Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Which Language....


Recommended Posts

Pro Sanctus Jehanne
Posted

OK,
Well I need to do a language for college and I have the option of German, French, Latin or Spanish...
I favor Latin or Spanish, with an outside shot at German.. Obviously from my lame forum name latin couldnt hurt. How does it stack up in difficulty? Would it just be a waste of time to pick it up these days (being a dead language and all) or does it still hold it's own in comparison to Spanish.

I considered latin as I thought it would be sort of cool to read the classics, perhaps interpret the latin mass...

Posted

[quote name='Pro Sanctus Jehanne' post='1341398' date='Jul 26 2007, 10:54 AM']OK,
Well I need to do a language for college and I have the option of German, French, Latin or Spanish...
I favor Latin or Spanish, with an outside shot at German.. Obviously from my lame forum name latin couldnt hurt. How does it stack up in difficulty? Would it just be a waste of time to pick it up these days (being a dead language and all) or does it still hold it's own in comparison to Spanish.

I considered latin as I thought it would be sort of cool to read the classics, perhaps interpret the latin mass...[/quote]


As a native German speaker who took Latin in high school, both are equally difficult when it comes to grammar. Spanish is the easiest of your choices, and most widely used as well, but you have to be careful of cultural differences between Spain and Latin American Spanish (even there are difference from country to country.)

Latin is a requirement for aspiring German physicians, as a lot of medical lingo is in Latin. This is why they still teach it in high school. Obviously you need it as well if you want to go to seminary.

Latin appeared to be more logical compared to German. It will also help you immensely if you decide to pick up any of its living offspring someday. BTW, there are still some pockets of what could be present-day Latin speakers in the hills of Corsica or Sardinia. (Forgot which.)

Pro Sanctus Jehanne
Posted

[quote name='Andreas E.' post='1341434' date='Jul 26 2007, 12:25 PM']As a native German speaker who took Latin in high school, both are equally difficult when it comes to grammar. Spanish is the easiest of your choices, and most widely used as well, but you have to be careful of cultural differences between Spain and Latin American Spanish (even there are difference from country to country.)

Latin is a requirement for aspiring German physicians, as a lot of medical lingo is in Latin. This is why they still teach it in high school. Obviously you need it as well if you want to go to seminary.

Latin appeared to be more logical compared to German. It will also help you immensely if you decide to pick up any of its living offspring someday. BTW, there are still some pockets of what could be present-day Latin speakers in the hills of Corsica or Sardinia. (Forgot which.)[/quote]


Thank you for the reply! It does answer some questions. Usefulness you cannot top Spanish, German I have a fondness for since my family line originated there so there is a facination (as well as the cinema- I still Love Lang's Metropolis and of course Run Lola Run) But the latin, I do feel a pull for seminary, it's something Im working through. Thank you very much though your advise helps me quite a bit!

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

C## is a good choice too

Pro Sanctus Jehanne
Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1341455' date='Jul 26 2007, 01:07 PM']C## is a good choice too[/quote]


Love to.. but a tad late to change the major now, My computer skills are limited to IT, Assembly and whatever program, Im using for art!

Cow of Shame
Posted

can't go wrong with Spanish. Unless you're planning on working in business where you'd encounter Japanese

Posted

Yeah I'd say choose a language based on where you think you'll go professionally. Spanish (or as Cow said Japanese) is pretty useful in day-to-day life, but if you're considering academics or priesthood as a future profession then Latin might be best.

Cow of Shame
Posted

won't you be able to learn Latin in priest-school, if you go that route? besides, spanish will still hold you in good stead being a priest.

Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' post='1341512' date='Jul 26 2007, 02:16 PM']won't you be able to learn Latin in priest-school, if you go that route? besides, spanish will still hold you in good stead being a priest.[/quote]
Good point.

Posted

Spanish is your best bet for many careers. And as a priest you will encounter many, many Hispanics so this would be very useful. Latin will help for priestly studies, but your time in seminary is limited, your priestly work last much longer.
Personally, I love the French language and have many years of study. It was very helpful in translating the work of St Therese. Unless you are headed for Canada, it probably will not be as much use in your life work.
Learning a language is never a waste of time. It teaches you many things beside just the spoken word. I think it is a lot of fun, but I enjoy study so am unusual!!

Posted

If you ever consider studying abroad and would like to do both Spanish and German at the same time, I can highly recommend the University of Mainz, Germany. Their Department of Applied Linguistics and Cultural Sciences (fancy way of saying "translating and interpreting") in Germersheim (on the Rhine between Mannheim and Karlsruhe) started as the school where all German diplomats were trained in foreign languages. I studied American English, Spanish and Russian there. There are a lot of non-German students there as well who attend just for learning one or more new languages. The instructors are first rate.

hoosieranna
Posted

I have to say Spanish as well. I took French. The only time I've actually used it was in Italy. Spanish is closer to Italian and would have been easier to use. Spanish wins the multiple-uses argument.

homeschoolmom
Posted
:yes:
Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' post='1341512' date='Jul 26 2007, 03:16 PM']won't you be able to learn Latin in priest-school, if you go that route? besides, spanish will still hold you in good stead being a priest.[/quote]

I have to agree with Cow. I have friends in different seminaries studying for different dioceses, and they both have to take a year or two of Latin there, but their seminaries/diocese are also requiring they learn Spanish. Most priests primarily read and pronounce Latin, and that is what most seminarians are being trained to do, while at the same time they are being trained to be able to hear confessions, do counseling, etc, in Spanish.

Cow of Shame
Posted

[quote name='tomasio127' post='1341562' date='Jul 26 2007, 05:52 PM']they are being trained to be able to hear confessions, do counseling, etc, in Spanish.[/quote]

...but are they being taught to rap in Spanish? 'Cause c'mon...a rapping priest?

sweet

Pro Sanctus Jehanne
Posted

Spanish it is!
Thanks everyone for your advisement, I hope to down the road add German and of course Latin. My japanese is quite rusty at this point so i'll need a refreser.


Phatmass Wa Sugoii!!

Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1341455' date='Jul 26 2007, 12:07 PM']C## is a good choice too[/quote]

Everyone knows COBOL is the up and coming language.

Posted

[quote name='Nadezhda' post='1341529' date='Jul 26 2007, 05:01 PM']I have to say Spanish as well. I took French. The only time I've actually used it was in Italy. Spanish is closer to Italian and would have been easier to use. Spanish wins the multiple-uses argument.[/quote]
Not up here, where all the old ladies speak French when they don't want people to know what their gossiping about. :detective:

I've studied Latin and French, and I have to say that French grammar is definitely easier. The vocabulary is easy too, because it's sort of a bridge between English and Latin. (Not historically, but vocabulary-wise.) French is harder to pronounce though.

Cow of Shame
Posted

[quote name='Pro Sanctus Jehanne' post='1342120' date='Jul 27 2007, 10:53 AM']Spanish it is!
Thanks everyone for your advisement, I hope to down the road add German and of course Latin. My japanese is quite rusty at this point so i'll need a refreser.
Phatmass Wa Sugoii!![/quote]


I had a friend who told me that after learning German, his English grammar improved....

good luck w/ all the languages.

Posted

Take Latin. It will definitely help you with understanding theology, philosophy and the Roman Liturgy.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...