outside of set compartments like liberal and conservative, or traddy and neo-cath. I don't think that human reality is quite that simple and it is an intrinsically divisive mentality.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1339798' date='Jul 24 2007, 01:37 PM']That's an interesting way of looking at things. Thanks.
I'm sure I'm not alone when I say that one of the most frustrating things is when people automatically presume to throw you into some cliche category (as a Catholic that is) after they've heard about 1% of your perspective on Catholicism. It is a relentless problem for me. I'm not saying that I don't have to wage constant battle against such tendencies, but it seems like quite often I encounter people who are incapable of seeing people outside of set compartments like liberal and conservative, or traddy and neo-cath. I don't think that human reality is quite that simple and it is an intrinsically divisive mentality.[/quote]
I definitely agree ... I wonder how much of that divisiveness is inherent to our culture, and how much is part of being human.

From my (very brief) reading of early church apologists I see this constant tension in understanding the nature of our faith. For example, the nature of Christ ... people argued either he was an extraordinary man, but not really God, or God but not really man. But we maintained the tension between the two, that he is both fully God and fully man. Same with the Trinity, not EITHER three persons OR one God, but BOTH three persons AND one God. It seems that we humans are most comfortable with the explanations which give us the least amount of trouble, the ones we don't have to wrestle with and that don't leave us with large chunks of stuff we don't understand.

I think the same is true when it comes to living as a Catholic ... that there is a temptation to focus on one body of teaching (that which conforms with the American political idea of "liberal" social justice, for example) and ignore the teachings that make elements of that position untenable such as those on life or sexuality or subsidiarity. Then we break into polarized groups within the church ... and the "pick a church where you feel most comfortable" mentality (which I admittedly struggle with) heightens the divisions because we aren't as often in situations where we must learn to lovingly interact with those who could provide balance to our own extreme tendencies (which we all have). So instead of being Catholic parishes we are liberal Catholic parishes and conservative Catholic parishes.

Posted

Orthodox.


Not liberal like some commie catholics like to claim and not conservative.

Posted

Thanks for posting, Terra! That's my line of thought!

Catholicism is radical.

Everyone read this!

Posted (edited)

Conservative all the way, baby! :smokey:

I'd honestly need to read more of this author's works to know how much I agree or disagree with him. In this article, he's made a lot of statements that are rather vague generalities.

And I would strongly disagree with much of Joe Holland's understanding of conservatism, but perhaps that's another topic.

I'd agree that "Conservative Catholic" and "Liberal Catholic" are often inadequate labels, and that orthodox and heterodox are generally more relevent - but, as I've argued elsewhere, I think they do have their place.
For instance, it seems someone always gets their panties in a knot everytime I speak against "liberal Catholicism."
While labels always have their inadequacies, "liberal Catholicism" is a useful shorthand for a particular flavor of heterodoxy which tends to predominate in the Church in America and much of the West. This liberalism has been specifically condemned by various popes in the past.
"Liberal Catholicism" is a vague ideology which tends to oppose Church authority and tradition, denies "traditional" moral teaching, downplays supernatural truth, and generally tries to make the Church into a kind of anything-goes democracy which changes constantly with the whims of the age.

(Not all heterodoxy is "liberal" - extreme "trad" movements such as Bayside come to mind - yet "liberal religion" does tend to be the predominant problem in the modern Church.)

I generally prefer "orthodox" (small "o") to "conservative" when referring to, well, orthodox Catholics, but the modern world will tend to categorize anything which promotes objective standards of morality and unchanging moral authority, and ties to ancient tradition as "conservative."
And I do not in any way consider conservative to be a bad thing, properly understood.
And the truth is (much as some may hate to admit this) that religious orthodoxy does tend to often coincide with political conservatism. One tends to find very few liberal Democrats where Catholic Orthodoxy is practiced.
(And most people lack a real understanding of the meaning of conservatism - tending to simply equate it with the Republican Party or President Bush).

I am proud to be conservative, and do not see it as being in any way at odds with Catholic orthodoxy.

The meaning of conservatism and liberalism in the Church is not exactly the same as in secular politics, and all labels tend to fall short - even "radical Catholic."
Obviously what the author refers to as "radical" here does not refer to some fanatic bomb-throwing Marxist or anarchist revolutionary.

Edited by Socrates
Posted

me i don't agree with some of the things that catholicism says, but i am pro life as well as for abstience education. im satisfied with my faith and where i see myself.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1340135' date='Jul 24 2007, 09:25 PM']Conservative all the way, baby! :smokey:

<snip>

Obviously what the author refers to as "radical" here does not refer to some fanatic bomb-throwing Marxist or anarchist revolutionary.[/quote]

I wondered if liberation theology was going to come up in the discussion of "radical" . . . but I can see where beating one's head against the wall of the status quo can lead in that direction

I'm getting to the point where I don't even want to use conservative/liberal labels when discussing civil politics . . . because I don't usually mean something as simple as party affiliation . . . but I also don't think my 17th Century definitions are still intact either

As Terra noted, to deliberately court the tension between the easy answer and the "not quite understood" answer is radical for our day and time . . .

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1340135' date='Jul 24 2007, 11:25 PM']I am proud to be conservative, and do not see it as being in any way at odds with Catholic orthodoxy.[/quote]

I think Catholic Orthodoxy often requires a person to be "conservative" when the world is too liberal and "liberal" when the world is too conservative.

Liberalism is so rampant now that a more "conservative" outlook on things makes sense. But a good Catholic has to be liberal in comparison to society when that society is too conservative. (i.e. focusing on rules because they're traditional, or going too much by the letter of the law). In Victorian England, for example, if a woman had a baby out of wedlock, she was as good as dead... that's too conservative, I think.

Of course, all this point of view depends on your definition of liberalism and conservatism. And that's debatable enough...

Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='1340432' date='Jul 25 2007, 08:42 AM']Of course, all this point of view depends on your definition of liberalism and conservatism. And that's debatable enough...[/quote]

Conservative = right
Liberal = wrong

:bluesbrother:

Posted

Conservatism is right now [i]only[/i] because it counterbalances extreme liberalism.

Liberalism to a degree is necessary to combat extreme conservatism.

It's not a new idea - it's basically the premise of Chesterton's [i]Orthodoxy[/i].

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...