Seatbelt Blue Posted July 28, 2007 Posted July 28, 2007 A friend of mine for whom I hold immense respect and love, both as a Christian and as a dear friend, asked me a question I have not been able to answer. This was nearly a month ago, and I've been wrestling with it internally, although, to be honest, no, I haven't really pursued it in research, mostly because "because the Church says so" isn't really cutting it for me right now. This isn't to be belligerent or anything; I'm simply in something of a weird place right now, and I'm a little iffy on simply accepting the episcopal sayso. The question is this: why is it that only through priests does God bring about the Eucharist? This arose in a long and painful discussion. Two friends, really, are very hurt at the notion that they are excluded from the Eucharistic feast. Both of them believe in the Real Presence, but do not understand why it is that only priests can officiate, so to speak, why only priests can tell the story and why only through priests the symbol becomes the reality. They both believe very profoundly in the Eucharist, and consider it central to Christianity and their own understanding of it. But I couldn't argue, I couldn't make the point, because I don't know the answer, and I'll be honest, I hadn't even considered the question, which shames me. Because when I do, the whole thing kind of stops making sense for me. Is apostolic succession the only thing I can fall back on? Is that tradition all I have to respond? Because it doesn't satisfy them, and it doesn't satisfy me, either. I dunno, I'm kind of in a weird place with regard to the position of the Western Church in particular to the rest of global Christianity, and this is one piece of it.
cappie Posted July 31, 2007 Posted July 31, 2007 I want to make three basic points. The first is, that the New Testament idea of the priesthood of the whole people of God undoubtedly informs much of the contemporary egalitarian push to allow lay people to preside at eucharists. The term 'priest' is not used of the Christian leader in the New Testament. It comes to be used by derivation from the High Priestly ministry of Christ himself, whose ministry is shared in the world by the priestly people of God as a whole. However, it is just as certain that there never was a time when the Church did not have specifically authorised ministers. The Church was never an undifferentiated community of believers without a clearly authorised ministry. In apostolic times the Church's ministry was, in a sense, co-terminous with its founding, for the very ones who shared the Last Supper with the Lord on Holy Thursday and who were mandated to continue to make remembrance of him with loaf and cup, were the very ones who three days later were commissioned to minister as witnesses to the resurrection, with a mandate to go into all the world proclaiming the good news of the Kingdom. From the start the Church always had a mandated ministry of Sacrament and Word. This apostolic ministry is prior to the Church insofar as the Church comes to be around the ministry of Word and Sacrament. By contrast with the ministry of the whole people of God in the world, the ordained are specifically authorised by ordination to minister to the community of faith as shepherds of the flock. Because this too is a share in the ministry of Christ, the Great High priest and shepherd of our souls, it is understandable why the early Church came to use the title 'priest' also of its ordained leaders. In any event, it is wrong to say that the Church is not a community gathered around a minister but a ministering community; in fact it is both. It is a community gathered around a minister, insofar as it is gathered by the ministry of Word and Sacrament, and by the continuing general ministry of pastoral care and oversight. We do not have to deny this in insisting that the Church is also a ministering community in the world. In advocating 'total ministry' we do ourselves no service by overlooking or devaluing the distinct and unique gathering role of the priest as shepherd of the flock. This means that those set apart by prayer with the laying on of hands have a ministry that is different in kind from the priesthood they exercise together with lay people as the priesthood of all faithful people. The priesthood of all people is a ministry exercised by the whole Church in the world, the ministry of representing God to the world and praying to God for the world. The unique ministry of those admitted by ordination to ministerial priesthood is a ministry in and to the community of faith, the seamless pastoral and liturgical ministry of leadership, involving responsibility for and oversight of the community. 2. The second point I want to make is that ordination is always effected by predecessors in the same office. As far as we can see this always has been so. Within the lifetime of the apostles presbyters were appointed by the apostles and hands were laid on them; in 1 Timothy 4.14 presbyters lay hands on presbyters, and after the death of the last apostle this authorising process seems to have passed to the presiding chief shepherd or bishop who now inherits the apostolic responsibility. To this day bishops consecrate bishops, the college of priests joins the bishop in ordaining priests. Though the Church as a whole assents to ordinations, and though ordinations take place within the context of the community gathered for worship, ordination is effected at the hands of predecessors in the same office. One thing that seems to be implied by this standing practice is that the setting apart or separation effected by the outward sign of the laying on of hands with prayer is not just a setting apart from the world, but in a sense a pastoral distancing of an individual from the Church for the Church so to speak. Those ordained to the Ministry of Word and Sacrament are not just expected to speak what the Church wishes to hear; the Word of God must be on their lips. Ministry comes not from the community but from Christ. In this sense ordained ministry is not thrown up by the Church, but is a gift to the Church. They must speak not just for the Church but, in the name of Christ to it, reminding it of its origin in Christ and taking responsibility for its formation as the Body of Christ, by seeking to ensure that its life always conforms to the norms and values of the Gospel. This clinches the truth that the ministry of those ordained to ministerial priesthood is not just a kind of intensification, focused in its leadership, of the priesthood of the whole community; it is not derived from the community as a kind of social contract; rather it is different in kind from the priesthood of all believers. 3. The third and final point I want to make is this: The particular shepherding responsibility of those ordained to ministerial priesthood is to keep the community true to its calling, to remind it of its origin in Christ, to form it as the Body of Christ, and to ensure that its life in the world conforms to the marks of his suffering and passion, and so to prepare it for its ministry of lowly service in the world. But, if the work of ordained leadership is a seamless one of pastoral and liturgical oversight, this means that we should anticipate this to happen in worship as much as in day to day pastoral work. The work of reminding the Church of its origin in Christ and of its intimate relation to Christ, and of calling it to sustain and renew its identity as the Body of Christ, and of building it up as the Body of Christ, happens both in the general life of the Church and in its gatherings for worship. It is exactly at this point that we can see why it is appropriate that those ordained to ministerial priesthood should preside immediately and directly at the Eucharist and inappropriate for lay people to do so. The reason is this: The Eucharistic Prayer is the second element of the fourfold action of taking, blessing, breaking and sharing, which Our Lord himself commanded to be done in remembrance of him. The Eucharistic Prayer is the verbal centre of the eucharist. Now, it is this prayer in which thanksgiving is offered to God for creation and redemption, and in which the Church commemorates and brings to remembrance the death and resurrection of Christ and is itself reminded of its unique identity as the Body of Christ. Moreover, it is in the course of the Eucharistic Prayer that the community is not just reminded of something but actually formed and renewed as the Body of Christ. At this point pastoral oversight and liturgical oversight coincide: the pastoral work of the ordained becomes a liturgical work and the liturgical becomes the pastoral. That is perhaps the single most important and compelling reason why it is appropriate that those ordained to this distinctive ministry in the life of the Church of overseeing the formation of the Church as the Body of Christ do actually lead the Sacrifice of the Mass. It is the central prayer in which, culminating in Holy Communion, the community is formed as the Body of Christ. And, given the seamlessness of the ministry of pastoral and liturgical oversight, this is why it is appropriate for those authorised by ordination for this distinct ministry to lead the reciting of it. To do otherwise would be to perpetrate the symbolic nonsense of saying one thing and doing another. We can affirm with confidence that there is indeed a unique role for ministerial priesthood which is both pastoral and liturgical. That is exactly what those ordained to ministerial priesthood are set apart for, by prayer with the laying on of hands, and authorised to do in ministry to, and for, the community. It belongs to 'a different realm of the gifts of the Spirit'. There is therefore without doubt, an inalienable future for ministerial priesthood. We do well to celebrate it. May many more be called to it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now